Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be relieved the world is starting to see some sense?

782 replies

portugalq · 19/06/2022 18:26

Fina bars transgender swimmers from women's elite events if they went through male puberty www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/61853450

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReneBumsWombats · 25/06/2022 16:55

MeredithTinkleberry · 25/06/2022 14:19

what you believe women and trans women have in common, if it is not a shared identity?

Some trans women are seen as and treated as women by those around them.
I know a born woman lesbian who has often been read as male, an experience she doesn’t have in common with most women.

No, but she isn't male. If she is perceived as male, she might escape some of the female socialisation crap, but only as long as she is not recognised as female. If she is, she'll get crap for being gender non conforming in a way a man wouldn't be. Being female will be relevant.

How she presents and appears will also make no difference in issues such as abortion bans and maternity rights in the workplace.

Even if she came out as a transman and fully transitioned, she would still need to take hormones, with associated health risks for her female body, and have major surgeries with all the accompanying risks and side effects. Not something any non-transitioning man has to endure.

She's female and it's going to shape her life and impact her choices and experiences. How she identifies won't change that fact.

babyjellyfish · 25/06/2022 15:11

MeredithTinkleberry · 25/06/2022 14:19

what you believe women and trans women have in common, if it is not a shared identity?

Some trans women are seen as and treated as women by those around them.
I know a born woman lesbian who has often been read as male, an experience she doesn’t have in common with most women.

Eesh. Quite a lot to unpick there.

  1. What does being treated like a woman mean? In situations where someone's sex isn't directly relevant, e.g. abortion rights, why would we treat men and women differently? That seems pretty sexist to me.
  2. If women are treated differently to men in situations where sex isn't relevant, women are invariably treated worse than men. But trans women are only treated differently to men because they choose to present themselves as women. Women don't choose to be treated worse than men and we can't self ID our way out of it.
  3. Trans women aren't actually treated like women. That's because the world is divided into people who don't acknowledge them as women, and people who do acknowledge them as women. But those who do acknowledge them as women tend to treat them better than they actually treat women. See how Lia Thomas is treated compared to the female swimmers, for example. Yes, ironically, the people who insist the most fervently that trans women are women actually treat trans women with...male privilege.
MeredithTinkleberry · 25/06/2022 14:19

what you believe women and trans women have in common, if it is not a shared identity?

Some trans women are seen as and treated as women by those around them.
I know a born woman lesbian who has often been read as male, an experience she doesn’t have in common with most women.

VestofAbsurdity · 25/06/2022 14:07

To add to my previous post, once you've made the word for half the population of the World utterly meaningless it is a piece of piss to remove their rights or for them to have anything purely for themselves as recent and immediate events show.

SolasAnla · 25/06/2022 13:39

334bu · 24/06/2022 17:00

The opening list of don't at me's demonstrates the worry writers have when publishing opinions on this.

Have I picked up a point incorrectly: is Australia issuing birth certs with "intersex" rather than female or male?

I noted the language creep from TW to female. Generally by swapping between M2F and F, it leads to reader confusion as the casual reader will read a female excluded form the Female races.

This thread also has a simple repeditive example of using people to hide from using the word man/male. If anyone is unsure of why the attack on language is so important reading the article and replace the various options used with man or woman.

The gloss over:
female swimmers are automatically excluded from female races when they are medicating (doping) as T provides compeditive advantage.

female swimmers are only allowed to dope to a limited degree when opting into the male races. This limit is on health grounds.

VestofAbsurdity · 25/06/2022 13:36

Woman is "anyone who says they are a woman" is a tired old circular trope.
It is utterly meaningless.

Add dehumanising and fucking offensive to that as well.

BoredofthisCrap7 · 25/06/2022 13:30

"It’s a personal identity. There aren’t any defining criteria."

So a man is entitled to walk into a hospital with lower abdominal pain and ask for a scan to check for ovarian cysts? For endometriosis? Can he book a smear test with his local nurse? Should he join his local breastfeeding group? Can he book an antenatal scan if he thinks he's pregnant?

Of course "woman" is not a personal identity.
It is a LIVED REALITY based on your biology.

If the man in question would be wasting everyone's time and resources by doing any of the above, why would that be?
What is it about them that means they will never NEED any of the above?
The defining criteria is obviously a biological one.

Woman is "anyone who says they are a woman" is a tired old circular trope.
It is utterly meaningless.

babyjellyfish · 25/06/2022 13:11

334bu · 25/06/2022 12:21

You forgot the racist trope
Excluding transwomen is just like excluding black women.

Yep. Ridiculous and racist.

I am white.

I have something in common with all black women. They are female, like me.

What do I have in common with trans women?

334bu · 25/06/2022 12:21

You forgot the racist trope
Excluding transwomen is just like excluding black women.

VestofAbsurdity · 25/06/2022 12:01

CaliforniaDrumming · 24/06/2022 15:45

Yes they are no more likely to be predators. But as with other men I won't know until is too late.

And when it is too late our ardent feminist Cookie will just expect you to take one for the team as they expect those being forced to change alongside Lia to do and it will be justified with one or more of the following phrases:

If men want to rape/sexually assault you they will anyway

What about the fact you share spaces with lesbians

Meaning - women have no right to safety, privacy and dignity ever because the feelings of men are paramount and let's just shoehorn lesbians in there because OMG they are sexually attracted to women -misogyny and homophobia all wrapped up in a nice neat bundle.

WellThatSeemsFair · 24/06/2022 23:38

Oh my goodness. What have I just read folks?!?! 😂😂😂*

Zero chance this is not a fella.

A few weeks off giving birth, in this heat, yet jovially engaging in endless back and forth with randoms on the Internet. So sprightly and always delivered with a sense of humour 😍🥰😍

My arse.

Have you ever actually encountered a heavily pregnant woman in the summer heat?

Again. My arse. Nice try though.

*excessive use of emojis and punctuation to prove I am definitely a woman.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 18:20

And they took verbal evidence from the study authors as well. It's all out there. But what do we expect from someone who can't enter "lia thomas changing room" into Google, or read the articles when given a link? And then just states they don't believe the story when they can't avoid it any more?

What does that prove? That evidence is useless for agenda-driven, wilfully ignorant, obtuse people who want knobs out in female spaces?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 18:13

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 18:08

They didn’t do anything with it did they…

They decided not to introduce self ID and reform the Gender Recognition Act along the lines of your moronic, intellectually dishonest and lazy, logically absurd, pro sex offending insanity. Because the evidence was clear that it was dangerous.

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 18:08

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 17:15

If you start engaging in good faith and answering the questions I asked you you can come back and ask that again.

They didn’t do anything with it did they…

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 24/06/2022 18:02

@StolenCookie What is the difference between a trans woman and a violent non trans man saying he is trans in order to enter what should be a women only space? How can we tell the difference? How can we let one in and keep the other out? It is possible to have grave and serious concerns about the repercussions of opening female spaces to non females without thinking all trans women are dangerous. It's possible to be distressed and triggered by seeing a penis without said penis being used to commit an assault (indeed it is possible to be triggered by the presence of a male body in what should be a female space without so much as a fleeting glimpse of a knob penis.

By declaring that any man who says he is a woman is welcome in female spaces you are putting out the red carpet for every pervert, psychopath, paedophile and misogynistic murderer * to say 'I feel like a woman' and be given free reign to waltz into women's spaces.

For the avoidance doubt by those who like to triple jump to conclusions I am not suggesting that all trans women fall into any/all of these categories. I am pointing out that if the definition of women we use is 'umm, err it's very tricky, you can't actually define it but if a man says they are one then that's good enough for me' then there is literally nothing to stop any* man declaring that he is in fact a women. How do you propose to stop bad men from exploiting this massive loophole?

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 17:22

They're certainly more dangerous if they're allowed unfettered access to women's spaces while scores of simpletons call for us to respect them getting their knobs out there. What worries us isn't their innate sense of self.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 17:17

Rainbowshit · 24/06/2022 16:14

Transwomen are male. I don't see them as any different to any other male in that a male is more likely to assault me than a female.

If a man or a transwomen are walking down the street behind me my perception of threat is the same. Females I don't feel anywhere near as much of a threat to me.

They are men with a serious psychological issue. It’s not clear if that increases or decreases their propensity to violence, or does neither.

Going by their threats to women on Twitter my starting assumption is that they are far more dangerous than other men.

FemmeNatal · 24/06/2022 17:15

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 16:10

What did parliament do with it?

If you start engaging in good faith and answering the questions I asked you you can come back and ask that again.

334bu · 24/06/2022 17:00

www.smh.com.au/sport/fina-rules-will-leave-some-devastated-that-does-not-mean-they-are-wrong-20220623-p5avyw.html

An article from the Sydney Herald which you might find interesting.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/06/2022 16:55

The derailing was worth it because it shows perfectly the arrant stupidity and dishonesty that is the inevitable consequence of this ideology, and what it ultimately causes people to justify. It isn't actually possible to defend it, as Cookies has so brilliantly shown for the last day and night.

I'm honestly not convinced that Cookies isn't some brilliant double agent who's actually here to expose the movement for the load of cobblers that it is. I couldn't have done it better. Tinker tailor soldier terf.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 24/06/2022 16:47

I think the difference between me and all of you is that how someone identifies doesn’t fill me with vitriol or unsubstantiated fears around women’s safety

such utter utter bollocks…ironically 😀

Peregrina · 24/06/2022 16:44

This thread has now got totally derailed. At least the FINA ruling means that the Lia Thomas's of the world, who did compete as men, so must have gone through male puberty, can no longer encroach on our spaces.

I am tempted to tell them to man up, and find something else they can be successful in, since they are not up to standard in the sporting arena.

Scream transphobe at me if you wish - like TERF it's now becoming a badge of honour.

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 16:15

Male bodies

TheKeatingFive · 24/06/2022 16:14

I think the difference between me and all of you is that how someone identifies doesn’t fill me with vitriol or unsubstantiated fears around women’s safety.

Its not about vitriol or fear

But don't you see the implications for women when male bodies move into their sports? Or spaces where they might be triggered by make bodies like refuges or rape counselling?

Or do you just not care about the implications for those women? They're just not important in your eyes - is that it?

Supersee · 24/06/2022 16:14

StolenCookie · 24/06/2022 16:08

And to the person continually asserting that they are a cat - I won’t lose any sleep if that is how you choose to identify.

Meow! 🐾

I think the difference between me and all of you is that how someone identifies doesn’t fill me with vitriol or unsubstantiated fears around women’s safety.

Trans women are women 💕

Except, they're not 🤷‍♀️. It's really that simple.