Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how people afford holidays!

406 replies

Dreaming34 · 21/06/2022 15:22

I mustn’t be budgeting very well on food etc and me and my DH have a joint income of 75k, we really struggle at the end of every month and we cannot afford to go on holiday! Everything is so expensive really we are really struggling

OP posts:
Lovinglife45 · 21/06/2022 18:56

OP
Our budget is roughly £10k more than yours and we struggle. High mortgage for a bloody small house, high outgoings increasing bills. Dc have one extra curriculum activity each. We have enough spare for school trips, pocket money, days out (within reason), unexpected cost etc.

I am not willing to live on beans and toast all year round in order to pay for a one week family holiday to Europe or 3 long haul holiday at a push. We cannot even envisage luxury 5 holidays to Florida/Caribbean/Thailand.

For what it is worth:
Shop at Lidl
Take lunch to work daily
Do not buy magazines
Dye my own hair
Shave my own legs
Do not buy coffees or snacks out - unless meeting friends
Polish my own nails
Take lunch to parks and beaches
Buy non leather shoes
Do not spend more than £30 on each item of clothing

The cost of living has greatly increased.

WombatChocolate · 21/06/2022 18:56

A lot if the differences are to do with the amount of debt being serviced. There are mortgage differences…..lots of people are mortgaged to the hilt and don’t have anything left. It’s fair enough if that was necessary to get a property, but less understandable if people have gone do bigger houses than they needed and consequently can’t afford anything else at all in life. And then there’s the car finance that seems to take £500 a month for people with 2 cars….and that take as necessary, unavoidable and an assumed and ongoing cost of life. If that’s £6k per year and it happens for 20 years, even without inflation, that’s £120k gone on cars. The alternative of buying perhaps 6 cars (3 each) to last 6-7 years each at £7k each for a 4 year okd car, could be £42k and a saving of almost £80k. That £80k is a lot of holidays, a bigger house, school fees, retiring 3 years earlier etc etc. But people only think about the monthly cost and affordability not the long term picture.

ApplesandBunions · 21/06/2022 18:52

pixie5121 · 21/06/2022 18:13

Good where?

It's a below average income for a household in London, AFAIK, and I'd very much struggle to raise kids on that, eat well, live a reasonably nice lifestyle AND go on holiday.

Where the OP actually lives. She's in Manchester where it's pretty decent, albeit there are a few areas where that wouldn't go far.

justgotosleepffs · 21/06/2022 18:52

DockOTheBay · 21/06/2022 17:44

the ingredients in the Tesco smoothie are juice, the Innocent Smoothies are pure fruit! juice is made of fruit...

But Innocent smoothies are special. They are made by the light of the moon, to the sound of shepherds playing pan pipes as the individual fruit pieces on rhe ingredient list are dropped into a mixing bowl one by one, by the bare hands of a local farmer.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 21/06/2022 18:51

I’m in the NE, joint income 2/3 of yours and we have multiple holidays a year. We don’t spend £3 on 5 strawberries or £20 on ice cream (his many people had an ice cream for £20?) as we prioritise holiday savings. Nor do my children do extensive activities. It’s all about priorities, you need to make holidays yours if that’s what you want to achieve and sacrifice other spending.

Hemax1 · 21/06/2022 18:51

Dreaming34 · 21/06/2022 17:27

meat from Tesco tastes like heaven compared to Lidl, you can’t deny that? I want to enjoy it.

I find it the other way round … that meat from Lidl is far tastier ! 🤷‍♀️

WombatChocolate · 21/06/2022 18:50

I’d say people with the same household income can have wildly varying standards of living due to how money savvy they are…..and that’s not due to age which determines the price they bought property at.

So for example, some people on £75k have over the years built up a pot of savings. They have £10-£15k they can draw on when needed. This means that when bigger expenditures appear they can buy a 3 year old car, or a new boiler outright and without any credit agreement. Therefore they don’t have hundreds going out monthly in payment plans and eating into what’s available for basic living or holidays. Some people on £75k will manage the weekly shop for their family for £60 and others will spend more than double that…with exactly the same number of people in the house. Some will have 4 TV subscription packages and others just 1. Some eat a takeaway every week whereas others might have it once every 6 months. Some check their utilities and insurance every year and switch and others don’t, meaning they might pay £500 or more on those things.

The impact of these different things all factored in together can make a huge difference. It can mean one family of 4 with kids the same age can manage 2 holidays a year and the others can’t have any. It can mean one family can upgrade to a bigger house and will retire 5 years earlier than the other.

Money savvy means no spending more than you need to on things. It doesn’t mean being cheap or going without, just that you get more value from your money. So ultimately the person who watches the pennies has more £ to spend.

I know families who have the same income as other families and the adults nad kids are similar ages and neither have had family help. They started from the same position. One have regular monthly payments going out for 2 cars which they replace every 2 years. They also eat takeaways weekly and spend a lot in the supermarket and keep their heating on high through the day and night in winter. They have also borrowed in the past for an extension and to do up their bathroom. They don’t have holidays as they are ‘skint’ even though they have more than £100k coming in. The other family has a similar income and lives in a slightly smaller house. They drive cars which are about 7 years old and monitor their bills and weekly spending. They eat out with friends but don’t have takeaways and only tend to eat out once a month. But they always have 3 holidays a year, including a big one and they manage to send one of their kids to a private school. They also have good pension provision and are looking at stopping at work just before 60.

These little focuses on money accumulate in impact and over the years mean some families live hand to mouth and others have flexibility and choices available to them. Often they don’t have so much of the immediate items which people might fritter on, but actually have more of the big stuff and importantly have spare cash so that when something crops up that they’d like or need, they can just choose it, without serious consideration of affordability. So they might get the letter about the school ski trip at £1.2k and look at it and say ‘yes’ because the savings are there, whereas the other family has no savings and knows that each month every penny goes.

Lots of people see money savvy and being a bit frugal as dull, boring and meaning people go without. Often it means they get far more because they know that always buying brands in the shop, when you can get similar or identical for 1/3 less, and always paying a lease for a brand new car fritter away hundreds each month which could be put to better use. It’s fine if you’d rather have the branded food and a new car every two years if you accept that then you can’t have the holidays or early retirement, or upgrade to a bigger house, but actually you can’t have everything and choices always have to be made….and they impacts that somehow people often can’t seem to see.

Teateaandmoretea · 21/06/2022 18:42

It’s because we don’t have a mortgage and nursery fees as our kids are older.

The thing is OP, they just have more money/ fewer outgoings it’s how it is.

smallbeetle · 21/06/2022 18:41

Are you kids in private nursery? Those costs won't last.

But otherwise you have a very good income and you just need to budget. Our joint income is the same as yours and we do have a holiday each year we do have savings, even though our mortgage each month is huge (1k per month).

user375242 · 21/06/2022 18:37

Perplexed0522 · 21/06/2022 18:02

It depends how you go about it…

For example my husband is going away with our two children in Summer, they are going to Egypt for 16 nights, All Inclusive and it’s cost about £1300.

In May, they all went to Egypt for 7 nights, All Inclusive again and it cost £700.

How?? I browse holidays I can't afford all the time. I have tried pricing up separate flights and accom and deals and have never seen anything like this. I suppose the price might double if you were going too?

addictedtotheflats · 21/06/2022 18:36

We have 1 child

addictedtotheflats · 21/06/2022 18:36

We earn 10K less as a household and dont feel like we cant afford things. We save £700 a month and after bills and food i have £800 disposable and my DP around £400. My mortgage is £340 and we could do with a bigger house but tbh id rather be able to afford what I want rather than have a massive mortgage.

user375242 · 21/06/2022 18:29

Our joint income is about 60k and we live in a very cheap area up north, have one second hand car, buy very cheap food, the children all do free or very cheap activities (Brownies is the most expensive) and we are skint and in overdraft each month. But my partner is in the higher income tax bracket and I earn very little due to his shifts and lack of childcare. So it sounds like a lot to some people but friends who are on a joint income of much less are better off than us and can claim things like free prescriptions (we both have more than two prescriptions a month so it adds up).

We do have a few short UK breaks and go camping, and have had some great holidays that way, but I'd love to go abroad. I never used to understand how those classed as a higher earner could claim to be skint, but honestly, we had more disposable income when our income was low enough for us to recieve child tax credits. That was the last time we could afford a holiday abroad.

StickyFingeredWeeNed · 21/06/2022 18:28

I earn a third of your income and we’re going 2 weeks AI next year. I’m paying monthly.

We’re also talking about buying a boat this summer.

In addition to this, my kids sometimes have an innocent smoothie (I think they’re junk… but whatevs). They get that smoothie as part of a Tesco lunch meal deal which we’ll have on a day out rather than dropping £50 on a nice cafe for lunch.

I can’t imagine where all your cash is going tbh.

user75 · 21/06/2022 18:27

I have a holiday to the Caribbean every year and earn half what you did. It is my priority. The amount you spend on activities and days out is extraordinary to me!

CandyLeBonBon · 21/06/2022 18:23

Lochjeda · 21/06/2022 18:08

Its just not true that making fruit in to smoothies alters the fiber 🤣 did you all do weight watchers or something who use to tell people eating a banana was less "points" than mashing it then eating it. The only way fiber is removed when making a smoothie is if you remove the skin which contains fiber in certain fruits.

You know that commercial smoothies are strained right? Which is why I differentiated between commercial smoothies and home made smoothies.

Onthegrid · 21/06/2022 18:21

You have a take home of somewhere between £4000 & £5000, unless you have some serious debit you are servicing you must be wasting far more than a few ice creams and some smoothies.
Analyse what you spend, make a spreadsheet, work to a budget, then you will find the money to go on holiday, it is easily within your grasp.

MarvelMrs · 21/06/2022 18:20

We live in the suburbs in SE London. We live ok, very tight but ok on a combined income of £33K plus standard child benefit. 3 kids. One car.
I am baffled as to how you can’t afford a holiday. I think I would be going through my outgoings with a fine comb and making saving for a holiday a priority. Ice creams, coffees, general stuff can go on the back burner for a while to save.

DaisyRain543 · 21/06/2022 18:19

Myself and my partner manage fine on about 3,200pm jointly after tax but we don't have kids and we live in the North west. Our rent is pretty low at the moment but we are looking to move. We don't have fancy holidays though as we have been saving for a mortgage. We've been going to a cottage for a week once or twice a year which is pretty reasonably priced. It's nothing fancy at all it's just for a little break.

Sallypally0 · 21/06/2022 18:19

Based on your posts I doubt very much that you are very strict with any kind of budgeting. Perhaps try and budget and you might be able to afford a holiday. Hint this includes reducing spending in some areas.

FemmeNatal · 21/06/2022 18:17

pixie5121 · 21/06/2022 18:13

Good where?

It's a below average income for a household in London, AFAIK, and I'd very much struggle to raise kids on that, eat well, live a reasonably nice lifestyle AND go on holiday.

No, average in London is around £45,000 per household.

data.london.gov.uk/dataset/focus-on-london-income-and-spending

DockOTheBay · 21/06/2022 18:17

Nutritional info for Innocent Smoothie and Asda Smoothie (same flavour). There are some very small differences, but broadly the same (fibre the same for example, vitamin C, sugar and protein Asda has slightly more)

To wonder how people afford holidays!
nalabae · 21/06/2022 18:16

Credit.
don’t be jealous of others.

Artwodeetoo · 21/06/2022 18:15

People prioritise different things. For some a holiday is important and so they plan to save and perhaps forgo/cut back on other things. On a joint income of £70k plus I'm sure there's some give in the budget somewhere if you are that fussed about saving.

FemmeNatal · 21/06/2022 18:15

Lochjeda · 21/06/2022 18:08

Its just not true that making fruit in to smoothies alters the fiber 🤣 did you all do weight watchers or something who use to tell people eating a banana was less "points" than mashing it then eating it. The only way fiber is removed when making a smoothie is if you remove the skin which contains fiber in certain fruits.

No, that's not right. If you rip open the cells then instead of the whole volume of the cell contributing to the fibre (as you can't digest it), now only the cell wall itself is.