Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it me who is the problem?

69 replies

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 05:14

I don't consider myself a "Karen" but I don't understand why I sometimes do clash with people. I used to think it was them, but maybe it's me? (Or maybe I just need to go back to sleep it's my birthday after all!)

Two examples:

Some time ago I was made redundant and was desperate for a job. I contacted career coaches and charities. The coaches seemed for the most part predatory (or didn't seem to offer quick fixes) but the charity was the worst. Their whole ethos is to get remote jobs. They were never honest that they really worked for entry level jobs and that I was out of their "scope". Never helped with my CV, and gave me very basic interview coaching that I didn't need (I wanted to discuss the feedback that I had received so far). I eventually found a job myself and signed off their services. They asked for feedback (and gave it) and was supposed to sign some forms so they could get funding from the local council, they never got back to me (but have always wondered why).

Lated one was a specialist nurse at my local hospital. I went back to visit my family across the pond and got a second opinion because a) it's easy and cheap b) I wanted to know what the protocols were over there. It never was because I mistrusted the NHS or anything, it's just a normal thing to do over there. The consultant gave a completely different diagnosis (much worse) and suggested swift action. Bear in mind I was on the public hospital pathway as it's a hybrid system, but ultimately the doctors had nothing to gain from me at this point. So I came back and asked for second/third opinion over here. It was a while saga, had to put a complaint with PALS etc...

So I don't know .. have I had by luck? Is it my tone of voice? (Which can come across as louder), my American accent?

I've never had this sort of issues at work, so I don't think it's necessarily me, but maybe even after 12+ years living in the UK I still haven't cracked down how to read people? Or how to request for things?

OP posts:
YouOKHun · 21/06/2022 11:25

Happy Birthday firstly!

It’s so hard to comment precisely based on two examples but I get the sense that you are dismissive and I wonder if you, possibly inadvertently, come across as patronising and dismissive of other people and their input or skills? You can decide that a charity’s employment support service isn’t pitched right for you and thank them for their input and swiftly go elsewhere. You can seek a second opinion on a diagnosis and use that information to ask useful questions to clarify things without getting someone’s back up by implying you think their knowledge isn’t up to scratch. Are you a bull in a china shop?

Using the Karen term makes you seem unaware as it’s clearly a misogynistic term. Saying you try not to be a Karen rather implies you apply this label to others. I wonder if you have a low opinion of other women and that comes across loud and clear?

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 11:04

Maybe? I was quite clear to ask if they could help me, as I prefer a black and white answer.

OP posts:
Meraas · 21/06/2022 10:58

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 07:01

@Testina there was no misunderstanding there, I had to sign some paperwork so they could send it back to the local council to get funding. (They charged my council something in the region of £1500 for their "consultancy" services). I never signed off those documents (as they never gave them to me once I have them my honest feedback).

I was quite honest to them, I needed help, pronto. Their whole ethos is around "remote working for this county" and what I needed was exactly that (just not entry level).

Someone else from the charity was in that interview coaching session and she thought herself it was very condescending.

I don't think you actually read what @Testina said about the charity not being geared to help you. That's possibly why they didn't claim from the council.

Could the issue be that you are not listening to people? I don't mean to be mean, I sometimes miss what people are telling me as well, as I hear what I think they're saying, and I'm sometimes wrong.

Seeingadistance · 21/06/2022 10:19

KangarooKenny · 21/06/2022 07:11

I got as far as ‘Karen’ and stopped reading. Please stop the misogyny.

This.

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 10:18

The nurse did say "they're trying to scare you" and ""their opinion is invalid" but she wasn't able to elaborate on it

OP posts:
hopeishere · 21/06/2022 09:27

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 08:05

@hopeishere yes I don't think they tried to get the funding given my feedback. In that coaching session it was obvious I was getting very upset (the other lady confirmed).

@ClarissaD no I wasn't abrasive, but she wouldn't understand why I'd get a second opinion unless I didn't trust their diagnosis.

But it's perfectly reasonable of them to do that re the funding. It's nothing to do with you. Im confused again about the reference to crying in a session.

LuaDipa · 21/06/2022 08:55

Agree about the use of ‘Karen’, it’s horrible. Why would you use it to describe your own behaviour?

The first example, the service was of no benefit to you. You had adequately described what you needed and they should have been upfront if they couldn’t help rather than wasting both of your time. You gave feedback accordingly. There is no issue.

The second example you simply sought a second opinion. While some NHS staff seem to take great offence at that, I think it should be actively encouraged. It worked out well for you as they identified that your condition was more severe than first thought. There is no issue.

Unless you were shouting and screaming and using offensive language which I assume you would have mentioned (although I have seen some pretty big drip feeds on here) both of the above scenarios were perfectly reasonable. Perhaps if you stop buying into misogynistic stereotypes about women you would realise that.

limitedperiodonly · 21/06/2022 08:43

Another one who couldn't get past the Karen shit.

purpledagger · 21/06/2022 08:43

Okay

EarthquakesinEastActon · 21/06/2022 08:42

In the first scenario, you went to the wrong sort of place for help. A charity like this is set up to help people who needs help with the basics. You’d have been better off with a recruitment agency, in particular one for your own field. But it sounds as though your reaction was the issue when you realised that the service wasn’t right for you.

Getting annoyed (which is what it sounds like you did) isn’t helpful or professional. You should just have said calmly that you hadn’t properly understood what they could offer and it wasn’t appropriate for you, and left.

The charity clearly didn’t feel they could claim their fee from your local authority after your feedback, so they have acknowledged that their service didn’t meet your needs. That was the correct course of action, and I don’t see why it’s upset you so much. It’s the charity which is out of pocket, not you or your LA.

In the second scenario, I can see why a health professional would feel put out at being told you didn’t trust their diagnosis so you went elsewhere for a second opinion and were now looking for a third. I wonder if you tackled this matter in a way which was also overly annoyed or inappropriate, given your reaction in the first scenario? It’s also well known that doctors in the US over-diagnose in order to generate income, so I can see why a UK HCP might feel a bit doubtful about it.

In both cases you weren’t wrong to be disappointed with how things turned out, but I’d be very interested to see exactly how you handled the interactions with people about them. If your feelings are very much on the surface and you let people know exactly how you feel about things, I wouldn’t be at all surprised.

PinkWisteria · 21/06/2022 08:42

KangarooKenny · 21/06/2022 07:11

I got as far as ‘Karen’ and stopped reading. Please stop the misogyny.

This! I despair at women using this term.

GodisaBC · 21/06/2022 08:42

I would say from this thread you ignore things you don’t like to hear.
E.G. Karen - Completely ignored everyone who has asked you to address it.

easyday · 21/06/2022 08:41

I don't understand the second scenario, but the first sounds like the service you needed was beyond what they were offering. I think pointing out the issue was fine and hopefully useful (and not filed in the bin).

Lalliella · 21/06/2022 08:41

Didn’t read past the “Karen” comment. Stop with the misogynistic bullshit.

AngelinaFibres · 21/06/2022 08:38

Billybagpuss · 21/06/2022 05:23

I’m sorry I don’t really understand what you’re asking, these just sound like scenarios that didn’t work out for you or were ongoing investigations in health care. It doesn’t sound like anything personal that you didn’t get what you should have.

an I missing something?

This. Your Op is very confusing

dworky · 21/06/2022 08:36

No-one's a Karen. Please stop using misogynist slurs.

KangarooKenny · 21/06/2022 08:34

Misogyny is bad enough, but far worse when used by a woman.

user75 · 21/06/2022 08:31

karenismyname.org/renamer
You completely alienated me by using a misogynistic term

SpaceJamtart · 21/06/2022 08:28

If you are going to get a second opinion somewhere else, they don't need to be told that, or made to understand understand your reasoning.
And it is going to come across like you don't trust their diagnosis.

Obviously different if your asking for a secound opinion within the same hospital.

ClaryFairchild · 21/06/2022 08:26

Do you mean you're Canadian rather than American? Not sure why you can't just come right and say it...

One of the cultural generalities I've noticed between North America and the UK is that in North America there is an expectation of 'customer service' to a high level and an expectation that because you pay for the service that it will be a good service. That just isn't there in there in the UK to that degree. Particularly in the NHS where it is a free service, you are almost expected to take what you can get. Long waiting times, referrals only if they deem you worthy of it etc, etc. it's hard to fight it. If you then went and told them that a medical professional in another country gave a completely different opinion to the one given my NHS, well for some people it would be like a red rag to a bill....

And then your accent, sadly there are a lot of people in the UK who will treat you badly just because of the accent. I've seen it happen with a few friends of mine and it has always saddened me.

cubangal · 21/06/2022 08:25

Yes, it's you. Don't use names in the way that you've used Karen.

SpaceJamtart · 21/06/2022 08:25

I don't really get your example, you haven't mentioned any of the antagonism happening?.

But also your tone of voice can't "come across as loud" if you are loud, you are loud. Which to be fair I do find agressive even when the person isn't being so, because regular conversations feel like I'm being shouted at.

But also in any of the cases where you wanted to get a second opinion, did you tell the 1st opinion people that thats what you were going to do? Just because that always seems stroppy, and needlessly aggro.

Like to say, loudly, something like "well I don't agree with this so I am going to go get a second opinion"
Seems antagonistic and I would assume that person is trying to get a rise out of the staff or to make them aware that you think their wrong, sort of blamimg them for a diagnosis you don't like. As opposed to something neutral like " Thank you for all the information, I'm going to go take some time to process"

Getoff · 21/06/2022 08:23

I think it's a slight clash of cultures with the medical one. In private systems getting a second opinion is far more usual. Although NHS says you are entitled to one, I think hardly anyone knows that, so they seldom happen, therefore the giver of the first opinion will have less experience of it. (Probably also unusual because it's nurse, I would imagine second opinions are sought more often in the case of more complex things a hospital doctor would be dealing with.)

When my father was temporarily in the UK he booked an appointment with the NHS GP "for a check-up". This was at a time when there was a three-week wait for local GP appointments. I wonder if the GP' had to retrieve his eyebrows from the ceiling after hearing that reason for a visit.

RealBecca · 21/06/2022 08:17

You say you dont want to be a Karen but the Karen thing is there to shut down women with perfectly reasonable concerns so it is sexist and it is working as you feel like you dont want to be negatively perceived for feeling dissatisfied.

Onlyrainbows · 21/06/2022 08:16

Nobody else was there to witness so I think I'd always have a skewed view about it. I totally accept it could be me, or elements of my personality.

OP posts: