Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to 'pay the landlords mortgage' but not your partners?

112 replies

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 11:00

So many threads I have seen where one person owns a house and the partner is moving in (sometimes planning) and they are told, you shouldn't pay towards their mortgage unless you are married and it is shared.

Why?

Why should someone live rent free just because they have chosen a partner who is in the position of owning a house?

Obviously you don't want to 'make a profit' on them, but equally you can't expect a free ride.

OP posts:
CurzonDax · 22/06/2022 09:43

Whilst I do agree with what some PP have said above about legal protection etc, I agree with the OP -yes you may not have a share in the equity etc, but not paying anything at all? Where in the world would you ever be able to live anywhere for free?

When DH and I first started dating, he owned a one-bed flat, and I rented a one-bed flat. (His mortgage was £480 a month + £170 service charge a month = £650). I was renting for £750 a month. Between us, we were spending £1400 for our places (we both had bills on top of that), but we were only using one of them - we were spending 7 nights a week together (at mine, as I had pets).

Eventually, my landlord gave me notice, and I was stressed trying to find somewhere else to live, with pets. He sat me down, and suggested I move in with him (we were spending all our time together anyway). We did have a chat about finances - everything was brought up, including the equity etc. He assured me he would never just throw me out, if we broke up, without somewhere else to go, but to be honest, I guess I never had that security.

I ended up paying half of everything - £325 for half the mortgage, and service charge (a lot less than my £750 rent), and half the bills. I can't remember what the bills cost now, but even with them, I was still paying less than what I had been paying in rent alone. I guess you could say that my security was the extra money that I was able to save, and so had savings if I needed to find somewhere quickly to move out.

We both agreed to save the difference we were both saving (we did), but keep the savings separate. The idea was eventually we could use the savings, and sell his flat for a deposit for somewhere together.

Two years after I first moved in with him, we both had savings, I had gained a little inheritance (very unexpectedly), and he had some money left over from the flat sale - we combined all the above and bought a house together (with a mortgage). However, I did say that I would only buy a property with him, if we would eventually get married. 6 months after we moved into our home, we got engaged, and 2 years after that, we married. Now we share all finances etc.

The truth of the matter is, I benefitted massively from moving in with him - I was able to save a lot, but the reality is that he had more equity on his flat, than I had in savings, and the intention was to use that for a house deposit together (at the time, I never expected an inheritance).

RudsyFarmer · 22/06/2022 09:39

I can see the argument. You’re not sleeping with the landlord, nor are you undertaking two or more people’s household chores when you rent alone. It’s all the extras that come along with a relationship alongside paying their mortgage. So when you break up they are financially better off and the other party has lost money, self respect and potentially a broken heart into the bargain.

PerfectlyQuiet · 22/06/2022 09:32

@JenniferPlantain That's a really tricky situation. I think I'd be telling them to speak to Solicetors too as I wouldn't know what was right. I suspect it's a maths question. Add up the total costs of everything and who paid what and work out what added value to the flat.

One of my kids partners stays at their house a lot and doesn't pay anything but they are paying for a flat elsewhere. My kids house is much bigger and nicer and not shared so is obviously a nicer place to stay. So far they don't pay anything. My kid likes that house to be theirs and for their partner to have no say in anything.

Fushiadreams · 22/06/2022 09:14

I totally agree with you and can’t grasp why some folks think if you move in you should live rent free. Wtf is that about.

Hont1986 · 22/06/2022 09:12

@JenniferPlantain you really can't work out what is right in that situation? I think it's fair to say that B should try to get back their contribution to the improvements, but imagining that 'they' (let's face it, she) should get half the equity for a house she doesn't own and only lived in for four years is ridiculously entitled.

MRex · 22/06/2022 08:16

The common issues tend to be someone losing out on universal credit due to the partner now sharing, or being asked to pay towards renovations in a house they don't own. Contributions to a mortgage can create rights to a property and both parties need a contract to protect them, but that doesn't mean that payment of rent is always wrong. Ringfencing initial deposits is sensible, but I don't really understand these "partnerships" where income and expenses aren't shared, it doesn't seem very much like "partners" to me and therefore more likely to break up accordingly.

femfemlicious · 22/06/2022 07:48

Needmorelego · 21/06/2022 11:07

When you rent you know that the house belongs to the landlord and will never belong to you.
If you are moving in with some in a relationship (with the hope that you will be together forever) but you don't marry but live together for 45 years and then split you could end up with zero money and have a house that you helped pay for but you have no claim on.
If you don't want to marry you should at least get added to the mortgage as proof you are paying towards it.

You shouldnt end up with "zero money". You should have been saving what you would have been paying for rent if you were living by yourself?. Half of a mortgage would be much cheaper than rent!

femfemlicious · 22/06/2022 07:43

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:05

You aren’t wrong. A reasonable amount of ‘rent’ as a contribution is completely normal in the real world.
The argument on here is he would be paying the mortgage if he lived alone, but the other partner would be paying rent or a mortgage to live elsewhere and too.
However this is mumsnet and if a woman moves in with her partner she shouldn’t pay a penny but if the genders are flipped he would be a freeloading scumbag.

👏👏THIS exactly what its like on here!

femfemlicious · 22/06/2022 07:41

@Luidaeg i agree with you 100%. Most times what they pay towards the mortgage is much less than renting as well...why should you live in someones gouse for free?

FortniteBoysMum · 22/06/2022 07:39

Personally it's because with a landlord you have rights. You have to be given notice to leave etc. With a partner you could pay them one day and the next they throw you out. You have no legal rights and because you live with them in their home they can also hold it over you if you disagree with them. I know many people who when arguing their partner is not pulling their weight with household chores they get told if you don't like it leave. That's no way to live.

BanjoKnickers · 22/06/2022 07:17

DockOTheBay · 21/06/2022 18:10

Its one of the (many) mumsnet double standards.

Woman owns a house, man moves in and doesn't contribute to the mortgage/pay rent = he's a cocklodger, wants a free ride, is taking advantage.

Man owns a house, woman moves in and doesn't contribute to the mortgage/rent = sensible

So true Grin

DinoWoman · 22/06/2022 07:12

@chiffchaffchiff And yet, @JenniferPlantain has told a story that shows the negative side to the gamble of moving into a partner's home. I understand that sometimes it works out, but it's a heart over head decision. I would never risk it.

If I had a partner that owned a home with lots of money paid into their mortgage, then I would be happy for that money to be contractually ringfenced in case we broke up. I just wouldn't want to risk being like poor B in @JenniferPlantain's story.

chiffchaffchiff · 21/06/2022 20:59

The partner receiving rent from their partner has absolutely no incentive to share a mortgage in the future either. It just seems like a very heart over head decision to make for the 'renter' in the relationship.

And yet here I am, with my name on a mortgage I only have because my (now DH) had 150k equity in his property. I never begrudged paying him rent before my name was on the property. I paid a fraction more to live in his 3 bed house than I paid for my room in a shared house and wouldn't have been close to getting on the property ladder if we hadn't moved in together anyway.

Beancounter1 · 21/06/2022 20:16

B should give A a backdated invoice for their half of all the childcare fees.

DockOTheBay · 21/06/2022 18:10

Its one of the (many) mumsnet double standards.

Woman owns a house, man moves in and doesn't contribute to the mortgage/pay rent = he's a cocklodger, wants a free ride, is taking advantage.

Man owns a house, woman moves in and doesn't contribute to the mortgage/rent = sensible

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 18:03

@JenniferPlantain that is a really tough one

Thinking about it - B should have been saving the money they saved on rent (hindsight is a wonderful thing) and not paid anything towards the renovations

OP posts:
JenniferPlantain · 21/06/2022 16:03

Totally agree OP.

The issue with a partner is lines get very blurred. If you do move in and subsidise rent you need terms written down somewhere

I am friends with a couple who are in the process of splitting up. Going to explain and try not to apply gender, as my DH and I are both friends with one of the couple and we cannot work out what is 'right' and we suspect there is no clear answer in the absence of marriage (hope this isn't hijacking the thread but I think it's relevant - just report comment if it bugs you).

Partner A owned a house for 3 years before the start of the relationship and put down a 30% deposit. When they got together (they had been friends for a long time) B was trying to buy a flat but in the end they moved in together to A's house because they couldn't rent anywhere of a similar size for anything close to the mortgage (London).

They have done 2 rounds of work on the house, funded 75% by A and 25% by B which has significantly increased value. Of course, when they were doing this work they were talking about it being their 'forever home' and where they wanted to watch their children grow up.

They lived together in the property for 4 years before having DC (1 DS).

They are not married.

B used to pay half the mortgage and bills (which in total was a lot less than they paid in rent alone), but for past 2 years has paid nursery fees for DC, which is actually higher than mortgage. They both pay 50% of bills.

B believes the house should be sold, deposit and first 3 years of equity returned to A and they should then get half the equity each from the date B moved in. A believes the house in in their name only, B had no deposit to buy anywhere before moving in and therefore B was renting and is not entitled to anything. We are talking about very large sums of money.

This is the problem with paying a partner's mortgage - one person feels they are investing in their future as a couple, when in reality if they split, they (may) become 'just a tenant'.

(We've told them both to talk to solicitors but whatever the conclusion they will probably both be unhappy and forced to compromise.)

FlemCandango · 21/06/2022 15:49

The difference is obvious. You pay rent to a LL and have a tenancy agreement then you have a legal right to occupy the property. The LL has obligations in law and so does the tenant. You have legal protection to peaceful enjoyment of that property and a legal process of eviction.

If you move in with a partner, none of those legal protections apply, if the relationship ends you can be required to leave, and would have to apply to the courts if you wanted to have your right to remain decided, share of equity etc.

It may make sense to a homeowner to require a "rent" / contribution to the mortgage if a partner moves in with them. But it does not equate to a legal tenancy.

If you live with someone you are not legally protected unless you formalise your relationship with a civil partnership or marriage. No point in being naive about this.

DinoWoman · 21/06/2022 15:36

I wouldn't move into a house my partner owned and pay rent. I would only move in with a partner by sharing a mortgage on a new property. I suppose some people may not be able to even afford to get a mortgage with the partner that already owns a property. I would still rent privately and save for a deposit if that was my situation, for the protections mentioned above from a tenancy agreement.

The partner receiving rent from their partner has absolutely no incentive to share a mortgage in the future either. It just seems like a very heart over head decision to make for the 'renter' in the relationship.

oldageprancer · 21/06/2022 15:31

You don't fuck your landlord, although of course you may feel they are fucking you.

If it's a lodger type arrangement with your own space then it's easier to see the logic of paying rent. But charging full room rental and offering half a bed and no time and space to yourself isn't really a lodger agreement either.

I'm not massively opposed to the concept, where it's a fairly new relationship, but when it's something longer term it's something I would feel less comfortable with. It leaves the house owner with a lot of power as the rent contribution might be stopping the other person from saving for their own deposit, whilst also making it hard for them to leave as they would also become homeless.

You'll probably find a lot of people think landlords are parasites as well though, so thry may think paying rent in both scenarios is terrible

altiara · 21/06/2022 15:20

i think you should pay rent, but not necessarily half of the market rate as you aren’t getting what you’d pay for if you were renting your own 1 bed house for example, you’re only getting half a room. Plus if it’s not your property, you don’t want to be worse off if you do split up, so you need to be able to save your own money for a deposit.
But I’d agree yes you’d need to pay rent and bills.
Then to complicate things, what if the owner partner earns loads, then you might be paying higher rent and bills than you can afford or would have chosen. Sometimes the owner might have no mortgage. Or the owner might not have much money and partner moving in increases their bills a lot.

There aren’t usually threads about people both benefiting, usually its when there’s something unfair about it.

Whammyyammy · 21/06/2022 15:18

I was once asked by a friend (not a close one) if they could rent my vacant flat for 50% market value as I had no outstanding mortgage on it....🙄 were no longer friends ss I declined her kind offer.

It's irrelevant what the monthly mortgage payment is on a house v rent payment.
Maintenance, deposit, amount of mortgage paid etc need considering. The going rate is only fair way

chiffchaffchiff · 21/06/2022 15:08

I tried to make this point on a thread the other day. Most posters were horrified that a woman was willingly paying to live in her boyfriends 3 bedroom house.

Mumzoo5070 · 21/06/2022 15:06

LOL at thinking lodgers rent is a much smaller amount than half a mortgage.

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 13:16

as the partner is benefiting from the owners equity by living there cheaper, and the owner is benefitting from a contribution to the mortgage - so everyone wins

OP posts: