Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 09:49

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 09:41

No, it asserts, it doesn’t explain.

Why can you change into a woman by fiat but not into a different race?

How can sex be a question of feeling over biology, but age, race, height or age not be?

That article posits the religious view that humans have an innate sexed soul from which an innate gender identity flows. That is unevidenced and, a-priori, a ludicrous assertion.

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 09:48

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 09:45

I can't believe a pregnant woman thinks there is no difference between her and a transwoman. Everyday about 800 women die from pregnancy or childbirth, but hey, maybe they can just identify out of that.

Stella Creasy, who spent months whingeing about how MPs don't get maternity leave and not being allowed to breastfeed her baby in the House of Commons, claiming that these are barriers to women in politics, thinks a trans woman is an adult human female.

Really, Stella?

Not only do we not need a word for "humans of the childbearing sex", but we don't even need a word for "the childbearing sex" at all?

Well that will make the barriers to humans of the childbearing sex in politics just magically disappear, won't it?

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 09:46

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 09:41

"Gender is our internal sense of self, whether that be man, woman, neither or both."

But this is fucking word salad.

It cannot simultaneously be about your internal sense of self, and also be about being a man or a woman, which are both words for groups of people.

Lia Thomas's internal sense of self has got absolutely nothing to do with the female swimmers. You admitted that yourself.

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 09:45

I can't believe a pregnant woman thinks there is no difference between her and a transwoman. Everyday about 800 women die from pregnancy or childbirth, but hey, maybe they can just identify out of that.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 09:44

TRAs don’t understand basic philosophy or epistemology.

They actually do. That's how they know they're wrong. That's why they get so angry and abusive.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 09:42

Morning, Cookies. Everyone knows you're still enraged about being proven wrong, definitively, over and over again yesterday. And you're still banging on because it's now a battle for your ego and nothing to do with trans people. But if you want to keep embarrassing yourself, far be it from us to stop you living your authentic self.

Googling "lia thomas changing room" brings up a zillion hits for the story that you didn't know about. The original interview was with the Daily Mail but the top hits are all American, NYP first. Keep looking at the hits and you'll see how women were also told to "get over" having Thomas' knob out in front of them.

I'm sure you're going to claim this is made up, or say that direct quotes cease to exist if the Daily Mail reports them, but that's to be expected from someone who thinks they can make up their own facts.

We aren't actually trying to get you to admit we're right. You obviously know we are, but your ego will never allow it. You're just posting now to show we haven't "beaten" you, because that's the level you engage on. This is now for the lurkers who really are looking for evidence and don't mind thinking.

Happy Friday and don't trip over any errant knobs.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 09:41

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 09:11

We’re not biologically classifying people.

Yes we are. It's a sex classification.

We’re talking about an identity. A conscious thing you feel.

Ok, so can I identify as another race? Another species? If not why not?

theconversation.com/no-you-cant-identify-as-transracial-but-you-can-affirm-your-gender-163729

This explains it better than I could.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 09:40

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 09:23

I don’t know what a woman is but trans women are definitely what I’m not sure about.

I don't get why people aren't more embarrassed by this nonsense. No critical thinking whatsoever.

I think that trans activists tend to be drawn from the opposite end of the gene pool to the intellectual elite.

Argument by assertion, circular definitions, special pleading and temper tantrums seem to be all that they have.

The very idea that a man can feel “like” a woman is incoherent. No-one knows what it feels like to be a woman, as opposed to feeling like a man.

Each of us only knows how it feels to be “me.” We have no idea which parts of that gestalt state we share with another woman, with all women, with another man or with all men.

TRAs don’t understand basic philosophy or epistemology.

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 09:38

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 09:08

Why do features of an identity have to be shared? We’re not biologically classifying people. We’re talking about an identity. A conscious thing you feel.

Also - please someone link me to a credible article about Lia Thomas assaulting women in the changing room. I do genuinely want to learn more about this if it actually happened.

The utter stupidity of this question.

Why do the features of an identity have to be shared?

Because if there are no shared features, this alleged "identity" has got absolutely nothing to do with being a woman, which is a word for a group of people making up roughly half the human population.

Lia Thomas's alleged "identity" is Lia's sole justification for why Lia, who has significant and obvious physical advantages over the female swimmers, should be allowed to compete with them rather than with the male swimmers. It is the reason why Lia believes that Lia and Lia's penis belong in the women's locker rooms and not the men's.

So yes, damn right, Lia - and everyone else who insists that trans women are women if that is how they "identify" - need to be able to explain what they are identifying with and that the fuck they think it has to do with being a woman.

Otherwise, if "woman" and "man" are both identities, but with no features or characteristics shared by people who have those identities, we do not need these words at all, because there is no actual difference between a woman and a man. If these are identities which are not shared but are unique to the individual, we can dispense with the words "woman" and "man" and simply refer to everyone as humans. No more single sex sports, changing rooms, prisons or toilets. Everyone in together.

Good luck explaining to your children how babies are made, or who is at risk of FGM, or who might need an abortion, or who might be at risk of getting testicular cancer though.

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 09:30

"The presence of a penis does not mean you are not a woman."

I mean I would rather be a TERF than parrot this nonsense.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 09:23

I don’t know what a woman is but trans women are definitely what I’m not sure about.

I don't get why people aren't more embarrassed by this nonsense. No critical thinking whatsoever.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 09:23

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 08:54

Good morning Mumsnet!

I awoke refreshed and renewed in my conviction that trans women are women. I knew it would be a good day and I hope you’re all well rested too after the fiasco last night 😄

I see that someone referred to ‘us TERFs’ up thread. Would I be accurate in describing yesterday as… a TERFnado? A TERFtastrophe perhaps!

Has a rumour started that I am a man? You rascals!

What is a woman? I don’t think there’s a clear answer to that question. But I believe it’s an identity you feel (rather than dictated by sex organs) and I would recognise anyone as a woman if that’s how they chose to identify.

Would I welcome a trans woman in a female space? Yes I would! The sight of a penis may be triggering for some women, which is a genuine problem, but that doesn’t negate the fact that trans women are women because the presence of a penis doesn’t mean you are not a woman.

As an aside: can anyone link me to a credible news source about Lia Thomas reportedly assaulting/harassing women in the changing room? I googled last night but couldn’t find anything.

Is Rachel Dolezal black?

Do you understand that definitions cannot be circular?

Is it fair to say that like everyone who pops up here parroting trans-activist rhetoric that you aren’t really aware of the structure of a valid argument? It’s like not a single one of you has a decent degree that involves developing an understanding of how an argument is formed.

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 09:21

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 09:08

Why do features of an identity have to be shared? We’re not biologically classifying people. We’re talking about an identity. A conscious thing you feel.

Also - please someone link me to a credible article about Lia Thomas assaulting women in the changing room. I do genuinely want to learn more about this if it actually happened.

You are using the Lia Thomas incident to obscure the fact that you think men should be able to feel their way into women's prisons, refuges, and services. As far as I know Lia did not assault anyone, but women in the swim team - some as young as 17- expressed their discomfort at having to see his tackle. They were told to shut up.

Women do not need to prove assault by a man in a changing room. It's enough to say we need safe spaces.

I consciously feel I am a cat and therefore don't need to pay taxes. Is that ok then?

Theluggage15 · 24/06/2022 09:19

‘I don’t know what a woman is but trans women are definitely what I’m not sure about.’ Hilarious!!

Just emperors new clothes nonsense . But luckily, just like in that story, because of people like Thomas and Bridges, more and more people are now pointing and laughing at the absolutely bonkers idea that a man can just say he’s a woman and everyone will go along with that despite the harm caused to women and girls.

334bu · 24/06/2022 09:15

Jon Pike(OU) is being interviewed at 10 am BBC Sussex about the unfairness of allowing male sexed athletes to compete against female athletes.
www.insidethegames.biz/articles/1124810/navratilova-criticises-ioc-transgender

An article in which Martina Navratilova criticises the IOC for passing the buck.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 09:11

We’re not biologically classifying people.

Yes we are. It's a sex classification.

We’re talking about an identity. A conscious thing you feel.

Ok, so can I identify as another race? Another species? If not why not?

Rainbowshit · 24/06/2022 09:09

So we're back to religious mantras. 🙄

Woman has a very clear definition in the equality act. I suggest you look it up.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 09:08

Why do features of an identity have to be shared? We’re not biologically classifying people. We’re talking about an identity. A conscious thing you feel.

Also - please someone link me to a credible article about Lia Thomas assaulting women in the changing room. I do genuinely want to learn more about this if it actually happened.

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 09:03

What is a woman? I don’t think there’s a clear answer to that question. But I believe it’s an identity you feel (rather than dictated by sex organs) and I would recognise anyone as a woman if that’s how they chose to identify.

I'm sorry @StolenCookie, but that isn't a good enough answer.

"Women" is a word for a group of people making up about half the human population. In order for that word to have any meaning or use, the people in that group need to have something in common.

What do women and trans women have in common, which makes them the same as each other and different to men, and justifies them using the same toilets and changing rooms, being housed in the same prisons and competing in the same sporting categories?

If you think it is that they share the same identity, you need to be able to explain what the features of that identity are.

Because I for one do not have a clue what trans women are identifying with.

If you ask me how I know I am a woman, I will tell you that it is because I am biologically female. I have a vagina, ovaries, a uterus and breasts. I have two X chromosomes. I menstruate. I have grown a human inside my body. I have not ever had a penis or produced sperm.

I do not know what trans women are identifying with, but it clearly isn't that.

And I am not identifying with anything other than that.

I certainly do not identify with liking the colour pink, playing with Barbies, shopping for pleasure, not being able to open jam jars, wearing dresses and makeup, not being able to parallel park, or any other sexist stereotypes associated with being a woman.

Once you remove female biology from the equation, all you've got left is sexist stereotypes.

TheElementsSong · 24/06/2022 09:03

Well, at least the mask has been dropped this morning.

Peregrina · 24/06/2022 09:02

What is a woman? I don’t think there’s a clear answer to that question.

Well I bl**dy well think there is a clear answer, and I only did O level biology.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 09:02

What is a woman? I don’t think there’s a clear answer to that question

I can't understand why people are so clear they are one then, if it's indefinable.

because the presence of a penis doesn’t mean you are not a woman.

Its like the twilight zone. More biology classes sorely needed I think.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 08:58

But I believe it’s an identity you feel (rather than dictated by sex organs)

So why does that only apply to being a woman?

why wouldn't being black, blind or a cat be an 'identity you feel' rather than 'being dictated by biological reality'?

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 08:54

Good morning Mumsnet!

I awoke refreshed and renewed in my conviction that trans women are women. I knew it would be a good day and I hope you’re all well rested too after the fiasco last night 😄

I see that someone referred to ‘us TERFs’ up thread. Would I be accurate in describing yesterday as… a TERFnado? A TERFtastrophe perhaps!

Has a rumour started that I am a man? You rascals!

What is a woman? I don’t think there’s a clear answer to that question. But I believe it’s an identity you feel (rather than dictated by sex organs) and I would recognise anyone as a woman if that’s how they chose to identify.

Would I welcome a trans woman in a female space? Yes I would! The sight of a penis may be triggering for some women, which is a genuine problem, but that doesn’t negate the fact that trans women are women because the presence of a penis doesn’t mean you are not a woman.

As an aside: can anyone link me to a credible news source about Lia Thomas reportedly assaulting/harassing women in the changing room? I googled last night but couldn’t find anything.

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 08:34

Just catching up on this thread.

It's amazing how some people, when backed into a corner and with no arguments left, will just fall back on "trans women are women", as if that settles it.

I have yet to come across anyone who believes trans women are women who can actually coherently explain what a woman is, or anyone who can meaningfully define the word woman and believes that a trans woman is one.