Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 24/06/2022 08:16

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 20:51

Really don’t understand your argument. The term “laddy” in relation to a trans person is not specific to the person in which it was used. It is purely transphobic and it doesn’t matter who you are referring to. The fact that the “laddy” in question was behaving abusively doesn’t make it ok to use that term.

I think if anyone is trivialising anything, it’s you trivialising transphobia..

Yes, your lack of understanding is very obvious.

I am referring here to your complaint about the accurate use of a term for penis, rather than laddy (although the idea that a male who is using their gender identity as a mechanism to mistreat women deserves to be referred to as anything other than a male is hardly an uncontroversial one). Your idea that this is aimed at all trans people is simply an invention. It's being aimed at one trans person who was sexually harassing women. Your comparison to that for the use of the n word that's been thrown at so many people for doing nothing more than existing is revolting. You are saying that accurately referring to a male engaging in very male misbehaviour is akin to racial slurs used against people for simply being alive and there, and that's simply inexcusable. You are all the way in the wrong here.

TLDR: you're trivialising racism and throwing black people under the bus.

georgarina · 24/06/2022 07:54

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 07:31

Because a small number of people have a variation of male or female sexual development and sometimes people lose primary or secondary sexual characteristics to cancer.

Exploiting DSDs and cancer patients with fallacious bullshit. That's what they've got. A woman post hysterectomy isn't really a woman. It really is that offensive and ignorant.

And conflation of sex and gender stereotypes, so a woman is someone who likes Barbie and baking. Obviously.

They should honestly be ashamed.

It doesn't stand up though because technically everyone is mixed race but it's still not acceptable to identify as a race if you're not. Race has a LOT more flexibility but that's still not ok. So there's no technicality about biological sex that makes it more ok or understandable.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 07:31

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 07:23

There's never any answer to this, but I'll have another go.

Why is it only sex where biology can be trumped by what I feel in my head.

Why can't I 'identify' as black, blind, a cat on the grounds that I was born in the 'wrong body'?

Because a small number of people have a variation of male or female sexual development and sometimes people lose primary or secondary sexual characteristics to cancer.

Exploiting DSDs and cancer patients with fallacious bullshit. That's what they've got. A woman post hysterectomy isn't really a woman. It really is that offensive and ignorant.

And conflation of sex and gender stereotypes, so a woman is someone who likes Barbie and baking. Obviously.

They should honestly be ashamed.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 07:23

There's never any answer to this, but I'll have another go.

Why is it only sex where biology can be trumped by what I feel in my head.

Why can't I 'identify' as black, blind, a cat on the grounds that I was born in the 'wrong body'?

334bu · 24/06/2022 07:02

Unfortunately the German FA has just thrown every female footballer under the bus by allowing any male footballer who identifies either as a woman or non binary to play in whichever category they like. Wonder what effect this will have on the number of women able to earn a living pkaying football?

itsgettingweird · 24/06/2022 04:32

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 20:34

Bingo!! Now we’re up to the racism equivalency. I can tick that off my card now. Does that mean if a TRA calls one woman a horrible name to one woman, they’re expressing misogyny and it’s like they’re being racist. Please please go and tell them that. Why are you more upset with the language used than the fact a male bullied himself onto a women’s swimming team, took a place from a woman, walked round exposing himself to vulnerable women, and Anyone who opposed this was a ‘transphobic bigot’. Why does the fact someone pointed out he has a penis upset you, but not his actions?

👏👏👏👏👏👏

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 04:24

I don’t understand how you can accept that penises in single-sex places where people might be getting undressed might not be welcomed by many women (which you do seem to accept)…

…and then also maintain that ‘transwomen are women’, @StolenCookie?

dropthevipers · 24/06/2022 00:12

well, it's been a long night. And yet, still no meaningful definition as why trans women are women. Going around making tautologous statements such as women are women would make people think you were a bit simple, so clearly the contentious bit is the term trans. to transition is to move from one state to another. Unfortunately, no one has ever yet in all recorded history changed sex so this transition is, and can only be, cultural or societal in nature. In other words, play acting. When people say, in all apparent seriousness, that they regard trans women as women I think they either dont know what they are saying or they are just fucking bonkers.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 00:01

Boomboom22 · 23/06/2022 23:58

Wow surely that is just a troll? So offensive and no thought to the reality of prisons, sports and schools. Unbelievable!

Thing is, that's so common now that even if it was a troll, it could easily have been real.

Boomboom22 · 23/06/2022 23:58

Wow surely that is just a troll? So offensive and no thought to the reality of prisons, sports and schools. Unbelievable!

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 23/06/2022 23:46

@StolenCookie So a fully functioning penis is OK on an inmate in a women's prison so long as the person it is attached thinks they are woman. Even if they have used said penis to commit rape? Even if their female cell mate has been the victim of sexual violence and doesn't want to share a cell with a penis? How can we tell a be-penised rapist who really feels like a woman from one who merely says they feel like a woman? Because if they say they are woman we must believe them and treat them as women even if they have committed the most unwomanly crime?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 23:45

I was inclined to believe it was a woman at first because it started off very "be kind", which is how women usually couch it. The "you love me really, doncha" stuff with the winky emoji did set my antenna waving a bit though. Plus the unending reverence for respect of the knob.

I do think the opinions, such as they were, were genuine though. The tone changed so much as he got steadily destroyed and there was so much obvious embarrassment at the end.

EaselArt · 23/06/2022 23:40

I’m a cat.

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 23:39

Definitely a he who gets off on thinking he made us angry.

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 23:38

How bizarre, after the talk about making a coherent argument he dodged every pertinent question and then disappeared

nolongersurprised · 23/06/2022 23:34

Of course not, because you don't give a shit about women and we do

And our daughters. Who, quite simply, wouldn’t get changed or go to the toilet if there were knobs in there.

nolongersurprised · 23/06/2022 23:31

the timing of how long knobs are waved about in your changing room before you're allowed to be uncomfortable

There’s probably a mathematical equation that helps you solve this.

With introduction of variables - any sighting at all of a knob is too much for the young, very religious or those who have been sexually abused in the past.

Then additional variables for length of time it was exposed for and whether it was erect/semi erect as with the penis-owner at the Wii Spa.

Any sighting of a knob in a women’s (or girls’) changing room should also be automatically be considered too much knob if that changing room is for athletes. If you have a knob you have a male body and shouldn’t be competing against females.

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 23:30

I’m not angry. Amused yes, angry no. Not in the slightest. I think it’s funny when a faux innocent pops up and tone polices us. The arse kicking is usually epic and tonight did not disappoint.

Clymene · 23/06/2022 23:29

What does the word woman mean @StolenCookie? If it's something anyone can be, what is it?

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 23:28

I only read about all this on MN. Until recently, I too was all about being inclusive and kind. Then I saw Martina Navratilova ( a true idol of mine) being roundly abused for being a TERF. Then I thought: hang on, Martina? The woman who had a trans coach and was a lesbian icon? There's something very wrong here.

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 23:27

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 23:25

Of course she doesn't.

She doesn't know that Stonewall now denounces lesbians as "sexual racists" who should examine their prejudices either. She hasn't heard of the cotton ceiling and she doesn't know that Stonewall employs the person who coined the term. She doesn't know what a woman is. She doesn't know why knobs in women's spaces make people angry.

I really can’t believe that she is a pregnant, feminist woman.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 23:26

I can’t help that this seems to make all of you incredibly angry!

where are you getting angry from

where on earth are you getting ‘all of you’ and ‘incredibly’ from

there might be the odd angry poster on here…but incredibly and all of us?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 23:25

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 23:21

I don't think you even know who Maya Forstater is tbh. Or Allison Bailey. That's why us TERFS are angry. You are just burbling on about your beliefs, but unable to say whether, for instance, you want TW to be in women's prisons.

Of course she doesn't.

She doesn't know that Stonewall now denounces lesbians as "sexual racists" who should examine their prejudices either. She hasn't heard of the cotton ceiling and she doesn't know that Stonewall employs the person who coined the term. She doesn't know what a woman is. She doesn't know why knobs in women's spaces make people angry.

VestofAbsurdity · 23/06/2022 23:24

And you certainly don't have the right to impose this ridiculous belief on other women who do not consent to knobs in their changing rooms.

Exactly. You cannot give consent on behalf of other women.

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 23:21

I don't think you even know who Maya Forstater is tbh. Or Allison Bailey. That's why us TERFS are angry. You are just burbling on about your beliefs, but unable to say whether, for instance, you want TW to be in women's prisons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread