Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think many people have confused their paying holiday rental with house sitting?

467 replies

HeleenaHandcart · 20/06/2022 10:23

Back from a week away and I’m starting to give up on UK holiday homes.

I obviously am happy to respect the property and be generally clean and tidy, but more and more I see higher and higher costs and higher and higher cleaning expectations. As well as earlier and earlier leaving times.

I don’t want to work as an unpaid house keeper before a long drive, nor generally add towards upkeep of the house I’m paying a ton for. I used to strip beds for example, but not with kids and an early leave time as well as wanting it all bagged up it’s a bit much before 9am. Frankly I’m not watering anything either. Now as well more and more places say you must leave by 9am, yet can’t enter until 5/6pm due to ‘cleaning’ but you must clean the place fully. Bins out and a list of chores for you.

Last week I was asked to be in for the washing machine repair man even (I said no). It’s not a bloody holiday- it’s house sitting and paying to be a house-sitter. My particular annoyance is stating ‘all surfaces to be cleaned and wiped, including the bathroom’ and they don’t leave a single cloth or cleaning product in the property. It’s like they also expect you to either purchase or bring a house cleaning kit.

Oh and ‘quirks of the property’, stuff that generally requires extra work to use stuff like ‘each day the windows all must be opened for 10 min’, ‘the shower cubicle has a daily water mark spray’ or ‘the boiler needs x, y…’

Its time to go back to hotel stays

OP posts:
nordicwannabe · 20/06/2022 13:33

In France, they often give you a choice between cleaning it yourself or paying (usually around 50 Euros) for them to do it. That seems sensible.

In the UK, I'll empty the dishwasher and bins, and have a quick wipe round kitchen surfaces, but that's it. Oh, and will grudgingly strip the beds and bag up. That came in with covid, and seems to be here to stay despite no other covid precautions staying.. funny that...

If there's a cleaning fee (which there invariably is) I expect that to be used to pay a cleaner to do a full clean. Which means that anything I do would just be redone. IF the cleaning fee is used to pay for the cleaning.

darlingdodo · 20/06/2022 13:32

Badbadbunny, yes, the grants many holiday property owners received were disgraceful.

Many pubs/restaurants in the Lake District are opening with restricted hours because they can't get staff, a lot to do with prospective staff, earning minimum wage, can't afford to live in, say, Keswick, Ambleside or Bowness. Or can't find anywhere to live regardless of rental cost. There are some villages in the LD where 85% of properties are either second homes or holiday lets. The situation is completely unsustainable.

Glitterspy · 20/06/2022 13:32

Yes!!! We stayed in a holiday cottage near Portscatho in Cornwall last year (tempted to post the name of it to warn others off as they deleted my bad review, CFs)

It was late 6pm check in, early 9am check out, each room had a repair needed “quirk”, we were asked to stop in for the washing machine repair on three consecutive days which eventually was only fixed the day before we left (it was broken when we arrived), tiny thin smelly towels, no hand soap let alone shower gel, ONE dishwasher tablet, horrible cheap synthetic bedding, no dish soap, no dishcloths, tea towels…just as tight as you can get in terms of hospitality. These are not expensive things to supply and get right and plenty of lovely rental places do them. On a farm and no fucker even came to say hello. It was £2k for a week. Never again!

RosesAndHellebores · 20/06/2022 13:30

I'm on the fence about this. We used to be out of the house when the dc were small by 8.30am on a daily basis. The bathrooms, kitchen, was always clean, dishwasher on, floors clean, etc.

Invariably when we have booked a UK holiday cottage, especially in a popular resort we have been up and out by 7.30 to beat the traffic.

Kitchens and bathrooms are always clean at home or away because it's normal behaviour to keep them so. It takes less than two minutes to strip a bed and bung the towels in a bag.

We always pack up the night before and it's never a particular issue.

We have a house and some gites in France so I see this from both sides of the coin and disappointingly some people leave holiday accommodation in a dreadful state. I shudder to think about the state of their homes if they think it's acceptable.

It is customary in France to make up one's own beds and to expect more cleaning on departure than in England. There are different rules for letting to English people although the cost is often higher to account for higher housekeeping charges.

I suspect the rules imposed by Covid are here to stay for the domestic lettings market but the 9am departure and 5pm arrival time needs to be relaxed.

Dobbysgotthesocks · 20/06/2022 13:29

Bingbangbongbash · 20/06/2022 12:56

@Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase

The flip side is that without holiday lets, the local economy will suffer - people who stay in the lets also spend money in the local shops & restaurants. There are also plenty of people who let out their second homes that wouldn’t bother if the tax was prohibitive, but wouldn’t necessarily sell them.

I do agree that air bnb is a scourge on many areas, and the housing system is broken, though. I wonder what the solution is.

@Bingbangbongbash actually the local economies wouldn't suffer at all if the holiday let's disappear and local people have the opportunity to stay in their communities where they contribute 52 weeks per year to the local community.
At present people like myself are being forced out of our homes because of the shortage of housing. The day we ban holiday let's and second home ownership will be a fab day. There are discussions about new builds all having primary residential only clauses on them to prevent more holiday homes.

Paq · 20/06/2022 13:26

*I'm not sure what people who come to lovely little quaint villages are going to think when the village they love for its atmosphere and little boats in the harbour and lovely little restaurants and cafes and fetes find them all shut down and abandoned because no one can afford to live or work there but they are actively contributing to the demise of these communities.

Tourism is eating itself in the beautiful but poor parts of this country, loads of people have left hospitality and they're not coming back for £9.60 an hour, however "competitive" business owners think that is.*

Agree 1000% with this. There has to be a balance.

Badbadbunny · 20/06/2022 13:23

Many are also taking the Piss as most did VERY well from covid support grants. Assuming they were registered for business rates (as they are a business), they'd have got the initial £10k grant, plus subsequent grants. They'd almost certainly also be eligible for local authority grants. I've got clients with multiple properties (one being a row in a barn conversion and another being a large detached house converted into self contained holiday flats) - despite them being open for most of the two years (due to having separate entrances), they got £28,000 PER PROPERTY in support grants, so each got £112k (4 properties each), which was more than they'd have earned if covid didn't happen! An absolute disgrace they got so much support on top of the income for the months they could open, and on top of charging guests more! It's been a licence to print money.

hamsterchump · 20/06/2022 13:21

Bingbangbongbash · 20/06/2022 12:56

@Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase

The flip side is that without holiday lets, the local economy will suffer - people who stay in the lets also spend money in the local shops & restaurants. There are also plenty of people who let out their second homes that wouldn’t bother if the tax was prohibitive, but wouldn’t necessarily sell them.

I do agree that air bnb is a scourge on many areas, and the housing system is broken, though. I wonder what the solution is.

They don't contribute that much and much less than people staying in hotels, campsites etc as most tend to do their Waitrose shop on the way and hole up in their lovely little bolthole without spending much. Many airbnbs are not paying business rates or registered for tax or insured either.

I'm not sure what people who come to lovely little quaint villages are going to think when the village they love for its atmosphere and little boats in the harbour and lovely little restaurants and cafes and fetes find them all shut down and abandoned because no one can afford to live or work there but they are actively contributing to the demise of these communities.

Tourism is eating itself in the beautiful but poor parts of this country, loads of people have left hospitality and they're not coming back for £9.60 an hour, however "competitive" business owners think that is.

There are tent villages starting to form on the cliffs and dunes of the holiday destination where I live and families living in damp caravans and bnbs as their emergency accomodation for which they have the privilege of being charged £2000 - £4000 a month if they have the misfortune of being employed.

It'll be interesting to see what happens down here I suppose. I was hoping that with people being able to go abroad again a lot of these new airbnbs would go back to being long term rental accommodation but it hasn't happened yet and all the local business owners are shutting their kitchens a few days a week and scratching their heads that they don't have people queuing up to work all hours for minimum wage like usual. It's funny how they're so much quicker to increase their menu prices than their wages isn't it?

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 20/06/2022 13:21

The solution is to levy higher taxes on holiday let’s as well as second homes. This will lower prices and make them more available to locals and also for the Council to purchase so that they can be let at an affordable rent to those in genuine need of housing - not for greedy investors…

rnsaslkih · 20/06/2022 13:21

I have never understood airbnb

If I'm going away, I don't want to do domestic work. If going away involves that, I won't go.

onthefencesitter · 20/06/2022 13:20

I have never used airbnb (DH is against it) but now I never would. I thought the point of a holiday was a break from normal life and surely that would mean a break from cleaning...I mean, I do see the appeal in having a kitchen...

Time for more aparthotels. I didn't have a great experience at my last aparthotel in Munich (adagio) but I did have an amazing experience with the same chain at brussels. To be fair, the whole visit was very pleasant until a staff member disabled our key card before we were supposed to check out. I had no complaints about the apartment; it was clean and cosy and comfortable and at a good price. I mean, it was a bit annoying cos there was a chihuahua next door barking incessantly but for dog owners, this could be a draw as they allow pets! They have apartments for up to 4 people so not great for bigger families.

Scottishskifun · 20/06/2022 13:19

We always look at the cleaning cost when booking, if they charge especially a higher fee then we do the bare minimum - no dirty dishes (will definitelyleave clean ones on the draining board!), bins out and beds stripped. I'm not paying for the property to be cleaned for me to clean it beforehand if they take on too many cleaning of properties then they need to hire people in to help!

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 20/06/2022 13:19

Bingbangbongbash · 20/06/2022 12:56

@Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase

The flip side is that without holiday lets, the local economy will suffer - people who stay in the lets also spend money in the local shops & restaurants. There are also plenty of people who let out their second homes that wouldn’t bother if the tax was prohibitive, but wouldn’t necessarily sell them.

I do agree that air bnb is a scourge on many areas, and the housing system is broken, though. I wonder what the solution is.

The problem is in some areas housing has become unaffordable for many due to holiday let’s and second home ownership - combine that with ever increasing fuel costs and other price rises and some businesses are finding it hard to recruit staff (into typically low paying jobs e.g bar and kitchen staff, shop workers, care workers etc.) because they cannot afford to travel to the area.

It is killing off local communities!

Indigogogo · 20/06/2022 13:19

I wouldn't expect to do any cleaning or maintaining property while on holiday. I'd make sure it wasn't left a mess and dishes were clean and dirty towels were in a pile like hotels ask, but I'd expect them to be doing a clean, vacumn, stripping & remaking beds especially if had to pay a separate cost for cleaning but hotels usually factor in cleaner wages as part of cost of stay.

9am check out is far too early and would put me off booking there.

Chevyimpala67 · 20/06/2022 13:15

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/06/2022 13:13

Many people would love to jet off but its not always that easy

That's why I mentioned those who prefer to stay in the UK, Chevy, as opposed to those who sadly have no choice
I'm the first to appreciate some can't holiday abroad, and actually it makes the exploitation in the UK even worse Hmm

I do prefer to tbh :)
So much of the UK I want to see/visit!

Funkyslippers · 20/06/2022 13:14

scj96 I probably would have cheekily assumed the list was for the cleaner, and just left it!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/06/2022 13:13

Many people would love to jet off but its not always that easy

That's why I mentioned those who prefer to stay in the UK, Chevy, as opposed to those who sadly have no choice
I'm the first to appreciate some can't holiday abroad, and actually it makes the exploitation in the UK even worse Hmm

HannahSternDefoe · 20/06/2022 13:13

Going back to my holidays with my parents back in the 80s/early 90s - we were expected to:
. Mow the lawns front and back (electric mower and we had to pay for cards for the pre-pay meter) water any plants/trim bushes or you couldn't use the drive
. Clean the bathroom (leaky loo and sink) and separate shower room (just a shower cubicle) although there were never any cleaning products/mop etc provided.
. Hoover thru with a hoover which should have been on Antiques Roadshow, stank of dog and hadn't been emptied since we'd been there the year before (we marked the bag to test out our theory that we were the only ones who ever cleaned the place)
. clean the oven 🤯 even tho it wasn't used - we mostly ate out.
there was only a black and white TV (portable with a coathanger for an aerial) we took all our own bedding/towels and there was no washing machine/hot water other than the shower or a kettle.
The owner got quite arsey when we didn't lift a finger after our final stay and complained we'd left a mess (not hoovered), let the garden "grow wild" and the bin overflow (it was over-full when we got there - we got rid of all our own rubbish each day)
Lazy cow - pay for a fucking cleaner.
🤷‍♀️

SirenSays · 20/06/2022 13:11

You're not wrong OP. When I last tried to book an AirBnb the price shot up with all the extra random fees added. And the list of expected chores was more than I'm expected to do at some housesits I'm paid for! It's ridiculous.

Zippea · 20/06/2022 13:11

We have in laws in Cornwall and visit regularly, there is no room for as at the in laws so we usually balance it by using a rental or premier inn.
The last rental we had took the pee monumentally - we had to be out by 9am and had a list of jobs as long as your arm to do. We also had paid £100 cleaning fee as part of the rental.
We ended up doing the cleaning on day 4 and leaving that night so didn’t stay the full 5 days

alwaysontheloo · 20/06/2022 13:10

We once paid a fortune for a place in the Lakes who left no welcome pack apart from one solitary dishwasher tablet and instructions to leave the whole house spotless with NO dishes.
I think the idea, along with paying over £100 cleaning charge, was that we would also buy dishwasher tablets and washing up liquid and cleaning stuff and leave them too...presumably for whomever who was actually paid to clean to take home...
If I'm paying £100. cleaning fees, like fuck am I cleaning AND buying you new dishwasher tabs etc. Get to fuck CF!

golfwidownomore · 20/06/2022 13:10

We own several air bnb's. We have a very flexible check in and check out. We do not add an additional cleaning fee. Have left signs up to specifically say we want you to enjoy your break. No need to tidy up. Our only request is to not let pets on the beds or sofas.
We offer an enhanced service of getting shopping in for you and restaurant reservations and recommendations.

RincewindsHat · 20/06/2022 13:08

Fully agree.

I always check if the owner has listed cleaning requirements in the description, and will not book anywhere that expects excessive cleaning (and I am happy to do a quick hoover, remove dog hair from soft furnishings where it's crept under the blankets I bring with me, leave sides & loos wiped down, strip beds, put laundry & dishwasher on, but some hosts do seem to expect a full deep clean on departure plus a cleaning fee...no).

I've also experienced inaccurate listing details and a lack of concern that you're not getting what you booked, eg free parking on premises turns out to be on-street parking in a road of terraced houses so it's luck each day as to whether you can actually park or not, or a private garden turns out to be shared by the owners who live next door (I raised this with them as soon as I checked in and they declined to refund me so I could go elsewhere because 'we've reserved the property for you and it wouldn't be fair to us'. I contacted Airbnb who refunded me instantly & found somewhere with an actual private garden).

I used to love Airbnb but honestly, the properties now are all expensive and it really is luck of the draw as to whether you get somewhere that's as nice as it looks in the photos online, plus the friendliness of hosts also varies hugely.

Chevyimpala67 · 20/06/2022 13:05

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/06/2022 13:02

maybe the flight chaos of this summer will compel more people to holiday in the UK again next year?

I doubt it, HesterShaw; the media love to make a drama out of a crisis, but IME the "chaos" is nothing like as bad as it's painted, and after the profiteering last year I'm frankly surprised there are so many left who still prefer a UK holiday

Because my elderly mum can't fly

Many people would love to jet off but its not always that easy

My dh flew from LHR T2 this morning to Frankfurt and the flight before his was cancelled. LHR have cancelled 10% flights today affecting 5000 passengers.

I really don't think that it's being over stated tbh.

GlitteryGreen · 20/06/2022 13:05

I agree.

Recently stayed in an Air BnB for the first time and while the host was nice, he was in touch almost every single day of our stay and insisted on being there to meet us when we arrived, even though we were coming from 5 hours away and weren't sure what time we'd arrive due to traffic etc. It just made the whole thing stressful when there was a keybox we could easily have used.

It wasn't too bad with the cleaning requirements, but he also gave us an unnecessary 'tour' of the house when we arrived - it was a 3 bed terrace - and at one point during our stay messaged to say he was going to drop in while we were out to deliver us an item which we weren't expecting him to provide and had already bought for ourselves. Luckily I saw the message and was able to tell him not to bother, as we really weren't comfortable with him letting himself in while all our belongings were in there.

It just felt very much like we were housesitters/his house guests, rather than that we'd hired out a property to be used in privacy as we wished.