Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to 'pay the landlords mortgage' but not your partners?

112 replies

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 11:00

So many threads I have seen where one person owns a house and the partner is moving in (sometimes planning) and they are told, you shouldn't pay towards their mortgage unless you are married and it is shared.

Why?

Why should someone live rent free just because they have chosen a partner who is in the position of owning a house?

Obviously you don't want to 'make a profit' on them, but equally you can't expect a free ride.

OP posts:
JuneJubilee · 22/06/2022 15:46

@JenniferPlantain

i think A should get the 30% deposit, then a split of something like A65 B35 of the remaining capital, but that also needs to be varied depending on where their DC is going to live.

DitzyBluebells · 22/06/2022 15:40

Presumably your personal contribution is low, so you'll always be subsidised and not need to worry about it.

Not sure if you're meaning to talk about my own personal circumstances her or if it's a general "you", but if you're meaning me then you're way off the mark, which is unsurprising really considering you know absolutely nothing about me.

Yes you're right that the partner moving into someone's home has no rental costs but they don't have "no living expenses". They have a proportion of the bills to pay, on a property that they had no say in choosing either the area/street/size/running costs/decor of and have no security to live there. One partner moving into another partners home is a compromise for both of them, it's not some kind of no-strings freebie for the one who moves in.

Luidaeg · 22/06/2022 15:38

Will you move in and pay half my mortgage?" isn't love

"I don't want to move in with you if it means starting again in a new property" isn't love

Can I live with you rent free because you own a property is cocklodging

OP posts:
Hont1986 · 22/06/2022 15:36

Paying rent to a Partner with no agreement in place can indeed be seen as you contributing to the mortgage and could indeed in a long term relationship put you in a position to claim an interest in the property.

No it can't. This is a very pernicious myth on Mumsnet and I wish people would stop repeating it because it encourages women to accept 'partnerships' rather than marriages, thinking they have some legal protection.

The circumstances to claim a beneficial interest in property are quite difficult to achieve. If you pay for an extension, or take over the mortgage for years while your partner is out of work, yes then there can be a potential claim (that will cost thousands to litigate). But your common-or-garden situation of a woman transferring £500 a month to her partner's account does not create any interest.

I see plenty of people encouraging other posters to start charging their kids rent at 18, why aren't they worried that their kids are getting into a position to claim an interest in the property?!

DitzyBluebells · 22/06/2022 15:29

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 13:37

Why would a partner want to move in with you if you're displaying signs from the beginning that you value something else (money and property and keeping the status quo) more than you value having your partner around?

Nobody would move in together if that was the expectation. Who can confidently say it's a long term relationship before they have lived together? Someone saying "I'll move in but I'm not contributing until I'm on the mortgage" would set off red flags for me.

You're twisting my words, taking things out of context by missing off the rest of my post. I didn't talk about not contributing, I actually specifically said the partner would be contributing - just not to the mortgage. I talked about not paying towards a mortgage when you're not on the deeds of that property which is totally reasonable. If someone wants equal finances then either rent together or buy together, not both pay towards a mortgage in one person's name, that's unfair and grabby.

MRex · 22/06/2022 14:01

@DitzyBluebells - the person moving in has moved in your scenario from paying all the rent to paying no accommodation costs, while the honeowner still has all the mortgage to pay as well as additional wear and tear on the property. Better yet, the person moving in might gain rental income from their own property over and above their mortgage, yet have no accommodation costs to pay of their own. You see, putting words in bold doesn't actually make things fair or not fair, what you need to do is write out the full impact on finances for both parties.

What's strictly fair is that neither party should lose out by living together, that each should contribute according to their means insofar as they are happy to do so, and that they should have a contract to guarantee fair treatment in separating. If one is happy to subsidise the other then they are at liberty to do so knowingly, but that makes them generous rather than making the situation fair. Presumably your personal contribution is low, so you'll always be subsidised and not need to worry about it.

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 13:37

Why would a partner want to move in with you if you're displaying signs from the beginning that you value something else (money and property and keeping the status quo) more than you value having your partner around?

Nobody would move in together if that was the expectation. Who can confidently say it's a long term relationship before they have lived together? Someone saying "I'll move in but I'm not contributing until I'm on the mortgage" would set off red flags for me.

ThePants999 · 22/06/2022 12:58

If I rented a home (maybe because I liked not being tied to a property) while having an amount of money sufficient to buy a house sitting in investments earning me interest, nobody would think it's reasonable for a partner to move in with me without contributing to the rent just because of other assets I owned. So why should things be different if I had exactly the same value of assets but they took the form of a property instead?

DitzyBluebells · 22/06/2022 12:24

To answer the OP - because the landlord is running a business and your partner isn't. A landlord has no moral obligation to care for you as anything other than a tenant. With a partner the whole point of the partnership is that you supposedly care about each other. If a partner wants to share the mortgage they should sell their home and invest the money (or keep it and rent it out to someone else) and start from scratch buying a shared home with their partner. A person shouldn't pay "rent" to their partner who they live with because it's not rent it's their grabby partner using them as a cash cow. Living in someone else's home because they've invited you to share it with them (whilst having zero rights to remain there and zero obligation from the homeowner for giving any notice period to leave, which you get if renting) isn't freeloading, it's of mutual benefit to both people because the homeowner would ordinarily have to pay all the mortgage (with the rights that gives them) and all the bills. If they invite their partner to move in they're only going to be paying part of the bills. So they get to keep all the rights to their house that comes with having bought it and having to pay the mortgage on it, their living costs reduce because someone else is paying part of the bills with them and they get the life enhancement of living with their partner.

"Will you move in and pay half my mortgage?" isn't love

"I don't want to move in with you if it means starting again in a new property" isn't love

Why would a partner want to move in with you if you're displaying signs from the beginning that you value something else (money and property and keeping the status quo) more than you value having your partner around?

theemmadilemma · 22/06/2022 11:58

I don't think it's an issue paying a Partner rent, I do however think it all needs to be very carefully laid out, and ideally legally tied up as to the expectations.

Paying rent to a Partner with no agreement in place can indeed be seen as you contributing to the mortgage and could indeed in a long term relationship put you in a position to claim an interest in the property.

It's needs to be agreed and clear if they are paying 'rent' or if they are contributing towards a property for the protection of all parties.

SnackSizeRaisin · 22/06/2022 11:41

Initially an arrangement where both parties are paying less per month than before seems sensible. But if the relationship is long term and there are children, it makes more sense for both people to go on the mortgage and deeds (ringfencing off the amount that the original owner put in). That way both are on the housing ladder. The other option is for the non owner to buy a separate property and rent it out. Obviously it depends on a lot of things like how much each earns, how much they contribute to housework, maintenance, childcare, etc

70kid · 22/06/2022 10:30

My son is buying a part buy rent that he can afford on his own ( big deposit 50k)
His partner is going to move in but will pay some rent - why wouldn’t they /

My son is paying the mortgage / rent and council tax
his partner will probably pay around £500 month at present he is paying £750 a month for a tiny en-suite room in a shared house of 7 people :

why shouldn’t someone pay to live somewhere I never get this logic

My sons flat that he is it’s a lovely 2 bed /2 bathroom apartment
and his partner wouldn’t get to live there for £400 a month it’s a choice that they are free to make £750 for a tiny room in a shared house
£400 a month in a huge apartment set in 10 acres of parkland . I know what I would choose

Renting just a room would cost a min of £600 -£700 in my city .
1 bed flat around £1100 plus bills .

So my son could get £600 a month min if he let the spare room and bathroom

They both win

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 22/06/2022 10:19

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:05

You aren’t wrong. A reasonable amount of ‘rent’ as a contribution is completely normal in the real world.
The argument on here is he would be paying the mortgage if he lived alone, but the other partner would be paying rent or a mortgage to live elsewhere and too.
However this is mumsnet and if a woman moves in with her partner she shouldn’t pay a penny but if the genders are flipped he would be a freeloading scumbag.

I agree.

Hallyup89 · 22/06/2022 10:17

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:05

You aren’t wrong. A reasonable amount of ‘rent’ as a contribution is completely normal in the real world.
The argument on here is he would be paying the mortgage if he lived alone, but the other partner would be paying rent or a mortgage to live elsewhere and too.
However this is mumsnet and if a woman moves in with her partner she shouldn’t pay a penny but if the genders are flipped he would be a freeloading scumbag.

This.

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 10:16

DinoWoman · 22/06/2022 07:12

@chiffchaffchiff And yet, @JenniferPlantain has told a story that shows the negative side to the gamble of moving into a partner's home. I understand that sometimes it works out, but it's a heart over head decision. I would never risk it.

If I had a partner that owned a home with lots of money paid into their mortgage, then I would be happy for that money to be contractually ringfenced in case we broke up. I just wouldn't want to risk being like poor B in @JenniferPlantain's story.

Yes but her friend was paying for renovations on a house she didn't own and had no legal interest in. Before DH and I got married and I went on the mortgage he paid for everything for the house. When the boiler broke, when the roof needed fixing, when the bathroom was replaced, when we decorated rooms etc. I only paid rent for living there. According to Mumsnet I shouldn't have been paying because it was his mortgage and he would be paying it anyway.

Ejk1990 · 22/06/2022 10:15

DockOTheBay · 21/06/2022 18:10

Its one of the (many) mumsnet double standards.

Woman owns a house, man moves in and doesn't contribute to the mortgage/pay rent = he's a cocklodger, wants a free ride, is taking advantage.

Man owns a house, woman moves in and doesn't contribute to the mortgage/rent = sensible

Summed up prefectly!

Trisolaris · 22/06/2022 10:11

Every couples situation will be different due to income and prior living arrangements so I have one simple rule that I think should be the number one priority:

Both partners should be better off each month by the arrangement than they were before. (Ideally by similar amounts/percentages)

StanleyStanleyStanley · 22/06/2022 10:09

It's already been mentioned about the lack of legal protection moving in with a partner. They could ask you to vacate the premise with zero notice and that's that.

But I think there's another key difference - when you move into a rented property you can decide where the furniture goes, you have access to all the rooms - it's a house you rent but it's your home to make decisions with.

If you move into a partner's house you are just co-existing in their space. You can't choose which bedroom you'd like as your own - the partner has already decided. You can't just decide one day you want a new sofa/ table/ mattress. You don't really get any of the real 'home' experience.

That said I don't agree that a contribution to rent shouldn't be paid, I just don't agree with half. The owner benefits completely, still retains control and decision making abilities and can terminate the situation immediately whereas the life-in partner is placing their entire security in the hands of the owner with no protection.

CurzonDax · 22/06/2022 10:07

@JenniferPlantain - That's a tough one. I get that B hasn't been saving wisely (as A recommended), but A has still benefitted from B living there; paying 50% of mortgage, contributions towards renovations, and 100% of childcare costs. That's a lot of saved money for A.

However, they do have a child involved. If they sell, and divide as B suggests, does A have enough for a home (something of a similar standard, even if slightly smaller) for their child (assuming she will be the resident parent here, which I appreciate may be wrong). Will B be able to buy/rent somewhere, with space for the child to visit and stay over? B will also need to pay maintenance for the child. Yep, this is complicated.

I'm also worried about a friend, who is a similar situation. Her and her DP have children from previous relationships; she is pregnant with their first child together (a child which he never wanted, and he was open about that at start of pregnancy). She owns her own home (outright, no mortgage) - he lives with her, and pays rent etc. He has just put in an offer for a bigger property for them all to live in - it will be solely in his name, and he is putting forward all deposit etc. I asked friend if she was keeping her property (I honestly thought, she was selling it, and they were going 50:50 together on new home, in both names) - she said, "Of course, I'm keeping it - it will still be mine, and will be needed to pay the mortgage". The gist of the situation is - friend will be keeping her property, and renting it out - she will then use this money to pay her DP rent to live in his home (fair enough, he has paid her rent for years).

My worry is - things will get sticky. They want to keep their properties separate, as they both have children (makes sense), but his property is bigger, and worth more. If they were to split, I can see his argument being, "You have a property - give your tenants notice, and move back", but her argument will be, "You have larger assets, and we have a child together. I have also paid X into this home."

We do have the kind of relationship, where I can be blunt and speak to her about things, but I could see she was getting defensive when I started to mention the above, and so I backed down (it's her life, not mine). He won't marry her, as he has larger assets (he has already said that).

Igmum · 22/06/2022 10:00

I think both should benefit. Most of the time (both working, both with some disposable income etc) this means that yes, you should pay rent. Look how critical Mumsnet is of cocklodgers - quite rightly. The amount of that rent may vary and may be purely nominal (one person on low wages, one on high for example). There may even need to be a transfer of funds the other way (someone loses Universal Credit or other benefits). But yes, the majority of the time, if you move in you pay some rent.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 22/06/2022 09:57

What do you suggest should happen when one partner already owns a house outright?

MrsSkylerWhite · 22/06/2022 09:55

Because a landlord is running a business and selling a service. A partner isn’t, presumably. If they’re happy to accept no rent, that’s up to them.

GetThatHelmetOn · 22/06/2022 09:52

I honestly don’t know. Even if you are not paying towards the mortgage you will be expected to be contributing in other ways in possibly the same amount so it doesn’t make any difference as long as the contribution was less than the total you would spend in rent and other living costs elsewhere.

Now, if you start thinking about children or s/he asks you to sell your own house, you either get in the mortgage or move out. There is soooo much else to consider when there are children involved.

rwalker · 22/06/2022 09:47

People get too blinkered on the finance side of it . Your pay to live somewhere a roof over your head how the person finances it is really nothing to do with you .
In basic terms you are paying for a service .

JenniferPlantain · 22/06/2022 09:46

Really interesting reading replies to my friends' situation.

For ref A is a woman and B is a man - though I get why you though it was the other way round @Hont1986 because it often seems to be that way. I think if they hadn't been planning for a future together for years and had no DC I'd agree with what you've said. I think I largely still do, but I can also empathise somewhat with B's position. Ultimately I suppose I believe they took gamble that didn't pay off.

@Luidaeg that's exactly what A is now saying - you were saving hundreds a month, which he ultimately used for hobbies and travel, rather than a deposit for an investment property or ISA or something (which A actively encouraged him to do, she claims).

I guess once you know a relationship is going to be long term, it is time to talk Trust Deeds. Unromantic but perhaps worth an awkward conversation for everyone to feel more secure and have absolute clarity.

Swipe left for the next trending thread