Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nephew and birthday present

88 replies

Wondog22 · 21/06/2022 14:37

Nephew is turning 6 soon and I recently asked him what he wanted for his birthday and he said he’d love a Nintendo Switch, all his friends have one but then said ‘Mummy and Daddy said we don’t have enough money’
Relayed the conversation back to DH and suggested we buy. DH thinks this is an awful idea and to buy him something else, we usually spend £50-£100 depending on what he want so obviously it’s more money than usual.
DH thinks no for several reasons 1. He thinks it’s undermining DB and DSIL, they’ve said no and we shouldn’t be buying it ‘behind their back’ 2. Thinks we’ll set a precedent with DN that we always buy expensive gifts
I think we should buy it because 1. We can comfortably afford it 2. It’s only money and I want my Nephew to have what he wants, it’s only the money aspect that is stopping me buying it , normally I’d just buy what he wants so why should I let that get in the way.

I did think about messaging DB and asking if we can buy it but DH thinks that’s even worse and I’d be drawing attention to the fact they can’t afford to buy it. My argument is surely they’d be happy that DS was getting what he wants and does it matter who it comes from?

DB is on my side of the family to be clear, so not DH relations (albeit close to them). Also no kids of our own yet so maybe I’m totally out of reality here.

Would you buy the Nintendo?

OP posts:
Cakecakecheese · 21/06/2022 15:33

Buy him a voucher for how much you normally spend or give the cash and say it's towards a Switch and other relatives can do the same?

Amid · 21/06/2022 15:32

Ask your brother and don't mention money.

My mum used to buy all the gadgets.when the DC were younger as I couldn't afford it. Was never embarrassing because I didn't care where it came from as long as they were happy.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 21/06/2022 15:27

Also he's only just 6- whether anyone can afford it or not it seems a hefty present for a 6yr old.

SummerInSun · 21/06/2022 15:27

Just tell your brother that you asked DN what he wanted, he said a Switch, you would be happy to get it for him but wanted to check it is ok? Nothing embarrassing about that at all.

Personally there is no way I wanted my 6 year old to have one, and I could well imagine just saying "it's too expensive" to bat off the requests, rather than trying to explain all the more complicated reasons and risk him repeating those to other kids or parents. (Even though I don't want him to have a switch, I also don't want him to be the kid who says "my mum won't let me have one because I should be reading books instead" or whatever 6 year old version of my explanation would come out and make me look like a Pratt!).

Bluetrews25 · 21/06/2022 15:23

Well if they can't afford it they can't afford the games for it either.
So you end up buying everything because you can, nephew gets a gift that his parents can't buy for him and the parents are made to feel really, really shit.
Unless you want to humiliate your DB and SIL, please don't do it.
This is the kind of thing that stings like hell when finance is tight but others think it's ok to be overgenerous without realising how it makes the recipient/recipient's parents feel.

MustBeDueSomeBetterFeet · 21/06/2022 15:20

Agree with all PP.

The other thing about the Switch is that you've got the console cost, but he will then want games (at £50 a pop), access to the Nintendo Store and online play (more cost). It's just not as simple as buying the console.

Do you have children yourself?

TiddleyWink · 21/06/2022 15:19

Wondog22 · 21/06/2022 14:45

@SandyWedges that’s what DH thinks , and I do understand I guess I’m just frustrated that we can afford it and he wants it but I don’t want to upset anyone so he’ll miss out. It’s a tricky one

Sorry to be blunt but I really don’t think it’s a tricky one at all. As evidenced by people immediately telling you your husband is absolutely right!

Its really not tricky to understand that you don’t undermine the struggling parents of a young child who isn’t yours, by buying them an expensive gift that you have no idea if the parents are even happy for him to have.

Do you have kids of your own? I think sometimes that provides a different perspective as it can be hard to place yourself in the parents’ position if you don’t. There are certain things that are just wildly inappropriate for anyone other than parents to do and buying expensive tech for a six year old is near the top of that list. I think you mean well but you really need to back off and observe appropriate boundaries with other peoples’ children.

supertedlasso · 21/06/2022 15:16

Are you sure they've not got him one but want to surprise him?

I spend too much on my nephews. It's really hard to undo it once you've started. Don't start it!

Elpheba · 21/06/2022 15:14

I think only parents should be buying tech for kids. They might not want him to have one full stop, they might have got it themselves, they might be suggesting he saves up etc. Definitely best to ask first or offer cash towards it but if they say no then listen.

MeltorFreeze · 21/06/2022 15:12

In my view, technology is not something you should buy other people's children unless you have the express permission of the parents.
The child is 6.
You will not have to deal with the constant tantrums demanding to play.
He is 6.
This is absolutely it your decision to make.

You have to ask. You could go for DN mentioned this, but we think he's so young, would you want him to have one yet? Let us know when you think he's old enough and we'll put some money towards it (I wouldn't offer to buy it in the future! Circumstances may change, devices may change and prices may too.)

You really don't need to shower kids with expensive gifts. My DC's favourite gifts have been a weekend away with BIL, BIL taking them on horse riding experience,
MIL taking them to the theatre. They remember those, doubt they could pick out the Lego set or whatever they got before.

Wondog22 · 21/06/2022 15:11

I’m not trying to buy a better present than his parents or make anyone feel rubbish.
I’d happily send it anonymously if that was feasible.
I know they haven’t bought him one, they’re really struggling (they’ve told me that, it’s not my assumption). And as far as I’m aware they’ve not said no they’ve said they can’t afford it.
I’ll either ask or find something else.

OP posts:
motogirl · 21/06/2022 15:07

I would speak to the parents - if it's a genuine money issue you could offer to buy, I'm sure they would be pleased but if the money was an excuse they can tell you that also, that they feel he's too young etc. i was in the situation and I told my brother they weren't having games consoles until older

lucylooareyou · 21/06/2022 15:07

i think you'd be overstepping a boundary here, and potentially upsetting your DB/SIL. There is no real way that you could buy a £300 present and it not make your DB/SIL feel inadequate and guilty for not being able to afford it themselves.

Also, he's 6 - maybe they dont want him to have one at that age and be glued to a games console.

There is no real spin you can put on this without insulting adults, and pleasing a 6 year old who would be equally happy with a nerf gun.

worraliberty · 21/06/2022 15:03

2. It’s only money and I want my Nephew to have what he wants, it’s only the money aspect that is stopping me buying it , normally I’d just buy what he wants so why should I let that get in the way.

Because his parents have said no.
His parents saying no should be the 'aspect' that stops you, unless you discuss with them.
"I want my nephew to have what he wants" is easy for you to say, because he's not your kid.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 21/06/2022 15:03

dont do it-will demean his parents !

skgnome · 21/06/2022 15:02

At 6 not all the friends will have it… as much as the friends will claim otherwise
by all means, speak to your brother… see what else to get, games are expensive and they may not want a 6yo to have access to a switch, let alone their own one

picklemewalnuts · 21/06/2022 15:01

Also, it's a bit mean to buy a better present than his parents. That makes you feel pretty crap, as a mum.

You could give him money to save up for one- great idea from a PP.
Discuss it with his parents in an ongoing way- you get the present, they pay for his party, for example.
Ask his parents what they'd like you to get him. Tickets for an outing would be great, when times are tight.

Also, there may be things they'd like him to have that aren't very exciting- new shoes, music lessons... the kind of stuff that cripples you as a parent but doesn't give you any kudos with your children!

Wallywobbles · 21/06/2022 15:01

I do not want any computer games devices in my home. I'd be very very pissed off if you did this.

TempName01 · 21/06/2022 15:01

It’s too much, I think you need to ask them firstly if they would like to buy him one, if so can you contribute and/or buy a couple of games to go with it. They might have already got one as a surprise or be totally against the idea so you need to communicate with them on this.

MissMaple82 · 21/06/2022 14:59

Why not just give him some money and suggest he can start saving up for something he really wants.

MissMaple82 · 21/06/2022 14:57

Absolutely not! For all you know, they may just be using the finances as an excuse to not but one because they don't want their child of only 6 to become reliant on gaming and electronics. It is not your place to buy such an expensive gift without consulting them

RevoltingHumanHead · 21/06/2022 14:57

Your DH is right. They might smile and say thank you but inwardly feel a bit crap their gift gets tossed aside once Auntie Bountiful (lovely though I'm sure you are) swoops in with the big ticket item.

11Hawkins · 21/06/2022 14:49

Just ask your brother?

They are expensive. You may have the console, but games are around £50 each.

Needmorelego · 21/06/2022 14:46

The games are usually around £45 - £50 so are you prepared to be spending that regularly?
This is NOT something for you to be getting. "Can't afford it" is more likely to mean "we don't want you to have a games console because you are 6" and they've told a white lie.

JaceLancs · 21/06/2022 14:45

I would ask his parents
if it is on financial grounds maybe you could share cost
if they don’t want him to have it for other reasons eg age then either buy him something else or gift cash and explain he can save it until he’s old enough to get switch and then he can put towards it or buy extra games