Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 20/06/2022 10:03

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as we don't think it's in the spirit of civil debate.

Fairislefandango · 20/06/2022 10:02

YANBU, it's great news!

And surprise surprise at the few posters plopping one 'you're all transphobes' post each, then pissing off, completely ignoring polite requests that they explain what is transphobic about having a category for trans people!

People use their (male or female) bodies to swim, run, box, kick etc, not their 'gender identities'.

viques · 20/06/2022 10:01

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 09:54

Fina will also aim to establish an 'open' category at competitions for swimmers whose gender identity is different than their birth sex

I am genuinely curious about this. Will the Lia Thomas's of the world want to swim in a trans category? Swimming with other transwomen would surely take the advantage that they have over women away? If they are happy with this, then yes, we can agree, it's just about being allowed to compete in sport.

I doubt many transwomen will be interested in a third category. They have already failed as male swimmers so won’t want to go down that route again, and swimming against other transwomen runs the risk of being beaten by someone who is a better swimmer.

And , let’s remember, there are actually two reasons for many transwomen wanting to swim against women, first it is an easy win, and second it validates their belief that they too are women, because look, here they are , swimming in a womens race. Proof.

TheKeatingFive · 20/06/2022 10:01

These posters parachuting onto threads, yelling TRANSPHOBIC and running away before they can be engaged in meaningful conversation is getting more than a little tiresome.

If you want to debate, debate. Hurling insults and promptly disappearing is pathetic.

JustWaking · 20/06/2022 10:00

It's not a one or the other situation in ration to chromosomes or hormones.

I do think this is a real casualty in the ideological drive to just change the category of 'women' to include transwomen, but without looking at the different ways we use that category, why having different spaces/events for women is justified, and exactly what boundaries make that category work as intended.

I think it would be more helpful to be a bit more thorough in considering each of the various situations where we treat men and women differently, and for each situation agree the most inclusive way that still fulfils the intended purpose - ie why it's OK to treat men and women differently in this situation in the first place!

It really isn't transphobic to recognise that there are genuine differences - between men, women, transwomen, transmen, medically transitioned/not - which sometimes need to be taken into account to be fair to all.

babyjellyfish · 20/06/2022 10:00

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 09:54

Fina will also aim to establish an 'open' category at competitions for swimmers whose gender identity is different than their birth sex

I am genuinely curious about this. Will the Lia Thomas's of the world want to swim in a trans category? Swimming with other transwomen would surely take the advantage that they have over women away? If they are happy with this, then yes, we can agree, it's just about being allowed to compete in sport.

Not only will it not give them a competitive advantage, it won't be validating enough.

They need to compete with the women in order for the world to recognise their womanhood.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 20/06/2022 10:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Leave women alone.

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 09:54

Fina will also aim to establish an 'open' category at competitions for swimmers whose gender identity is different than their birth sex

I am genuinely curious about this. Will the Lia Thomas's of the world want to swim in a trans category? Swimming with other transwomen would surely take the advantage that they have over women away? If they are happy with this, then yes, we can agree, it's just about being allowed to compete in sport.

ApplesandBunions · 20/06/2022 09:53

babyjellyfish · 20/06/2022 09:44

I think they will probably have done so much damage to their body with the puberty blockers that elite sport is out of the question anyway.

Yes, I have my suspicions this is intended as a sop. Obviously there's a discussion to be had about whether a red line would've been better but I doubt they actually envisage someone in that position ever getting near elite sports competition.

viques · 20/06/2022 09:49

ZeldaFighter · 19/06/2022 23:07

What happened in Bristol?

Masked men screaming abuse at unmasked legally demonstrating women, chalking threats on the pavements that “first it was Colston next it will be terfs” . The odd threat of rape, written and verbal invitations to suck dicks, that sort of stuff. The usual, because they are men and are apparently allowed to express their anger , make threats of physical violence and disguise their identities without being arrested.

Thank goodness they weren’t being really aggressive and doing violent acts like putting stickers on lampposts saying transwomen are men or tying suffragette ribbons on fences like those wicked frightening women a few months ago who got themselves arrested for their abusive and terrifying actions.

babyjellyfish · 20/06/2022 09:46

Suddha · 20/06/2022 09:30

Personally I think this is the wrong decision. They said anyone who went through male puberty can’t compete as a woman. But if a male transitioned before the age of 12 they can compete. We shouldn’t be encouraging young athletes to transition at that age. There should be a blanket ban on people born male competing as females, and recognition that 12 is too young for transition to be permitted so it’s simply not possible for someone to transition before puberty.

This.

But this decision is still a good start.

I reckon that within the next decade most European countries will have banned puberty blockers for this purpose.

babyjellyfish · 20/06/2022 09:44

Nancydrawn · 20/06/2022 09:11

Sorry, I think I was unclear.

I was actually asking whether you'd be okay with person born a male who took puberty blockers and thus never went through male puberty racing against women as an adult. As in, whether it was the chromosome (born with XY) or a hormone (went through testosterone--based puberty) that was the issue at hand.

It was a genuine question.

I think they will probably have done so much damage to their body with the puberty blockers that elite sport is out of the question anyway.

BIWI · 20/06/2022 09:40

tttigress · 19/06/2022 23:12

There should be a female class, and an "open" class for everyone else who wants to participate. The open class would be mainly men, but trans and even women could go in the open class.

@tttigress from the article:

Fina will also aim to establish an 'open' category at competitions for swimmers whose gender identity is different than their birth sex

SolasAnla · 20/06/2022 09:38

Nancydrawn · 20/06/2022 08:52

Out of actual curiosity, if a person had taken puberty blockers early enough not to go through male puberty, would you be comfortable with that person swimming in the women's races?

In other words, is it a chromosome difference (XX vs XY) or a hormone difference (a body that either has significant testosterone or has had significant testosterone vs one that hasn't)?

No, because why should womens sport is seen as the be kind competition?

Out of actual curiosity, if a person male had taken puberty blockers early enough not to go through male puberty, would you be comfortable with that person male swimming in the women's races?

I note how you had to edit out sex for the male/man but used women.

Was that an active choice to "desex" the male child?

Out of actual curiosity, if a person male had taken puberty blockers early enough chosen not to go through male puberty, would you be comfortable with that person male swimming in the women's races?

It is either a mixed sex or single sex race.

ApplesandBunions · 20/06/2022 09:36

Sparing a thought for Reka Gyorgy today, the woman who missed out on her rightfully earned place in the NCAA final because of Lia Thomas. This must be bittersweet for her.

CrossStichQueen · 20/06/2022 09:34

Peronsim

Are just another one of those ploppers who's echo chamber is so delicate you cannot cope with respectful discussions?

Why don't you ask MNHQ for a hide the thread button so you can ya know hide any threads you don't like.... .oh hang on a moment they already have one!!

Terfydactyl · 20/06/2022 09:33

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 20/06/2022 09:15

Mumsnet would be a very weird place if it actually had different parts of the forum for homophobia or racism or transphobia

i think its great that they will be creating an ‘open’ section

Mic drop

AngelinaFibres · 20/06/2022 09:32

TidyDancer · 20/06/2022 09:14

What's transphobic on this thread?

Nothing.
Unless actual biological women having opinions that don't fit the agenda is transphonic.....oh wait 😂

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 09:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Why is this discussion transphobic? What's the hate crime?

JanisMoplin · 20/06/2022 09:31

Yelling transphobia to cow women is not going to work anymore. I can see the tide slowly changing and Lia Thomas is responsible! I was furious when I saw him- and yes, he's a him- grandiosely announcing his plans for Olympic trials. Get back in the bin of sub- par males.

Suddha · 20/06/2022 09:30

Personally I think this is the wrong decision. They said anyone who went through male puberty can’t compete as a woman. But if a male transitioned before the age of 12 they can compete. We shouldn’t be encouraging young athletes to transition at that age. There should be a blanket ban on people born male competing as females, and recognition that 12 is too young for transition to be permitted so it’s simply not possible for someone to transition before puberty.

Batdad12 · 20/06/2022 09:23

This is massive progress for sports fairness.
unfortunately i fear the trans community now have an excuse to push puberty blocking drugs on children well before they are ready, or certain its what they want. Especially if other sports follow suit it will be a case that the are up against a hard time limit. the trans activists will say children need to transition before age 12 or they will not be able to compete in the category of their chosen gender.
Its all a really hideous mess

334bu · 20/06/2022 09:20

We know some DSDs affect females meaning they can have higher levels than the female average of testerone so can share the same male physical advantages which needs to be addressed also so they do limit the T levels in females.

Even the 1989s East German elite female swimmers who were all being doped with testosterone, never came close to male times. Male puberty is more complex than just testosterone levels and no tinkering with T levels can mitigate the differences between male and female athletes.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 20/06/2022 09:15

RenegadeMatron · 20/06/2022 04:20

Where where?

Mumsnet would be a very weird place if it actually had different parts of the forum for homophobia or racism or transphobia

i think its great that they will be creating an ‘open’ section

TidyDancer · 20/06/2022 09:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What's transphobic on this thread?

Swipe left for the next trending thread