Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:39

What is the fear surrounding trans women? Do you feel that women are unsafe in a world in which trans women exist?

Rainbunny · 24/06/2022 13:39

It's not directly related to the sports issue but I read today in the DM about a man who is suing the NHS for not warning him of any of the negative outcomes of MTF sex reassignment surgery.

He is basically castrated with ongoing medical and psychological issues. He says he was given no counselling, no information about the physical outcomes (which are pretty horrifying to read about) no information on how he would be rendered infertile etc... Now that he's broken and depressed by what he's been through, the gender clinics have no interest in helping him. I'm sure they wish he didn't exist. This man was in his twenties when he went through this, imagine how even worse it may be for people who did this in their teens. I hope he wins and it's widely publicised. I don't like the NHS being sued since it's taxpayer's money at the end of the day but I fully support him.

I think it's the inevitable flood os lawsuits that will truly reign in this extreme idealogy the NHS has fallen captive to.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:36

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 12:45

Once you’ve answered that question - which is ‘why are there different words for women and transwomen if they’re exactly the same thing?’, I’ll repeat my other question for you.

I don’t want to derail getting an answer to the first question.

It’s not that complicated…

You can share the identity of woman whilst also retaining differences.

You can be a short woman and a tall woman.
A black woman and a white woman.
A woman who feels they are born in the correct body, and a trans woman.

They’re all women. They’re all different.

Mascia · 24/06/2022 13:19

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 12:32

The whole idea of being in the 'wrong body' is so bizarre. You cant be in another one.

Also - what if one feels in the "wrong" body just because one would like to be taller, shorter, prettier? What if someone has a disability, a chronic illness that makes their everyday life difficult?

MiniPiccolo · 24/06/2022 12:57

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 22/06/2022 13:37

I suspect Open will be extremely unpopular or devalued as a category, but it’s sensible to have it.

it’ll effectively function as (and be perceived as) a second tier men’s category. One where anyone can have a go, but everyone knows the real prestige is in the Mens category.

The risk is it becomes a place for people who didn’t quite qualify for the Mens to access competitions anyway. If adopted at grassroots level, Open may end up full of men and boys who are just short of a qualifying time and need a chance to swim
at a particular level to try to get one, or to go to the (for example) nationals when them missed the QT for the mens. So a less prestigious men division 2 category. But where you might find yourself swimming against the odd woman or transperson.

I expect it will turn out to be quite hard to set QTs for the Open category.

And it’s likely that many trans women don’t want to swim in Open anyway. Or Mens. They want their identity validated (and the biological advantage) to be gained from being in the Women category.

Oh no... trans people will have to compete against people who have a hormonal and biological advantage. Poor them 🙄

Wonder who else has been having to do that... 🤔

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:54

How did Thomas know which competition and changing room to enter?

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 12:52

If transwomen are women - what is a woman?

Beowulfa · 24/06/2022 12:51

Well, I may have started off reading the thread thinking FINA's carefully researched and worded statement was sensible, but StolenCookie's glittering arguments have persuaded me otherwise. I now know:

-it's really hard to define a "woman", but if a man says he is one then he definitely is (whatever it is).
-if you are in a female changing room and you see a penis, it's awfully rude of you to call it a knob.

I hope other lurkers are similarly enlightened.

babyjellyfish · 24/06/2022 12:50

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:22

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

So what do male people who believe they were born in the wrong body have in common with female people who don't believe they were born in the wrong body?

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 12:45

Once you’ve answered that question - which is ‘why are there different words for women and transwomen if they’re exactly the same thing?’, I’ll repeat my other question for you.

I don’t want to derail getting an answer to the first question.

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 12:41

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:22

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

But that doesn’t make any sense.

You’re saying transwomen are women?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:40

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:37

I agreed not to use it in relation to yourselves. I identify as a cis woman and I have every right to state that!

But you aren't using it only for yourself. You have imposed your view upon us by stating "you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women)."

You are being highly offensive, misgendering us and mislabelling us.

What is a woman's body?

How can you identify as a woman if woman is indefinable?

Mascia · 24/06/2022 12:39

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 11:54

But I’m afraid my appreciation of this topic as being a complex one doesn’t convince me that trans women are not women. They are

But you can't define what a woman is, so how can you state that?

Your only justification for that position is how they feel. But that's no different to me, deeply and sincerely feeling that im a cat. Am I a cat?

That's a very good question and I'm yet to see a coherent answer - can anyone self-identify as anything? If that is how they feel?
How can words have meanings if we can't define them?

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:37

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:27

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

I thought you agreed not to use that offensive term any more.

What is a woman's body?

I agreed not to use it in relation to yourselves. I identify as a cis woman and I have every right to state that!

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 12:32

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:22

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

You are again using the offensive term “cis”. Why are you choosing to be offensive like this?

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 12:32

The whole idea of being in the 'wrong body' is so bizarre. You cant be in another one.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 12:31

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:22

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

We are only our bodies. You are positing a dualist view, that there is a sexed soul which exists independently of our physical selves. That is completely unevidenced. It’s a religious / spiritual viewpoint.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 12:28

or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity

How would you know if another body matches your gender identity? You've never been in another.

What if you're born into a body that doesn't match your internally understood racial identity? Why is that not legit?

And more fundamentally than any of that, you can't actually escape your own body. Chopping bits off it doesn't make it essentially different.

VestofAbsurdity · 24/06/2022 12:27

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

This tedious, illogical waffle just gets worse. How can you be born into a body? What kind of risible nonsense is that?

and coming from someone, allegedly, pregnant....Hmm

Rainbowshit · 24/06/2022 12:27

You're very far behind the time Stolen, no one says born in the wrong body anymore. Not even those crackpots Mermaids.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:27

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

I thought you agreed not to use that offensive term any more.

What is a woman's body?

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 12:26

What if some of us feel we are born in the wrong human body and identify with cats? I have a cat whom I adore and I often feel closer to her than humans.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 12:22

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 12:14

I don’t understand why you keep (repeatedly) distinguishing between women and transwomen.

You say they’re one and the same.

So why do you keep referring to women and transwomen?

Also, just wondering @StolenCookie - do you know how babies are made?

Because you are either born in what you feel is the correct body for you (cis women) or born into a different body that doesn’t match your gender identity (trans women).

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 12:14

Don't know what happened there. Here's the link.

Justice for Zuby the strongwoman.

RenegadeMatron · 24/06/2022 12:14

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 11:52

People keep asking me for answers. I’ve been very clear I don’t have them! I don’t know how we both protect vulnerable women and protect vulnerable trans women’s rights.

But I’m afraid my appreciation of this topic as being a complex one doesn’t convince me that trans women are not women. They are 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don’t understand why you keep (repeatedly) distinguishing between women and transwomen.

You say they’re one and the same.

So why do you keep referring to women and transwomen?

Also, just wondering @StolenCookie - do you know how babies are made?