Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is top CF?

41 replies

willithappen · 21/06/2022 13:56

Posting for traffic mainly and hoping for help/advice too

A couple weeks back I was in a very small car accident, where only the slightest of scratch on the car has occurred. To the point I didn't even bother putting in a claim because it's bare minimum damage

I had parked in a spot in a local town square, facing a shop. The road behind me is a one way road so to get out I had to reverse ever so slightly to the left and out onto the road. As I was doing so a car had driven past, waiting for it to go and then started reversing. This car then reversed back and went to go into the space next to me. Because they reversed at the same time as I was the front right of my car and the side right of theirs scraped against each other. Their car was is quite older, mines a 17 plated BMW so there was more of a scratch on theirs (possibly because they kept reversing while my car was more stationary.

Anyway, they have put a claim in for theirs. Was kind of expecting this but hoping that with logic it could be seen it wasn't entirely, if at all, my fault. I have just received a call today to tell me that the third party has put in an injury claim against me and is claiming they were injured in this!! I'm totally baffled and in disbelief considering the minuscule damage done and that fact my car couldn't have even been doing 2+ mph at the time either.

Is it possible an injury could occur or are they changing their luck with what they could get? They got out the car and we exchanged details and there was no sign of injury at all, she didn't say she had either and said it was a case of both of us reversing.

As it happened in front of the shop and I know one of the girls behind the till saw it all I'm going to get her details to put in as well.

If I'm the worst case scenario I was found at fault and they say she's injured from this because of me (which I'd be extremely baffled by but I don't know how all this works), what would happen to me? Claim against me, would I pay the excess on my insurance if it pays out to them and would I be due the other driver anything for injury?

Sorry, first time in any incident with another driver so totally clueless and upset by it all. I was in the car with my 5 month old dd at the time as well so my main concern was making sure she was okay (which she was - as it was literally bare minimum scraping)

OP posts:
balalake · 21/06/2022 14:20

Yes and such people trying to steal money (as that is what it is, nothing less) result in higher insurance premiums.

If only lying in insurance claims resulted in a driving ban, perhaps there would be less attempts.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 21/06/2022 14:20

Tbh with the new whiplash tariff it's hardly worth your insurers defending it.

HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 14:18

I dont think you need to pay anything on yours unless you are claiming for damages or injury. If you were claiming you would have to pay excess fee but as you have decided not to the insurance company will pay for her damage/injury claim. You will likely find your premiums go up though when you renew as you will need to declare it.

caramac04 · 21/06/2022 14:16

It’s called Whipcash. She’s trying it on as it’s hard to disprove as the Dr who makes diagnosis is paid about £300 for his time and almost always sided with the claimant.

QuitMoaning · 21/06/2022 14:13

Dotjones · 21/06/2022 14:10

They're trying it on. Try to gather all the evidence you can and ask the businesses around the area whether they have CCTV of the incident.

Your only real danger is if your insurance company invalidates your policy because you failed to declare incidents where damage occurred. Most policies have a clause stating you have to inform the insurer if an incident occurs which could have resulted in a claim - even if it didn't. The fact you didn't report the original incident with the scratch may fall foul of this and insurers are notorious for trying to get out of payment any way they can.

Of course, the person claiming you injured them has to prove their case against you, which sounds unlikely.

The OP did report it. It states so in their second post.

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:13

I reported it on the day, I just noted I didn't want to claim for any damage to my car because it was so minor.

There was no bump, just scraping - some of their paint was on my car. She got out the car fine and stood there and exchanged details with me. I was probably the one who appeared more shaken at the time but that was the nerves of the situation.

So if she gets any injury claim it would just go as a claim against my insurance like normal?

I think it's probably more likely a 50/50 decision if being reasonable but do still believe she was slightly more in the wrong as she reverse back on a one way system

OP posts:
Billybagpuss · 21/06/2022 14:11

You’ve done everything you can, just get yourself a cuppa, make sure you have the excess put aside just in case and it is very unlikely to go to court.

Travis1 · 21/06/2022 14:11

*thing and flooring 🤦🏻‍♀️

Dotjones · 21/06/2022 14:10

They're trying it on. Try to gather all the evidence you can and ask the businesses around the area whether they have CCTV of the incident.

Your only real danger is if your insurance company invalidates your policy because you failed to declare incidents where damage occurred. Most policies have a clause stating you have to inform the insurer if an incident occurs which could have resulted in a claim - even if it didn't. The fact you didn't report the original incident with the scratch may fall foul of this and insurers are notorious for trying to get out of payment any way they can.

Of course, the person claiming you injured them has to prove their case against you, which sounds unlikely.

Travis1 · 21/06/2022 14:08

You only have to pay your excess regardless of their claim.

only think I’ll say is a car hit the back of me in stationary traffic because they were trying to stop someone cutting in front of them 🙄 I had 6 months of physio because the knock got me ‘just right’ and I already had back issues so it just exacerbated them. I did ask the physio about it and he said he’d seen people roll their car and come for an assessment to be fine but then someone else have a minor accident and it flooding them for months.

Sswhinesthebest · 21/06/2022 14:07

I’m sure it will end up 50/50 especially if there was a witness.
CF

CannaeRemember · 21/06/2022 14:07

As the PP says, you must report every incident. I had a similar thing happen when my DD was 5 months old. I reported it to the insurance company but nothing came of it. I highly doubt that any injury has been caused. Sounds like a CF looking for a spot of compensation.

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:05

I reported the incident immediately and they have all the details and photos. The only thing I messed up on was that I didn't take a photo of her car damage at the time.

But I informed my insurance straight away so they have my version. Was just wondering what would happen if they believe she was injured. I've spoken to the shop assistant who is happy to speak with them and say that she didn't appear injured afterwards.

Just worried about being forced to pay a load myself or any court action.

OP posts:
redastherose · 21/06/2022 14:04

It sounds like they are trying it on. Notify your insurance company of precisely what happened and get your witness and any CCTV around if possible.

EarthquakesinEastActon · 21/06/2022 14:03

It’s too late now, but this is exactly why you report every incident to your insurer, so your version of events is on file right from the start, and you give them photos. Of course they’re trying it on, but you’ve made your insurer’s job of debunking it more difficult.

Billybagpuss · 21/06/2022 14:01

Worse case scenario, you will have to pay excess and loose a portion of your ncb.

did you inform your insurance company of the accident? You were both reversing, so I’d question how it could be anything but 50/50 but that is the insurance companies job to decide.

it does sound like they are cf?