Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My adult child is very overweight & I'm worried

187 replies

Stressedout65 · 20/06/2022 07:29

I'll probably get flamed for fat shaming, but this is my adult child I'm talking about and I'm worried. When she hit puberty she started to become chubby. Then she did really well and lost some. She did have an illness a few years back which was not the cause of this weight gain but prevented her from exercising at all. Now she is over her illness and in a sedentary job, does not exercise and is more overweight than she has ever been. I have gently mentioned it to her, but she lies to me and herself by saying she's the same weight. I can see with my own eyes she's not. I have offered to baby sit so she can go to the gym/swimming and pay but she makes an excuse about being shattered by the time kids go to bed and she has to be up very early for school run & work, which is true.
What do I do? Show her photos of how she was at the end of her illness compared to how she is now? Be brutal about it? I'm so worried for her future health. She has small children. At the rate she's growing she'll end up on a mobility scooter. She needs to do something for her children's sake and her own future health. I don't want to upset her though as she's a grown up - but she's still my child

OP posts:
Artwodeetoo · 20/06/2022 10:09

Some people are in denial about their weight and have lost sight of how big they actually are. I include myself in that, I am a healthy weight now but after having DS my weight crept up- I could squeeze into a size 20 but only if it was elasticated; I told myself it's not that big. I started to get out of breath easily and blamed it on all sorts, I had to be weighed and actually couldn't believe I was over 18 stone. I'd been 11 since I was a teen (I'm tall so that was healthy). I was mortified, I hadn't really seen myself in photos as I didn't let anyone take any of me, but I look back now and realise how large I was. If I hadn't have been weighed I expect I would have carried on buying stretchy and baggy clothes and convincing myself it wasn't that bad.

tldr: yes fat people know they're fat, a lot in denial about how big

Ragwort · 20/06/2022 10:09

The OP clearly said in her opening post that she has 'gently mentioned it' so she has addressed the issue but there is absolutely no point going on and on about it. I know I could lose weight and be healthier if I stuck to 1800 calories a day and did 30 mins exercise every day ... writing that down it doesn't sound too bad but I enjoy my food, I enjoy my lifestyle and don't want to limit my food intake and faff about with exercise (yes, I've tried everything Grin).

SallyWD · 20/06/2022 10:08

In this country we tend not to mention someone's weight and just tell people they're still beautiful if they mention being fat. It's different in other countries. I have friends and family from all over the world and if someone puts on weight their families will say "Look, you're getting fat! Time to cut down. Eat less." It's not seen as so acceptable to let yourself get fat. Having said that I don't know if you talking to her will help. She needs to really be motivated to lose weight. If she's feeling down about herself or life in general she's probably not in the right place to make those changes.

recoveringyoungalco · 20/06/2022 10:04

@Worldgonecrazy ""For some reason society doesn’t like us talking about obesity and we are not allowed to express concern in the same way we could if someone was drinking or snorting themselves to an early grave.""

I came on to say something like this. Maybe you can guess from my name drink was/ is my issue (sober a nice while now but the issue will always be there). I was functioning and I think some of the signs were harder to see. But once my family started to see them my god they pushed me!

The things everyone is saying about OPs DD - she's not stupid, she knows, she's a grown woman. I was all of those thing but I still was in denial. Also someone said that parents/ loved ones pointing out their weight didn't make them want to change, well it didn't make me want to stop drinking either, in fact it did the complete opposite. I thought I am a grown woman I can handle myself what do they know, I am not going to do what they say. But untimely without their meddling I would not have sought help.

Over eating to the point of morbid obesity (unless on some meds) is an addiction and it is because you are masking something in there. Many of us can become a little over weight/ chubby due to easy life style/ very easy access to high cal foods but extreme over weight comes from massively over eating. OP something is up with your DD. She needs help and who better to help there than her mum. Honestly without my family strong arming me to wake up I would not have sought help. I would not have taken those steps if I was allowed to remain comfortable.

I am not suggesting for one minute you shame her for being over weight just talk to her find out what is going on. How is she feeling. Tell her you are concerned for her health, that this isn't because you care how skinny she is! If she was a healthy active size 16/18 I can't imagine you would care about her weight. I know plenty of people in that category. Yet they are at higher risk for certain things and it wouldn't hurt to lose some weight but they can also do a charity park run

Ragwort · 20/06/2022 10:04

Agree with others, those of us who are overweight know that we are overweight. My DM (from a place of kindness and concern I am sure) has done everything suggested on this thread, paid for a cleaner to give me more 'time', accompanied me to slimming clubs, paid for gym memberships so many over the years, taken me to health farms, looked after my DC so I can get to exercise classes etc etc. Some of these work in the short term but I remain overweight because I am greedy and love food.

Constantly going on about it will not make any difference.

Mainfeature · 20/06/2022 10:03

I would carry on being kind and supportive but I would stop commenting on anything to do with weight/diet/exercise for now.
If she is that overweight, exercise will make little difference the only thing that will help is a change of diet and eating habits in the long term.

Happy healthy people do not tend to overeat. Sounds like she may have low self
esteem. Are there any underlying problems you can help with? What about a partner (if she has one) are there problems in the relationship?

Iwanttenofthose · 20/06/2022 10:01

It is a hugely sensitive and emotive topic and to an extent I agree that we need to develop the ability to talk openly and objectively about body weight and its impact on health. I was in hospital next to a lady who was obese and she put a complaint in against her consultant for "fat shaming" because he dared to suggest that some of her many health issues could be exacerbated by her weight and explained how a healthier lifestyle could benefit her. I don't think the level of oversensitivity we have as a society around weight is always helpful.

That said, of course someone with a weight problem is always going to be made to feel worse by judgment and criticism and that's not going to help them overcome anything. I think the important thing is to make sure the conversation focuses on their health and wellbeing rather than their appearance. It's important to separate those things despite the links between them. You wouldn't tell a drug addicted adult child that they needed to give up because it's making them look ugly - you'd talk about the impact on their health and longevity, because you love them and want them to have a happy healthy long life, right? So why is it different with body weight? You absolutely shouldn't tell her she's "too fat" or comment on her appearance AT ALL or use photos to make your point. But explaining how concerned you are for her health and wellbeing, once only without following up with nagging, and then supporting her in any subsequent attempts she makes to adjust her lifestyle - that's absolutely ok and I'm surprised people thing that's a damaging conversation to have.

Ilovewinetoomuch · 20/06/2022 10:01

Les Mills on Demand (4 months £16.00) and Health at Every Size by Linda Bacon PHD (£10.00 WH Smith). You can buy both of these for her for under £30. I have been obese since I was 8 years old and I wish my mother had addressed it then. Both my parents are obese as to are my siblings. My child is a healthy weight. My one aim in life was to break the obesity cycle. You are justified in being concerned as you do not want your daughter's children to become part of a generational obesity cycle.

MadameMachin · 20/06/2022 10:00

11Hawkins · 20/06/2022 07:38

She has to do it off her own back unfortunately. You can't force her or she won't have the motivation to carry it through and loose the weight.

This

sjxoxo · 20/06/2022 10:00

Maybe I’m missing something but I don’t think talking to your adult child about a health concern you have for them is fat shaming? If my child smoked I would speak to them and show my disapproval.. yes smoking is a choice someone has made and weight is often not ‘chosen’ but OP says her daughter is doing no exercise which is a choice I think. I know I would certainly be heavier if I didn’t exercise and I force myself to do it for my long term health. Unless there’s an alternative reason for the circumstances she is in I can’t say. If you can’t talk to her and offer your support in her life towards a healthier lifestyle perhaps you could take the kids to something each week so she has a block of time free for herself regularly. Best of luck to both of you xxxx

RudsyFarmer · 20/06/2022 09:59

Yep you just leave her alone I’m afraid. If she wants to talk to you about it that’s different.

JanisMoplin · 20/06/2022 09:59

RepublicOfNarnia · 20/06/2022 09:40

Sometimes I really wonder how families work going by Mumsnet:

OP - "My son's arm is hanging off and he won't go to A&E"
Mumsnet: "OP it's none of your business! You sound so interfering! It's not your arm!!"

Honestly! OP, it must be hard but I do think you need to address it with your her. Yes she knows and I suppose it depends on the type of relationship you have with her but my mother and I communicate very honestly - to a level deeper than just 'any other adult'.

I have to admit I don't seek family advice on MN because I don't relate to it. Parents don't stop worrying about their adult DC because they are adult. Also baffled by the aggression on this thread.

frydae · 20/06/2022 09:58

Hallyup89 · 20/06/2022 09:43

I genuinely don't think the advice to "shut the fuck up" is helpful. Your daughter knows she is overweight, and will only lose weight if she wants to. I don't think that a kind conversation coming from a point of genuine concern is a problem. Don't criticise her, and don't tell her she's fat, but make it obvious that you're worried about her. Then leave it. Don't nag, don't ask her if she's started dieting or whatever, just let her know that you're there to support her.

The helpful pointing out of the obvious was really bad for me mentally. I honestly can't emphasise this enough, overweight people know they are overweight. It doesn't matter what angle a person is coming from, it is not helpful to have it pointed out. Quite the opposite. My nana used to tell me how worried she was about me, it made me want to curl up into a fucking ball and die. What actually happened was that over time I became more and more depressed and the more helpful comments (because it won't just be OP who says something to her DD - there are always others) the more I ATE.

I'm now 20 stone and understand I have an eating disorder that won't be cured by a concerned relative.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 20/06/2022 09:57

I think you're doing the right thing by telling her actually coming from someone who is overweight herself.
It is easy to be in denial and think you are a bit overweight when really you are more than a bit and risking your health.

It took me a long time to try and do something about it and recognise I needed to start dieting, mostly gradual things like recognising certain clothes weren't fitting anymore. Feeling embarrassed in public around healthier people, sometimes I think you need to hear and see it for yourself for it to sink in.

I don't think the comments telling you to shut the fuck up are helpful, when you are expressing perfectly normal concern and even offering to help.

SmallPrawnEnergy · 20/06/2022 09:55

ParanoidGynodroid · 20/06/2022 09:43

Would you say that to a parent whos dd is anorexic? Her body her choice

I wish people would stop equating obesity with anorexia. Obesity is a health condition that builds up over a long period of time as a result of bad habits, poor diet, lack of exercise... anorexia is a mental health condition.
If you tell someone they're obese and should do something about it for their own good they could say "OK, I'll lose weight"; an anorexic person, on the other hand, can't just say "OK, I'll stop being anorexic." They need specialist help, and have a mental health issue to overcome.

Obesity and mental health are very much related, and it’s absolutely pig ignorant to think otherwise. Educate yourself on the matter before weighing in with such shitty false narratives. Also, if it was as easy as just saying “ok I’ll lose weight” there would be no fat people, no one wants to be obese. Get your head out of your arse.

oopsfellover · 20/06/2022 09:55

Feel for you OP and not sure why you're getting these aggressive 'none of your business' type comments. She's your child, and it's understandable that you're worried - maybe about her emotional as well as physical wellbeing.
It's tricky though because, as others have said, it's really up to the individual to decide when and how to address their weight. I know my mum has always worried about mine, and would speak to me about it if she could, but she can't because I don't want the conversation with her (for various reasons, not all of which will be the same for your DD), so very quickly put up defences. It wouldn't help at all if she showed me old photos of myself, told me I was overweight or offered to pay for slimming clubs.
It's a tough situation for you because her weight and lifestyle are not within your control. Carry on being kind and supportive to her, I guess. I'm sure she knows you care.

Mumz0612 · 20/06/2022 09:50

Leave your daughter alone she will lose weight if and when she’s ready to. If she’s happy that’s all that’s matters doesn’t matter what you think

SmallPrawnEnergy · 20/06/2022 09:49

SexyLittleNosferatu · 20/06/2022 09:07

They don't. They absolutely know that it isn't a "cure". It is just that fat people aren't allowed to exist in their bodies and it's acceptable to hide disgust for fat people under the veil of "concern for health".

Yup. And notice not one bit of concern for mental health here from the fat phobes. All they’re concerned about is getting the wobbly people to not be so disgusting anymore.

kimfox · 20/06/2022 09:46

Why don't you ask her how she actually is? Is she happy? Is she worried? Let her tell you if she's actually worried about her weight. Do not bring it up. Show an interest in the whole person, don't assume you know what she feels or what she is thinking about. Then and only then (after time) can you have a conversation about if there's anything she would like to do to change anything in her life. By which I mean introduce the notion of change without saying what YOU think the change should look like! Then you can offer to support her or help. You can definitely do something but it's not the way you think.

What I'm saying is that you need to be a safe space for her to open up or ask for help, not someone with all the answers to the problems you imagine she has. I know this may sound harsh, but telling people what they "ought" to do very rarely helps ime. First steps are being genuinely curious about what is going on for her under the surface stuff about being busy with kids / job etc.

ParanoidGynodroid · 20/06/2022 09:43

Would you say that to a parent whos dd is anorexic? Her body her choice

I wish people would stop equating obesity with anorexia. Obesity is a health condition that builds up over a long period of time as a result of bad habits, poor diet, lack of exercise... anorexia is a mental health condition.
If you tell someone they're obese and should do something about it for their own good they could say "OK, I'll lose weight"; an anorexic person, on the other hand, can't just say "OK, I'll stop being anorexic." They need specialist help, and have a mental health issue to overcome.

Hallyup89 · 20/06/2022 09:43

I genuinely don't think the advice to "shut the fuck up" is helpful. Your daughter knows she is overweight, and will only lose weight if she wants to. I don't think that a kind conversation coming from a point of genuine concern is a problem. Don't criticise her, and don't tell her she's fat, but make it obvious that you're worried about her. Then leave it. Don't nag, don't ask her if she's started dieting or whatever, just let her know that you're there to support her.

ferretface · 20/06/2022 09:42

Leave her alone. It's understandable that you're worried but commenting on it (even peripherally like making pointed comments about enjoying eating healthy salad/doing sport yourself) will just make her feel worse and probably worsen the issue. Focus on being a loving support to her WITHOUT JUDGING HER. If she mentions her weight, acknowledge that losing weight can be hard and then move swiftly on.

GCRich · 20/06/2022 09:41

To be clear, I believe that ultimately people are overweight because they eat too many calories, often of the wrong food compared to what their body needs.

I also believe that some people are incredibly lucky and can eat what they like and not put on weight, for others eating the right amount for their body is next to impossible. Most slim people would be overweight if they had an overweight person's metabolism and propensity to feel hungry, and vice versa.

RepublicOfNarnia · 20/06/2022 09:40

Sometimes I really wonder how families work going by Mumsnet:

OP - "My son's arm is hanging off and he won't go to A&E"
Mumsnet: "OP it's none of your business! You sound so interfering! It's not your arm!!"

Honestly! OP, it must be hard but I do think you need to address it with your her. Yes she knows and I suppose it depends on the type of relationship you have with her but my mother and I communicate very honestly - to a level deeper than just 'any other adult'.

hamstersarse · 20/06/2022 09:40

Lots of people saying 'she will know she is fat, she will know the health issues'. Fine.

So she is still doing nothing about it. Does that not indicate that there are other issues (same for everyone else saying that they are fat and know the health issues). There is surely still some level of denial?

How do people come out of denial? It is only through conversation. Not nasty judgemental conversation, but yes, conversations.

It is crueler to never mention it. It is an elephant in the room, clouded in shame, and the only way to break down that shame is by having open, honest, empathetic conversations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread