Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 14:41

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 13:55

Several people on here think you are a man, Cookies. You champion sexual harassment, discredit women, make creepy comments about me liking you, demand respect for errant knobs and don't give a shit about women's dignity and safety. To many of us, those are typically male traits. If there's no objective definition of what is a man or woman, why are you so outraged that some of us think you're a man? If there's no definition, how can we possibly be wrong?

Where have I been outraged?

jeaux90 · 24/06/2022 14:34

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:39

What is the fear surrounding trans women? Do you feel that women are unsafe in a world in which trans women exist?

Transwomen are males.

Males commit 98% of sexual assaults.

Males with special identities do not belong in womens sports, spaces or services.

It's really that simple.

VestofAbsurdity · 24/06/2022 14:21

Yes @334bu and justified it all on the basis of something, something, something, identity, no criteria, feelings, not nice. Thankfully, FINA have seen sense, used science and actual provable defining criteria and said NO.

My gripe is that it should NEVER have got this far in the first place.

334bu · 24/06/2022 14:14

StolenCookie is managing to divert the whole topic of the gross unfairness of male athletes being allowed to compete with women,; an unfairness which results in denying them the opportunities of scholarships, prize money,professional contracts, sponsorship etc,etc.
Sporting bodies have colluded with TRA lobbying groups to introduce with absolutely no scientific evidence , male bodied athletes into the female category and have thus excluded women from the benefits that performing at an elite level can bring. The professional women cyclists denied prize money and professional contracts, the Argentinian female footballers losing places on top flight teams to biological males, the female volleyball players who cant play professionally, the female snowboarder losing prize money, the female golfers losing prize money, the female archer and weightlifters denied Olympic status and all the little girls who no longer play a sport they love because a biological male makes competing unsafe or takes their place.

Mascia · 24/06/2022 14:08

How can people "share the identity of woman" when it's a "personal identity" without "any defining criteria"?
How can you share something that can't be defined?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 14:06

What else has no defining criteria?

Cookies' ability to reason.

VestofAbsurdity · 24/06/2022 14:06

TullyApplebottom · 24/06/2022 13:58

And there is nothing to transition from or to. And we can all go home! Praise be

Exactly, our dear friend who claim to be uber supportive and totally pro trans has just denied the very existence of trans.

VestofAbsurdity · 24/06/2022 14:04

It’s a personal identity. There aren’t any defining criteria.

Then everyone is and no-one is.

What else has no defining criteria?

Mascia · 24/06/2022 14:02

Can "surgeon" be a personal identity without any defining criteria? Or "Asian"? Or "cat"?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 13:58

How can gender identity even exist as a concept if there's no way to define it?

TullyApplebottom · 24/06/2022 13:58

And there is nothing to transition from or to. And we can all go home! Praise be

iamlucyvanpelt · 24/06/2022 13:56

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:54

It’s a personal identity. There aren’t any defining criteria.

Then it doesn't have anything to do with being a woman or a man.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 13:55

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:54

It’s a personal identity. There aren’t any defining criteria.

Are you honest enough to stop dodging the troublesome follow-up questions yet?

Why is race, nationality or race similarly open to being defined by personal conviction?

Mascia · 24/06/2022 13:55

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:45

If that’s how a particular woman identifies as being a woman then sure 🤷🏻‍♀️

The identify of a woman is whatever that person feels makes them a woman.

That is circular logic (yet again) and it doesn't explain anything.

"A woman is whoever feels they're a woman."

Would you apply it to any other concepts?

"A three year old is whoever feels they are three." "A surgeon is whoever thinks they are one." It doesn't make sense and you know it.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 13:55

Several people on here think you are a man, Cookies. You champion sexual harassment, discredit women, make creepy comments about me liking you, demand respect for errant knobs and don't give a shit about women's dignity and safety. To many of us, those are typically male traits. If there's no objective definition of what is a man or woman, why are you so outraged that some of us think you're a man? If there's no definition, how can we possibly be wrong?

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 13:54

As you are really struggling with the whole idea of epistemology and knowledge, try this one.

If a child asks you if they are a boy or a girl, what do you tell them? How are they supposed to know which they are?

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:54

VestofAbsurdity · 24/06/2022 13:46

You can share the identity of woman whilst also retaining differences.

What is the identity of woman? What are the defining criteria?

You can be a short woman and a tall woman.
A black woman and a white woman.

Yes.

A woman who feels they are born in the correct body, and a trans woman.
They’re all women. They’re all different.

No.

It’s a personal identity. There aren’t any defining criteria.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 13:51

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:36

It’s not that complicated…

You can share the identity of woman whilst also retaining differences.

You can be a short woman and a tall woman.
A black woman and a white woman.
A woman who feels they are born in the correct body, and a trans woman.

They’re all women. They’re all different.

You need to define what a woman is in order to make this assertion. Come on, at least have the decency to try to understand the structure of a valid argument here, instead of relying on assertion.

Without a definition of woman to start from it is literally nonsensical to argue that anyone or any thing is or isn’t it.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 13:51

If there is no objective definition of woman, how did Thomas know which competition and changing room to enter?

Thomas should have been happy competing against the males if the males all simply said they felt like women. Why wasn't that an option?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 13:48

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:45

If that’s how a particular woman identifies as being a woman then sure 🤷🏻‍♀️

The identify of a woman is whatever that person feels makes them a woman.

So a woman is whatever each individual person thinks it is?

So why can't we all say that Thomas is not a woman? Why have the word at all?

iamlucyvanpelt · 24/06/2022 13:48

If that’s how a particular woman identifies as being a woman then sure 🤷🏻‍♀️
The identify of a woman is whatever that person feels makes them a woman.

So it has nothing to do with what makes anyone else a woman then?

What is the difference between a woman and a man?

VestofAbsurdity · 24/06/2022 13:46

You can share the identity of woman whilst also retaining differences.

What is the identity of woman? What are the defining criteria?

You can be a short woman and a tall woman.
A black woman and a white woman.

Yes.

A woman who feels they are born in the correct body, and a trans woman.
They’re all women. They’re all different.

No.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:45

Mascia · 24/06/2022 13:40

What is "the identity of a woman" though? Liking to wear dresses? To bake? Going to the nail salon and for cocktails with girlfriends?

If that’s how a particular woman identifies as being a woman then sure 🤷🏻‍♀️

The identify of a woman is whatever that person feels makes them a woman.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 13:45

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:36

It’s not that complicated…

You can share the identity of woman whilst also retaining differences.

You can be a short woman and a tall woman.
A black woman and a white woman.
A woman who feels they are born in the correct body, and a trans woman.

They’re all women. They’re all different.

But you don't know what a woman is, so how can you say this?

How can one identify as a woman if there is no definition?

Mascia · 24/06/2022 13:40

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 13:36

It’s not that complicated…

You can share the identity of woman whilst also retaining differences.

You can be a short woman and a tall woman.
A black woman and a white woman.
A woman who feels they are born in the correct body, and a trans woman.

They’re all women. They’re all different.

What is "the identity of a woman" though? Liking to wear dresses? To bake? Going to the nail salon and for cocktails with girlfriends?