Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to 'pay the landlords mortgage' but not your partners?

112 replies

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 11:00

So many threads I have seen where one person owns a house and the partner is moving in (sometimes planning) and they are told, you shouldn't pay towards their mortgage unless you are married and it is shared.

Why?

Why should someone live rent free just because they have chosen a partner who is in the position of owning a house?

Obviously you don't want to 'make a profit' on them, but equally you can't expect a free ride.

OP posts:
FloydPepper · 22/06/2022 19:50

RepublicOfNarnia · 22/06/2022 18:23

Landlords shouldn't exist.

But there's no way in hell I'd contribute to a partners home and receive nothing in return.

There’s no way I’d let someone move into my house without paying towards living there

and there’s no way I’d give them a share of my house

married, kids, it’s different. A girlfriend, nope

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 19:40

So when I moved in with my ex-husband he lived in a beautiful house in a lovely area that needed an awful lot doing to it. My house was alright but in a shit area to be honest anyway the decision was made that my house would be sold upon us getting married and that the funds I received would go into the marital home paid for the way didn’t pay for a few holidays that kinda thing.

naturally when we got divorced he completely forgot about the check for 65 grand that I paid into his account.

as it was 14 years ago unfortunately none of the banking records went back that far that were available to me anyway we got divorced during lockdown.

and all of the equity ended up going to the solicitors anyway in costs.

if I had my time again that is absolutely no way I would do anything other than sell both properties put equal amounts into them by way of deposit legally protect that and if either of you have any surplus money, you do as you please with it.
my solicitor said the law has very little to do with justice my god did I find out to my detriment that’s true.

genuinely didn’t matter who was right and who was wrong.

muddyboots · 22/06/2022 19:32

When I moved in to my boyfriend's (now husband) house I paid him the amount I had been paying my landlord. We had a verbal agreement that he would then use the extra money towards saving for home improvements. If it didn't work out with us he would give me some money out of this - although I accepted that if things went really wrong he could be a dick and I could have nothing.

After a couple of years we realised that we needed to spend a lot more money on the house so I made him marry me and have increased my monthly financial contribution to our combined pot.

BelperLawnmower · 22/06/2022 18:44

RepublicOfNarnia · 22/06/2022 18:23

Landlords shouldn't exist.

But there's no way in hell I'd contribute to a partners home and receive nothing in return.

You get accommodation.

(Unless you don't live there, in which case I agree, don't contribute.)

RepublicOfNarnia · 22/06/2022 18:23

Landlords shouldn't exist.

But there's no way in hell I'd contribute to a partners home and receive nothing in return.

WalkerWalking · 22/06/2022 18:17

There's never any pretence that you and your landlord are entering into an equal partnership.

I wouldn't expect a fully equal, trusting relationship with someone you just met. But on the other hand, I would consider a financial imbalance, where one partner has no financial security, within an long term, committed relationship, to be financially abusive. And it's very grey as to where exactly that changeover happens.

caringcarer · 22/06/2022 18:15

Most btl LL only have interest only mortgage so not paying down capital. So actually you are not buying LL their house as many think. Also LL have to give 2 month's notice soon to be unable to ask a person to leave unless they are selling house or they or family member going to live there. In a relationship if it goes wrong you will be prettyuch.put on your ear.

CaptSkippy · 22/06/2022 18:10
  • My landlord has no access to my house and doesn't make a mess here, only I do
  • I don't have to watch his kids or take them to school
  • I have a decent notice period
  • I can hold my landlord legally accountable for a lack of repairs
  • I don't have to have sex with my landlord (people underestimate the importance of this)
  • I am not expected to be "grateful" towards my landlord. We have our agreements and responsibilities on paper
  • My landlord does not use ulities in my home that I would then have to pay for
  • Everything in my home belongs to me and I can take it all with me when I go
  • I don't have to do my landlord's laundry
  • I don't have to buy extra food to cook for my landlord as well
  • All the guests in my home are there for me and not my landlord
  • I don't have to let my landlord know when/where I am going and what time I'll be back.

And most impotantly of all, It's not half the mortgage I pay. It's more like a fraction of it. That is if my landlord has a morgage at all and doesn't own the building outright.

I pay for the right to use it as I see fit without having to discuss things first. As long as I don't do any damage I am golden.

XenoBitch · 22/06/2022 18:03

orwellwasright · 22/06/2022 18:01

It's not ok to pay the landlord's mortgage though. Private rental shouldn't exist.

What is the alternative to private rental? Social housing? There is a waiting list for that.

orwellwasright · 22/06/2022 18:01

It's not ok to pay the landlord's mortgage though. Private rental shouldn't exist.

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 17:58

You're twisting my words, taking things out of context by missing off the rest of my post. I didn't talk about not contributing, I actually specifically said the partner would be contributing - just not to the mortgage. I talked about not paying towards a mortgage when you're not on the deeds of that property which is totally reasonable. If someone wants equal finances then either rent together or buy together, not both pay towards a mortgage in one person's name, that's unfair and grabby.

I didn't include the whole of your post because it was quite long. I stand by what I said. I happily paid rent to my DH with no expectation of an interest in his property if things didn't work out. Why on earth would he have rented a different place with me when he already owned his own property? Rent for a commercial landlord would be more expensive than his house, he'd have to take on the additional expense of remortgaging because you need a buy to let mortgage, he'd have to risk having his house ruined by dodgy tenants or paying the mortgage while it was empty on top of the rent. Financially it makes no sense.

As for buying together, what incentive is there to incur those costs if you already have a perfectly good house? I moved on to the mortgage later but it was very much later when we were engaged and knew the relationship wasn't going to fizzle out in a couple of years.

XenoBitch · 22/06/2022 17:50

I moved in with someone who owned their home. I signed something to say I had no interest in the house.
Maybe my circumstance was unusual as I was unable to work and contribute anything anyway, and because I was living with them I was unable to claim any benefits.

FloydPepper · 22/06/2022 17:39

emeraldcity2000 · 22/06/2022 17:13

@FloydPepper if you see it purely as rent then it is additional income - did you declare and pay tax on it?

No it’s a contribution to a bill, not an income

Sandinmyknickers · 22/06/2022 17:30

RewildingAmbridge · 21/06/2022 11:19

I agree OP, when now DH first moved in with me he was renting and I owned my home (mortgage), he paid half of everything because he's an adult and should pay his way, it was still significantly cheaper for him than private renting so he had no objections. We did discuss what would happen if we split and he said well I can save more each month than I could in rented so I'll be better off anyway. We liked out savings plus the equity from my property when we got married and bought our first house together, but neither of us would've felt hard done by if it hadn't panned out that way.
There was no way I was paying the mortgage by myself while he had a shedload more disposable income than me and I was putting a roof over his head, if he'd suggested it he wouldn't have moved in.

Exactly what me and my DP currently do (except I pay more than half as I earn more, we split it on %)
It's a win for him as he's paying way less than he would do in rent and therefore is saving more (his protection I suppose if we split), and its a win for me as I also pay less.
Hopefully it's an investment in our future together for when we get married, but if we do split then we've both had a short term financial benefit from it and we will go back to paying higher rent and higher mortgage respectively

IRememberXanadu · 22/06/2022 17:18

luxxlisbon · 21/06/2022 11:05

You aren’t wrong. A reasonable amount of ‘rent’ as a contribution is completely normal in the real world.
The argument on here is he would be paying the mortgage if he lived alone, but the other partner would be paying rent or a mortgage to live elsewhere and too.
However this is mumsnet and if a woman moves in with her partner she shouldn’t pay a penny but if the genders are flipped he would be a freeloading scumbag.

This. Not paying 'rent' makes a person a freeloader.

emeraldcity2000 · 22/06/2022 17:13

@FloydPepper if you see it purely as rent then it is additional income - did you declare and pay tax on it?

emeraldcity2000 · 22/06/2022 16:48

JenniferPlantain · 22/06/2022 09:46

Really interesting reading replies to my friends' situation.

For ref A is a woman and B is a man - though I get why you though it was the other way round @Hont1986 because it often seems to be that way. I think if they hadn't been planning for a future together for years and had no DC I'd agree with what you've said. I think I largely still do, but I can also empathise somewhat with B's position. Ultimately I suppose I believe they took gamble that didn't pay off.

@Luidaeg that's exactly what A is now saying - you were saving hundreds a month, which he ultimately used for hobbies and travel, rather than a deposit for an investment property or ISA or something (which A actively encouraged him to do, she claims).

I guess once you know a relationship is going to be long term, it is time to talk Trust Deeds. Unromantic but perhaps worth an awkward conversation for everyone to feel more secure and have absolute clarity.

Another question here is did they declare the additional income they were receiving from their partner and pay relevant tax? If not, I'd say it's not a strictly rent type relationship and some equity should be shared...

xogossipgirlxo · 22/06/2022 16:15

I don't know about others, but for me YANBU. I didn't own a house when me and my boyfriend (then) moved in, but we shared the finances together after a year, so I think paying a mortgage together is a natural thing. It's just a matter of choosing sensible partner instead of ignoring red flags and moving in with some scumbag.

FloydPepper · 22/06/2022 16:08

When my now ex first moved in to my house we split bills in proportion to earnings, but I did want a “rent” contribution of 1/3 of the mortgage, I paid 2/3. She was saving massively my no longer renting.

this seemed to constantly be an issue, they were never happy “paying my mortgage” and even me saying it was “rent” was apparently saying I only wanted them there for the money.

we’ve now split. Was I wrong?

bumpytrumpy · 22/06/2022 16:05

Hont1986 · 22/06/2022 15:36

Paying rent to a Partner with no agreement in place can indeed be seen as you contributing to the mortgage and could indeed in a long term relationship put you in a position to claim an interest in the property.

No it can't. This is a very pernicious myth on Mumsnet and I wish people would stop repeating it because it encourages women to accept 'partnerships' rather than marriages, thinking they have some legal protection.

The circumstances to claim a beneficial interest in property are quite difficult to achieve. If you pay for an extension, or take over the mortgage for years while your partner is out of work, yes then there can be a potential claim (that will cost thousands to litigate). But your common-or-garden situation of a woman transferring £500 a month to her partner's account does not create any interest.

I see plenty of people encouraging other posters to start charging their kids rent at 18, why aren't they worried that their kids are getting into a position to claim an interest in the property?!

Exactly this.

bumpytrumpy · 22/06/2022 16:03

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 18:03

@JenniferPlantain that is a really tough one

Thinking about it - B should have been saving the money they saved on rent (hindsight is a wonderful thing) and not paid anything towards the renovations

The problem here is when A & B are a couple, their money is "family money" and gets spent on what makes most sense for the family.

No one would advocate 1 parent saving money in their own name in lieu of rent whilst the other parent renovated their family home at their own sole cost.

Yet when the relationship breaks down it's suddenly all his & hers and the non-owner is supposed to have had the hindsight to save for a situation they weren't expecting. Most often it's the women who has the double whammy of also reducing work hours, pension etc.

This is why marriage before children makes sense. I'm as feminist as they come, many argue that it's outdated etc (and yes white dresses and fathers giving you away maybe) but in many cases marriage as a legal contract IS the feminist thing to do.

DitzyBluebells · 22/06/2022 15:59

MRex · 22/06/2022 15:49

I know you approve of freeloading off a partner @DitzyBluebells, and that you don't understand that a person owning a home gives something up in sharing it. It certainly all suggests you don't really have a full grasp on how things work as a homeowner, whatever you protest.

I don't approve of freeloading off anyone Mrex. I do however think you're just looking for a fight so I'll not engage with you further.

JuneJubilee · 22/06/2022 15:57

Itloggedmeoutagain · 22/06/2022 09:57

What do you suggest should happen when one partner already owns a house outright?

@Itloggedmeoutagain

I don't see where the complication is with this one.

the house belongs to Dave, he invites Betty to live with him, they split the other bills.

they split up, Betty moves out, she has savings where she hasn't had to pay mortgage/rent. Fred has additional capital on HIS Asset, but only due to time, nothing Betty has added. They've both gained from splitting the bills.

what's the issue??

DitzyBluebells · 22/06/2022 15:56

Luidaeg · 22/06/2022 15:38

Will you move in and pay half my mortgage?" isn't love

"I don't want to move in with you if it means starting again in a new property" isn't love

Can I live with you rent free because you own a property is cocklodging

If you ask someone, then yes potentially a cocklodger (because it shows bad attitude) and definitely a CF. A person should wait to be invited to move in to someone else's home, not invite themselves. Which is not to say the non-homeowner can't start a conversation about living together, of course they can, but it should be respectful and come with the expectation to either rent together or purchase together. There should be no expectation of being invited to live with someone for free.

Living by invitation in someone's home, rent free or otherwise, isn't cocklodging if you're contributing towards bills and pulling your weight with housework.

People who get described as cocklodgers are doing nothing except permanently hanging out in someone's home. Living there whether it's their official address or not and sometimes not having been invited to move in but having done it by stealth. Contributing nothing or very little, either financially or in terms of effort, whilst often increasing the home owner's costs and getting waited on hand and foot too.

MRex · 22/06/2022 15:49

I know you approve of freeloading off a partner @DitzyBluebells, and that you don't understand that a person owning a home gives something up in sharing it. It certainly all suggests you don't really have a full grasp on how things work as a homeowner, whatever you protest.