Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:19

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:12

there’s nothing I can realistically do to change any of your behaviour. Other than put together excellent arguments and hit ‘post’!

So why haven't you?

Admit it @ReneBumsWombats , you’ve grown fond of me during this discussion! 😊

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:17

So @stolen, why do you believe transwomen are women? If we are ‘anti-trans’ for not believing that, why don’t you do one of your excellent posts to show us why TWAW.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:16

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:12

I never said I knew better! Just expressing an opinion, same as everyone else. I guess everyone believes what they say to be true and sensible?

And I also never said I don’t need to be educated. I’ve welcomed knowing that a certain subsection of feminists find ‘cis’ offensive. That was new information for me! And as much as people have been completely infuriated by my posts, it’s not really been my intention to offend people. If a woman tells me not to refer to her as ‘cis’ then I shan’t. I take no pleasure in mislabelling anyone!

I'm starting to think you can't be for real. You had whole posts about how you thought we needed to be tone policed and you were totally the heroine to do it. They're right there. And your "excellent arguments" have been nothing but offensive and ignorant false equivalences, cries of transphobia when people state facts and demands to respect a penis in a women's space.

It's truly embarrassing. I would be worried if I thought you actually believed you'd made "excellent arguments" but you clearly know you haven't. Who do you think you're fooling?

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:16

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:12

And I’ve not realised till just this very evening how anti trans Mumsnet actually is

mumsnet isnt anti trans

there are undoubtedly anti trans posters on mumsnet and homophobic ones and racist one but their existence doesn’t make the site anything but an online forum

Sure, I get that, but I would have thought someone somewhere would agree with me on this topic and literally no one has.

It feels pretty anti trans around here! If I were trans I’m not sure ‘welcomed’ would be the feeling I’d have here…

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:15

If @stolen wants to see racism I recommend TRA Twitter, where they try to prove that transwomen are women because black women are women. It’s a definite eye opener for sure.

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:14

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 22:11

And there it is. You post nothing approaching a decent argument, and then just go for the insults.

Let’s drop the pretence sonny, everyone can see what you are.

Hang on though. Someone up thread literally said they come to Mumsnet to get away from the ‘trans women are women’ nonsense.

Calling that website ‘anti trans’ feels like a fact rather than an insult.. do you really disagree?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:12

And I’ve not realised till just this very evening how anti trans Mumsnet actually is

mumsnet isnt anti trans

there are undoubtedly anti trans posters on mumsnet and homophobic ones and racist one but their existence doesn’t make the site anything but an online forum

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:12

there’s nothing I can realistically do to change any of your behaviour. Other than put together excellent arguments and hit ‘post’!

So why haven't you?

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:12

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:06

I'm actually going to put the sarcasm aside for a moment.

You came on here telling us we needed you to police our language because you knew better. And yet you didn't know that many women consider "cis" to be offensive, or what I was referring to when I mentioned Thomas' knob in the women's changing room. You also appear to think that "knob" is equivalent to racist or sexist slurs.

Perhaps it is not we who need further educating.

I never said I knew better! Just expressing an opinion, same as everyone else. I guess everyone believes what they say to be true and sensible?

And I also never said I don’t need to be educated. I’ve welcomed knowing that a certain subsection of feminists find ‘cis’ offensive. That was new information for me! And as much as people have been completely infuriated by my posts, it’s not really been my intention to offend people. If a woman tells me not to refer to her as ‘cis’ then I shan’t. I take no pleasure in mislabelling anyone!

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 22:11

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:04

And I’ve not realised till just this very evening how anti trans Mumsnet actually is. I’ve had my eyes truly opened!

And there it is. You post nothing approaching a decent argument, and then just go for the insults.

Let’s drop the pretence sonny, everyone can see what you are.

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:10

See the days when you could get women to shut up by shouting" transphobic" or " terf" are fast fading. We don't care any more. Happy to be called that.

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:10

@StolenCookie gor away from you as fast as I could. I don’t engage with misogynistic idiots in real life.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:10

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:04

And I’ve not realised till just this very evening how anti trans Mumsnet actually is. I’ve had my eyes truly opened!

Except that you're hung up on precisely two comments in a long thread, one of which was merely acknowledging the fact of women being forced to endure a knob in their changing room.

While you're feeling so enlightened, may I suggest you now cast your pearls among TRA Twitter?

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 22:09

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:03

Absolutely no one needs to give a damn what I think. We’re all just on the internet to discuss things aren’t we? As much as I’ve disliked the tone here, there’s nothing I can realistically do to change any of your behaviour. Other than put together excellent arguments and hit ‘post’!

Why don’t you give that a try then, rather than just telling people that they are transphobic?

Why not start by clarifying what you mean by “woman”? Your posts suggest you don’t have a bloody clue what the word means.

Or will you just dodge the question?

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:09

Me too @CaliforniaDrumming I’ve been called a TERF and transphobe so often it holds no meaning now. When weather, biology, and trees are transphobic, and transphobe means acknowledging reality, yeah I’m a transphobe.

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:08

Peregrina · 23/06/2022 21:57

Laddy in reference to a trans woman is transphobic.

It may be in your book, but it isn't in mine. A Transwoman is not a woman. Even if he has surgery and takes hormones to suppress his testosterone, he is still not a woman. Most of them don't have surgery.

And I think this is the crux of the whole of the last few mad pages. I consider certain language to be transphobic, the rest of you don’t. I don’t see why there needed to be such fury over this but I guess being on the internet does bring out the rage! I wonder what any of you would have done if you’d met someone like me in the pub 😂

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 22:07

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 21:52

Laddy for a man is patronising.

Laddy in reference to a trans woman is transphobic.

Are you claiming here that a trans woman is a woman? It certainly reads that way.

What definition of “woman are you using”?

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:06

Netmums might suit you. There are a lot of " Be Kind" 'cis' women there.

If believing that transwomen are transwomen is transphobic, I am happy to be so.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:06

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 21:58

I haven’t intended to scold, just expressing a view. If anyone has been scolded I think we can safely say it is me! I’ve been called a penis up thread! 😂 I can be a feminist and also stand up for the rights of trans people. And no one has been forced to reply to me! If you wanted to spend your evenings doing something else you really should have!

I'm actually going to put the sarcasm aside for a moment.

You came on here telling us we needed you to police our language because you knew better. And yet you didn't know that many women consider "cis" to be offensive, or what I was referring to when I mentioned Thomas' knob in the women's changing room. You also appear to think that "knob" is equivalent to racist or sexist slurs.

Perhaps it is not we who need further educating.

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:05

Well when you’ve put together an excellent argument do press post. They do say if at first you don’t succeed…..

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:04

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:01

"Cis women". I come on MN to get away from that nonsense. It is literally the only place where most posters are not drinking the " Transwomen are women" Kool-Aid.

And I’ve not realised till just this very evening how anti trans Mumsnet actually is. I’ve had my eyes truly opened!

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:03

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 21:57

Why should anyone give a damn what you think, or moderate their behaviour because of it?

You do not want women to use accurate language to describe a male abusing women. You seem like someone who’d tell a rapist to refer to her attacker as “she” and call them transphobic if they didn’t. Don’t you dare try to police my tone.

Absolutely no one needs to give a damn what I think. We’re all just on the internet to discuss things aren’t we? As much as I’ve disliked the tone here, there’s nothing I can realistically do to change any of your behaviour. Other than put together excellent arguments and hit ‘post’!

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:01

"Cis women". I come on MN to get away from that nonsense. It is literally the only place where most posters are not drinking the " Transwomen are women" Kool-Aid.

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 21:58

I haven’t intended to scold, just expressing a view. If anyone has been scolded I think we can safely say it is me! I’ve been called a penis up thread! 😂 I can be a feminist and also stand up for the rights of trans people. And no one has been forced to reply to me! If you wanted to spend your evenings doing something else you really should have!

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 21:58

To be fair, I call Lia detransitioning as soon as Lia graduates college. I think Lia was about to lose scholarship due to the abysmal performance in the men’s races, and this was a way to keep the scholarship, abuse women and become a member of a ‘vulnerable and oppressed’ group. I see Emily Bridges going the sane way