Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Star of the week awards

30 replies

Irritatedmum · 20/06/2022 15:05

Hi all. My DD is in reception and is starting to get a bit upset that she’s never had a star of the week type award. Do teachers tend to keep track of who’s had one and make sure they all get it? Or do they literally just pick? I feel sorry for her 😂

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
easyday · 20/06/2022 20:08

I hate these wretched awards. Star of the Week seems to be spread around but then there's points for good behaviour, which tends to rewards those unruly kids when they do behave yet those kids who always behave rarely get recognised.
Then there are kids who will get the science prize every year, because if they are top of the class (or whatever criteria) they will most likely be the same the next year. And inevitably there's always a couple kids who are brilliant all rounders so they also get the music and sport prize as well as the science prize! So the schools start making up 'year tutor prize' vague 'most improved' prize and so on.
I've sat through 12 years of prize giving and only once has one of my kids got a prize, yet they have to sit there year after year watching the same dozen kids get rewarded. Well deserved as those kids are, even they must get tired of it!

EmeraldShamrock1 · 20/06/2022 19:06

I don't think teachers include everyone AFAIK it depends on excellent behaviour.

DS is ending his 2nd year with the same teacher he never got it, he has plenty of stickers for minor things and a big effort.

Jott · 20/06/2022 19:01

Mommabear20 · 20/06/2022 16:32

Another meaningless award! If everyone gets it at some point, it's not 'star of the week' it's 'whose name is randomly picked this week' 🤦‍♀️

Part of the ethos of our school is that every child is a valued member of our school community snd every child contributes something special to that community. Making sure everyone gets star of the week at some point during the year reinforces that ethos by recognising that they all bring something to the table.

We also do individual recognition outside of star if the week, for example of a child gets a medal at their football club or a badge at cubs or some other notable achievement then parents can send in their medal/badge/certificate and they get presented with it in assembly (as well as their original presentation wherever they first got it from).

There is a weekly friendship award which is given to pupils who have been kind, friendly, inclusive, and helpful.

There is a monthly reading award that comes with a cumulative reward. Every time a child reads they get a point. Ten points they get a gold headteacher award sticker given in assembly, twenty they get a certificate, forty an extra ten minute playtime, fifty a bookmark, and so on.

It's possible to celebrate individual achievement as well as celebrating everyone but making one reward inclusive of everyone regardless of ability makes sure everyone gets recognition at least once. This is important for children.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 20/06/2022 17:36

I hate this shit, all children need to feel some recognition and it's a very rare child who does nothing kind, helpful or who achieves something beyond 'their normal'.

I'm not a fan of praise for the sake of praise, but relentlessly uplifting some children at the expense of others is just cruel.

Glittertwins · 20/06/2022 17:29

ColmanFlamingo · 20/06/2022 16:49

Yep my two quiet children never got theirs until June or July because they were the invisible ones. Meanwhile little Tommy used to get one every other week because that week he hadn't hurt anyone!

Oh yes, the one about not hitting anyone one this week resonates here!
I know how upset they get when it's always the same child who gets it. I gave up trying to reason it

Crankley · 20/06/2022 17:19

I agree you should have a word. It seems wrong to me that a child is rewarded for not doing something bad when yours is helpful and kind. I know a lot of teachers may disagree but many do have favourites.

I'm in my 70s but still remember being voted as one of four team leaders in my class. The teacher said to the children, 'did you really mean to vote for Crankley - wouldn't Janet (her favourite) be better?' They stuck to their vote and she was furious as she gave me the blue sash.

Irritatedmum · 20/06/2022 17:08

Thanks all for the advice and input. From what’s she’s told me - and from what I know from my older DD - it tends to be used either to encourage the very quiet or badly behaved kids and the others tend to get missed. It must be strange for a 5 year old to see someone who is often hitting other children get an award for having a good day, but then not get it themselves.

OP posts:
Abraxan · 20/06/2022 17:05

Irritatedmum · 20/06/2022 15:05

Hi all. My DD is in reception and is starting to get a bit upset that she’s never had a star of the week type award. Do teachers tend to keep track of who’s had one and make sure they all get it? Or do they literally just pick? I feel sorry for her 😂

Every teacher at my school keeps a list, as well as a central list in our Celebration Awards book/record.

Each of our classes still have 2-3 children who have not yet had a SOTW type award as we generally only award one a week per class in the assembly.

Unfortunately someone always has to be one of the last to get their's but it definitely doesn't mean they haven't deserved one or that they won't get one.

ColmanFlamingo · 20/06/2022 16:49

Yep my two quiet children never got theirs until June or July because they were the invisible ones. Meanwhile little Tommy used to get one every other week because that week he hadn't hurt anyone!

megletthesecond · 20/06/2022 16:45

You should mention it to the teacher. They don't always keep track. DS didn't get anything in reception year, some of his friends got two awards. He was above average (but not top) and always really well behaved.

He said he'd start being naughty then being good so he got something. Obviously I shot that idea down quickly and spoke to his teacher instead who assumed he'd had a star of the week. Sadly there wasn't enough time in that academic year to get anything in the end.

Cryingbutstilltrying · 20/06/2022 16:45

Definitely have a quiet word with the teacher.
DN is a quiet and helpful child, no trouble at all, and almost always got overlooked. SIL brought it up at July parents evening as he hadn’t had one all year and was upset. The teacher insisted he had, SIL insisted he hadn’t, made her check, he hadn’t. Of course he got it the next week.
DD and DS are shitbags so rarely got them. DD had 5 through the whole of primary but she didn’t care as she sussed quite quickly how they always went to the same kids. DS has SEN and seems to get them slightly more consistently for not throwing pens etc. So there might well be something in that theory.

PeekAtYou · 20/06/2022 16:44

My dd worked out when she was y2/3 ish that if you wanted to win one then the easiest way was to behave badly one day then behave normally/well the next. I understand why children with behavioural issues benefit from rewards but children who behave well at school might be battling with their own issues like anxiety or an unstable home life which doesn't get the same recognition at school because the teachers aren't therapists and behaviour that puts people's safety at risk is obviously more urgent.

skgnome · 20/06/2022 16:41

It’s hard when your kid is constantly one of the last getting it… my DD’s last name starts with a U… I’m convinced it’s alphabetical in her school….
then again, the week she gets it she’s soooo happy!!

iluvsummer · 20/06/2022 16:39

I’d ask as the term is coming to an end soon. We keep tick lists and I write all my certificates out at the beginning of the year (add in the date etc when they’re given out) so it’s really easy to keep track then of who has had one and there are no duplicates.

orwellwasright · 20/06/2022 16:39

InChocolateWeTrust · 20/06/2022 16:12

Then there's the really special award for exemplary behaviour and that's genuinely given to the kids who go above and beyond. It's often won multiple times by the same child and some kids will never get one.

I think a school is getting something badly wrong if an award is won multiple times by the same child.

Whilst I believe that acknowledging every child at some point will promote desirable behaviour so it's appropriate to share the praise, particularly for little ones, it's a fact that some children naturally display those behaviours more frequently than others. So why shouldn't they be acknowledged every time they do?

That's how life works isn't it? You don't tell the Olympic athlete she can't win gold because she won gold four years ago, do you.

SilverPeacock · 20/06/2022 16:37

Dd once didn’t get one all year and then not until later in the next year whilst other kids had had multiple. I was nearly phoning them. She still remembers this years later! Stupid idea if you ask me. I would ask the teacher. Don’t make the mistake I made and still have your 14 year old bringing it up as a point of trauma 😆

Aksbdt · 20/06/2022 16:34

I asked the teacher as I didn’t know whether to prepare DD that it might not happen but apparently they all get it at some point in her class although am very aware that it’s nearly the end of the year…

Mommabear20 · 20/06/2022 16:32

Another meaningless award! If everyone gets it at some point, it's not 'star of the week' it's 'whose name is randomly picked this week' 🤦‍♀️

PeekAtYou · 20/06/2022 16:30

I used to have to mention it at parents evening and they'd win the following week.

In theory is should be on a rota but in practice I found that some kids would win it multiple times and others would get it once because their parent had nudged the teacher into it.

lanthanum · 20/06/2022 16:30

DD never got it before about May. As I explained to her, if one of the silly boys has a good week, the teacher gives it to them because they might not get another chance. She was always sensible and did good work, so they were safe to leave her until later in the year, because they'd always be able to find a reason!

Later they changed the system so that there was a theme each week (linked to the start-of-week assembly) and so they had to be caught doing something related to the theme (eg being kind to someone, picking up litter). It did make it more random and less of a rota - so more possible that some children never got it, but at least they could see why the recipient was chosen.

Narwhalelife · 20/06/2022 16:28

My daughter is in year 7 now but I remember this well from primary school!

she won it once I think in all the years - as she got older she said it went to the kids this managed to sit still for longer than 5 minutes or who didn’t throw a pen at the teacher that day 🙄

I get that some kids have additional needs but come on, what about the kids (like my DD) who are just normal, generally good kids!

she is in a grammar school now and they are very generous with lots of different awards, prizes etc much nicer way if approaching things

NewOrleansOrDie · 20/06/2022 16:27

At this point in the year there is absolutely nothing wrong with mentioning that she hasn't had one.

tithead22 · 20/06/2022 16:25

I keep a spreadsheet and I ask for pupils to nominate classmates to because lots of things happen without teachers knowing.

jellyfrizz · 20/06/2022 16:21

At every school I've worked at you keep a spreadsheet to make sure everyone gets one at some point.

InChocolateWeTrust · 20/06/2022 16:12

Then there's the really special award for exemplary behaviour and that's genuinely given to the kids who go above and beyond. It's often won multiple times by the same child and some kids will never get one.

I think a school is getting something badly wrong if an award is won multiple times by the same child.