Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My adult child is very overweight & I'm worried

187 replies

Stressedout65 · 20/06/2022 07:29

I'll probably get flamed for fat shaming, but this is my adult child I'm talking about and I'm worried. When she hit puberty she started to become chubby. Then she did really well and lost some. She did have an illness a few years back which was not the cause of this weight gain but prevented her from exercising at all. Now she is over her illness and in a sedentary job, does not exercise and is more overweight than she has ever been. I have gently mentioned it to her, but she lies to me and herself by saying she's the same weight. I can see with my own eyes she's not. I have offered to baby sit so she can go to the gym/swimming and pay but she makes an excuse about being shattered by the time kids go to bed and she has to be up very early for school run & work, which is true.
What do I do? Show her photos of how she was at the end of her illness compared to how she is now? Be brutal about it? I'm so worried for her future health. She has small children. At the rate she's growing she'll end up on a mobility scooter. She needs to do something for her children's sake and her own future health. I don't want to upset her though as she's a grown up - but she's still my child

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmeraldShamrock1 · 23/06/2022 14:15

My mother was like this. Very happy with a sedentary life, TV, craft and lovely food. My dad loved her the way she was. Not a problem. Until she died in her 60s of an obesity related illness.
Snap. My DM was the same, happy in her world until she developed many health problems relating to obesity.

She became further depressed and ate more.

She spent months in/hospital her dignity destroyed wearing a nappy, extra unhappy porters required to roll her.

We had to lift her from the chair.
It wasn't only her size but the damage to her knees and spine.

My mother was slim until menopause.
I imagine a lifetime of obesity would be even worse when older.

Like you I wish we had of intervened earlier.

Bluepolkadots42 · 20/06/2022 19:43

Op- I think the answer is in your first line of response to me, ahe did it without 'nagging' etc from you. She did it last time of her own volition and as others have said, and I tried to get across (albeit probably not well) is, like an addict, it is something that can only come from her to do. I totally understand why you are so worried, I really go- I have a DD and if she grows up to be like me in this sense it would break my heart. That tbh is the main thing that motivates me to try and do something about my weight- thinking about the example I'm setting for her by being the size I am. Your own DD may feel similarly. I am ashamed to admit this but at my weakest moments wanting better for my own DD still isn't enough to stop me making bad food choices. And that feels really awful on so many levels. If you have tons of money to throw at this then I would say offer to pay for a cleaner, keep offering to have the kids- overnights if you can now and again, take her on a spa day, compliment her regularly- her hair or colour of her top or what a good mum she is etc, ask her to join you for a zumba class or regular walk. I am always better able to sustain better eating when I am rested, feel loved, feel good about myself and feel supported. I wish both of you luck.

5128gap · 20/06/2022 19:25

I accept the points people are making about obesity and the complex psychological issues surrounding it. But, I think there is a danger of applying this to every overweight person and deciding the same issues apply to all. So no one can ever discuss weight with an OW person, they all know already, it will do more harm, it won't work etc. But this doesn't apply across the board. Mant people can and do lose weight if they have the right incentive.
Other people who are overweight are genuinely not bothered by it. Their appearance doesn't matter to them and they don't mind the restrictions of their size. My mother was like this. Very happy with a sedentary life, TV, craft and lovely food. My dad loved her the way she was. Not a problem. Until she died in her 60s of an obesity related illness.
I genuinely think if we'd have spoken to her she may have lost weight especially to be around for her DGC. But no one ever did, it just wasn't done, and we didn't know the risks we do now.

SirChenjins · 20/06/2022 18:42

catflycat · 20/06/2022 16:08

Quite a few studies linked here..
christyharrison.com/what-is-weight-stigma

With all due respect, that’s not evidence to show that the stigma of being fat is more a health risk than actually being fat.

DogsAndGin · 20/06/2022 18:36

Sounds like she needs all the help and support she can get OP, I don’t think YABU

lljkk · 20/06/2022 18:22

The dynamics of anorexia are not the same as obesity.

People who flipflopped between those states have told me they believe otherwise. <shrug>

The one lesson from this thread is that no matter what OP does : it's wrong. The only question then is "what kind of wrong thing would you like to do?" You don't get to avoid doing a wrong thing.

Fairislefandango · 20/06/2022 18:17

Sometimes I really don't understand MN. Fat is bad.

That's not the point. You can't make somebody else lose weight. And trying to may well be counter-productive. Weight-naggers (however well-intentioned) nag to vent their own feelings, and to make themselves feel like they are doing something, not because they have any good reason to believe that nagging will actually work.

There's an interesting podcast on the BBC by two doctors who are twin brothers. One is very overweight, the other is a healthy weight. The slim brother is very worried about his twin and has spent years trying on and off to help him and encourage him to lose weight, to no avail whatsoever. It's interesting listening to the experts they talk to (doctors, psychologists etc) unpicking not only the weight issue, but the dynamics of how it's affected the brothers' relationship, and the real motives of the slim brother and why his efforts have ultimately been actually unhelpful.

JanisMoplin · 20/06/2022 17:39

Sometimes I really don't understand MN. Fat is bad. I am not saying dieting is good, but fat is bad for your health, when you come down to it. Obesity is so normalised in this country that we are pussyfooting around this. Being fat is far more damaging than any messaging, IMO. Clearly diet culture has not taken hold if the majority of people in the UK are overweight or obese.

Stressedout65 · 20/06/2022 17:33

@Bluepolkadots42 when I say she did really well, it was of her own decision, not as as result of nagging by me. She wasn't in puberty or teenage years when she lost the weight, she was in her early 20's. I have never instilled the fact of fat = bad & thin = good. If you really listen to both my posts you will see that it is not about body image, but about her health & how it could impact on her ability to care for her own children. Also, if you really read my second post you will see that she was very ill & temporarily disabled. Carrying less weight could have helped her recovery & will help future recovery should she become ill again. What is wrong with worrying about my own daughter's health & how it could impact her children's lives? What is wrong with trying to help my own daughter so that she has as healthy & fulfilling life with her own family?
I do understand that she will already know how big she is too, so I asked for advice on here on how best to help/encourage her to try to lose some weight; but obviously I want to go about it in the right way so as not to hurt her feelings

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 20/06/2022 16:49

5128gap · 20/06/2022 13:12

So if saying something and offering support doesn't work, what should concerned relatives do? Nothing seems to be the preferred course of action. But there's no evidence that ignoring it works either. And how long should you sit back and ignore it? Until the person's weight becomes life limiting? Interferes with the parenting of her children? Causes her to be housebound or disabled? If any other factor than weight that had the potential to escalate was at play, alcohol, mental health issues, self harm no one would say nothing. So why is this different and how is ignoring it helpful?

Our family can relate to this as one of DH’s sisters is morbidly obese. She’s been getting larger for about 15 years and now she’s in her mid-40’s, health problems have started. One hospitalization so far and recently diagnosed as pre-diabetic. Her family is very loving, but no one knows how to help her, people have tried exercising with her, cooking for her, etc.

DH’s older sister has talked to him about in floods of tears, because she’s close to her little sister and says she doesn’t want to lose her early, which tbh is likely to happen if something doesn’t change.

But she’s an adult, it’s her choice. It’s painful to witness though.

Bluepolkadots42 · 20/06/2022 16:48

I'm half wondering if you're my mum writing about me....

Few things to know as your Dd and I sound very similar...

  1. she likely knows full well how big she has got. 2( she likely feels huge shame about how big she has got.
  2. her feelings of shame will be impacting her motivation to do anything about it.
  3. parenting small children is really draining of mental, emotional and physical energy. It is highly likely she is beyond tired by end of each day.
  4. being so big, feeling ashamed etc. often means self esteem and self worth are in gutter. She may have given up on herself or even feel: whats the point. Or she just doesn't have the energy to prioritise herself right now.
  5. she may have some.form of disordered eating eg binge eating, compulsive overeating etc. Similarly to any other substance abuse ossue like alcoholism, it is not as simple as just stop eating so much. The reasons why she eats so much or so poorly or both need to be dealt with and ultimately she must come to her own decision and realisation she needs help and wants change. If/when she comes to that point be there to support her- paying for therapy is likely to be far more beneficial than paying for gym membership.

I don't know what the answer is here- I definitely haven't found it hence why I'm so big still, however the way you phrased 'she did really well' when talking about a time she lost weight speaks volumes to me about the attitude towards weight and body image you consciously or unconsciously instilled in your daughter at a very delicate time of her life (young, pre pubescent and then pubescent). I speak as someone who bears out the impact of that kind of messaging from the parent I loved and admired most as a kid. Messages like fat = wrong, bad and thin/dieting/ Weight loss = right and good can be really damaging to children and young people.
I hope your daughter can find her own way to better health.

fairycakes1234 · 20/06/2022 16:33

Vodika · 20/06/2022 07:37

You leave her the fuck alone. She knows she's put on weight. She doesn't need you or anyone else to point out the blatantly obvious.

How about you so something to lighten the load in her day to day life? Like baby sit the children on the weekend so she can have a rest? Maybe help with the school runs?

@Vodika what is your problem? She asked for advice and you swear? Angry much?

catflycat · 20/06/2022 16:31

Neverendingdust · 20/06/2022 15:09

@catflycat but when living in an oversized body is statistically proven time and again to carry significant health implications then surely as a caring human being you would want to preserve life and encourage change? Even more so if it’s a close relative or friend? It’s no different to having a relation who is addicted to heroin or alcohol, the repercussions for them and everyone else can be catastrophic regardless of the stigma surrounding it.

How does a grandparent explain the death or serious illness of their grandchild’s parent due to obesity without wondering if there was anything more they could have done to prevent it, did they exhaust every avenue?

Is it though? I have read that it's very difficult to show cause and effect - do those health conditions cause people to be in larger bodies, or is it the larger bodies causing those health conditions? This is apparently not as clear cut as we've been led to believe.

But I think the important thing to remember is that people aren't in larger bodies just because they are endlessly eating 😱 We're all a product of our genetics, the environment we live in, the people surrounding us and the things that have happened to us. Dieting isn't the answer, it doesn't work long term (more then 5 years) for most people (apparently less then 5% of people). You could say that being really tall has some poor health outcomes, there's no fix for this, but we don't tell tall people they need to sort themselves out. I think we should be supporting people in having a healthy relationship with food, rather then restricting, and judging, and we need to do something about the diet culture we're all living in, it's so dangerous and also not helpful to judge people by their size and to continue the rhetoric that thinness must be the goal above all else.

Also do you think if someone is addicted to alcohol or heroin that you can talk them out of that? I don't disagree that addiction could be very destructive for their lives and relationships, I'm pretty sure no-one in that position wants to be in that position, but at the end of the day it's up to them to want to make a change or do things differently. You could support that person by looking at the cause, if they wanted to.. Perhaps they are depressed, grieving, have lost hope, don't have security in their home or family. But you can't make them stop using/drinking. Equally if someone had low self esteem or wanted help with improving strength/flexibility/time to do activities they enjoy, you could support them with that, but that should be coming from them, not what you deem is right for them, and shouldn't be centred around weight loss in my opinion.

I think you're last statement is incredibly dramatic, but we all have to make our own choices in life. We all make subjectively good and bad ones, we could all probably do with more support to care for our own well-being. But telling a child they're too fat, showing them pictures of how they looked when they were ill, isn't supportive in my opinion.

GreatCrash · 20/06/2022 16:20

5128gap · 20/06/2022 13:12

So if saying something and offering support doesn't work, what should concerned relatives do? Nothing seems to be the preferred course of action. But there's no evidence that ignoring it works either. And how long should you sit back and ignore it? Until the person's weight becomes life limiting? Interferes with the parenting of her children? Causes her to be housebound or disabled? If any other factor than weight that had the potential to escalate was at play, alcohol, mental health issues, self harm no one would say nothing. So why is this different and how is ignoring it helpful?

Unfortunately, the answer to this is that nothing works - ignoring or interfering. Once a person is morbidly obese, the probability of them returning to a healthy BMI is very low (see link below).

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4539812/

Therefore, it's better to ignore and retain a good relationship with your child than interfere and risk losing that.

5128gap · 20/06/2022 16:17

Worldgonecrazy · 20/06/2022 15:35

I think there is something in your theory and that body dysmorphia may play a part, perhaps driven by social media.

of my two step daughters, one is convinced she is a size 19 because she buys stretchy clothes in vanity sizes and squeezes into them.

The other only ever posts heavily edited or strategically shot so that she actually looks quite slim, even though she is size 20/22.

I wonder if constantly seeing the slim version themselves on social media allows them to keep a mental distance from the reality of their weight?

This will not be a popular view, but I agree. Vanity sizes, the increase in number of overweight people so it is the norm, euphemisms like 'curvy', comments like 'size 12/14 is slim!', the ability to instantly delete unflattering photos, enabled me to be in denial about my 2 stone excess for years. And I'm not young either.

catflycat · 20/06/2022 16:08

SirChenjins · 20/06/2022 15:23

There is research to suggest the stigma around living in a bigger body is actually more of a health risk for people then the physical affects of living in a bigger body

Can you point to this evidence please?

Quite a few studies linked here..
christyharrison.com/what-is-weight-stigma

LadybirdsAreNeverHappy · 20/06/2022 15:58

Worldgonecrazy · 20/06/2022 15:35

I think there is something in your theory and that body dysmorphia may play a part, perhaps driven by social media.

of my two step daughters, one is convinced she is a size 19 because she buys stretchy clothes in vanity sizes and squeezes into them.

The other only ever posts heavily edited or strategically shot so that she actually looks quite slim, even though she is size 20/22.

I wonder if constantly seeing the slim version themselves on social media allows them to keep a mental distance from the reality of their weight?

PP did not say body dysmorphia. Body dysmorphia is something entirely different.

Worldgonecrazy · 20/06/2022 15:35

oldtableleg · 20/06/2022 14:51

All the “she knows she’s fat” responses … yup but

There’s loads of evidence that obese people (particularly people who were obese to begin with & gain more weight) underestimate their weight. The daughter quite likely knows she’s fat but distorted body image means she may well not appreciate both how fat she is & significantly underestimate how much she’s gained.

I think there is something in your theory and that body dysmorphia may play a part, perhaps driven by social media.

of my two step daughters, one is convinced she is a size 19 because she buys stretchy clothes in vanity sizes and squeezes into them.

The other only ever posts heavily edited or strategically shot so that she actually looks quite slim, even though she is size 20/22.

I wonder if constantly seeing the slim version themselves on social media allows them to keep a mental distance from the reality of their weight?

Ameliarosethistle · 20/06/2022 15:32

Try to build her confidence- tell her about all of the things that she has done well in life- be genuine- notice the things that she does well. Feeling criticised leads to demotivation and possibly to weight gain, praise is much more motivating.

SirChenjins · 20/06/2022 15:23

There is research to suggest the stigma around living in a bigger body is actually more of a health risk for people then the physical affects of living in a bigger body

Can you point to this evidence please?

Neverendingdust · 20/06/2022 15:09

@catflycat but when living in an oversized body is statistically proven time and again to carry significant health implications then surely as a caring human being you would want to preserve life and encourage change? Even more so if it’s a close relative or friend? It’s no different to having a relation who is addicted to heroin or alcohol, the repercussions for them and everyone else can be catastrophic regardless of the stigma surrounding it.

How does a grandparent explain the death or serious illness of their grandchild’s parent due to obesity without wondering if there was anything more they could have done to prevent it, did they exhaust every avenue?

PerfectlyQuiet · 20/06/2022 15:02

I doubt if the OP said she was troubled by her daughter taking drugs or drinking too much that the replies on this thread would be so nasty.

OP, I think offering to look after the kids is a good thing to do. What about telling her that you want to lose weight and asking if she wants to join you.

catflycat · 20/06/2022 14:53

Neverendingdust · 20/06/2022 14:42

I agree with you.

Families hold interventions for those with other addictions when they are causing harm to themselves and others and yet trying to encourage those with weight issues to be careful is heavily frowned upon. I would hope that anyone in this situation is able to step out of the ‘I know, it’s my issue to deal with’ mentality and realise the devastating impact that obesity related health issues or death would have on their children and families.

It’s fine to be unhealthily overweight but it’s quite selfish to expect those around you to pick up the pieces and be expected to care for you or watch you decline to a point where day to day activities are impossible or the risk of diabetes becomes real.

What is the answer?

There is research to suggest the stigma around living in a bigger body is actually more of a health risk for people then the physical affects of living in a bigger body. Issues around food are most often CAUSED by diet culture and restriction. I think we need to work towards acceptance of the fact that people are different shapes and sizes, accept that dieting doesn't work for 95% of people, and that the pressures put of people from such a young age around food and diets could be at the root of the EDs and weight fluctuation people suffer in later life.

So the answer is that there are many many reasons why people are living in different sized bodies, and it really isn't anyone else's business - leave people alone, foster a culture where people aren't bullied for being different, teach your kids not to judge people for any aspect of how they look and have a go at doing that yourself.

oldtableleg · 20/06/2022 14:51

All the “she knows she’s fat” responses … yup but

There’s loads of evidence that obese people (particularly people who were obese to begin with & gain more weight) underestimate their weight. The daughter quite likely knows she’s fat but distorted body image means she may well not appreciate both how fat she is & significantly underestimate how much she’s gained.

Coughee · 20/06/2022 14:44

hamstersarse · 20/06/2022 14:35

Nothing can flip a switch in your brain to start you on a weight loss journey?

Are you saying there is literally nothing that will help obese people lose weight?

It's such a hard thing to understand. Why is obesity such a different scenario to spending too much money, drinking too much wine, smoking too many fags? Nothing that could flip your switch? That's incredible.

She actually wrote 'nothing SHE SAYS can flip a switch'. Which is completely different to what you're implying.

And it would a absolutely apply to booze and fags etc. There is no magic set of words you can utter to change somebody's behaviour. Unless you're perhaps a therapist and even then it would probably take a long time not a couple of sentences.