Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to 'pay the landlords mortgage' but not your partners?

112 replies

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 11:00

So many threads I have seen where one person owns a house and the partner is moving in (sometimes planning) and they are told, you shouldn't pay towards their mortgage unless you are married and it is shared.

Why?

Why should someone live rent free just because they have chosen a partner who is in the position of owning a house?

Obviously you don't want to 'make a profit' on them, but equally you can't expect a free ride.

OP posts:
Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 13:15

Dancingwithhyenas · 21/06/2022 11:25

I think it’s okay to pay some rent but it shouldn’t be half the mortgage. It’s a different situation, you basically have almost no rights if you aren’t married so it should be a much smaller figure - like a lodger amount.

what if half the mortage is way cheaper than half the rent would be for a similar property in the area?

3 bed house in Crawley West Sussex - first one - £1350 a month
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/123928076#/?channel=RES_LET

3 bed house same area £325,000 - say they have 150k equity, mortgage is around £812 a month
www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/123549818#/?channel=RES_BUY

So if partner was renting the first one and paying 50% they would pay £675 a month, against £406 to the mortaged one

What is fair from that? I think that £406 is very fair

OP posts:
Madickenxx · 21/06/2022 11:33

It's obviously different as, with a rental, you have a tenancy agreement so will get a minimum of 2 months notice etc.

I've been discussing this recently with DP as we are talking about moving in together. We have the option of moving in to his and do some renovation work or buy a house together. If we decide for me to move in with him we will re-mortgage in joint names. I will also invest an amount into the house which will pay for the renovations. Basically, we will write a contract that ring-fences his current equity and my investment. The remainder will be mortgaged between us. Should we split up in the future we will get the ring-fenced money back and any further equity (as a result of reducing the mortgage or the house rising in value) will be split 50/50. This feels fair to me and both protects our own investments but also means that I will get the benefit of paying into the mortgage and any increase in the house value.

We are still in the early stages of discussing this and will get advise from professionals but it seems fair and reasonable to me. Personally I wouldn't move in with anyone and pay half the mortgage without either an arrangement as above, reduced contribution to allow the non-owner to create savings for protection, or a tenancy agreement of some kind.

Dancingwithhyenas · 21/06/2022 11:25

I think it’s okay to pay some rent but it shouldn’t be half the mortgage. It’s a different situation, you basically have almost no rights if you aren’t married so it should be a much smaller figure - like a lodger amount.

SeasonFinale · 21/06/2022 11:22

RewildingAmbridge · 21/06/2022 11:19

I agree OP, when now DH first moved in with me he was renting and I owned my home (mortgage), he paid half of everything because he's an adult and should pay his way, it was still significantly cheaper for him than private renting so he had no objections. We did discuss what would happen if we split and he said well I can save more each month than I could in rented so I'll be better off anyway. We liked out savings plus the equity from my property when we got married and bought our first house together, but neither of us would've felt hard done by if it hadn't panned out that way.
There was no way I was paying the mortgage by myself while he had a shedload more disposable income than me and I was putting a roof over his head, if he'd suggested it he wouldn't have moved in.

This is far too sensible and normal an answer for MN Grin and exactly what we did too.

RewildingAmbridge · 21/06/2022 11:19

I agree OP, when now DH first moved in with me he was renting and I owned my home (mortgage), he paid half of everything because he's an adult and should pay his way, it was still significantly cheaper for him than private renting so he had no objections. We did discuss what would happen if we split and he said well I can save more each month than I could in rented so I'll be better off anyway. We liked out savings plus the equity from my property when we got married and bought our first house together, but neither of us would've felt hard done by if it hadn't panned out that way.
There was no way I was paying the mortgage by myself while he had a shedload more disposable income than me and I was putting a roof over his head, if he'd suggested it he wouldn't have moved in.

BackToTheTop · 21/06/2022 11:18

Because when you leave a rented property you can't make a claim to the house, or make the landlord sell the house and you get a % of the equity.

Pay your partners mortgage, you split and move out, there's a possibility you can make a claim to any equity in the house

Dotjones · 21/06/2022 11:14

If you rent somewhere and are not a complete idiot you will have signed a tenancy agreement which gives you certain rights, such as limits on the notice you get before eviction. If you move in with a partner it's unusual to have a signed agreement.

Your basic idea is right though, partners who move in should share the bills and pay "rent" to the other partner. It should be documented though so that both partners have a degree of protection when the relationship goes wrong.

Gizlotsmum · 21/06/2022 11:08

If the relationship breaks down you aren’t entitled to a notice period to leave, you have far less protection than when renting (although obviously that isn’t always secure you do have legal protections

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 21/06/2022 11:07

Because with a landlord you a degree of legal protection?
Because a landlord/tenant relationship is a business arrangement ?

Needmorelego · 21/06/2022 11:07

When you rent you know that the house belongs to the landlord and will never belong to you.
If you are moving in with some in a relationship (with the hope that you will be together forever) but you don't marry but live together for 45 years and then split you could end up with zero money and have a house that you helped pay for but you have no claim on.
If you don't want to marry you should at least get added to the mortgage as proof you are paying towards it.

AquaticSewingMachine · 21/06/2022 11:06

Because your landlord doesn't owe you jack shit (other than managing their properly legally and responsibly) and you probably aren't going to cut your work hours in order to take care of your landlord's kids.

If you are a woman and your partner is accumulating equity in a home in which you have no stake, it's extremely sensible to think about whether that's what you want and what your situation would be if the relationship were to end.

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:05

You aren’t wrong. A reasonable amount of ‘rent’ as a contribution is completely normal in the real world.
The argument on here is he would be paying the mortgage if he lived alone, but the other partner would be paying rent or a mortgage to live elsewhere and too.
However this is mumsnet and if a woman moves in with her partner she shouldn’t pay a penny but if the genders are flipped he would be a freeloading scumbag.