Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
Imabouttoexplode · 20/06/2022 01:13

Oestrogelsmuggler · 19/06/2022 21:41

Always knew it'd be sport that peaked people.

It certainly was for my oh. He neither understood or gave too much of a toss about it all up until sport. Then he got it all in spades.

UniversalAunt · 20/06/2022 01:04

Bristol demo Sunday 19th June 2022

Bristol Anarchists & TRAs overran & intimidated Standing for Women meeting

So far, nowt on BBC national, BBC Bristol & the Guardian.
Bristol Post:

Mail online: www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10931901/Bristol-Womens-rights-activists-silenced-balaclava-clad-trans-rights-mob.html

UniversalAunt · 20/06/2022 00:41

It’ll be interesting to see how much of the big sponsorship money follows the athletes.

Eightiesfan · 20/06/2022 00:18

The male class in sports is already an open one. Trans women in elite sports are not good enough to compete as men. Lia Thomas is an average swimmer at best, and Emily Bridges only decided to transition after she was dropped from her elite team. Both of them would have won Olympic gold had they been allowed to compete.

If this lunacy was allowed to continue, I really believe it would have all come to a head at the Olympics. By then there would have been so few women competing it would have been a joke. As it is I believe the Iranian women’s football team has at least 7 male born players. No women’s team would be able to compete with them.

The sad fact is that too many people are completely unaware of what is happening and the power that is wielded but the TRA. However, if every female medal winner on the Olympic podium possesses a penis the backlash would be glorious whilst illustrating just how ridiculous this whole woman with a penis ideology is.

Eightiesfan · 19/06/2022 23:53

HappypusSadpus · 19/06/2022 23:20

Hopefully the 'still' men will compete in it too, show them how it feels to be perpetually pitted against someone with a biological/hormonal advantage.

They'd be the first to fucking moan and cry unfairness.

Now, that would be a joy to see 🤣

BIWI · 19/06/2022 23:26

Fantastic news.

cushioncovers · 19/06/2022 23:21

Great news.

HappypusSadpus · 19/06/2022 23:20

Eightiesfan · 19/06/2022 22:27

For full inclusivity it’s the only option. However, in reality it will just be a category for Trans women.

Men will not compete in this group as there is no prestige attached to winning as the trans swimmers will be of a much lower standard. Trans men compete as they have no chance of winning against trans women.

Plus the times in the Open category will be most likely be compared to the Mem’s and as a result will fall way short, as let’s face it Lia who was winning almost everything in the women’s category was fairly mediocre as a male swimmer.

The truth is that the trans women athletes can only be considered ‘elite’ athletes and win if they are competing in the women’s category. I don’t think this fight is over, The TRA and their allies on Twitter are probably going ballistic.

Hopefully the 'still' men will compete in it too, show them how it feels to be perpetually pitted against someone with a biological/hormonal advantage.

They'd be the first to fucking moan and cry unfairness.

jcyclops · 19/06/2022 23:19

Sport ruling bodies also need to tackle rules over transmen, or you can get situations like Mack Beggs who was born female but transitioning to male as a teenager. Rules did not allow him to compete in the men's competitions that he wanted, and he had to compete in the women's which he won easily two years running.

I also wonder why FINA want a third category of competition when surely "Female" and "Open" are the only two that are necessary ie. scrap the men's category. Several sports allow men and women to compete against each other, so what objections are there for this to happen in the "open" category?

tttigress · 19/06/2022 23:12

There should be a female class, and an "open" class for everyone else who wants to participate. The open class would be mainly men, but trans and even women could go in the open class.

Forestgate · 19/06/2022 23:11

Its brilliant news,!!

ZeldaFighter · 19/06/2022 23:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

What happened in Bristol?

SpinningRoundRightRound · 19/06/2022 22:52

Male puberty >>> male sports for you, laddy

dropthevipers · 19/06/2022 22:48

Eightiesfan · 19/06/2022 22:27

For full inclusivity it’s the only option. However, in reality it will just be a category for Trans women.

Men will not compete in this group as there is no prestige attached to winning as the trans swimmers will be of a much lower standard. Trans men compete as they have no chance of winning against trans women.

Plus the times in the Open category will be most likely be compared to the Mem’s and as a result will fall way short, as let’s face it Lia who was winning almost everything in the women’s category was fairly mediocre as a male swimmer.

The truth is that the trans women athletes can only be considered ‘elite’ athletes and win if they are competing in the women’s category. I don’t think this fight is over, The TRA and their allies on Twitter are probably going ballistic.

They can go as ballistic as they fucking well like. Any legal challenge will be met with-"OK, make your case, show us the evidence". Game over, they dont have any-and they know it, hence the toddler tantrums.

Eightiesfan · 19/06/2022 22:27

For full inclusivity it’s the only option. However, in reality it will just be a category for Trans women.

Men will not compete in this group as there is no prestige attached to winning as the trans swimmers will be of a much lower standard. Trans men compete as they have no chance of winning against trans women.

Plus the times in the Open category will be most likely be compared to the Mem’s and as a result will fall way short, as let’s face it Lia who was winning almost everything in the women’s category was fairly mediocre as a male swimmer.

The truth is that the trans women athletes can only be considered ‘elite’ athletes and win if they are competing in the women’s category. I don’t think this fight is over, The TRA and their allies on Twitter are probably going ballistic.

Oestrogelsmuggler · 19/06/2022 21:41

Always knew it'd be sport that peaked people.

Snowflakes1122 · 19/06/2022 21:39

YANBU! Great news. Can’t understand how it got to this. Things have been bizarre.

KangarooKenny · 19/06/2022 21:32

It’s a start , let’s hope it’s pushed all the way back 🤞🏻

Americano75 · 19/06/2022 21:26

It's a start at least!

UWhatNow · 19/06/2022 21:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Assistanttotheregionalmanager · 19/06/2022 21:03

Not being unreasonable

DOBARDAN · 19/06/2022 21:01

It's a good start, that's for sure.
Let's hope it spreads to non elite women's swimming too and all other women's sporting events.

TooBigForMyBoots · 19/06/2022 20:58

Good stuff.

riesenrad · 19/06/2022 20:57

Great news although I expect it will go through several rounds of legal challenges.