Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to 'pay the landlords mortgage' but not your partners?

112 replies

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 11:00

So many threads I have seen where one person owns a house and the partner is moving in (sometimes planning) and they are told, you shouldn't pay towards their mortgage unless you are married and it is shared.

Why?

Why should someone live rent free just because they have chosen a partner who is in the position of owning a house?

Obviously you don't want to 'make a profit' on them, but equally you can't expect a free ride.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
strivingtosucceed · 25/06/2022 13:26

DinoWoman · 23/06/2022 07:48

@strivingtosucceed Wait a second, so if you were with a higher earner then they would end up paying more of your mortgage than you actually do? That's crazy. I mean, why would you ever put them on the mortgage when they are paying the majority of it off for you?

If you break up with the boyfriend after 3 years of living together in this way, then your he has missed out on paying into a mortgage for 3 years and has nothing to show for it. Would you honestly sell up your home and live as the renter in this set up?

It's too romantic to risk paying into a partner's mortgage with the hope you might some day be put on it at the home owner's will. Some people can live for decades in this type of set up as they never marry or have children.

I would advise anyone I care about to avoid being a tenant to their partner at all costs. They might end up paying higher rent than they would with their partner for a year or two but they would then begin life living together as equals with a shared mortgage whenever they both felt ready. It isn't as if renting your own flat is going to prevent you regualarly staying over at your partner's home afterall. By doing it this way as the tenant, you prevent the home owner partner from getting too comfortable with you paying off their mortgage in my opinion.

In that case, i'd probably pay the same mortgage costs and less bills.

People seem to cling to the idea that their partner should never benefit from your payments and would rather enrich their landlords than their partner they claim to love. Saying that they won't benefit from capital appreciation or whatever but happily living in a property they didn't save money for, don't pay interest on and don't carry the risk of owning. Neither would they be happy to accept the capital depreciation if the property reduces in value. Seems very selfish and self serving.

I feel that as long as both parties equally benefit from the move, it's fair to both parties.

TooOldToBeAGoth · 24/06/2022 20:02

orwellwasright · 22/06/2022 18:01

It's not ok to pay the landlord's mortgage though. Private rental shouldn't exist.

And why not?

mewkins · 24/06/2022 15:53

You don't actually have many rights as a lodger though. Just a short notice period.

Which most people would do if a relationship broke down anyway.

Hont1986 · 24/06/2022 15:20

The house owner should definitely provide them with the equivalent legal protection of a renter in their position, i.e. a lodger, because they are living with the landlord.

Naunet · 24/06/2022 14:00

Luidaeg · 21/06/2022 11:00

So many threads I have seen where one person owns a house and the partner is moving in (sometimes planning) and they are told, you shouldn't pay towards their mortgage unless you are married and it is shared.

Why?

Why should someone live rent free just because they have chosen a partner who is in the position of owning a house?

Obviously you don't want to 'make a profit' on them, but equally you can't expect a free ride.

That goes both ways though doesn’t it? The house owner doesn’t get a free ride either and should therefore be providing the legal protection of a tenancy agreement. Right OP?

blibbleflop · 24/06/2022 13:36

The sensible thing to do in this situation is to split "house costs" and "living costs". "House Costs" is mortgage, maintenance, home improvements and decorating. "Living Costs" would be council tax, food, electricity, gas, water, TV, etc.

Home owner pays all of the housing costs. The living costs then get split 50/50.

mewkins · 24/06/2022 11:11

But someone moving in a suddenly saving a grand or so a month and just contributing to bills isn't very loving either. For most the biggest bill is the mortgage. Mortgages aren't just giving your money to the mortgage lender for them to put it aside for you. Most if not all will pay massive amounts of interest over the years. Why shouldn't an adult contribute?

Most of the threads here involve men moving in with women who have kids. I would suggest that they will benefit massively from the arrangement. It also isn't often practical or particularly helpful for kids to be uprooted in order for both partners to take out a mortgage together on a new home.

Everyone should be paying for their own living expenses,whether that's for a mortgaged house or rented. It's life. You can say that the mortgaged person is making money from the other partner. But it works the other way round too. Both will likely be saving money from the arrangement.

The person with the mortgage has the security but also all of the liability for meeting the payments etc

mewkins · 24/06/2022 10:57

But half my mortgage would be fair bit less than what a lodger would pay for a room.

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2022 10:04

femfemlicious · 23/06/2022 08:19

Why do people compare not having to have sex with your landlord and having sex with your partner. Do you not enjoy sex with him, is sex not for both parties?. Is sex payment for living with him?

Its about power dynamics in a relationship and how the relationship functions.

Most healthy relationships start on a more equal basis where both parties have equal say and input into where they are going to live. One partner already owning a house often narrows the other partner's choices dramatically. The homeowner will not want to rent with their partner if they already own somewhere and will be reluctant to add them to the mortgage if they don't absolutely have to. Buying a house together becomes complicated as the homeowner already owns a property and will have built up equity. They are already on the housing ladder so won't be desperate to buy in the same way that someone who doesn't own a property might be, especially if you are getting to the age where mortgage term lengths etc can become a problem.

If the non-homeowner wants the relationship to progress by moving in together then they effectively have to move in with their partner and this will disproportionately benefit the homeowning partner if the other partner ends up contributing equally to the mortgage but doesn't benefit from the house price increases, capital growth and housing security that the homeowning partner does.

femfemlicious · 23/06/2022 08:19

Why do people compare not having to have sex with your landlord and having sex with your partner. Do you not enjoy sex with him, is sex not for both parties?. Is sex payment for living with him?

burnoutbabe · 23/06/2022 08:17

I own my flat , boyfriend moved in. I didn't charge him any rent as I didn't want him to have any claim and also I didn't have mortgage payments anyway so why should I make money out of him?
He saved the rent he used to pay so if I had chucked him out he would have had £10k saved up each year anyway.

newnamethanks · 23/06/2022 08:10

'Can't expect a free ride'. Quite. Most - all? - landlords wont be getting the 'perks' that go with a partnership. It's a completely different dynamic between participants which shouldn't require explanation and is too lengthy to go into here.

femfemlicious · 23/06/2022 08:08

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 17:58

You're twisting my words, taking things out of context by missing off the rest of my post. I didn't talk about not contributing, I actually specifically said the partner would be contributing - just not to the mortgage. I talked about not paying towards a mortgage when you're not on the deeds of that property which is totally reasonable. If someone wants equal finances then either rent together or buy together, not both pay towards a mortgage in one person's name, that's unfair and grabby.

I didn't include the whole of your post because it was quite long. I stand by what I said. I happily paid rent to my DH with no expectation of an interest in his property if things didn't work out. Why on earth would he have rented a different place with me when he already owned his own property? Rent for a commercial landlord would be more expensive than his house, he'd have to take on the additional expense of remortgaging because you need a buy to let mortgage, he'd have to risk having his house ruined by dodgy tenants or paying the mortgage while it was empty on top of the rent. Financially it makes no sense.

As for buying together, what incentive is there to incur those costs if you already have a perfectly good house? I moved on to the mortgage later but it was very much later when we were engaged and knew the relationship wasn't going to fizzle out in a couple of years.

This makes total sense!

femfemlicious · 23/06/2022 08:03

FloydPepper · 22/06/2022 16:08

When my now ex first moved in to my house we split bills in proportion to earnings, but I did want a “rent” contribution of 1/3 of the mortgage, I paid 2/3. She was saving massively my no longer renting.

this seemed to constantly be an issue, they were never happy “paying my mortgage” and even me saying it was “rent” was apparently saying I only wanted them there for the money.

we’ve now split. Was I wrong?

You wrre VERY right!

DinoWoman · 23/06/2022 07:48

@strivingtosucceed Wait a second, so if you were with a higher earner then they would end up paying more of your mortgage than you actually do? That's crazy. I mean, why would you ever put them on the mortgage when they are paying the majority of it off for you?

If you break up with the boyfriend after 3 years of living together in this way, then your he has missed out on paying into a mortgage for 3 years and has nothing to show for it. Would you honestly sell up your home and live as the renter in this set up?

It's too romantic to risk paying into a partner's mortgage with the hope you might some day be put on it at the home owner's will. Some people can live for decades in this type of set up as they never marry or have children.

I would advise anyone I care about to avoid being a tenant to their partner at all costs. They might end up paying higher rent than they would with their partner for a year or two but they would then begin life living together as equals with a shared mortgage whenever they both felt ready. It isn't as if renting your own flat is going to prevent you regualarly staying over at your partner's home afterall. By doing it this way as the tenant, you prevent the home owner partner from getting too comfortable with you paying off their mortgage in my opinion.

PurpleCarpets · 23/06/2022 00:52

PurpleCarpets · 23/06/2022 00:51

Totally agree, this seems totally obvious.

Hang on a minute, are you a man? This seems totally abusive and misogynistic profiteering.

PurpleCarpets · 23/06/2022 00:51

FloydPepper · 22/06/2022 19:50

There’s no way I’d let someone move into my house without paying towards living there

and there’s no way I’d give them a share of my house

married, kids, it’s different. A girlfriend, nope

Totally agree, this seems totally obvious.

strivingtosucceed · 23/06/2022 00:46

I've often wondered about this too OP. I don't see why I would automatically put a bf on the mortgage just because he's moving in. Most people keep finances separate until kids/marriage so I don't see why accommodation should be different just because I happen to own the property. This is probably how I would slice it:
-Just moved in: Separate finances. 50% each on bills & mortgage if earnings are similar, more proportional split if one earner is higher. I pay for all renovations, repairs and maintenance. Partner has 0 interest in the property.

-Marriage & kids: Joint-ish finances. Partner is on the mortgage with my deposit & equity ringfenced. Partner's contributions are also ringfenced and any future equity is shared equally regardless of salary. Other costs are shared proportionally.

As long as both parties benefit, I see no reason why you should expect to have an interest in a property you didn't purchase. You got the benefit of accommodation so it's not like they're taking advantage of you. How much you should pay is likely always going to be based on personal circumstances.

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 23:53

🤣 Yeah we're definitely not going to agree here

DinoWoman · 22/06/2022 23:21

chiffchaffchiff · 22/06/2022 10:16

Yes but her friend was paying for renovations on a house she didn't own and had no legal interest in. Before DH and I got married and I went on the mortgage he paid for everything for the house. When the boiler broke, when the roof needed fixing, when the bathroom was replaced, when we decorated rooms etc. I only paid rent for living there. According to Mumsnet I shouldn't have been paying because it was his mortgage and he would be paying it anyway.

Hmmmm....but my point is not that it isn't fair for you to pay 'rent' in your circumstance. My point is that I would never agree to the set up you had unless I was in a lot of debt or financially vulnerable in some way. It might just be that I prioritise financial security more than you. I have always wanted to have a mortgage as quickly as possible and it would therefore not suit me to continue paying rent when I could have a mortgage with my partner.

Most people can't afford a mortgage on their own. It isn't unfair to expect to be put on a mortgage or purchase a new house in both names prior to living together in my opinion. If I wasn't ready to share a mortgage with a partner, then I wouldn't move in. You can sell a house a split the assets if you break up.

We aren't going to agree...

DinoWoman · 22/06/2022 23:12

I couldn't agree more with @Bumpitybumper

Bumpitybumper · 22/06/2022 20:42

In my mind this issue is often (but not always) linked to other feminist issues hence why there is apparent hypocrisy on Mumsnet depending on the sex of the home owner.

Typically the man will be older than the woman in a relationship and therefore had more time to financially establish himself and buy a property. This is particularly true in the current housing market where prices have risen dramatically and being just that slight bit older can make all the difference in terms of getting on the housing ladder. When a relationship gets serious the woman often has no real choice but to live in the man's house if they want to live together. He is unlikely to want to move out to rented when he already owns a property, especially when mortgage payments are often cheaper than rent.
The woman therefore ends up paying rent to live in a house not of her choosing owned by the man whilst he uses that money to pay off his mortgage and build up equity in the property. The financial inequality in the situation bis obvious.

If the woman isn't happy with this situation then there are often barriers in place to stop them buying a house together. Often the property is big enough for both of them to live in already so there isn't any desperate need to move. The man may have already built up a decent chunk of equity in the house so it can be messy and difficult to add the woman to the mortgage and ringfence equity etc.

Ultimately though, the reason the woman is rarely added to the mortgage in these types of scenarios is that there is no incentive for the man to do this. He benefits disproportionately from the arrangement as he gets a massive chunk of his mortgage paid off reducing his day-to-day expenses, gets to build up equity in the property and doesn't risk losing the property in the event of a relationship breakdown. Meanwhile the woman paying the exact same amount of money in some cases benefits only from the first of these things. Add in childrearing and domestic work disproportionately falling to women and the gender pay gap and you can see why men conveniently retain the financial advantage in the relationship and the gap between men and women's financial circumstances grows.

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 20:22

Fushiadreams · 22/06/2022 20:19

It’s fine to put the money in You just habe a solicitor draw up and agreement saying if you split you get the money back

putting the money in, keeping one house etc are all perfectly good decisions. It fell apart because you kept no records and didn’t protect your money at the time

the issue was I was told that because I was married I had that security and actually turned out to be complete custard.

Fushiadreams · 22/06/2022 20:19

Nothappyatwork · 22/06/2022 19:40

So when I moved in with my ex-husband he lived in a beautiful house in a lovely area that needed an awful lot doing to it. My house was alright but in a shit area to be honest anyway the decision was made that my house would be sold upon us getting married and that the funds I received would go into the marital home paid for the way didn’t pay for a few holidays that kinda thing.

naturally when we got divorced he completely forgot about the check for 65 grand that I paid into his account.

as it was 14 years ago unfortunately none of the banking records went back that far that were available to me anyway we got divorced during lockdown.

and all of the equity ended up going to the solicitors anyway in costs.

if I had my time again that is absolutely no way I would do anything other than sell both properties put equal amounts into them by way of deposit legally protect that and if either of you have any surplus money, you do as you please with it.
my solicitor said the law has very little to do with justice my god did I find out to my detriment that’s true.

genuinely didn’t matter who was right and who was wrong.

It’s fine to put the money in You just habe a solicitor draw up and agreement saying if you split you get the money back

putting the money in, keeping one house etc are all perfectly good decisions. It fell apart because you kept no records and didn’t protect your money at the time

warofthemonstertrucks · 22/06/2022 20:08

I agree op. My ex partner and I lived together but we weren't married. I put a huge deposit down on the house we lived in with the equity from my previous sale and ported my mortgage over and he paid me towards the mortgage monthly. We paid equally into the house whilst we loved there. When we split up he couldn't afford the house and I could so I stayed in it (plus I had more equity etc and it was effectively my mortgage. he wanted all the money he had paid towards the mortgage back plus the money he spent on improving the house. I gave him the money he had spent on improvements and no more more. He couldn't get his head around the fact that he hadn't had the right to live for free for 4 years. In fact he was paying under the market rental rate for even half the house we lived in. The solicitor had to explain to him that that's what he'd agreed to and it was fair-but he couldn't see it at all.