Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have said something to this mum?

161 replies

rocksonrocks · 20/06/2022 18:30

I was waiting for my husband in my car earlier when a woman pulled up next to me and got out of her car. As she walked away from her car she said "do not open the door or talk to anyone" and when I looked inside she had left her her daughter in her car seat whilst she went into the shop. It's really hot where I am and she didn't leave the window open, and the little girl can't have been older than two.

We left after about 5 minutes but it's been niggling me ever since. Should I have said something? WIBU if I did?

OP posts:
rocksonrocks · 21/06/2022 09:07

I can't quite believe how many people have said this is acceptable or that they've done it themselves! There's no way it's okay, and I really really wish I'd stayed with her until her mum came back.

It was very hot yesterday where I live, I was sat waiting in my own car whilst my husband was in the shop and I had both windows down because of the heat. No way would I have sat in there comfortably with the windows open.

And aside from the heat, it's dangerous and stupid to leave your young child alone in a car where you can't see them. For SO many reasons.

OP posts:
Skinnermarink · 21/06/2022 09:03

Fadeout83 · 21/06/2022 08:48

This blows my mind. I feel sick thinking about those kids left in the cars. Horrible, horrible people. And shame on anyone here thinking this is ok.

Indeed that is bloody awful and how neglectful of that parent. But how did you know the child then went on to be admitted to hospital with dehydration?

Fadeout83 · 21/06/2022 08:48

Lifeispassingby · 21/06/2022 04:18

Last year on one of the hottest days of the year DH and I saw a child locked in a car. Turns out his dad had gone in the supermarket to do the shopping and although he had left the window open the car had automatically locked and shut all the windows. The child had a severe panic attack and was leaping around the car banging on the windows. The car wash opposite said the car had been there 20 mins and no one had done anything. DH and I rang the police and asked for a tannoy announcement, the car wash man smashed the window, when the father arrived back he didn’t even thank us but made more fuss about his broken window. Apparently he hadn’t intended to be so long! The child passed out and was admitted to hospital for dehydration. It was awful.

This blows my mind. I feel sick thinking about those kids left in the cars. Horrible, horrible people. And shame on anyone here thinking this is ok.

Skinnermarink · 21/06/2022 07:16

How do you confuse a toddler with a seven year old child ?

LMB0716 · 21/06/2022 07:00

You make your 3 year old stop playing and come upstairs every time you need a wee? What about when you’re cooking tea, do they have to stay in the kitchen? Are they in the same room as you at all times? This has my mind blown.

RandyK · 21/06/2022 07:00

I would have said something. Someone could have kidnapped the child.

Landlubber2019 · 21/06/2022 06:59

@Tilltheend99

Years ago I found 2 toddlers alone in a car parked in a municipal car park. I had returned from shopping and waited10 mins for the parent to return before I dialled 999 for assistance. The parent arrived at the same time as the police about 5-10mins later, in passing I spoke to the mum carrying multiple bags from various high street stores, she initially thought I was joking when I said I had called the police, she then got really angry with me! I left with the police giving her a right royal rollicking about the inappropriateness of leaving kids alone in the car. It also turned out the kids were 2 and 7, not both toddlers and so mum had left the 2yr old under the care of the 7yr old. It made no difference to the police officer who advised it was still inappropriate.

Elderflower14 · 21/06/2022 06:57

Lifeispassingby · 21/06/2022 04:19

I also think when unattended children are left what if something happens to the adult who left them and no one knows the child is there?

Absolutely this!!!!

OperaStation · 21/06/2022 06:50

berksandbeyond · 20/06/2022 19:09

I would have gone into the supermarket and asked them to put out a tannoy announcement for the owner of vehicle with that reg, because she'd left her baby locked in a hot car. And yes I would confront someone over this, children have died from this?

Exactly this. I’ve heard announcements like this for dogs so it’s the very least we should do for children.

BetterDaysareComming · 21/06/2022 06:24

It's worrying to know that some people think this is ok to do.

I agree with the poster who said to inform the shop so they could make a tannoy announcement. It might remind any other parents who've left their children in their cars too.

SinnermanGirl · 21/06/2022 06:23

Rosehugger · 21/06/2022 03:36

I wouldn't bother if it was a few minutes in the UK. We aren't in Australia and it wasn't that hot today!

You don’t need to be in Texas or Australia to care about young children’s safety. It’s ok to look after children in the UK too.

It’s weird the way some people treat child neglect like something to be proud of.

Pumasonsatsumas · 21/06/2022 05:16

People interfere for dogs on hot days, wth would you not interfere on behalf of a child?

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 21/06/2022 04:31

People saying it’s not Texas/Australia- try sitting in your car in the sunshine for 15 mins tomorrow. I sat in the car to take a conference call the other day, as I was on the school run. It wasn’t a heatwave day. Good god after 10 mins I couldn’t bear it.

Even if the mum thought she’d only be a couple of minutes, it’s a supermarket, she can’t see what the queues are like, she might think she’ll just grab this and just grab that.

Even in winter - would you leave your handbag on the car seat in a supermarket car park? No!! So why would you with the thing worth a million times more to you.

I’d have waited 5 mins (timed it) and called police if she didn’t come back then. But the tannoy is a better idea.

Lifeispassingby · 21/06/2022 04:19

I also think when unattended children are left what if something happens to the adult who left them and no one knows the child is there?

Lifeispassingby · 21/06/2022 04:18

Last year on one of the hottest days of the year DH and I saw a child locked in a car. Turns out his dad had gone in the supermarket to do the shopping and although he had left the window open the car had automatically locked and shut all the windows. The child had a severe panic attack and was leaping around the car banging on the windows. The car wash opposite said the car had been there 20 mins and no one had done anything. DH and I rang the police and asked for a tannoy announcement, the car wash man smashed the window, when the father arrived back he didn’t even thank us but made more fuss about his broken window. Apparently he hadn’t intended to be so long! The child passed out and was admitted to hospital for dehydration. It was awful.

JambalayaOrGumbo · 21/06/2022 04:13

Just read the following info from raisingchildren.net.au/toddlers/safety/car-pedestrian-safety/never-leave-children-in-cars#:~:text=Heatstroke%20and%20other%20facts%20about%20children%20in%20hot%20cars,-Here%27s%20what%20you&text=And%20most%20of%20this%20temperature,are%20parked%20in%20the%20shade.

Heat is the main risk for children left unattended in cars. Children can suffer life-threatening heatstroke, rapid dehydration, suffocation and death.
This is because cars can get very hot very quickly. In fact, on a hot day, the temperature inside a parked car can be as much as 40°C hotter than it is outside. When cars are parked, it takes less than 5 minutes for them to heat to temperatures that can seriously harm children.
Cars can heat to dangerous or fatal levels even on cool or overcast days or when they’re parked in the shade.
The younger children are, the more sensitive they are to heatstroke and the faster they’ll dehydrate.

Leaving your child in your car can be dangerous for other reasons too. For example, your child could:
release themselves from their seat, leave the car and get onto the road
disengage the car’s handbrake, causing it to roll forwards or backwards
choke on food, a toy or other objects within their reach
play with the windows and get their limbs or neck caught
be involved in a car crash
be a victim of a break-in
accidentally lock you out of the car

Maybebabyno2 · 21/06/2022 04:06

When it's a dog, everyone is willing to smash the windows. When I stupidly put the keys in my sons carseat and walked around the car to grab something and he locked the door, no one was willing to help. I had nothing I could smash the window with and onlookers were unwilling to help me SMASH MY OWN FUCKING WINDOW to get back into the car. They didn't seem at all bothered there was a 2 year old in there alone. They didn't offer to call police or anything, just chuckled at my predicament, said something about terrible twos and wondered off.

I had to run into the nearby shop and practically beg for help, they didn't seem bothered either!

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/06/2022 04:06

I'd call the police and let the supermarket know.

I can still remember the fear, I let off the handbrake in my Mums Renault 4, when left outside a shop (not a supermarket, small shop on a small precinct).. the car rolled down the slight slope towards the (not very busy) main road.

The terror of the car suddenly moving, then tbh the even bigger terror of people shouting.. and then people screaming as they realised there was a kid in there.. then my MOTHER screaming.. and then the almighty bollocking I got when she finally got to me, when the car hit the kerb and stopped.. and didn't cross the pavement and roll into the main road.

I can only have been 2/3 at the time.

The risks of a hot day, plus a kid who may be able to unclip themselves, meddle with stuff etc... its too much.

Marvellousmadness · 21/06/2022 04:00

This happened where i lived. And then the car got stolen . . With the kid in it.

I would have notified the police. Taken video evidence etc. Its neglect

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 21/06/2022 03:53

Cherryblossoms85 · 21/06/2022 00:03

I dislike busybodies so much that I would generally say it's none of your business, but keeping the windows shut does seem stupid. Not sure how hot it was though. People do act as if 20 degrees is the same as 40 degrees in Texas...

20 degrees outside can easily result in 40 degrees inside a car if the sun is on the car. Have you never returned to the car on a sunny day and needed to open the doors for a bit before you could get in?

Rosehugger · 21/06/2022 03:36

I wouldn't bother if it was a few minutes in the UK. We aren't in Australia and it wasn't that hot today!

Maverick101 · 21/06/2022 03:23

Yep very illegal in Australia -- this is worth a watch for those of you who are blase about the heat.

Kerrrmieee · 21/06/2022 01:27

I popped in to local co-op (tiny one) to do a mad dash grab milk and out.

On the way to pay, I heard this booming racket - think sound system bass from idiot driving past.

My daughter had accidentally kicked the radio volume on to full blast . Shit! Chuck quid at man and leg it out.

Bless her, she was terrified and screaming. I didn't leave her after that.

I would have stayed and watched the child in your situation OP.

What's done is done though and I'm sure child is fine. However, it's a case of how many risks does the mum want to take.

wandawaves · 21/06/2022 01:15

It's illegal in Australia. That would be an immediate call to the police and a smashed window here, no questions asked.

Fadeout83 · 21/06/2022 00:50

Weatherwax13 · 21/06/2022 00:48

@teleskopregel yes it's illegal here. Pretty much every year there's a news report about a child/baby dying in a hot car. And a car can overheat when it's only in the 20s outside.
It doesn't even have to be a boiling hot day.
It's not being dramatic or a busybody to intervene.
LOs and dogs can die frighteningly quickly like this so you can't hang about - particularly if you've just arrived on the scene and don't know how long they've been there.

It is remarkable how blasé people are about leaving a small child that is unable to regulate its body temperature in a car on a hot day! No words.

Swipe left for the next trending thread