Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
Peregrina · 22/06/2022 18:49

When did people forget that you can't have everything you want in life?

When did TWs forget that a majority of men are actually good sports? The sort of man who didn't make it to the World Swimming/Cycling/Golf/Football etc. championships, but accepted that they are not quite good enough, get on with their lives and still enjoy their sport at the level they are comfortable with. Not whining why they can't compete against women.

babyjellyfish · 22/06/2022 16:32

ApplesandBunions · 22/06/2022 16:10

I can make my peace with it.

Me too. The reality is that no one will be interested in watching it.

itsgettingweird · 22/06/2022 16:20

GoodThinkingMax · 22/06/2022 11:27

Again to quote Simon Fanshawe: "I cannot accept that they are women. They are transwomen and I respect them for that."

Absolutely!

Very simple and clear.

I don't see how others cannot see that.

Eightiesfan · 22/06/2022 16:15

334bu · 22/06/2022 12:43

Megan Rapinhoe might sincerely believe that including male football players in female teams is fair but I doubt she would feel the same, if she had lost her place in the World Cup team and all the prestige and money that followed from it, to a probably quite mediocre male football player or maybe even her under 15 counterpart in the schoolboy team which thumped the USA'S Female World Cup winning team.

FIFA, better be quick, at te last count Iran was fielding a team where seven of the women had/have a penis.

ApplesandBunions · 22/06/2022 16:10

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 22/06/2022 15:14

I feel exactly the same. More opportunities for males, yay 😒

But if it means males stay the hell out of the women's, and can't moan about not being included, it'll have to do.

Maybe an open category with a testosterone limit, seeing as they seem to think that's some sort of all important magic key into female categories! It can keep the non medicalised males out instead.

Ok, it might not be a category with a lot of entrants, but then it's more chance of winning, and they like winning, so what's not to love?

I can make my peace with it.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 22/06/2022 15:59

tttigress · 19/06/2022 23:12

There should be a female class, and an "open" class for everyone else who wants to participate. The open class would be mainly men, but trans and even women could go in the open class.

I have long thought this might be a good solution, thinking about things like athletics rather than contact sports.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 22/06/2022 15:14

ReneBumsWombats · 22/06/2022 12:58

A third "Open" space will effectively be another men's competition. No female born person will have a chance. Two shots for men, one for women.

However, I'd be prepared to accept it (with gritted teeth) if it meant keeping the women's sports protected and stops it from being the "hobbled/middle aged/crap men" category.

I feel exactly the same. More opportunities for males, yay 😒

But if it means males stay the hell out of the women's, and can't moan about not being included, it'll have to do.

Maybe an open category with a testosterone limit, seeing as they seem to think that's some sort of all important magic key into female categories! It can keep the non medicalised males out instead.

Ok, it might not be a category with a lot of entrants, but then it's more chance of winning, and they like winning, so what's not to love?

ReneBumsWombats · 22/06/2022 13:43

GCMM · 22/06/2022 13:16

When did people forget that you can't have everything you want in life? If transitioning is so important, then you have to accept that some doors may now be closed to you. If you're lucky, new opportunities may be available. That's just the way it is. You can't have everything - get over it.

I find that male people find it harder to understand this (yes, I'm generalising). They haven't lived with the knowledge of sharp limits on things like their fertility, their likely odds in a fight or race with members of the opposite sex and the impact of a baby on their body and subsequent career. To find out that there may be restrictions imposed upon them by their biology is very, very, very difficult for some of them to accept. They've never faced it before.

That's why women who try to state that TWAW like to use a "be kind, be wonderfully inclusive and progressive like me" approach, while men who do it usually show offence and quite astonishing ignorance at the idea that they couldn't become women if they wanted to.

They'll often claim, in essence, that women are just hobbled versions of them, or with added interior incubators that have no significant effect on the rest of their biology. They can't understand that gestation and delivery are complex processes that require extensive physiological differences and they frequently forget about periods altogether. The women know this is bollocks, so to speak, but their Cinderella complex makes them think there's some reward or inherent goodness in pretending it doesn't matter.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 22/06/2022 13:37

ReneBumsWombats · 22/06/2022 12:58

A third "Open" space will effectively be another men's competition. No female born person will have a chance. Two shots for men, one for women.

However, I'd be prepared to accept it (with gritted teeth) if it meant keeping the women's sports protected and stops it from being the "hobbled/middle aged/crap men" category.

I suspect Open will be extremely unpopular or devalued as a category, but it’s sensible to have it.

it’ll effectively function as (and be perceived as) a second tier men’s category. One where anyone can have a go, but everyone knows the real prestige is in the Mens category.

The risk is it becomes a place for people who didn’t quite qualify for the Mens to access competitions anyway. If adopted at grassroots level, Open may end up full of men and boys who are just short of a qualifying time and need a chance to swim
at a particular level to try to get one, or to go to the (for example) nationals when them missed the QT for the mens. So a less prestigious men division 2 category. But where you might find yourself swimming against the odd woman or transperson.

I expect it will turn out to be quite hard to set QTs for the Open category.

And it’s likely that many trans women don’t want to swim in Open anyway. Or Mens. They want their identity validated (and the biological advantage) to be gained from being in the Women category.

GCMM · 22/06/2022 13:16

When did people forget that you can't have everything you want in life? If transitioning is so important, then you have to accept that some doors may now be closed to you. If you're lucky, new opportunities may be available. That's just the way it is. You can't have everything - get over it.

ReneBumsWombats · 22/06/2022 12:58

A third "Open" space will effectively be another men's competition. No female born person will have a chance. Two shots for men, one for women.

However, I'd be prepared to accept it (with gritted teeth) if it meant keeping the women's sports protected and stops it from being the "hobbled/middle aged/crap men" category.

334bu · 22/06/2022 12:44

Under 15 boy counterpart

334bu · 22/06/2022 12:43

Megan Rapinhoe might sincerely believe that including male football players in female teams is fair but I doubt she would feel the same, if she had lost her place in the World Cup team and all the prestige and money that followed from it, to a probably quite mediocre male football player or maybe even her under 15 counterpart in the schoolboy team which thumped the USA'S Female World Cup winning team.

babyjellyfish · 22/06/2022 12:38

SoupDragon · 22/06/2022 12:21

Well, it can't be easy being either a trans man or trans woman. All people should be treated with respect though (with a few exceptions, obviously!) including those who wish to live as the opposite sex.

It's not easy being a woman.

And our feelings most certainly aren't pandered to the way trans women's are.

I agree that all people should be treated with respect, but trans people aren't entitled to any more respect than anyone else in my opinion.

Peregrina · 22/06/2022 12:38

I also wonder why FINA want a third category of competition when surely "Female" and "Open" are the only two that are necessary ie. scrap the men's category.

Got to pander to the men but hides the fact that the situation now is effectively Open and Male.

GoodThinkingMax · 22/06/2022 12:28

I also wonder why FINA want a third category of competition when surely "Female" and "Open" are the only two that are necessary ie. scrap the men's category.

There’s the rub - men must be named and centred. The “Open” category others men, and merges them as part of the “not-women” category.

It’s inconceivable (to men) that they would not be named. How dare we suggest they be “othered” ?

</sarcasm font off.

Peregrina · 22/06/2022 12:24

Let's hope this is the end of "transwomen are women. No debate"

Absolutely, and there are going to be some very prominent people who insisted that TWAW who look very stupid indeed.

I don't suppose any of those who issued rape and death threats to JKR and the like are going to be offering up apologies any time soon though.

SoupDragon · 22/06/2022 12:21

babyjellyfish · 22/06/2022 11:55

Why is being a trans woman worthy of respect?

More so than being any other type of human, I mean.

Well, it can't be easy being either a trans man or trans woman. All people should be treated with respect though (with a few exceptions, obviously!) including those who wish to live as the opposite sex.

SolasAnla · 22/06/2022 12:18

babyjellyfish · 22/06/2022 11:55

Why is being a trans woman worthy of respect?

More so than being any other type of human, I mean.

Social status

Men steping down, and reducing their social status.

"extremely impressive or attractive"
And
"endure or face (unpleasant conditions or behaviour) without showing fear"

ReneBumsWombats · 22/06/2022 12:15

I didn't take it to mean that he thought they deserved more respect than other people. I took it to mean that he acknowledged their gender identities and was supportive of them expressing it and being themselves, but he couldn't accept that they "are" women, because they're not. They're transwomen.

babyjellyfish · 22/06/2022 11:55

Why is being a trans woman worthy of respect?

More so than being any other type of human, I mean.

GoodThinkingMax · 22/06/2022 11:27

Again to quote Simon Fanshawe: "I cannot accept that they are women. They are transwomen and I respect them for that."

Absolutely!

ReneBumsWombats · 22/06/2022 11:19

GoodThinkingMax · 22/06/2022 10:53

Let's hope this is the end of "transwomen are women. No debate"

Again to quote Simon Fanshawe: "I cannot accept that they are women. They are transwomen and I respect them for that."

GoodThinkingMax · 22/06/2022 10:53

Let's hope this is the end of "transwomen are women. No debate"

babyjellyfish · 22/06/2022 10:43

CherryReid · 22/06/2022 05:46

It's a bit annoying that all the announcement makers and decision makers seem to be men. and that it's taken them this long to state the bleeding obvious

Yep.

It's only not transphobic when a person with a penis says it.