Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 22:40

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:24

I believe people can identify how they wish.

You all told me you are most definitely not ‘cis women’, you are women - so that is what I shall refer to you as tonight in my diary! I will write about how I made a lot of new women friends on the internet tonight 😀

And if a trans person says they are a woman, I believe they are a woman and will respect them as such. And if they expose their penis to me in a changing room I will report them to the police, whilst still retaining my respect for the trans community as a whole and not calling them a “laddy”!

Do you also believe that Rachel Dolezal is black?

If not, why the double standards?

FemmeNatal · 23/06/2022 22:38

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:14

Hang on though. Someone up thread literally said they come to Mumsnet to get away from the ‘trans women are women’ nonsense.

Calling that website ‘anti trans’ feels like a fact rather than an insult.. do you really disagree?

You are saying it’s transphobic to disagree that “TWAW”?

Again, you must be using a very strange definition of “women” to feel that.

What do you mean by “woman”?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:38

if a trans person says they are a woman, I believe they are a woman and will respect them as such. And if they expose their penis to me in a changing room I will report them to the police,

Why would you report a woman getting undressed in a women's changing room?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:37

I would never refer to a trans person as ‘getting their knob out’. It makes me cringe, it sounds transphobic and derogatory. That was really all I was expressing!

and this is part of the problem

that person was wandering round the changing room with an erection

its fair to comment on that, saying that is not transphobic or derogatory its a fact…and to be fair thomas obviously has no issue whatsoever in doing that

most men i know would be mortified if they had an erection at the wrong place or time, they would go to great lengths not to show it…not thomas though and i think that says something

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:37

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:27

And if a trans person says they are a woman, I believe they are a woman

Well, I say I am Ming the Merciless. Also that we are all right in this ridiculous "discussion" and you don't know how being a woman works.

So what do you believe now?

I believe that Ming the Merciless has truly lived up to her name.

I am a pregnant 34 year old woman and I don’t know how being a woman works?

You hurt me Ming! 😟

Peregrina · 23/06/2022 22:36

I don’t see why there needed to be such fury over this but I guess being on the internet does bring out the rage! I wonder what any of you would have done if you’d met someone like me in the pub

If you were a sportswoman who had lost a medal place and possibly a scholarship to a 'Woman' who used to compete as a man, it would be surprising if you weren't furious. Particularly if you were one of the women who had to share a dressing room with Lia Thomas, but weren't allowed to speak out because of the cry of transphobe.

What if we met you in the pub. I think we would find as now, that your arguments don't stand up so you resort to 'transphobe' and 'cis'.

If you personally think that transwomen are women it's up to you, but I don't - biological sex i.e. male or female is what matters.

Like a poster a few threads back, I think that once the sporting bodies start to take a proper stance and say that those who went through male puberty cannot enter women's sport, then yes, a good few men will decide that they won't be following Emily Bridges or Lia Thomas.

FOJN · 23/06/2022 22:35

And I’ve not realised till just this very evening how anti trans Mumsnet actually is. I’ve had my eyes truly opened!

I think you might mean pro women. Intersectional feminists often find it quite jarring when they encounter the type of feminists who prioritise the needs and concerns of women.

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:35

But @stolen. What if it was a transman that we’d said was getting his knob out. Would that be transphobic or gender affirming?

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:35

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:33

You could be right! I may have misunderstood. As much as people want me to be some rabid troll, I’m really not. But personally, in a discussion around trans issues, I would never refer to a trans person as ‘getting their knob out’. It makes me cringe, it sounds transphobic and derogatory. That was really all I was expressing!

Yes yes, your complaint about not showing due respect to a knob being got out in a women's changing room and causing much distress has been noted and given all due respect.

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:33

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:26

Personally stolen i think you misunderstood the ‘penis’ comment but aren’t able to back down from your stance

just my opinion in an ‘everybody has one’ kinda way

You could be right! I may have misunderstood. As much as people want me to be some rabid troll, I’m really not. But personally, in a discussion around trans issues, I would never refer to a trans person as ‘getting their knob out’. It makes me cringe, it sounds transphobic and derogatory. That was really all I was expressing!

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:33

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:28

Yes I agree I think things got quite derailed with ‘knob gate’. But interestingly very few people (I think only one actually) acknowledged the ‘laddy’ comment as being questionable. I still don’t see how a group of people who identify as not anti trans can stand by a comment referring to a trans person as laddy!

Well I don't see how a self-confessed intersectional feminist can equate "knob" with the N word or "bint". Or believe a male person is a woman while denying that person access to a women's changing room. Or complain about not showing respect to a knob in a women's changing room. Or ignore the questions asked about Muslim women who cannot undress in the presence of males. Or complain about disrespectful language on here while ignoring the landslide of misogynistic abuse I linked to just before.

Guess we're both going to have to live with confusion.

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:30

@StolenCookie because we are grown ups. We don’t language police people.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:29

I would have thought someone somewhere would agree with me on this topic and literally no one has.

That's because you are wrong. You're wrong about what a woman is, you're wrong about the word knob and you're wrong about what's funny.

But if an intact male person claims to be a woman and you therefore believe that, why can't that person use the women's changing room?

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:28

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:24

Sure, I get that, but I would have thought someone somewhere would agree with me on this topic and literally no one has

to be very fair it was your comment regarding knobs (god i hate writing that 😀) that people are particularly commenting on

if you’d just have said that you found the laddy comment transphobic/disrespectful you may have slightly less comments

Yes I agree I think things got quite derailed with ‘knob gate’. But interestingly very few people (I think only one actually) acknowledged the ‘laddy’ comment as being questionable. I still don’t see how a group of people who identify as not anti trans can stand by a comment referring to a trans person as laddy!

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:27

Beginning to believe you are a troll sent to check out transphobic MN @StolenCookie. Do you think transwomen should be allowed in female toilets and changing rooms? Never mind Mr Thomas.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:27

And if a trans person says they are a woman, I believe they are a woman

Well, I say I am Ming the Merciless. Also that we are all right in this ridiculous "discussion" and you don't know how being a woman works.

So what do you believe now?

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:26

@stolen. Why would you phone the police about a woman getting changed in the women’s changing rooms? You realise you would not have a leg to stand on. You are the person wanting mixed sex changing rooms so you can’t complain if you see a penis in there can you?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:26

Personally stolen i think you misunderstood the ‘penis’ comment but aren’t able to back down from your stance

just my opinion in an ‘everybody has one’ kinda way

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:25

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:22

You can believe that TW are not women while still not being anti-trans. Just like you can believe that cats are not dogs while not being anti-cat.

To make it simple, I believe that TW can dress however they want, call themselves by any pronouns or names ( which I will use for them), be treated equally in the workplace and so on. But they must be kept out of women's sports, safe spaces, quotas, awards and anything meant for women. I think that is as clear as I can make it.

Honestly, if your final paragraph were the ‘tone’ of this whole discussion I never would have piped up in the first place, and you all would have had a much less aggravating evening!

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:24

Total agreement @CaliforniaDrumming and me expressing that view got me called a TERF.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/06/2022 22:24

Sure, I get that, but I would have thought someone somewhere would agree with me on this topic and literally no one has

to be very fair it was your comment regarding knobs (god i hate writing that 😀) that people are particularly commenting on

if you’d just have said that you found the laddy comment transphobic/disrespectful you may have slightly less comments

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:24

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:17

So @stolen, why do you believe transwomen are women? If we are ‘anti-trans’ for not believing that, why don’t you do one of your excellent posts to show us why TWAW.

I believe people can identify how they wish.

You all told me you are most definitely not ‘cis women’, you are women - so that is what I shall refer to you as tonight in my diary! I will write about how I made a lot of new women friends on the internet tonight 😀

And if a trans person says they are a woman, I believe they are a woman and will respect them as such. And if they expose their penis to me in a changing room I will report them to the police, whilst still retaining my respect for the trans community as a whole and not calling them a “laddy”!

CaliforniaDrumming · 23/06/2022 22:22

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:14

Hang on though. Someone up thread literally said they come to Mumsnet to get away from the ‘trans women are women’ nonsense.

Calling that website ‘anti trans’ feels like a fact rather than an insult.. do you really disagree?

You can believe that TW are not women while still not being anti-trans. Just like you can believe that cats are not dogs while not being anti-cat.

To make it simple, I believe that TW can dress however they want, call themselves by any pronouns or names ( which I will use for them), be treated equally in the workplace and so on. But they must be kept out of women's sports, safe spaces, quotas, awards and anything meant for women. I think that is as clear as I can make it.

Conflictedunicorn · 23/06/2022 22:21

I saw in another thread that sport might be the turning point in all this nonsense. For example, if a TW is not considered a woman for sporting purposes, where would they be considered a woman? With this and the the fact people seem to be waking up to this madness, I think we may see a return to sanity.

ReneBumsWombats · 23/06/2022 22:19

StolenCookie · 23/06/2022 22:19

Admit it @ReneBumsWombats , you’ve grown fond of me during this discussion! 😊

Is this all you've got now? At least make it funny.

Swipe left for the next trending thread