Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect 14yr old DD to be on top of homework

38 replies

theanswerunknown · 19/06/2022 23:09

Just that really....
14yr old DD just told me about a maths test she has first thing tomorrow.

Apparently she told me about it ages ago and it's my fault for not reminding her...
Oh and now I'm not being supportive of her because I told her that she needs to be more on top of her schedule.

AIBU?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anothernamechangeplease · 26/06/2022 19:24

I have adhd and I totally get how difficult it is for us to organise ourselves! I have a lifetime's experience of struggling with this. However, at 14, you're old enough to take individual responsibility for your own studies regardless. If you know you struggle to stay on top of stuff, then yes, it's great to have other people to remind you but you can't make it their fault if they don't!

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 20/06/2022 14:02

For those that don't know, having ADHD or being ND in other ways can feel like metaphorically drowning all the time. You always feel like there is something you're meant to be doing that you've forgotten or that you're doing X but there's a worry that you would be better off doing Y.

It's easy to lose yourself in something enjoyable and then panic when you realise there was something for important that you'd forgotten.

It's honestly hell.

I'm diagnosed with autism but not ADHD but I think I have both.

OPs daughter might be 100% neurotypical but she also might not be. I feel for her in her panic and distress at managing all this either way.

steppemum · 20/06/2022 11:44

summermornings · 20/06/2022 11:31

@steppemum

A situation where a child has additional needs and requires sustained and guided support because of suspected autism, is in no way comparable to the OPs situation. I’m sorry, it’s just not.

guess you missed this bit then:

She does have anxiety and now I've had some time to think I wonder if the blame bit is a cover up as she's gone into panic mode.

so she is anxious and struggling.

sounds like she needs some support then

PineappleWilson · 20/06/2022 11:41

Of course you're being unreasonable - a mother's place is in the wrong! Grin Ask her how she needs to record things to remember them - post-its on her wall, diary, message on her phone the day before etc. Work with her to find solutions, and use this as an example of why she needs to use them. wouldn't be the first time we've had "unexpected" 8pm French homework

summermornings · 20/06/2022 11:31

@steppemum

A situation where a child has additional needs and requires sustained and guided support because of suspected autism, is in no way comparable to the OPs situation. I’m sorry, it’s just not.

steppemum · 20/06/2022 11:17

summermornings · 20/06/2022 10:57

For those that believe @theanswerunknown is unreasonable for not being more supportive towards her daughter regarding the maths test, good luck with raising responsible, independent and self motivated adults.

At 14 years old she is more than capable of remembering and studying for a class test, without the input of her mother. If she forgets, then she probably won’t perform well in her test. That will set her up to realise, that if she fails to prepare, she must be prepared to fail. That’s a great lesson for 14, as in a couple of years she is going to be sitting major exams. This is all prep work for it and understanding she is responsible for a good outcome.

I have raised 2 super independent, responsible and self motivated adult thanks.

But my youngest needs a different type of parenting. It is amazing to me that people assume that one size fits all in anything to do with parenting. If there is one thing I have learnt over the years it is that all kids are different and you have to do what is right for your particular child.
Some kids continue to need more support and structure for much longer than their peers and siblings.
Standing back so they can be more independent, and watching them crash and burn in a panic of anxiety and ditstress, which then makes then next time worse is not actually helpful. Given them support so that next time you can pull back and give less support, works.

Wow, who knew, we are not all the same.

summermornings · 20/06/2022 10:57

For those that believe @theanswerunknown is unreasonable for not being more supportive towards her daughter regarding the maths test, good luck with raising responsible, independent and self motivated adults.

At 14 years old she is more than capable of remembering and studying for a class test, without the input of her mother. If she forgets, then she probably won’t perform well in her test. That will set her up to realise, that if she fails to prepare, she must be prepared to fail. That’s a great lesson for 14, as in a couple of years she is going to be sitting major exams. This is all prep work for it and understanding she is responsible for a good outcome.

steppemum · 20/06/2022 10:51

I have 3 teens, the youngest is 14.The older 2 were totally on top of their own work and planning, I rarely know if there is a test etc until they give me the result.

But my youngest really needs support. She needs me to check in with her more often, she needs some structure and support in timing.
Occasionally she needs me to sit next to her and help her step by step through the work.
But at the same time, it is always my fault if it goes wrong and I have many instances of being told 'don't nag' when nicely reminding her of something that she asked me to remind her over. The verbal backlash is mostly just her own frustration and anxiety over her homework.

She is probably autistic, and struggles much more than her siblings.

I have had to change my parenting massively to deal with her, and her needs. We have had to let lots of things go that I would normally pick up on (like the verbal backlash) and we have had to learn to bite our tongues and play the long game.
Do what she needs, not what anyone else tells you she needs. Find what works for her.

summermornings · 20/06/2022 10:47

avamiah · 19/06/2022 23:33

my DD ( 12 ) also has a maths test tomorrow which she asked me to remind her about this morning and considering she has a amazing memory as she often reminds me of how much pocket money I owe her or that I promised her a new pair of trainers I thought it strange that she needed a Reminder so I told her No.

Refreshing to see some good parenting

balalake · 20/06/2022 10:39

Perfectly reasonable to expect a 14 year old to manage their diary and have some method of ensuring they do not forget things. Make some suggestions as to how they can do this.

Fairislefandango · 20/06/2022 10:22

YABU a bit. I'm a teacher with teenage dc too. It's always a bit of a balancing act between letting them get on with it without interference, in the hope that they'll develop independence, and keeping them on the straight-and-narrow a bit.

But you can only parent the child you've got. If she's generally fine with just the occasional 'Have you got any homework tonight?' comment, then I'd leave her be over this one test, and put her reaction down to anxiety and defensiveness over the fact that she forgot. If it becomes a regular occurrence, she may need more support, especially if you think she has sone ASD traits.

10HailMarys · 20/06/2022 10:22

Is she NT? I'm autistic and possibly have undiagnosed ADHD and I really struggled to keep on top of this stuff. It was so easy to distract me and my parents would fill my weekends with stuff and then I'd panic when I realised I'd forgotten to do homework.

Pretty sure this chimes with the experience of billions of neurotypical schoolkids too, though. It's a hell of a leap from 'my teenager forgot a test and got in a strop' to 'they must be neurodiverse'.

orwellwasright · 20/06/2022 10:21

Can you even revise for maths? She's remembered the test, no harm done.

10HailMarys · 20/06/2022 10:16

Not remotely your fault - I would expect a secondary school kid to be keeping track of their own homework, dates of tests etc. (I would accept that they would forget stuff sometimes but that's life; they need to learn from that and deal with it. If they get a crap mark on a test, so be it.)

Messing up and then furiously blaming someone else is classic teenage behaviour, so I would take your daughter's moaning with a giant pinch of salt and tell her you have no intention of babying her by monitoring her homework and that it's her problem if she forgets.

I remember having a giant row with my mum at around that age because I went to get a clean school shirt from the wardrobe one morning and I didn't have any. didn't have any. I, of course, hadn't actually put the dirty ones in the laundry basket and had just left them festering in a pile of other clothes on the floor in my room. When my mum pointed this out I had a massive strop because for some reason I thought she should have NOTICED that there hadn't been any school shirts in the washing for ages, and REMINDED me to put them in the laundry and OH MY GOD MUM I CAN'T THINK OF EVERYTHING, NOW I'M GOING TO HAVE TO WEAR A SHIRT THAT PROBABLY STINKS AND MY LIFE IS BASICALLY OVER AND IT'S YOUR FAULT AND I DIDN'T ASK TO BE BORN etc.

SandyWedges · 20/06/2022 08:53

Hopefully she'll learn from this and it won't happen again but the good thing is she actually cares that she has forgotten.

MrsDrSpencerReid · 20/06/2022 08:48

My DD15 really struggles with organisation so I always keep track of assessments and exams so I can give her reminders.

We get an assessment booklet at the start of the year that has the years assessment schedule on it, so due dates get written on the calendar in the kitchen.

I also have google classroom on my phone so when notifications pop up I can double check with her that she’s on top of it.

She’s had a hard time with anxiety and depression the last few years so this is just one little thing I can do to try and help her from getting overwhelmed.

Runnerduck34 · 20/06/2022 08:33

I think yabu a bit.
Of course at 14 they need to start to take responsibility and unless they say you won't know what work they've been set.
But it's not uncommon for teens to struggle with organisation and planning, their brains are still developing at this age ( can't remember full scientific explanation!)
So they do often need a bit of support. So I would remind them about homework / revision in a general way once or twice a week and if they mention any homework or test in particular I would try and make sure they did it and ensure they had free time to complete it.
Anyway hopefully this will be a learning curve for your daughter.

RepublicOfNarnia · 20/06/2022 08:31

@Odoreida has captured my thoughts exactly. It's not your fault and there's no need to focus on apportioning blame now she's in panic mode. I think having a giant planner would help to have a global view of all that's going on wrt exams / coursework etc. The reaction is one of stress but you know your daughter best. Having said that at her age I knew exactly what pocket money was owed to me and when and wouldn't hesitate to give my parents an itemised list of chores I'd done and monies owed etc so keep that in mind!

Odoreida · 20/06/2022 08:24

@theanswerunknown sorry I didn't mean to be harsh - it just resonated with my experience as a teenager. She is obviously upset about it. She's lashing out because she's worried about the test and she wants to share her fears and it is coming out in that particular teenage way. Of course she needs to be more on top of her schedule and she needs help with organisation, but this is what strikes me initially.

Ginseng1 · 20/06/2022 00:16

We helped DS also 14 to stay on top of things a this year. We do not want him to fail everything to teach him a lesson this esrly. Expect him to be more independent next year & more as years go on obvs. We often get the night before panic of a test looming that apparently the teacher only told them about that day (BS!)

avamiah · 20/06/2022 00:12

@theanswerunknown
In my opinion you should speak with her school if you feel she needs extra help with her studies or extra help with anything.

My daughter is a handful now so I’m not looking forward to her teens at all.🙁
I’m sure everything will be ok with your daughter,
Try not to worry too much .
x

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/06/2022 00:06

You are really

She’s 14. You have to stay on top of most kids that age. Not that you shouldn’t tell her it’s her job, you should, but you still have to have their backs - or rather you don’t, but then you have to accept they may, like, forget to turn up for a test..

bridgetreilly · 20/06/2022 00:03

I’m not certain my parents ever knew when my homework was due or when I had tests or exams. I just got on with it, and if I forgot, it was my own fault. But if your daughter has been used to having a more actively involved parent, she’ll need to be told that you’re expecting her to take more responsibility for her own education and explain what she’ll need to do as a result.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 19/06/2022 23:54

Your post just resonated with me as it was such a feature of my adolescence. I felt like
I wasn't given the tools or the space to do what I needed to do to stay on top of my life.

I used to (verbally) lash out at my parents too when it suddenly dawned on me that all the time had gone and I hadn't even started what I planned to do at the weekend. If she has inherited the ADHD then keeping track of deadlines and time in general is something that feels almost impossible.

theanswerunknown · 19/06/2022 23:48

@JulesRimetStillGleaming I think she's NT although she does have some ASD tendencies.

I'm always open to hearing about ways to help aid organisation and am a great believer in finding what works for individuals - my husband was late diagnosed with ADHD and some of the strategies he uses work for him but would completely confuse me!!

OP posts: