Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 11:56

the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown

What's the reasoning behind that?

Mascia · 20/06/2022 11:55

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 08:53

Or you could keep your transphobia to the relevant part of this forum so that decent people don't have to see it.

Rubbish. Transphobia, or trans-hate would be say sacking all trans people from their jobs, or making them all wear red triangles. Telling them that there are sex differences is just fact.

You are the one who needs to shut up. We have had enough of men with penises and testicles thinking that just wearing women's clothes means that they can barge into female spaces. Spaces that we have fought hard for.

Couldn't agree more.

BordoisAgain · 20/06/2022 11:52

Wanderingowl · 20/06/2022 11:42

Any boy that transitions that young will be semi-functional as an athlete. They won't come close to elite status, they will be extremely lucky to have basic levels of fitness due to the damage done to their bodies.

Quite. But the point I am making is that some sporting bodies dgaf about the health and well-being of child athletes and will dope and drug kids just to see if it gives any perceived advantage.

Even if it turns out to be a failed experiment, it's only a few kids who's lives are ruined.

It happened in the 80's and will happen again

FOJN · 20/06/2022 11:52

Well, the debate has been had, and the answer is no. Finally, a no. They can have their own, fair, category and if they don't like it they know where the door is. Women's sport is not a validation exercise. Women are not validation tools. We are not human shields, we are not easy competition. We are not there to be used at will, against our will. No.

A woman after my own heart. NO NO NO, we need to keep on saying it.

Rosehugger · 20/06/2022 11:46

Very pleased about this and hope other sports follow suit.

Wanderingowl · 20/06/2022 11:42

BordoisAgain · 20/06/2022 11:05

Given the pressure and abuses put on children in some sports, is it really that impossible to imagine that similar pressures won't/aren't being put on kids to transition?

If some countries sporting bodies aren't beyond doping and abusing the bodies of kids in one way then why is it difficult to believe they won't try it in another way? I mean who cares if their bodies start falling apart in 5 years if they've already managed to win medals now?

Any boy that transitions that young will be semi-functional as an athlete. They won't come close to elite status, they will be extremely lucky to have basic levels of fitness due to the damage done to their bodies.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 20/06/2022 11:41

And , let’s remember, there are actually two reasons for many transwomen wanting to swim against women, first it is an easy win, and second it validates their belief that they too are women, because look, here they are, swimming in a womens race. Proof.

This. This is why there's such a furore. This is why there's people arguing the toss with such ridiculous hyperbole defending men (the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown 🙄).

Males want to beat women and be validated and applauded whilst doing it. And for some unfathomable reason coughmisogynycough people can't seem to say no to them.

So we have to have big debates and discussion and research. 38 seconds. THIRTY EIGHT bastarding seconds L.Thomas beat a woman into second place by, and still there will be people coming up with ridiculous levels of unmitigated bullshit to defend it.

Well, the debate has been had, and the answer is no. Finally, a no. They can have their own, fair, category and if they don't like it they know where the door is. Women's sport is not a validation exercise. Women are not validation tools. We are not human shields, we are not easy competition. We are not there to be used at will, against our will. No.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 20/06/2022 11:40

One category for women, who were born female.

One category for all others: men, transwomen, transmen (since they may have taken testosterone), non-binaries.

That's a simple and fair solution.

Callingoccupants · 20/06/2022 11:39

It's great news but the fact that it was allowed to happen in sports in the first place is disgraceful. Then again, with this wishy washy weak Liberal minded era we are now living in, I'm not surprised.

Readingtonian · 20/06/2022 11:38

FOJN · 20/06/2022 10:47

How any sporting body can even suggest it is beyond me.

Sporting bodies are not advocating for childhood transition. They have set criteria which will make it almost impossible for biological males to compete in women's elite swimming events.

Unquestioning affirmative care for children is coming under increasing scrutiny and I hope will be a thing of the past quite soon. There will be legal cases and devastating accounts of the damage done to children by this ideology before we fully appreciate the magnitude of the mistake which has been made.

I completely agree. This isn't about pushing for children to complete transition by 12 or earlier, it's saying that "X can only happen if Y happens - Y won't ever happen so therefore X won't take place".

The tide is turning in more way than one, and the Times articles about GIDS/the Tavistock this weekend more than highlight the problems that are coming down the track towards the affirmation model and the idea of handing over puberty blockers like sweeties.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 11:33

The problem with a third Open category is that women haven't got a chance so it's essentially a second opportunity for males only. Either the men's category has to become open or people need to choose between sex segregated OR open.

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 11:28

Thinking back to when my DC were about 10, the majority of the boys were already bigger and stronger than the girls of the same age. Definitely faster when it came to running. So maybe 12 isn't the correct age to use as a cut off.

Terfydactyl · 20/06/2022 11:24

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 09:54

Fina will also aim to establish an 'open' category at competitions for swimmers whose gender identity is different than their birth sex

I am genuinely curious about this. Will the Lia Thomas's of the world want to swim in a trans category? Swimming with other transwomen would surely take the advantage that they have over women away? If they are happy with this, then yes, we can agree, it's just about being allowed to compete in sport.

Fina will aim to establish.
If theres no one wanting to take part in an open category, then meh, no open category will last long.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/06/2022 11:17

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 11:14

Ah! Just gone back and checked and it restricts competing to before the age of 12! Phew!
Even so, the Ideology activists are very much encouraging puberty blockers and transitioning in primary schools. So it is still a very real risk.

That is a real concern and one I believe other countries are taking action on? I believe we need to take action to stop these things from happening. It should not be encouraged. I would really look down on anyone who encourages child transitioning, they're only children. It's too big a decision to make.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/06/2022 11:15

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 11:12

I understood that FINA have said that in order to compete against women, boys must have transitioned before the age of 12.

But they are not advocating for that to happen. That would mean they are arguing for them to transition before 12, they aren't, simply saying if someone has transitioned before that age, they could compete with females. They aren't advising them to transition at all.

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 11:14

Ah! Just gone back and checked and it restricts competing to before the age of 12! Phew!
Even so, the Ideology activists are very much encouraging puberty blockers and transitioning in primary schools. So it is still a very real risk.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 11:12

lifeturnsonadime · 20/06/2022 11:08

Just want to put a shout out to the wonderful Sharron Davies who has really stuck her neck out on this issue and has received the usual abuse for openly doing so.

All sporting bodies need to follow suit and as PP has said it needs to trickle down to regional, county and grass routes level otherwise chances to make it to elite level for girls are diminished.

I have a 13 year old daughter who represents her county at cricket. She is one of the stronger players on her county team. She plays on a mixed team at club level. Because of the physical differences between her and the boys on her team she is not the strongest player even though she is the only one who represents the county.

Allowing males on to female county teams removes opportunities for girls and ultimately women.

This nonsense must stop.

Yes yes. There will be significant differences even at 13, especially if she has started her periods and even if the boys are skinnier.

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 11:12

I understood that FINA have said that in order to compete against women, boys must have transitioned before the age of 12.

lifeturnsonadime · 20/06/2022 11:08

Just want to put a shout out to the wonderful Sharron Davies who has really stuck her neck out on this issue and has received the usual abuse for openly doing so.

All sporting bodies need to follow suit and as PP has said it needs to trickle down to regional, county and grass routes level otherwise chances to make it to elite level for girls are diminished.

I have a 13 year old daughter who represents her county at cricket. She is one of the stronger players on her county team. She plays on a mixed team at club level. Because of the physical differences between her and the boys on her team she is not the strongest player even though she is the only one who represents the county.

Allowing males on to female county teams removes opportunities for girls and ultimately women.

This nonsense must stop.

ApplesandBunions · 20/06/2022 11:07

And yet there are still people arguing for 'trans inclusion' in rugby, as if women are merely a support service for the validation of male-born people at any cost. As if women being killed or injured doesn't matter as long as male-bodied people feel included.

That is genuinely what they think. Those people are telling you who they are.

BordoisAgain · 20/06/2022 11:05

Given the pressure and abuses put on children in some sports, is it really that impossible to imagine that similar pressures won't/aren't being put on kids to transition?

If some countries sporting bodies aren't beyond doping and abusing the bodies of kids in one way then why is it difficult to believe they won't try it in another way? I mean who cares if their bodies start falling apart in 5 years if they've already managed to win medals now?

babyjellyfish · 20/06/2022 11:03

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 10:59

They may not be advocating puberty blockers/transition at 12 and under, but there will be those who use the new rule to lobby for it.

They are lobbying for it anyway though.

Brideandprejudice · 20/06/2022 11:01

I am so happy to hear this. Finally one small bit of of hope for women.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 10:59

They may not be advocating puberty blockers/transition at 12 and under, but there will be those who use the new rule to lobby for it.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/06/2022 10:55

Anybody who advocates doing this to children is not worthy of respect in a civilised society. How any sporting body can even suggest it is beyond me.

They aren't advocating it at all. If you took that from it, you're understanding it wrong. They are ensuring females will not have to compete against biological males. They are correct in their reasons for this policy change.

Swipe left for the next trending thread