Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many people have confused their paying holiday rental with house sitting?

467 replies

HeleenaHandcart · 20/06/2022 10:23

Back from a week away and I’m starting to give up on UK holiday homes.

I obviously am happy to respect the property and be generally clean and tidy, but more and more I see higher and higher costs and higher and higher cleaning expectations. As well as earlier and earlier leaving times.

I don’t want to work as an unpaid house keeper before a long drive, nor generally add towards upkeep of the house I’m paying a ton for. I used to strip beds for example, but not with kids and an early leave time as well as wanting it all bagged up it’s a bit much before 9am. Frankly I’m not watering anything either. Now as well more and more places say you must leave by 9am, yet can’t enter until 5/6pm due to ‘cleaning’ but you must clean the place fully. Bins out and a list of chores for you.

Last week I was asked to be in for the washing machine repair man even (I said no). It’s not a bloody holiday- it’s house sitting and paying to be a house-sitter. My particular annoyance is stating ‘all surfaces to be cleaned and wiped, including the bathroom’ and they don’t leave a single cloth or cleaning product in the property. It’s like they also expect you to either purchase or bring a house cleaning kit.

Oh and ‘quirks of the property’, stuff that generally requires extra work to use stuff like ‘each day the windows all must be opened for 10 min’, ‘the shower cubicle has a daily water mark spray’ or ‘the boiler needs x, y…’

Its time to go back to hotel stays

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 21/06/2022 09:48

greenteafiend · 21/06/2022 03:42

Someone above mentioned aparthotels and I think that sounds like a good model. I'd also like to see more "connected rooms" setups in hotels, where the children can sleep in one room accessible only by a door leading into the main room where the parents sleep.

Agreed - we always book self-catering properties (often flats) but I'm aware of the issue with holiday homes in many locations, and would rather not contribute to it. But it's usually our only option if we don't want to have me, DH, a 3 year old and a 1 year old in one room. We've done that for the odd night, but I'd rather not go at all than do it for a whole holiday. I also like having a kitchen, but could live without that.

Lavapalaver · 21/06/2022 09:42

100% agree.

antelopevalley · 21/06/2022 09:42

@Caspianberg I wasnt commenting on your place at all. But you claimed that people stayed because of the family vibe and that your toddler is part of that.

Caspianberg · 21/06/2022 09:40

@antelopevalley - huh? My place is full all summer.
The only way you can guarantee child free is an exclusive adult only resort. Otherwise of course families live in normal houses

antelopevalley · 21/06/2022 09:38

Last air bnb place I stayed in was awful. Filthy and shabby. It had beautiful photos and 5 star reviews that I suspect were all faked. I gave up on air bnb after that experience.

themessygarden · 21/06/2022 09:34

Ohthatsexciting · 20/06/2022 16:02

If you take a risk on a poorly reviewed and pretty low budget rental Op… you just gotta suck that shit up

wouldn’t be a holiday to me

Hence i throw money at holidays and never experience this kind of thing

It's not always poorly reviewed properties though, especially AirBnB because you are not allowed an overly critical review (or it will be removed).

I was looking for a 2 bedroom exclusive use apartment in London, I found one with was 4,000 for 6 nights with 5 star reviews. . The front page shows it has two bedrooms, 1st bedroom with a double bed and single bed and the 2nd bedroom with a double bed. Then you look at the detail and this is what it says

"Exclusive use of this apartment with all that you need for your stay.

One double bed (in bedroom 1)
One double sofa bed with extra thick layer of memory foam, making it feel like a standard bed (in bedroom 2).
Single folding bed (with a standard, comfortable single mattress) available if requested.
No separate living room"

"If you want to use the cooker (stove, oven), access is subject to host's discretion and additional fee of two hundred pounds payable before your trip starts."

"In addition there is a daily charge of ten pounds to use the cooker to keep my apartment’s price lower for those who do not need to use stove/oven."

"Babies under age of two are considered paying guests which will add extra guest fee after the booking of twenty pounds"

So basically a 1 bedroom apartment with sofa bed in living room and no access to a cooker unless you pay more.

antelopevalley · 21/06/2022 09:34

@Caspianberg No one books your place because your toddler is on site.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 21/06/2022 09:18

HeleenaHandcart · 21/06/2022 09:06

@420Bruh I have family near Lulworth and saw properties empty in June half term… they were asking 3k for the week though!!!
It struck me as greed issue, rather than a market issue

Precisely the reason I'm avoiding Dorset and the New Forest region at present. Pricing like that just doesn't need encouraging. No wonder the airports are in such a mess!

pixie5121 · 21/06/2022 09:11

100%. These people are cheeky fuckers.

It's beyond entitled to charge someone a fortune for accommodation and then give them a list of things to do before they leave. I've had people say "well we need to turn over the rooms in a short space of time" as if that's somehow my problem. Hire more staff, then, or sell the business to someone more competent. It's just ridiculous to charge someone £200 a night for a cottage and expect them to clean. Throw away rubbish, yes, take the binbag out, yes, wash dishes, yes, give surfaces a wipe, yes, maybe strip the beds. Anything more than that and they're completely taking the piss. I don't go on holiday to clean showers and mop floors.

MugginsOverEre · 21/06/2022 09:09

JimTheShit · 20/06/2022 12:07

An alternative perspective.
I am Airbnbing a flat the moment in between long term rentals (long story).
I'm doing it through an intermediary/management company.
Couple of observations:
The charge to the guest is extortionate. I don’t set the rate, the management co does. But from my perspective, after I pay

  1. the Airbnb fee to me, this is on top of what the guest pays Airbnb.
  2. the management company fee of 20% of the gross amount ie before cleaning and Airbnb’s fees
  3. plus the management co’s monthly fee of £30 (on top of the 20% management fee) I’m lucky if I get half of it of the gross amount the guest pays.

The cleaning fee is crazy. it’s a small 1 bed flat. When I lived there I had a cleaner for a couple of hours a week at £10/hour. It could be done in one hour except no one wants to work for an hour so I paid for 2. The cleaning charge to the guest is £76.
The cleaning company presumably get £76 for what could be at most 2 hours work.
The management company also take 20% of the cleaning fee so in effect I also pay around £15 for cleaning.

Most people now try to complain about something in order to get money off the extortionate fee they’ve paid Airbnb. I don’t blame them and it works every time. However the amount they refund to the guest comes out of my net income, after the air bnb fees and after the management company fees all of the gross.
So every time someone complains (sofa not comfortable or “not enough pots and pans”, in reality there are adequate pots and pans for 2 guests but not for 6 guests that they had for dinner) and they get a refund, I’m down another 20/30%. I don’t blame guests for trying their luck to complain. The pricing is crazy.

Point being, between the tax, the mortgage, the crazy utilities prices at they moment (and guests all seem to have heating on 24/7 despite being 20+ degrees here every day); and the amount of things I have to supply, Airbnb has been a massive money pit. I earn less than I do when the property is rented to long term tenants despite the headline figure indicating that Airbnb would earn me twice what long term tenants pay.
Never again.

That's terrible. Imagine a flat owner being forced to use such a company. It's a shame you cannot employ someone else... Hmm

HeleenaHandcart · 21/06/2022 09:06

@420Bruh I have family near Lulworth and saw properties empty in June half term… they were asking 3k for the week though!!!
It struck me as greed issue, rather than a market issue

OP posts:
Stroopwaffels · 21/06/2022 09:01

What's so bad about Sykes? We've used them a few times for self-catering in the Uk without any problems.

The last place we stayed was in Aviemore at Easter - lots and lots of properties in the town are self catering. We often choose self-catering because as a family of 5 it's hard to get hotel accommodation, and we like the space you get with a house. Check in was 4pm which was fine, when we arrived there was an issue with the heating and DH contacted the owner who talked him through how to reset it. She did say if there was a still a problem she'd send round an engineer BUT the engineer would be able to pick up a spare key from her agent's office and wouldn't disturb us, and as the heating was in the garage the engineer wouldn't need to come into the house at all. During the week we were asked if we'd leave the bins out for collecting and there was a schedule of waste collections - again, a 2 minute job which nobody minded.

On the Friday before we left the cleaners arrived with clean laundry and a request to leave it in the hall - but only if it was convenient - and that was not a problem. On leaving we were asked to strip the beds and put them in the labelled bags provided along with towels, and to leave the dishwasher running. Also to leave the place "generally clean and tidy" and take the bins out. That's all very reasonable if you ask me - no extra cleaning, no hoovering or mopping.

We did stay in a place in France 3 years ago which was a private gite with the owner living in another part of hte same building, we had to be out by 9am on the dot although we were not asked to strip beds. No towels provided either which was a right pain.

Tinymrscollings · 21/06/2022 08:37

I’m an Airbnb host, and I’ve spent quite a lot of time on hosting forums over the years. What’s clear from what I see there is that whilst there are undoubtedly a lot of guests out there who don’t know how to look after a self catering property, they are vastly outnumbered by the number of hosts who really, really shouldn’t be in the hospitality business. It makes me quite angry. It’s not a huge amount of work and you can make good money, but it isn’t free money and those who treat it as if it is and their guests are an inconvenience to be managed make me furious.

The check in and check out times thing is trickier, though. If you want somewhere nice to stay that’s clean and ready for you then the person preparing it needs time. When you say leave at 9, it’s often 10. When you say check in at 5, it’s often 4, so we’re always bearing that in mind when we give timings. The full 8 hours is rather a lot though, unless it’s a mansion.

themessygarden · 21/06/2022 07:43

ElephantsFart · 20/06/2022 11:48

Not being able to control the heating in winter is a deal breaker.

This happened to us, and it was over the Christmas period, it was miserable.

They had one of those remote nest things and when we asked them to increase the heating, the owner was really pissed off and eventually agreed to increase it by 1deg, 'but no more than that'. We had paid thousands for the pleasure.

420Bruh · 21/06/2022 07:28

I think people must really agree with you though, as the market is crashing in the south west. People have started turning airbnbs back into longterm lets, and investment properties sitting empty in June!

DangerouslyBored · 21/06/2022 07:24

I won’t stay at these places. Sod stripping the bed! I don't so that at a hotel so why the fuck should I do it at your holiday home. We own a place in France that we let out in August. We don’t ask our guests to do anything when they leave, just to be respectful. We pay a lot of money for a cleaner but why the hell should we expect our guests to clean when they are on holiday! It’s just cheeky fuckery.

I’m also fed up with shoddy overpriced hotels. DH and I stayed in a pub in the Jurassic Coast. £230 a night, bed was so hard neither of us got any sleep and the property was old and so we heard every sneeze, snore from our neighbours and then upstairs some people decided to have a party at 1am. The duvet was like something from Asda economy range. I was so pissed off, we came home shattered. Couldn’t wait to get back to our own comfortable bed and peaceful house.

We’re going to buy a touring caravan for next year. I just won’t do UK hotels anymore.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 21/06/2022 07:04

QuidditchThroughtheAges · 21/06/2022 00:23

@CanaryShoulderedThorn oh my word that sounds like hell on earth! Did you complain??

We did complain and the reply we got was that the owner was very elderly and quite eccentric but a lovely woman. Which is all very well but it was an awful holiday and we were offerred no compensation.

TurquoiseDress · 21/06/2022 06:38

YANBU!

I've stayed in a handful of Air BnB over the last several years but none post-Covid

Shocked at the list of tasks some of you have had to get done whilst on holiday! Confused

HarlanPepper · 21/06/2022 06:03

@Caspianberg most reasonable people don't have a problem with a 10am check-out. I think it's been standard in every holiday rental I've stayed in and it's never been an issue, even when our children were small. I don't like hanging around on my last day anyway - can't relax when there's a long journey ahead.

Caspianberg · 21/06/2022 05:39

@minuette1 - well it is my guests problem. I ask for check out by 10am, and check in after 3pm for a reason. My guests usually stick to it happily. It’s just someone above who says they can’t be bothered. I don’t ask for any cleaning done by guests.
I charge a reasonable rate and no extra cleaning fee. Otherwise I would have to put costs up also to other guests to allow for that one who doesn’t abide so I can pay a nanny or cleaner €20 per hour x5 ( so an extra €100 on every stay). That’s why others have increased rates and then people also moan.
My rental is part of my own house, it’s for me to make a little money. It’s not a luxury 5 star hotel.
I don’t have back to back bookings, but sometimes people ask to add an extra day or two due to plans changing. Again, I try and accommodate this for people and that’s when I might get same day changeovers. If I have a 4 day gap, then I do let guests know they are also welcome to arrive a bit earlier or leave a bit later

I could also speed up ‘clean’ and allow you in at 2pm instead of 3pm. But then you also wouldn’t get things like the welcome hampers, kids toys and high chairs brought in you want, the beach stuff cleaned and checked in cellar. I would just have to take all that off list of what’s available as not time to do. I provide, for Free. People book family run places for that reason, the extra touches, the family vibe. That includes my Toddler being on site. If you want no one on-site, then book a remote private villa ( for 5x the cost)

Ozgirl75 · 21/06/2022 05:37

Aparthotels are fab where you can find them (although still smaller than a good Airbnb) but I guess what I like about Airbnb or other house type places is that they’re so different. We recently stayed in a place in the Blue Mountains and it had a massive beautiful kitchen, lovely living room, four double bedrooms, two bathrooms, a hot tub, garden, view over the wilderness, massive balcony and it cost us $350 per night (about £220 I believe?). Hotels just can’t compete with that.

We’ve also stayed in beachside houses, a flat overlooking the Eiger and a lovely home with a pool and tennis court in Byron Bay.

greenteafiend · 21/06/2022 03:42

Someone above mentioned aparthotels and I think that sounds like a good model. I'd also like to see more "connected rooms" setups in hotels, where the children can sleep in one room accessible only by a door leading into the main room where the parents sleep.

greenteafiend · 21/06/2022 03:40

In Japan, they changed the law a few years back so that you cannot run AirBnB unless you are registered as a "minshuku" (a kind of hostel or proper BnB) with the local authorities, which requires meeting a whole bunch of requirements. It has helped keep AirBnB very minimal and I think that is a good thing.

Summerfun54321 · 21/06/2022 02:06

We’ve had too many poorly equipped kitchens and a lack of basic health and safety to bother with Air b n b anymore.

Goldengoosey · 21/06/2022 01:53

Me too. I’m so over Airbnb having spent every day of my break a few weeks ago chasing the host about things not working/missing. On my day of departure I eventually got a refund but it was hassle I could have done without. The one before that different issues but hassle. Heating not working. Wait in for boiler man etc. F off I’m on holiday.

The stripping of beds that was introduced as part of covid makes no sense to me other than getting guests to do some of the work.

I’m in a hotel at the mo and it is bliss. No instructions about recycling/putting bins out/watering plants/tubs etc 😎