Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is top CF?

41 replies

willithappen · 21/06/2022 13:56

Posting for traffic mainly and hoping for help/advice too

A couple weeks back I was in a very small car accident, where only the slightest of scratch on the car has occurred. To the point I didn't even bother putting in a claim because it's bare minimum damage

I had parked in a spot in a local town square, facing a shop. The road behind me is a one way road so to get out I had to reverse ever so slightly to the left and out onto the road. As I was doing so a car had driven past, waiting for it to go and then started reversing. This car then reversed back and went to go into the space next to me. Because they reversed at the same time as I was the front right of my car and the side right of theirs scraped against each other. Their car was is quite older, mines a 17 plated BMW so there was more of a scratch on theirs (possibly because they kept reversing while my car was more stationary.

Anyway, they have put a claim in for theirs. Was kind of expecting this but hoping that with logic it could be seen it wasn't entirely, if at all, my fault. I have just received a call today to tell me that the third party has put in an injury claim against me and is claiming they were injured in this!! I'm totally baffled and in disbelief considering the minuscule damage done and that fact my car couldn't have even been doing 2+ mph at the time either.

Is it possible an injury could occur or are they changing their luck with what they could get? They got out the car and we exchanged details and there was no sign of injury at all, she didn't say she had either and said it was a case of both of us reversing.

As it happened in front of the shop and I know one of the girls behind the till saw it all I'm going to get her details to put in as well.

If I'm the worst case scenario I was found at fault and they say she's injured from this because of me (which I'd be extremely baffled by but I don't know how all this works), what would happen to me? Claim against me, would I pay the excess on my insurance if it pays out to them and would I be due the other driver anything for injury?

Sorry, first time in any incident with another driver so totally clueless and upset by it all. I was in the car with my 5 month old dd at the time as well so my main concern was making sure she was okay (which she was - as it was literally bare minimum scraping)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
willithappen · 21/06/2022 21:08

The damage to mine id honestly something t-cut would solve, literally so minor.

Apparently her car is written off... it's an older cat so can only assume it's value isn't much but ugh just annoyed at someone chancing it really.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 21/06/2022 16:42

It will be their insurer trying to avoid paying out. The injury claim could be something as simple as the £25? charge the GP makes if you see them following an accident so not necessarily a scammer - but if it is being investigated its likely the insurance people think someone is trying to pull a fast one. Just hold to your story of the event. The worst your insurance can do is charge you for your excess and bump up your premiums going forward. (If they are going to do that however you might as well get your damage repaired through them too).

willithappen · 21/06/2022 16:28

Riverlee · 21/06/2022 16:26

If it was by a shop, is there any cctv footage covering the road? Matpy be worth checking, and if so, let the insurer know.

There's only one camera in that area and it faces the shop on the corner of the right side directly - doesn't look onto the area we are parked at unfortunately.

The camera is right on the corner but faced directly at their door entrance

OP posts:
willithappen · 21/06/2022 16:27

Some people will chance anything! Luckily I do have the details of the shop assistant now and can provide those. It's the costwald group who contacted me today so seems like it is being investigated. Contact from them is the first I heard about any injury. Her insurance had also called me last week directly but I informed them to go through my own insurance for anything they needed because I'd already provided all details. Wondering now if they were chancing catching me out in something and going to use that along with the injury to avoid payout themselves and for it to come from my insurance claim.

OP posts:
Riverlee · 21/06/2022 16:26

If it was by a shop, is there any cctv footage covering the road? Matpy be worth checking, and if so, let the insurer know.

annonymousse · 21/06/2022 16:21

I had a similar situation once. I was approached by a woman as I was getting out of my car and she claimed I had clipped her wing mirror. We checked her car and mine and no visible damage so to either car didn't think any more of it. I was in uniform with my name badge on show. A few days later I got a call from my insurance company. She was claiming her airbag had deployed and she had injuries. I was flabbergasted. The insurance company were very good. I told them what had happened and they said it sounded like she was chancing her arm. I never heard any more about it. I was just astonished that someone would so blatantly lie. She had obviously taken note of my name etc and I was easy to track down.

whynotwhatknot · 21/06/2022 16:05

No you dont pay anything unless youre having your car repaired aswell

as for the injury claim just let them get n with it not alot you can do but your premium will go up either way im afriad

Eightiesfan · 21/06/2022 16:00

I’m sure that if they put in a fraudulent claim for injuries and they are found out, their insurance will be declared null and void. I’m nowhere near an expert, but I think insurance companies have cracked down on ‘whiplash ‘ claims.

Marmight · 21/06/2022 15:50

Insurers are wise to low speed whiplash claims.
Try not to worry.
Fault in insurance terms is not the same as blame.
Just give your side of the story.
If a claim is below a certain amount, insurers normally pay out with no quibbling to save on staff costs and time.
As you were both moving, I can't see this being anything other than 50:50.

Blowthemandown · 21/06/2022 15:45

She’s scamming the insurer. If she was reversing in and you out, neither should have enough speed to cause injury. Make sure you state this. Get any cctv as well.

Thatboymum · 21/06/2022 15:43

I think it’s probs her legal team you get with insurance that’s prompted her to go for injuries as I was in a really similar accident and wasn’t injured and can’t tell you how many times they tried to push me to claim for injuries I didn’t have! I said no and that was it but I remember thinking it’s so wrong and the whole reason peoples insurance is so high. Deffo stand your ground and say you don’t accept sole responsibility it was an accident with both partys at fault or if you felt inclined counter sue her 😂

Nein9 · 21/06/2022 15:38

I don't think anyone has answered your question about court costs (sorry if someone has and I missed it).
Say it's the worst case scenario and you're found completely at fault and they accepted her injury claim as valid, even then your insurer would cover court costs, if it went that far. It never usually gets to court because one insurer will generally admit liability before going through that, especially if they think can't defend the claim and would be likely to lose. You would only pay your excess, if you wanted your car repaired. If not, you won't pay as your insurance covers her costs, but your premium will always go up, even with a no fault incident (as I've found!).

willithappen · 21/06/2022 15:30

HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 15:02

So did they start reversing in before you moved out?

No, as the space was empty when I started moving

OP posts:
HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 15:02

So did they start reversing in before you moved out?

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:58

Provided a diagram because I know how frustrating it is to read and respond to posts but not quite understand 🙈

Top bit is a layout of the area. The arrows show it's a one way system. I was in the section on the right, parked in with front facing the shop (no reverse parking only in place here for fine and very common to do). I was reversing out, only just got out a little. Had looked to the left, clear, looked to the right and focussed on there as it's a one way system and cars come that direction. The other car had driven past me but obviously then stopped to reverse park into the spot next to me.

There is usually a bit that makes it hard to see on the left when you reverse out of here so you need to reverse very slowly in the event a car drives past while you are reversing out. I'd stopped (my very bare creeping out reverse) to then check right again and it was at this point the cars scraped. So she has began reversing in as I was coming out and looking to the left and rear

Very prepared for it to be deemed 50/50, just was shocked at the injury claim.

To ask if this is top CF?
OP posts:
Useranon1 · 21/06/2022 14:58

Crayfishforyou · 21/06/2022 14:40

If you were stationary and they were moving they have no claim against you.

But OP wasn't stationary.

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 21/06/2022 14:55

Liability will be tricky to sort unless there is impartial evidence of you being stationary (like cctv / dashcam footage), although even with it it is likely that liability will be split as you both had a duty to ensure that the space you were reversing into was clear of obstructions.

In such a low velocity impact, injury is unlikely but not impossible and that's what you pay your insurer to deal with.

When you speak to them, tell them how minimal the impact was and offer either images of your car or to allow an Independent Assessor to inspect it so you can confirm the lack of damage caused.

Hopefully between that and the realisation that the third parties car repairs weren't extensive either, your insurer can contest the injury claim. It's a hassle but the company I work for argue this regularly.

Also, as PPs have said, you shouldn't have to pay anything outright as excess generally only applies if you claim for damage to your own car.

With regards to next years premiums, how they're calculated varies from insurer to insurer so some will charge a lot because you've had an accident, some will lower those charges if the claim didn't cost much etc however, liability itself is only part of what they consider and you can't alter most of it anyway.

HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 14:44

Crayfishforyou · 21/06/2022 14:40

If you were stationary and they were moving they have no claim against you.

I think this will depend on ops position on the road as she was mid manoeuvre by the sounds of it and in the road?

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:41

Sorry for the typos in that one 🤦🏼‍♀️

Huge thanks to those for explaining though and easing my mind a bit. Will get the witness details in and hopefully the story will tell itself. I have a video interview with them on Monday to give my side again

I'm a bit more calm about things now thank you!

OP posts:
Crayfishforyou · 21/06/2022 14:40

If you were stationary and they were moving they have no claim against you.

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:36

I didn't protect my no claims discount no :( rookie mistake. As I said first incident since I passed my text in 2011 so just never thought about these things.
It will go down to three years no claims if they find me at fault. I'm assuming it will be the same case if it's found 50/50

OP posts:
HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 14:26

The amount the premium goes up by will mostly depend on who they find to be at fault

HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 14:26

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:22

Thank you. I did read this somewhere but wasn't completely sure if it was accurate so thank you for also noting.

Hoping premiums don't go up too much, but I have to declare the incident whether it's my fault or not since it's been reported I believe so I will see how it affects things.
I'm such an over thinker it's been panicking me.
She had text me a couple of days after to ask if my daughter was okay - no mention of injury to her in that text either. Wondering if she was thinking I'd claim injury against baby from it

Is your no claims discount protected? I think most companies dont allow you to protect until you have built up 3 years

willithappen · 21/06/2022 14:22

HangOnToYourself · 21/06/2022 14:18

I dont think you need to pay anything on yours unless you are claiming for damages or injury. If you were claiming you would have to pay excess fee but as you have decided not to the insurance company will pay for her damage/injury claim. You will likely find your premiums go up though when you renew as you will need to declare it.

Thank you. I did read this somewhere but wasn't completely sure if it was accurate so thank you for also noting.

Hoping premiums don't go up too much, but I have to declare the incident whether it's my fault or not since it's been reported I believe so I will see how it affects things.
I'm such an over thinker it's been panicking me.
She had text me a couple of days after to ask if my daughter was okay - no mention of injury to her in that text either. Wondering if she was thinking I'd claim injury against baby from it

OP posts:
jcoc147 · 21/06/2022 14:22

In regards to your excess you will only need to pay if you are claiming for repairs to your vehicle unless 6our policy has a third party excess clause which are very rare to be included in most policies. In respect of the accident it will more than likely go down as a 50/50 split liability which will mean your insurers will pay for 50% of and damages to the third party vehicle plus 50% of any injury claim that they can prove via medical reports.

Swipe left for the next trending thread