Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him or do I let this go?

234 replies

Furrbabymama1987 · 21/06/2022 09:27

I just want to say before I type this that this is a new account, but I have been on MN for years under basically the same user name but for a few digits. I had to start a new one under a new email address as had trouble getting back into the old one. So anyone is free to check that if this seems odd for a newish account.
A few years ago I met this guy on a night out. We had what I thought was a one night stand, but then a week later, bumped into him again in the same club and history repeated itself. He told me he was 19 and I had no reason to think otherwise. He looked 19, he was confident and was being served alcohol at the bar. He later admitted he was 17 and I felt bad about it but I liked him by then. I was 22 or 23 at the time.
I developed feelings for him and we wanted to be together but I was ashamed about the age gap and that he was a student when I was an adult woman with a young child, so kept it under wraps and it fizzled out eventually.
After a while I met a new partner and we later had a child together. We were argumentative and frequently split up and got back together. He was a bit abusive in some ways and I wasn't happy but found it hard to leave. So, I started texting this guy again and we met up and had sex and it led to a casual sex thing that went on for about 2 years, every time I split with my now ex, I would go back to this guy. I wanted there to be more between us, he did too, but we were afraid of other people's reactions.
I went on to have another child with my ex when we got back together.
Everyone comments she looks nothing like him. I'm now married to someone else and ex isn't in my children's lives at all anymore.
I recently saw this guy in my doctors surgery. He lives relatively local to me but we've never crossed paths. This was the first time in years. I saw him looking at me but we never spoke. I can't stop thinking how much my child looks like him. He will have moved on and I'm a distant memory now and he won't be expecting this. He deserves to know but I don't know if this is just opening up a can of worms. She has a father figure, my husband and doesn't need the confusion, but I'm unsure what to do. I feel shame around the fact I potentially had a baby with a teenage guy, although he would have been around 19 when I conceived. And she could be my ex's although she looks nothing like him, or me for that matter.

OP posts:
Furrbabymama1987 · 30/06/2022 17:49

I don't know the best way to go about it. I feel terrible for feeling this, but in a way I'm happy. I had a baby to someone I was deeply in love with at the time, not a miserable relationship and I've got a connection to him.

OP posts:
Lilypickles1 · 30/06/2022 17:27

Agree with previous posters, you should definitely tell him

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 16:31

You're really just making excuses.

This is a very hard situation. Youre having to face stuff you dont want to face. There is no way around that and no way to make this not awful for you to actually have to go through.

But you're an adult. You messed up. You fix it. That's life. This thing involves other people; it isnt yours to keep secret or hidden.

Rip the plaster off and tell the guy. Although I suspect you probably wont.

AryaStarkWolf · 30/06/2022 16:20

I think it would be very unfair to your daughter not to be able to tell her who her Biological father is and give her the opportunity to have a relationship with him

felineweird · 30/06/2022 16:12

Sorry if I've missed this but definitely tell him before you tell her. That way if he wants nothing to do with her you have nothing to gain by telling her

Furrbabymama1987 · 30/06/2022 16:08

To be fair, from what I remember and it's hard because it was so long ago. But I remember one night he messaged me on WhatsApp asking to meet and I said I can't, I'm heavily pregnant and he said laughing " oh not mine is it?" or something along those lines. At the time I must have known there was a chance but I was more towards her being my partner's at the time. I'm sure there was something to do with implantation bleeding that made me think the dates didn't add up. Basically thought I'd had a lighter period than normal but must have been implantation.

OP posts:
WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 15:21

To be frank, this is your screw up and it affects a man out there who has no idea he has a child, it affects your child and it affects the man you led to believe was her dad (not as much since he has nothing to do with her).

Keeping is secret is for your own comfort, no one else's.

You messed up. You need to accept that this is u comfortable for you but that you need to do it.

So she already knows your partner isnt her bio dad. She knows she has another dad out there. Makes it quite easy to then tell her that this man wants to see her, you're not starting from zero. You're not having to explained that your partner isnt her dad and she actually has another one. She already knows that. Makes it so much easier.

You need to tell the man and be prepared for all reponses; anger, hurt, possible disinterest, confusion or desperation to have contact. You're going to have to roll with it.

You can still have boundaries. You can manage it so she builds up visits with him gradually. But you cannot keep this information to yourself.

Furrbabymama1987 · 30/06/2022 15:16

She's never asked about her dad, maybe her development delay is something to do with that.So she knows she has a dad, just not who it is. I don't want to make a big deal or saying, actually it's this guy, not that guy when she doesn't know their names or who either of them are. So I don't think she'd be shocked. The main issue is them 2 not being full siblings, but again I don't know how much of that she understands.

OP posts:
WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 15:04

He wants you not to for his sake, not for hers. And you want to keep it secret for your sake, not for hers.
At least be honest with yourself.

At her age, she has had the start of sex ed. It wont be difficult to explain biological dad and step dad who lives with you and is also very much her dad.

You arent taking anything away from her. She still has a dad she has had for years. She also gains the truth about who she is and where she comes from.

You should probably tell the man first. If he wants nothing to do with it then telling her is different because you'd tell her but then have to explain that he doesn't want to see her. That's something for when she is older. If he wants nothing to do with it then tell her when she is older maybe.

Desmondo2021 · 30/06/2022 15:03

I think you've had a tough time on this thread and you handled it well! So at 22 you slept with a 17 year old who looked older and said he was older. Big bloody deal. Massive kudos to him I'd say!

I feel you do have to tell him, I think it's going to be rocky, he may ask why you didn't explore this earlier on when you first had suspicions. But if you make it clear you need and want nothing from him beyond what he wants to give, I think telling him is the right thing to do.

I feel a little more concerned about your relationship with your husband. He sounds like a decent, responsible chap but he's gonna need a whole lot of love and reassurance not to feel slightly concerned about this unexpected turn of events and the contact you may end up having with someone who you were once very fond of.

Tyrtle · 30/06/2022 14:53

is still*

Tyrtle · 30/06/2022 14:53

Furrbabymama1987 · 30/06/2022 12:18

I think my main worry aside from confusing her is that she doesn't remember a time my husband wasn't in her life. In every way but biology, he is her dad and she calls him dad. He just says its up to me what I want to do but I think probably he'd prefer me not to contact. He knows this guy is a sore spot for me.

It might be confusing for her to learn about such a thing as a bio dad (her dad, your husband, is on us till her dad in everyone’s eyes) but it will be a lot less confusing for her to learn it now that to find out a big, identity shaking, secret as an adult.

I’d recommend finding a good family therapist you and her can go to, to make this all as smooth as possible.

stepuporshutup · 30/06/2022 13:30

The bio father needs to know
It might be the only child he ever has for whatever reason
Your daughter needs to know she has a bio dad
Sorry I have no advice how you approach this
But hope it all works out good

Furrbabymama1987 · 30/06/2022 12:18

I think my main worry aside from confusing her is that she doesn't remember a time my husband wasn't in her life. In every way but biology, he is her dad and she calls him dad. He just says its up to me what I want to do but I think probably he'd prefer me not to contact. He knows this guy is a sore spot for me.

OP posts:
chocolatecoffee · 30/06/2022 09:12

Please tell him, it's not fair on your daughter to live a life her entire life. She would grow up thinking her dad is this horrible man where this young man MIGHT be better

HappyCup · 30/06/2022 08:36

Furrbabymama1987 · 29/06/2022 22:28

Thanks for replies. I don't know if I should tell him. I know it's the right thing to do morally but I don't know if its right for my daughter. And if I did I don't know the way to do it. I know the street he lives on but don't fancy knocking and dropping the bombshell.

Don’t keep this to yourself out of fear. You owe it to your daughter to be brave.

Walkingalot · 29/06/2022 23:51

There's going to come a point in your DD's life when knowing about her father is important. Could you hand on heart lie to her?
I think you should do the sibling test, in secret, and decide on the next course of action if your suspicions are correct.
I also don't think the age thing is an issue, you were both young and no one else needs to one the whole story anyway.

WeAreBob · 29/06/2022 23:10

It is right for your daughter to know her father or at least know who he is.

You'll have to tell her when she is older, and then she may track him down. And then you need to answer why you didnt tell anyone.

You messed up years ago. You can fix it now by being honest and giving him the chance.

Furrbabymama1987 · 29/06/2022 22:28

Thanks for replies. I don't know if I should tell him. I know it's the right thing to do morally but I don't know if its right for my daughter. And if I did I don't know the way to do it. I know the street he lives on but don't fancy knocking and dropping the bombshell.

OP posts:
WeAreBob · 29/06/2022 20:52

Just... dont take too much time. This man has lost out on years with his daughter and your daughter has lost out on years with her father.

He may want nothing to do her her. But, dont leave it too long.

LadyEloise1 · 29/06/2022 20:09

You take your time. I'm sure it's still a shock though you were suspicious.
At least DD1's father isn't in the picture to make matters more difficult.

Furrbabymama1987 · 29/06/2022 19:15

I'm going to think about what I should do regarding telling the guy. I roughly know his address but I've no idea if he's married or has kids. From what I've seen on his social media I don't think he does. He only seems to talk about football and politics on his twitter account that I found. I'm not going to tell my ex, we split in the pregnancy and he's never seen her and not had any further contact with his older child, plus he is volatile and I don't want to start contact with him again.

OP posts:
CinderellaFant · 29/06/2022 18:37

Agree with everyone else to take your time to figure out your next move. This has been a secret for 9'yeats so a few more days/weeks won't make a difference. The father does have a right to know he has a child though

XJerseyGirlX · 29/06/2022 18:25

Op take some time to let this sink in before you make any decisions

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 29/06/2022 18:24

That's a shock alright OP. Take time to digest it before telling your daughter or her bio father.
I can't remember the situation with your ex (who you thought was her dad), is he involved with your DD?