Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
Eightiesfan · 20/06/2022 15:55

givethatWolfAbanana · 20/06/2022 07:38

It’s wonderful if all men’s category becomes an “open” to include trans athletes as well as certain women who like to compete in a tougher field (is that right that this is happening in the swimming ?)

thst way everyone can compete, without affecting women who want to compete against their own sex only.

trans athletes are not excluded from sport

everyone gets to compete in the fairest category

win win

That’s the irony of all of this the men’s category is already open and always has been. if an elite male athlete is trans they are not likely to transition until their career is over. However, it is the mediocre ones who can’t compete against men who transition and try to force their way into the women’s category.

SolasAnla · 20/06/2022 15:45

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 14:53

I'd like to hear how the science explains that someone who had been through make puberty will drown if they can't swim in a swimsuit like a woman 🤦🏼‍♀️🤣

The logic goes like this

The male will not be allowed to enter the female catagory in compeditive races.

Once the parent realises that their 4 year old will never make it to Olympic Gold , the parent will not allow the child to learn how to swim. (If the parent has other children they will all be taught to swim.)
The child will never learn and be at risk of drowning because the child will still jump into the swimming pool /river or sea.

This will be based on projecting from socioeconomic research of how young children from poor backgrounds are not taught via free school programmes as the area has no pool or whos parents cant afford to pay for private lesons or where there may be no cultural experiences of going swimming as a leisure activity.

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 15:41

MrsOvertonsWindow · 20/06/2022 13:36

Let's see what the hardline Misterhood say about it Grin Grin

.

🤣🤣🤣👏👏👏👏

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 15:40

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 12:35

But the point I am making is that some sporting bodies dgaf about the health and well-being of child athletes and will dope and drug kids just to see if it gives any perceived advantage.

We have just seen a pretty damning report about what was happening to children, mainly girls, in gymnastics, so can we hope that the "dgaf if medals are to be won " attitude, is also being called into question?

Same with ice skating. They have or are petitioning to raise the age level for elite ice skaters from 15 to 17.

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 15:39

FOJN · 20/06/2022 12:09

the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown

Bless their heart. Life must be really tough if you think the FINA policy excludes you from the local swimming pool.

I'm starting to feel a bit offended by how pathetically weak the arguments are.

Your posts however are strong and I couldn't agree more with everything you say.

babyjellyfish · 20/06/2022 15:35

And that I doubt whether there are any competitive swimmers who didn't learn to swim as small children.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 20/06/2022 15:28

Or is that trans people (who have not learned by then) will just refuse to learn to swim? They’ll be so disgusted by the transphobic stance of FINA (a body most people won’t have heard of) and refuse to learn to swim (as adults) and be more likely to drown?

Seems an unnecessary worry given that swimming is part of the primary school curriculum. And most people learn to swim as children.

Beowulfa · 20/06/2022 15:23

Wow, a sporting body actually prepared to stand up for women's sports. Fingers crossed others will now follow?

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 20/06/2022 15:18

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 14:53

I'd like to hear how the science explains that someone who had been through make puberty will drown if they can't swim in a swimsuit like a woman 🤦🏼‍♀️🤣

Maybe being entered into a category they don’t identify with literally causes them to forget how to swim. They’re so overwhelmed by it that they will drown.

Its like the hyperbolic arguments I’d have made as a teenager about how I would literally did if I had to wear or do whatever dreadful thing my parents expected me to.

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 15:15

On the swim.org website you still select the swimmers gender to get their rankings etc.

I hope that we start to see that chance to say sex soon. They need a consistent message.

itsgettingweird · 20/06/2022 14:53

CrossStichQueen · 20/06/2022 08:46

According to a Dr on twitter who apparently was a D1 swimmer and coach this decision will increase the drowning rates in transpeople!

I mean really? This is the level of desperation they will sink to in order to force their ridiculous ideology on the rest of the world.

I'd like to hear how the science explains that someone who had been through make puberty will drown if they can't swim in a swimsuit like a woman 🤦🏼‍♀️🤣

Glittertwins · 20/06/2022 14:03

endofthelinefinally · 20/06/2022 11:28

Thinking back to when my DC were about 10, the majority of the boys were already bigger and stronger than the girls of the same age. Definitely faster when it came to running. So maybe 12 isn't the correct age to use as a cut off.

Swimming county champs for 11 yr olds show that the girls are faster than the boys. Regional qual times are also faster for 11-12 girls than boys too.

British Swimming and Swim England framework also has girls moving up a stage at 12 as opposed to boys at 13 so I'd say FINA's use of age 12 fits this.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 20/06/2022 13:53

FOJN · 20/06/2022 12:09

the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown

Bless their heart. Life must be really tough if you think the FINA policy excludes you from the local swimming pool.

I'm starting to feel a bit offended by how pathetically weak the arguments are.

They’ll drown?

does not getting to compete in the category you want actually remove your ability to swim? 🤣

Did they change the swimwear rules at all? The FINA rules have specific regulations for male and female competitions, which would prevent a trans woman (from example) from competing in the male
category but wearing a skinsuit rather than jammers (or skimpy briefs). Letting swimmers wrestle themselves into skinsuits rather than jammers in the men’s category seems reasonable (if they’re so inclined). I would imagine FINA would need to consider whether the skinsuit wearers gained an unfair advantage (as in the full tech bodysuit debacle), but I guess they wouldn’t be preventing everyone from wearing one in the men’s category.

Swimsuits are likely to be more problematic because of coverage issues for people with male physiology. Sure, those little briefs are skimpy but they aren’t cut like swimsuits and actually hold the relevant parts in.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 20/06/2022 13:39

OnceMoreWithoutFeeling · 20/06/2022 10:32

Haven't read the full thread but is anyone else concerned that this ruling will up the pressure on young male swimmers with identity issues to take puberty blockers prematurely in order to avoid falling foul of it?

If you’ve seen what swimming looks like for 11 year olds with potential to be elite swimmers, you wouldn’t even be asking the question.

No child taking puberty blockers - with the serious effects they have on the body - is going to be dragging themselves to early morning training, then again in the evening multiple days a week, doing land training and pool training, travelling to competitions. Even if they did, they wouldn’t be able to compete with the other kids (of either sex) who aren’t on such serious medication.

It’s just not a realistic prospect. This is why TRAs are likely incensed by the ruling. It means that trans-identifying athletes will simply not be able to compete in the sex category they want to. The steps required to meet the criteria of not going through male puberty will rule out elite sport on performance grounds. No amount of tinkering around with testosterone levels or whatever can admit them entry to women’s competition after puberty. They just can’t have what they want.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 20/06/2022 13:36

Let's see what the hardline Misterhood say about it Grin Grin

.

VoiceaFromUranus · 20/06/2022 13:34

Excellent decision.

At one end you get trans athletes winning races simply because of their inbuilt male advantage. At the other, if any sport adopted a no questions asked trans approach, it would get abused. A little "T" for trans in the footnotes won't remove the gold medal next to the name and given the stakes, you just know it would get abused massively.

The Open category is a great idea. Let's see what the hardline Misterhood say about it.

I had been wondering when reading a previous thread just how big the differences could be and I looked at the 100m. The late great Florence Griffith Joyner broke the women's 100m record in 1988, a record which still stands. Her world record wouldn't even get her into the top 6,000 times in the male rankings...

Greeneyedminx · 20/06/2022 13:29

This is fantastic news for women, let’s hope every other sport starts copying this So that women can compete fairly with other women, not men who think they are now women.
Sharon Davies has put her head above the parapet in order to stop this and to draw attention to this. We’ll done Sharon and every other person who has fought for this.

Mascia · 20/06/2022 13:23

borntobequiet · 20/06/2022 10:18

That transwoman MMA fighter was interviewed on the Today programme (I think it was they) this morning, saying that transitioned males have no advantages. I have to say I was a bit gobsmacked.

I remember seeing a similar comment (no advantages after transition) somewhere couple of years ago, when the whole TWAW movement has started gathering momentum.

Since it became apparent that transwomen do have certain physical advantages against women (like in the case of Lia Thomas), the narrative seems to have shifted towards: "Well, some women are just taller/bigger/stronger than others".

After Lia Thomas' victory I've seen a comment somewhere saying that the actual issue was that we as a society expect women to always be slim and delicate. Apparently, that was the real reason some people were objecting the likes of Lia competing against women.

Such a weird arguemt in my opinion - surely depending on the sport we're used to seeing female athletes of different shapes and sizes? The biological women competing against Laurel Hubbard weren't delicate and dainty and yet nobody would expect them to.
The fact that biological women can be tall/ strong/ have broad shoulders doesn't mean that biologically male people are women too.

xogossipgirlxo · 20/06/2022 12:39

Faith in common sense restored. Yay.

Peregrina · 20/06/2022 12:35

But the point I am making is that some sporting bodies dgaf about the health and well-being of child athletes and will dope and drug kids just to see if it gives any perceived advantage.

We have just seen a pretty damning report about what was happening to children, mainly girls, in gymnastics, so can we hope that the "dgaf if medals are to be won " attitude, is also being called into question?

Mascia · 20/06/2022 12:20

Guiltycat · 20/06/2022 06:44

The overuse of ‘transphobia’ as an empty attempt at shutting down discussion is what suddenly woke me up out of my ‘just be kind, it’s no big deal’ sleepwalk like attitude to this madness.

It became increasingly clear that those who pulled the pin in that particular grenade and lobbed it at anyone who disagreed with them, NEVER actually stated their case or attempt to engage in discussion that isn’t them screeching ‘burn the witch!’. They just expect that word to say it all, because they have nothing else to say.

That was the case for me too. I was supportive of trans people as part of the wider LGBT+ group and when J. K. Rowling got attacked for her comments, I was really surprised why a woman who always struck me as caring and wise would be openly hostile towards a marginalised group.
I read her essay and realised she wasn't being hostile at all, just raising legitimate questions and cocerns about woman's rights. Labelling these questions as transphobic is just an easy way to shut up women.

FOJN · 20/06/2022 12:09

the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown

Bless their heart. Life must be really tough if you think the FINA policy excludes you from the local swimming pool.

I'm starting to feel a bit offended by how pathetically weak the arguments are.

SidewaysOtter · 20/06/2022 12:09

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 11:56

the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown

What's the reasoning behind that?

You're assuming that reason and logic come into it. They don't have a rational argument - and they know it - so all they've got left are loose accusations of "literal violence", "transphobia" and so on in the hope that if you fling enough mud some of it will stick.

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 12:08

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 20/06/2022 12:01

Honestly, I haven't a scooby doo. Batshittery perhaps? This is from someone who has Dr in their twitter name and in the same tweet says they are a former D1 swimmer (don't know what that is) and coach. Claims it will discourage people from learning to swim, hence the drowning.

But putting males in women's swimming won't discourage women from swimming, obviously.

Sorry, I know you didn't say it.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 20/06/2022 12:01

ReneBumsWombats · 20/06/2022 11:56

the latest take on batshit twitter being that FINA decision will mean trans people will drown

What's the reasoning behind that?

Honestly, I haven't a scooby doo. Batshittery perhaps? This is from someone who has Dr in their twitter name and in the same tweet says they are a former D1 swimmer (don't know what that is) and coach. Claims it will discourage people from learning to swim, hence the drowning.

Swipe left for the next trending thread