Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my friend that I’m not keen on her baby name?

258 replies

AllHailKingLouis · 21/06/2022 16:29

Friend told me today she has chosen the name Susan for her baby. I don’t like it personally but automatically said “oh, that’s nice”.

she’s just WhatsApp me asking if I really liked the name as she got the feeling that I didn’t (oops, I’m a shit liar).

would I be unreasonable to admit that I don’t? Or should I carry on lying about it? (Which I can do easier via WhatsApp!)

OP posts:
Ikeabag · 21/06/2022 18:34

Hard to know whether she actually wants to know. (Don't ask her that.) I'd go with the 'unexpected' line. If she really wants to know, tell her. But also tell her it's her choice and names change depending on who has them. Susan's got enough morphing juice in it to wrap around a lovely kid and become something beloved to others. And yeah, good nicknames. It's not to my taste either, but you should see my private nameberry lists, OP. I am ridiculous.

Does anyone else have "My Name Is Not Susan" as an earworm now?

RenegadeMatron · 21/06/2022 18:32

You can give her your honest opinion, but she will remember that you don’t like the name forever more.

The thing is - a baby name by itself without a baby attached to it is very different from a child/adult who has ‘become’ the name. The name is them - they own it and it owns them, and it’s impossible to imagine them being called anything else.

Susan is a nice, albeit slightly dated name. Which simply means, to this generation of kids, it will be new and fresh sounding.

Your friend’s child will become Susan, and the name will be just right for her because it’s her name.

There is literally nothing to be gained from any of the passive aggressive, ‘it’s not to my taste, but you like it, so that’s all that matters’ (how to say you hate the name without actually saying you hate it!), blatantly transparent suggestions.

‘It’s a great, classic name, and I can’t wait to meet her!’ is all that needs to be said.

Just10moreminutesplease · 21/06/2022 18:27

I don’t like some of my friends baby names. They would never know it though!

This is a situation that calls for a white lie.

KilmordenCastle · 21/06/2022 18:23

Badgirlriri · 21/06/2022 17:15

Can’t believe the amount of people that would lie when asked their opinion. If I ask a friend for their opinion I expect an honest answer!

Absolutely this!

I'm getting a bit paranoid now that every time I've asked one of my friends a straight question they've just lied to my face 😂

Tbf I never asked anyone for their opinion on the names of my dc's because I didn't want to know if they didn't like it. But if I ask someone for their honest opinion on something then I want their honest opinion, not a lie. And I wouldn't lie to anyone if they asked for my honest opinion either. I mean, I wouldn't be a dick about it, I'd phrase it in the nicest way possible, but I wouldn't lie.

SailingNotSurfing · 21/06/2022 18:21

I wouldn't say anything about her choice of name, she might be offended. Susan, Pamela, Julie, Linda, Mary, Jean, Patricia - all 60's and 70's names, no reason why they shouldn't make a comeback.

IncompleteSenten · 21/06/2022 18:20

I would lie my fucking arse off.

It's a perfectly nice name, lots of nickname options too, love me a bit of the Susie quattro vibe etc etc.

Charlize43 · 21/06/2022 18:19

Susan is a perfectly good name with lots of derivatives and the child won't suffer.

At least she's not calling her something awkward like 'Augusta' or pretentious like 'Talullah' or far fetched like 'Magenta'...

DawnTinsley · 21/06/2022 18:18

Hard one. I've never quite forgiven someone for telling me that they thought the name I picked for my son was a "drippy, unoriginal and twatty" name, and I didn't even ask their opinion, so had nothing riding on it.

His name is James, btw.

oopsfellover · 21/06/2022 18:18

Just say you like it. It doesn't really affect you. One of my friends gave her DD a name I thought was awful, but I like it now there's a lovely little person to associate it with. It wouldn't have helped, at any stage, for me to say I disliked the name.

Nanny0gg · 21/06/2022 18:17

Minfilia · 21/06/2022 16:36

She’s asked for your honest opinion, so I’d give it. As diplomatically as possible.

My friend called his children Arthur and Martha… I think I somehow contorted my face into an expression that was acceptable…

Then clearly you weren't honest!

ClarissaD · 21/06/2022 18:17

I quite like it. I also think it’s a name that will have a completely different feel to the next generation than it does to ours.

I think (unless someone hasn’t realised they’re naming their child after a serial killer or Seymour Butts or something) the correct response is “lovely”. It’s not your job to substitute your taste for theirs.

BanjoVio · 21/06/2022 18:15

RevoltingHumanHead · 21/06/2022 17:59

But you probably have a friend who think the name you give your child is a bit crap. Would their telling you have changed your mind?

If they had a reason I agreed with, yes I think it would. If not, I would ignore it. But then again I do go by the golden rule of keeping names to yourself before the kid’s born. The friend clearly cares what OP thinks otherwise she wouldn’t have shared the name or messaged later for clarification.

incywincyspidery · 21/06/2022 18:14

My middle name is Susan, I always thought it was dull. But... it could be the next name to have a big revival and there's nothing like a cute baby or toddler to make a name seem lovely. I never liked "Elsie" or "Lottie" when the names belonged to my extremely elderly great aunts. But now there's lots of adorable little ones running around with those names I quite like them. So, don't tell your friend you don't like it because 1) it's not worth losing a friend over and 2) when the baby arrives, she'll become the name and you won't be able to think of her as anything else.

Youcansaythatagainandagain · 21/06/2022 18:12

I wouldn’t lie outright and say I liked it but would instead say that it isn’t a name you hear much these days.

If she asked you, she probably isn’t fully decided on it.
i would never tell her I disliked it though.
She won’t thank you - unless she’s playing a joke on you and has absolutely no intention of calling the baby Susan and just wants to see your reaction?

SherbertLemonDrop · 21/06/2022 18:10

Susan is awful. If you are close, tell her.

DoraDont · 21/06/2022 18:08

I told my parents we were going to name our baby 'Oscar' if it was a boy and my dad piped up, 'oh that just makes me think of Oscar Pistorious now' (paralympian who'd just been convicted of murdering his girlfriend). Cheers dad!

Luckily I ended up having a girl.

Banoffe · 21/06/2022 18:04

Unless the baby is called Unicornfrankenstien or some outlandish equivalent I’d just say you like it. It’s not a name that will harm the baby and it’s fairly normal.

erinaceus · 21/06/2022 18:03

She might be looking for a psychological "out", if she is having second thoughts or her partner likes Susan and she doesn't. Avoid telling her you don't like it outright but don't lie either, and perhaps say something more open so that she can explore her options a bit more.

BowiesJumper · 21/06/2022 18:03

Just say, no! I was just surprised as you don’t hear it often for babies now, so it’s nice you’re using it!

this is one of those times where a white lie hurts nobody.

bitofawait · 21/06/2022 18:02

Suzie is a sweet nickname. I'd reply that.

KisstheTeapot14 · 21/06/2022 18:00

As long as she doesn't name any further babies after Queen's corgis all will be fine! @fortifiedwithtea

Crikeyalmighty · 21/06/2022 17:59

Maybe there's a reason behind it- deceased mum/aunt etc??

RevoltingHumanHead · 21/06/2022 17:59

BanjoVio · 21/06/2022 17:55

What’s wrong with everyone?? Tell her - she’s asked you! Real friends tell each other the truth. And it might prevent the poor child from being saddled with the name ‘Susan’ forever. Suzie or Suzanna are lovely alternatives.

But you probably have a friend who think the name you give your child is a bit crap. Would their telling you have changed your mind?

KisstheTeapot14 · 21/06/2022 17:58

DowntonCrabby · 21/06/2022 17:07

“I really don’t fee strongly either way, it’s a nice, classic name” You’re not lying by gushing to tell her you love it.

Yes, as above. Also

Then read any Terry Pratchett novel featuring Susan (adoptive granddaughter of the Grim Reaper). She is a great character, and appears in Soul Music, Hogfather, and Thief of Time. ''Being both human and supernatural, Susan is frequently and reluctantly forced away from her normal life to do battle with malign supernatural forces. As the series progresses, she also begins to take on roles educating children, so that, she has "ended up....a kind of Goth Mary Poppins".

See if that doesn't help you like the name more.

Rosscameasdoody · 21/06/2022 17:56

I don’t think honesty is the best policy here as it will more than likely cause offence. Just say that it’s not a name you would choose for your own child, but if she loves it she should use it. And maybe point out all the lovely nicknames suggested by PP’s - if Susan seems a bit old for a baby, Susie is lovely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread