Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Public sector pay rise demands unreasonable?

727 replies

stickershock · 20/06/2022 21:20

I’m a nurse and outraged that we’ll only be getting (most likely) a 3% wage increase. I’m fully in favour of a strike action. But I’ve also just read that the junior doctors are planning a strike if they aren’t awarded a 22% increase 😮

We have all been losing wages year on year but 22% seems unrealistic. AIBU or have they got brilliant bargaining tactics?

OP posts:
TeaAndBiscuitsAndWine · 20/06/2022 23:20

Oh there’s lots of money around, it’s just not ‘trickling down’ the way the Tories said it would (its actually a long since defunct economic theory but that didn’t stop them). I had a senior city job till recently, and still know plenty of people on salaries of quarter of a million plus, never mind partners on three and four times that (before bonuses). The rich have been getting richer as everyone else gets poorer, yet the government still won’t address legal corporate tax evasion, dirty money distorting the housing market, overseas tax havens etc. If they did, there would be enough money to start paying public sector workers a better wage, funding early years support etc. Things that would actually enrich the country (not just economically), but not them and their mates, which is why they won’t do it.

QuebecBagnet · 20/06/2022 23:19

MPs have had several inflation busting pay rises over the last few years while a nurses wage is in real terms more than 7% down on previous wage (article is from 2020 so probably worse now.

i am worried about the long term economic recovery if everyone gets huge pay rises. The experts reckon it will make inflation worse long term. Saying that MPs are about to scrap some cap on bankers pay rise or possibly on their bonuses. So one rule for the elite, one for everyone else?

www.thelondoneconomic.com/politics/mps-get-8-pay-rises-in-10-years-while-nurses-salaries-are-slashed-197695/

Topgub · 20/06/2022 23:18

@fyn

I never claimed to be an economist 🤷‍♀️

Cut their wages enough and they'll be like everyone else

Your lack of understanding on what motivates people and the fact that the general population dont have a firm grasp on economics at that level is clear.

We cant get people to drop demand despite telling them they are literally destroying the plant.

You think they'll give a fuck about inflation?!

🤣🤣

Because rich people are worried it will impact their savings

🤣

lightisnotwhite · 20/06/2022 23:18

Paying more just means more inflation. Then interest rates go up. A lot of people have borrowed money especially now petrol and other basics are astronomical.

I’d rather have less pay than having to pay back my borrowing at huge interest rates . It’s not great having debt but at least it’s currently affordable.

BouncyBalls · 20/06/2022 23:17

Im private sector in a company thats done well out of covid but i only received a 2.3% payrise this year. Im on a fairly goid wage but struggling nonetheless 😢

starzyy · 20/06/2022 23:16

fixing issues like this cannot be done by one country acting alone,

agreed, it's not a global initiative

starzyy · 20/06/2022 23:15

We already do, as seen from the % of overall income tax contributed by "the top"

Tax is really not equal at the top, there's a reason the gap is growing & the rich are getting richer.

"Using anonymised data from personal tax returns, we show that in 2015-16 the average rate of tax paid by people who received one million pounds in taxable income and gains was just 35 per cent: the same as someone earning £100,000. But one in four of these paid 45 per cent – close to the top rate – whilst another quarter paid less than 30 per cent overall. One in ten paid just 11 per cent—the same as someone earning £15,000. The rich, it seems, are not all in it together."

Fairisleflora · 20/06/2022 23:15

Companies such as Starbucks etc ensure their profits arise in low tax jurisdictions such as Ireland and Luxembourg. That’s changing. A minimum corporation tax rate is being brought in internationally. fixing issues like this cannot be done by one country acting alone, which is why it hasn’t been tackled by the UK government up to now.

MarshaBradyo · 20/06/2022 23:15

Who pays for the increases?

Who gets taxed most

DdraigGoch · 20/06/2022 23:14

wonderstuff · 20/06/2022 22:43

@Blinkingbatshit if the privatise they still need people to do the work. Nurses and Drs. currently going to the private sector, it won’t save the government any money! Train drivers have already been placed in private sector, hasn’t stopped them taking industrial action! They’re privatising all the schools anyway, seems to just mean a layer of well paid management, you still need teachers! In fact several private schools have seen strikes over taking them out of the teachers pension scheme.

Privatising may well cause wages to rise. That's what happened with train drivers, under BR they didn't earn a living wage and were reliant upon overtime to put food on the table. Once BR was broken up, the new companies realised that it was cheaper to poach drivers from other operators, rather than training their own. So wages rocketed as the companies tried to out-compete each other.

I could see that happening with doctors, after all there is a shortage. Freed of the NHS monopoly, doctors would have many more opportunities to offer their services elsewhere so healthcare providers would have to compete for them.

fyn · 20/06/2022 23:13

@Topgub your lack of understanding of economics is astounding.

It makes absolutely no odds what the top earners make, they’ll be able to pay for the goods no matter what. We need the general demand from the majority of the population to drop.

Nat6999 · 20/06/2022 23:13

Benefits are increasing by a minimum of 9.5% next year, surely there is an argument for all salaries increasing by the same amount. If the public has no spare money then industries like retail will crash.

carefullycourageous · 20/06/2022 23:11

I see they are TODAY talking about removing restrictions on bankers' pay and bonuses - I wonder how it is that my pay rise is inflationary, but a banker's pay rise is not Hmm Angry

twitter.com/christopherhope/status/1539006333374156800

If you fall for the Tory bullshit on wages needing to be 'responsible' you are either super rich or super stupid or both.

DdraigGoch · 20/06/2022 23:08

Hoardasurass · 20/06/2022 22:33

@Topgub that will definitely make a significant contribution if we actually make companies like Starbucks, amazon et al pay the tax the should and close all tax loopholes we might just get somewhere

Ironically the main reason that these loopholes don't get closed is that those companies pay their tax accountants more than HMRC, so can attract the talent.

Topgub · 20/06/2022 23:08

The % of over all tax isn't enough, proportionally regardless of the over all figure and the old oh they'll just avoid and evade is a load of bollocks and could easily be prevented if the govt had the balls to.

SQLserved · 20/06/2022 23:07

Yodaisawally · 20/06/2022 21:48

Lots of private sector industries have had pay freezes. I don't get a pay rise for five years. This year it was 1%.

I too am private sector and have never not had a pay rise. This year it was over 10%.

We are not all in a race to the bottom.

You want to accept little or no pay rise for yourself. But why should everyone else have to do the same?

mrwalkensir · 20/06/2022 23:07

Does the rate of inflation take into account massive rental price rises?

JoanOgden · 20/06/2022 23:07

If private sector organisations can't recruit they raise salaries... the public sector should do the same. Focus the money on where the biggest recruitment gaps are and at the starting stage of each profession, to encourage people to join it.

Agree we should tax capital more to fund this. And revalue council tax, which is still based on what properties were worth in 1991.

starzyy · 20/06/2022 23:07

To reduce inflation we need there to be less demand, which is why the government will not meet the unions demands for higher wages. If wages increase, demand won’t decrease and the situation will be extended for everyone.

The problem is we also have far more inequality than the 70s. So some will be unaffected & still have money & there will be demand.

Keha · 20/06/2022 23:07

As a public sector worker I'd be interested to know how a job with my level of qualification, responsibility, stress etc would be paid in the private sector. I know a private sector worker in IT who doesn't manage anyone, noone dies if it goes wrong (although I guess people lose money) and who seems to have an average level of "specialist knowledge" but gets paid double what I do. But then I also know someone managing a 100 people, where poor risk assessments could lead to serious harm, working crazy hours getting paid less. I feel like I don't want more than anyone else, or someone else to be worse off as I am better off. But it also irks me that I work really hard doing something quite thankless and other sectors may pay a lot more for something "easier".

Topgub · 20/06/2022 23:06

@fyn

That ignored what motivates people.

People are motivated by worth and value.

Its what we hear although time about higher earners

Funny how you're not suggesting we massively cut higher earners wages to help reduce demand

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/06/2022 23:05

We need to be taxing more at the top

We already do, as seen from the % of overall income tax contributed by "the top"

Also, not often being shackled by PAYE, "the top" have a lot more flexibility. Demand too much and (perfectly legal) arrangements get made whereby the exchequer receives nothing - in other words yet another case of being careful what's wished for

Legrandsophie · 20/06/2022 23:03

TheKeatingFive · 20/06/2022 22:57

Right, but how bad do you want the recruitment crisis in the NHS to get. Unless their salaries can compete with the private sector then they will not be able to recruit.

The private sector won't be doling out rises in line with inflation, don't worry.

The nhs needs a radical overhaul, with its purpose, management and how it's funded all rethought. Either we move to a much higher tax economy or large swathes of it get privatised, the current model just isn't functional.

The private sector already pay more, that’s the issue. If you are a young person looking at where to invest your time and energy would it be medicine or the tech industry? One pays an average wage for long and unsociable hours and the other is increasingly WFH and well paid.

Why should people work in a job where inflation is gouging there wages when they could move to another sector and earn more. Answer: they won’t and the whole system will collapse under the strain.

The same goes for social care (some of the lowest paid public sector workers), teaching assistants, fire fighter etc. These are all vital jobs. They need to be paid well enough to keep vacancies low. I’m not sure that any business would look at the enormous list of job vacancies the NHS has and not raise their salary off to attract interest. Why is it not the same for the public sector?

starzyy · 20/06/2022 23:02

BofE printed £445 billion in the 8 years that followed the financial crisis. It printed a further £450 billion in the two years during Covid, stopping for a breather in May 2022.

I'm not sure what the point of your numbers was? I simply said QE was propping up the economy before covid.

On the lockdown point, we had a choice to not lock down healthy working age adults. Choices have consequences. This situation was not inevitable.

Again my point was if you do go with lockdown you can't not support people. They were paid in part to be passive.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 20/06/2022 23:02

But while we wait for a pay rise my employer is increasing the cost of parking for staff… yay 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread