Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
334bu · 24/06/2022 12:12

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/live:bbc_radio_sussex

From just after 11 discussion on whether male athletes who identify as women should be included in female sport.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:12

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=twitter.com/zubymusic/status/1100348562041462784%3Flang%3Den&ved=2ahUKEwiL74nS-cX4AhUyQEEAHUUJAcQQwqsBegQIBhAB&usg=AOvVaw34cBAqix0nGTqYO0KPlRfv" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">The rapper Zuby beat a women's weightlifting record while identifying as a woman.

Why is Zuby not now listed as one of the strongest women in the world, if a woman is both indefinable and also anyone who identifies as one? This is rank injustice. Aren't you going to fight for Zuby's medal?

georgarina · 24/06/2022 12:07

@StolenCookie How do you know you are a woman if 'woman' can't be objectively defined? Or do you not know?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:07

If you can't define a woman, how do you define a transwoman?

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 12:05

Maybe I'm actually a skyscraper 🤔

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 12:04

A cat is whoever identifies as one. It can't be defined. Similarly an ironing board.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:04

A woman is whoever identifies as one! I don’t believe it can be objectively defined.

Then how do you know which competition and which changing room Thomas should enter?

How do you know which of your parents is your mother?

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 12:03

My contribution here, which I see as worthwhile, is insisting that trans women are women. If you don’t see that as a worthwhile contribution that is okay, but it won’t stop me reiterating it in response to the people here who are arguing otherwise!

Well it's not a worthwhile contribution because you can't explain what a woman is, so it's just word salad really.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 12:03

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:01

A woman is whoever identifies as one! I don’t believe it can be objectively defined.

That is a circular definition, it does not work. What is the thing that they identify as? How do they know that it’s “woman”?

Come on, surely you are not this thick, are you?

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 12:02

A woman is whoever identifies as one! I don’t believe it can be objectively defined.

so can I identify as a cat? Really keen to know.

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 12:02

I have no answers to the problem of some TW raping and assaulting women in prison. It is so complex I can't get my head around it.But I believe they should be allowed in because Be Kind! Puppies and rainbows! Kumbaya!

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 12:02

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:59

My contribution here, which I see as worthwhile, is insisting that trans women are women. If you don’t see that as a worthwhile contribution that is okay, but it won’t stop me reiterating it in response to the people here who are arguing otherwise!

You are asserting it, but it’s worthless, as you admit that you don’t know what a woman is.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:01

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 11:58

In what sense? If you don’t know what a woman is, how can you know that someone is one?

Your argument here is utterly incoherent. You seem to have literally no idea why you think this to be the case; you are asserting that some males are definitely women, but with no idea what a woman is. You are then studiously avoiding any question that might clarify your thought process.

Argument by assertion is literally how children argue. It’s not tenable for an adult to do it.

A woman is whoever identifies as one! I don’t believe it can be objectively defined.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:00

My contribution here, which I see as worthwhile, is insisting that trans women are women.

But you don't have a definition of woman, so why are you so sure?

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:59

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 11:57

People keep asking me for answers. I’ve been very clear I don’t have them!

We know you have no answers. You've been proving it for half a day. So if you're a thinking person, then stop talking, stop obsessing over hard ons, stop championing sexual harassment, stop discrediting victims, stop erasing women, stop disrespecting other cultures and stop being scientifically illiterate.

Start reading, listening and thinking and come back when you've got something worthwhile to add.

My contribution here, which I see as worthwhile, is insisting that trans women are women. If you don’t see that as a worthwhile contribution that is okay, but it won’t stop me reiterating it in response to the people here who are arguing otherwise!

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 11:58

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:52

People keep asking me for answers. I’ve been very clear I don’t have them! I don’t know how we both protect vulnerable women and protect vulnerable trans women’s rights.

But I’m afraid my appreciation of this topic as being a complex one doesn’t convince me that trans women are not women. They are 🤷🏻‍♀️

In what sense? If you don’t know what a woman is, how can you know that someone is one?

Your argument here is utterly incoherent. You seem to have literally no idea why you think this to be the case; you are asserting that some males are definitely women, but with no idea what a woman is. You are then studiously avoiding any question that might clarify your thought process.

Argument by assertion is literally how children argue. It’s not tenable for an adult to do it.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:57

georgarina · 24/06/2022 11:53

This is the quote.

“It’s definitely awkward because Lia still has male body parts and is still attracted to women."

It could literally mean nothing else.

Well we will have to agree to disagree! I think you’re conflating two things to try and make a case that Lia doesn’t belong in a women’s changing room. I disagree with you and believe Lia has every right to change her clothes in peace in a female changing room.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 11:57

People keep asking me for answers. I’ve been very clear I don’t have them!

We know you have no answers. You've been proving it for half a day. So if you're a thinking person, then stop talking, stop obsessing over hard ons, stop championing sexual harassment, stop discrediting victims, stop erasing women, stop disrespecting other cultures and stop being scientifically illiterate.

Start reading, listening and thinking and come back when you've got something worthwhile to add.

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 11:55

Oddly other people have come up with the relatively simple answer of third spaces for transwomen.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 11:54

But I’m afraid my appreciation of this topic as being a complex one doesn’t convince me that trans women are not women. They are

But you can't define what a woman is, so how can you state that?

Your only justification for that position is how they feel. But that's no different to me, deeply and sincerely feeling that im a cat. Am I a cat?

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:54

Theluggage15 · 24/06/2022 11:51

But you’re not a woman though are you? You don’t know what a woman is. Are you saying you’re not a man? How do you define a man? And yeah sure you’re having a baby. 😂

It’s ok to not believe me. I am very amused by the idea that people think I am a man though! Do you all really think this? 😅

georgarina · 24/06/2022 11:53

This is the quote.

“It’s definitely awkward because Lia still has male body parts and is still attracted to women."

It could literally mean nothing else.

Peregrina · 24/06/2022 11:52

A thread which got taken down yesterday had mention of a sister accidentally seeing her brother's tackle.

If most would prefer not to see a family member's tackle (apart from a DH or DP) then why on earth should completely unrelated women have to put up with getting an eyeful?

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:52

People keep asking me for answers. I’ve been very clear I don’t have them! I don’t know how we both protect vulnerable women and protect vulnerable trans women’s rights.

But I’m afraid my appreciation of this topic as being a complex one doesn’t convince me that trans women are not women. They are 🤷🏻‍♀️

Theluggage15 · 24/06/2022 11:51

But you’re not a woman though are you? You don’t know what a woman is. Are you saying you’re not a man? How do you define a man? And yeah sure you’re having a baby. 😂