Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 20/06/2022 10:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I agree, UWhat. But each victory is encouraging.

The injustice is particularly unmistakeable in sports. Males can just stroll into women's sports and pick up the medals, monetary prizes, scholarships etc. When people's eyes are opened to this, they may start looking at the other areas too.

334bu · 20/06/2022 10:52

Channel 5 Jeremy Vine asking for telephone calls on this at Jeremy Vine Extra.
"Is it wrong to ban transwomen from competing in the women's category?"
Tel 0207 862 2222

FOJN · 20/06/2022 10:47

How any sporting body can even suggest it is beyond me.

Sporting bodies are not advocating for childhood transition. They have set criteria which will make it almost impossible for biological males to compete in women's elite swimming events.

Unquestioning affirmative care for children is coming under increasing scrutiny and I hope will be a thing of the past quite soon. There will be legal cases and devastating accounts of the damage done to children by this ideology before we fully appreciate the magnitude of the mistake which has been made.

SherbetDips · 20/06/2022 10:36

It was bound to happen eventually. I’m all for inclusion and people living their chosen life etc but there has to be a limit or a lien in the sand.

OnceMoreWithoutFeeling · 20/06/2022 10:32

Haven't read the full thread but is anyone else concerned that this ruling will up the pressure on young male swimmers with identity issues to take puberty blockers prematurely in order to avoid falling foul of it?

borntobequiet · 20/06/2022 10:32

The idea that any child so obsessed with their gender identity that they might be treated with puberty blockers would also be sufficiently motivated to train hard enough to enter serious sporting competitions is pretty ridiculous, not to mention the debilitating side effects of such medication both physically and mentally.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 20/06/2022 10:31

I really don’t understand the fear that it’ll
create some rush to medically transition primary school children.

Being an elite athlete is tough in your body. All the medical intervention and ongoing drug regimes are going to prevent anyone going through it from getting where they need to be. We are talking about processes that put the body under enormous stress and have profound affects. There’s simply no possibility of just popping an 11 year old on puberty blockers and them carrying on with no negative impact on their performance.

Early medical transition would just prevent any kind of sporting achievement. And then there are all the important ethical considerations that make it an unacceptable thing to do to a pre-pubescent child who cannot possibly grasp the lifelong implications.

It feels like a bogeyman that couldn’t possibly exist. It’s like planning your life to mitigate against Bigfoot attacking you.

pbj · 20/06/2022 10:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What hate crimes are you talking about? The numerous hate crimes against women?

what are the “relevant” boards? Do you not know how to use online forums? You can hide threads or choose not to read ones you don’t like because your opinion is in the minority.

Pride “month” ? it’s all bloody year round corporate rainbow washing and intelligent people can see through it now. It’s no longer about equality for same sex attracted people.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/06/2022 10:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Please explain where the transphobia is. My guess is you can't as there isn't any on this thread.

borntobequiet · 20/06/2022 10:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

There’s a hate crime board? Goodness.

apintortwo · 20/06/2022 10:26

Fallon on radio 4 now. Apparently its not fair

Why don't the BBC interview interview Tamikka Brents (the woman with the bronken skull) instead of Fallon? So much for unbiased reporting!!

pbj · 20/06/2022 10:24

Batdad12 · 20/06/2022 09:23

This is massive progress for sports fairness.
unfortunately i fear the trans community now have an excuse to push puberty blocking drugs on children well before they are ready, or certain its what they want. Especially if other sports follow suit it will be a case that the are up against a hard time limit. the trans activists will say children need to transition before age 12 or they will not be able to compete in the category of their chosen gender.
Its all a really hideous mess

I don’t think it’s necessarily the “trans community” pushing for puberty blocking drugs on children or if they are it’s because they’ve been sadly manipulated by the fact this agenda is ultimately driven by big pharma and capitalism.

Some of them are not even aware of how much this ideology has made them a victim.

Alexandra2001 · 20/06/2022 10:18

I sincerely hope this decision will apply to ALL levels of swimming competition and not just elite.
A Trans woman competing at regional level, is robbing a female of a place in the pool and hence the possibility of making it to elite competition.

Needs to apply to all sports, my DD does Cross Country, its hard enough as it is to be competitive without a male turning up to run in a sports bra.

borntobequiet · 20/06/2022 10:18

BordoisAgain · 20/06/2022 08:29

It happened in MMA. The fight lasted 2 minutes and the female was left with a broken skull.

That transwoman MMA fighter was interviewed on the Today programme (I think it was they) this morning, saying that transitioned males have no advantages. I have to say I was a bit gobsmacked.

TheGoogleMum · 20/06/2022 10:17

Yanbu, even those who don't consider themselves gender critical often think in sports it wouldn't be fair for trans women to compete with women (anyone with any knowledge of biology anyway). Common sense has won

Nothappyatwork · 20/06/2022 10:16

viques · 20/06/2022 09:49

Masked men screaming abuse at unmasked legally demonstrating women, chalking threats on the pavements that “first it was Colston next it will be terfs” . The odd threat of rape, written and verbal invitations to suck dicks, that sort of stuff. The usual, because they are men and are apparently allowed to express their anger , make threats of physical violence and disguise their identities without being arrested.

Thank goodness they weren’t being really aggressive and doing violent acts like putting stickers on lampposts saying transwomen are men or tying suffragette ribbons on fences like those wicked frightening women a few months ago who got themselves arrested for their abusive and terrifying actions.

Do not forget how differently women were treated protesting of poor Sarah Everads vigil.

heathspeedwell · 20/06/2022 10:16

I remember reading that World Rugby conducted extensive research into this and found that including transwomen in contact sports with women means that the natal women suffer at least a 30% increase in risk of serious or fatal injury.

And yet there are still people arguing for 'trans inclusion' in rugby, as if women are merely a support service for the validation of male-born people at any cost. As if women being killed or injured doesn't matter as long as male-bodied people feel included.

It's great that people are finally waking up to the fact that women are people in our own right. We are allowed to have our own sports and our own spaces. We have a right to be able to enjoy competing fairly, and to enjoy being able to get changed in the privacy, dignity and safety of a single sex changing room.

borntobequiet · 20/06/2022 10:13

YANBU
It’s a great relief. Bring on the common sense and fair competition.

JustWaking · 20/06/2022 10:12

Ie in a given situation, if there's no good reason to treat men and women differently/have different categories then we absolutely shouldn't. In which case, there is no justification for treating Trans people any differently, and it would already be illegal under the Equality Act.

If there is a good reason to treat men and women differently/have different categories (what the Equality Act calls a 'proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim') then we have to make sure that how we define the categories still achieves the aim!

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 10:12

As pp mentioned, the question of children given puberty blockers, cross sex hormones and surgery by the age of 12 really isn't relevant. Those children will be so damaged due to cardiac problems, osteoporosis, incontinence and chronic pain that there will be no possibility of any sport participation at all.
Anybody who advocates doing this to children is not worthy of respect in a civilised society. How any sporting body can even suggest it is beyond me.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/06/2022 10:11

TheKeatingFive · 20/06/2022 10:01

These posters parachuting onto threads, yelling TRANSPHOBIC and running away before they can be engaged in meaningful conversation is getting more than a little tiresome.

If you want to debate, debate. Hurling insults and promptly disappearing is pathetic.

All they've got is that word. Nothing to back it up. Quite embarrassing for them tbh.

334bu · 20/06/2022 10:07

If they are happy with this, then yes, we can agree, it's just about being allowed to compete in sport.

As transmen and non binary individuals like the American footballer Quinn are happy to compete in the female category as it corresponds to their biological sex and offers them their only chance of success, it may be more than just being allowed to compete.

Merlo · 20/06/2022 10:06

TheKeatingFive · 20/06/2022 10:01

These posters parachuting onto threads, yelling TRANSPHOBIC and running away before they can be engaged in meaningful conversation is getting more than a little tiresome.

If you want to debate, debate. Hurling insults and promptly disappearing is pathetic.

And this 100%!!

Merlo · 20/06/2022 10:05

As the auntie of a very talented female swimmer, this news made me so, so happy!!

Pureimaginations · 20/06/2022 10:05

About bloody time.

Can’t argue with the science.

If men were pitted against a stronger group in the same way - that group would likely not be tolerated.