Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nephew and birthday present

88 replies

Wondog22 · 21/06/2022 14:37

Nephew is turning 6 soon and I recently asked him what he wanted for his birthday and he said he’d love a Nintendo Switch, all his friends have one but then said ‘Mummy and Daddy said we don’t have enough money’
Relayed the conversation back to DH and suggested we buy. DH thinks this is an awful idea and to buy him something else, we usually spend £50-£100 depending on what he want so obviously it’s more money than usual.
DH thinks no for several reasons 1. He thinks it’s undermining DB and DSIL, they’ve said no and we shouldn’t be buying it ‘behind their back’ 2. Thinks we’ll set a precedent with DN that we always buy expensive gifts
I think we should buy it because 1. We can comfortably afford it 2. It’s only money and I want my Nephew to have what he wants, it’s only the money aspect that is stopping me buying it , normally I’d just buy what he wants so why should I let that get in the way.

I did think about messaging DB and asking if we can buy it but DH thinks that’s even worse and I’d be drawing attention to the fact they can’t afford to buy it. My argument is surely they’d be happy that DS was getting what he wants and does it matter who it comes from?

DB is on my side of the family to be clear, so not DH relations (albeit close to them). Also no kids of our own yet so maybe I’m totally out of reality here.

Would you buy the Nintendo?

OP posts:
Wondog22 · 21/06/2022 14:45

@SandyWedges that’s what DH thinks , and I do understand I guess I’m just frustrated that we can afford it and he wants it but I don’t want to upset anyone so he’ll miss out. It’s a tricky one

OP posts:
Gnusmas · 21/06/2022 14:43

Give your dB some money to put towards gifts but I've just bought 2 days at a summer camp for my neice. I asked my dB first and he was OK about it because it'll give him a break.

MsSquiz · 21/06/2022 14:43

There's no way I'd buy someone else's child such an expensive gift without having spoken to them first.

They might not want him to have one
They might not be able to afford it
They might have told him they can't afford it but are getting it as a surprise

Plus, with things like a games console, you also need to factor in the expense of the games and additional items like headphones, etc

So, would I buy the Nintendo? Not without speaking to his parents first

Aksbdt · 21/06/2022 14:43

They may have lots of reasons for not buying it and you’re likely to embarrass them. I don’t think you should

Wondog22 · 21/06/2022 14:43

I did think about messaging to ask if he could have it with him only being 6 and not mentioning the money aspect. Then I guess if they don’t want me to buy it then can just say he’s too young, that could work.

OP posts:
Happyplace88 · 21/06/2022 14:42

I personally don’t see any problem with you buying this gift as long as his parents are fine with it. I wouldn’t frame it as “we know you can’t afford it”. Maybe ask like “I know it’s a slightly more expensive gift than usual, we are happy to buy it, he’s said you are getting him a different gift. Would you mind if we fought it for him?”. They might then buy him a game for it so could still get some of the joy of being involved in the gift.
also you sound really kind, thoughtful and considerate OP.

mumonthehill · 21/06/2022 14:42

Ask! I used to use the it’s too much money excuse if I wanted it to be a real surprise or if it was something that I did not feel was appropriate at that time.

SandyWedges · 21/06/2022 14:42

If you've got a usual budget for gifts stick to it. If the parents can't afford it they might feel rubbish if someone else buys it.

RedAngel19 · 21/06/2022 14:41

I'm with your DH on this for the reasons he's given. Perhaps you could gift cash instead and he can put it towards a Switch? That might be a good compromise here? How lucky that your nephew has such a lovely and generous auntie :)

Mally100 · 21/06/2022 14:41

I have a 6yo ds and I wouldn't buy him one. I very much doubt your nephew's all my friends line because I do know for a fact most of ds don't have one. I'm in total agreement with your dh for all the valid reasons he pointed out. Why not give his parents the money and they can use that to top up if they wish to get him one. I would not broach it with his parents either.

User478 · 21/06/2022 14:40

Definitely not without discussing it with his parents.

JustLyra · 21/06/2022 14:40

You shouldn’t buy a present that expensive without speaking to your DB given the age of your nephew.

They may be buying him it as a surprise. They may not want him to have it that young. Etc etc.

Your DH’s points are very valid ones.

WhatTheHeckShrek · 21/06/2022 14:40

If ask your brother. You don't have to tell them that your nephew said they can't afford it. You can just tell your brother that you asked nephew what he'd like for his birthday and he said a Nintendo switch ahd would it be ok if you got it for him.