Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Which would you choose?

38 replies

IndecisionnCentral · 19/06/2022 18:15

Dh and I can't agree which is the better option. AIBU #1 YANBU #2

Currently
Income from investments £1500pcm
Savings £600k

Option 1: buy nice house in main town/city for 600k, both get part time jobs as investment income allows flexibility & then have a good work/life balance with plenty of time for hobbies and holidays

Option 2: buy a rural smallholding for 600k, start a business like dog boarding/airbnb for income, definitely more of a change in lifestyle choice

Pros and cons to both and very privileged for this dilemma, genuinely would appreciate others experiences and advice. Am going around in circles.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BarbaraofSeville · 20/06/2022 08:39

Hybrid of 1 & 2.

Buy a property in a village/quiet suburb not too far from a city for about £400k so you can increase your investment potential and set up a dog walking/cat feeding business from that home.

Obviously depends on property prices locally, but round here, there would be plenty of properties at that price that would feel very rural, but are only 5/10 miles from a city and even closer to potential clients to walk their dogs and feed their cats.

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/120604199#/?channel=RES_BUY

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/120924407#/?channel=RES_BUY

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/113788529#/?channel=RES_BUY

www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/122905112#/?channel=RES_BUY

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 20/06/2022 08:28

Is a mix not a possibility? House in the countryside, jobs in the city nearby?

Ragwort · 20/06/2022 08:05

Isn't there a compromise? I live on the outskirts of a market town, plenty of countryside around, could buy a very nice five bedroom house for £450k (we live in one Grin) and offer AirBnB or dog walking etc on a part time basis ?

ClaryFairchild · 20/06/2022 08:00

If you really wanted option 2 you wouldn't need to ask for opinions. It's the type of choice that someone should REALLY want to do, not a fall back option.

Because of that, I think option 1.

easyday · 20/06/2022 07:24

Option 1 for me, though £600k would be a small flat round here. But I'm a city girl and couldn't take being out in the sticks.
A lot of investment required to start up a business like those you suggest.

Bolsa · 20/06/2022 07:16

Airbnb or kennels will NOT give you any sort of work/life balance. You will be tied to the house and for not as much return as you might think

Lilyhatesjaz · 20/06/2022 07:12

I would do option 1, probably in a small to medium sized town with good access to the countryside and a garden big enough to have a greenhouse and grow my own vegetables

Jengnr · 20/06/2022 07:12

Where do you live? Can you move somewhere semi rural so you get all the benefits but town, work etc is still accessible?

I live in a small town in West Yorkshire. You could definitely buy a house here, which is seemingly in the middle of nowhere but is, in reality, only a mile or so from a large town with good transport links.

Philisophigal · 20/06/2022 07:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

MinnieMountain · 20/06/2022 07:04

Can your DH ask his parents about the realities of farming? It might make it clearer to him why option 1 is a safer bet.

rookiemere · 20/06/2022 07:00

Yes I thought that might be the case @IndecisionnCentral .

You're both in a very fortunate position because you don't absolutely have to have career jobs. Would there be scope to buy a small property in the town and a county cottage as well - that way you have somewhere to retreat to for weekends and holidays but it's not eating up all the funds and your efforts.

IndecisionnCentral · 20/06/2022 06:35

This is so helpful!

DH is pulled towards #2 and I'm more #1.

The smallholding was a shared dream but we've had a hellish few years of stress, bereavement etc so I just want an easier time of it. Lots of things appeal about a smallholding, but also lots doesn't!

Plus, the responsibility of a new business would be down to me, and I realise the amount of sacrifice and time/energy needed but I don't think DH does.

He's a coaster, not a doer, he's on medication for anxiety and I think realistically #1 would be more stable for him. But his heart is in the country, where he grew up on a farm, so he feels a rural move would 'fix' everything.

OP posts:
HairyScaryMonster · 19/06/2022 22:04

Goodness, do you have a passion for the country, being your own boss, animals, the satisfaction of hard graft coming to fruition. You'll be working hard, more than full time for a good few years with option 2. Will you feel tied down (busiest during holiday season) with option 2 or bored with option 1 (not lots of extra income to do exciting things, limited career progression)?

parietal · 19/06/2022 20:13

No 1 is definitely more flexible. You can still do dog walking or Airbnb or all sorts if you are based in a town. But a smallholding is endless work and no summer holidays. You have to be passionate about the land to make it work.

Go for the easy life in a nice town with scope to train ins new role or travel or be part of the community

IndecisionnCentral · 19/06/2022 20:11

HollowTalk · 19/06/2022 19:54

I really wouldn't do option two. What jobs do you do now? Can you do them part time?

How secure are those investments? Are they likely to go down as well as up? I am assuming so.

Jobs wise - we both work part time now in low skilled industries, DH couldn't retrain but I definitely could; if we didn't do option #2 then I would use the time/freedom to choose a qualification/career.

Investment income is very secure and should only increase slightly year on year.

OP posts:
AnnaSW1 · 19/06/2022 19:55

1 definitely

HollowTalk · 19/06/2022 19:54

I really wouldn't do option two. What jobs do you do now? Can you do them part time?

How secure are those investments? Are they likely to go down as well as up? I am assuming so.

Ihatethenewlook · 19/06/2022 19:42

MistyRuins · 19/06/2022 18:53

Having been self employed with a business based on premises - I would personally go for option one.

A business can take over your life in ways you don't expect.

This. Option 2 sounds a bit bizarre for people who presumably have no experience in it. It all sounds very lovely in theory, but it’s a 24/7 job with never ending responsibility. And a business that goes tits up very easily has the power to drag you down with it.

rookiemere · 19/06/2022 19:35

Option 1.
I know two sets of people who invested everything in their own businesses and ended up losing it all and it cost one set of them their marriage.

Is your investment income index linked ? £1500 per month is a decent amount but doesn't allow for a luxurious lifestyle-particularly as it will go down in value in real terms if not index linked.

I'd go for Option 1 but also try to find something I was passionate about - be that the job I took or doing some volunteering on top.

namechange30455 · 19/06/2022 19:34

Can you not do option 2 but get a job there? Rural but commutable a couple of times a week into a city?

DogsAndGin · 19/06/2022 19:30

Dog boarding and airbnb will not give you any work life balance. You’ll be working evenings and weekends and getting up during the night dealing with dogs - and the insurance / risk for liability would be a nightmare.

Equally, airbnb sounds like a can of worms. People in your private space - you’ll be busiest during holidays and weekends.

You don’t need the hassle.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 19/06/2022 19:26

I would look for wfh options in a rural setting.

Have then to fall back on if the self employment/passive income doesn't work out.

NorthernMarmiteLover · 19/06/2022 19:18

Option 2 sounds the preferred option for sure, but I feel like option 1 is more realistic and more "doable" for everyday ease.

MistyRuins · 19/06/2022 18:53

Having been self employed with a business based on premises - I would personally go for option one.

A business can take over your life in ways you don't expect.

IndecisionnCentral · 19/06/2022 18:50

This is really helpful, having a gut-feeling reaction to replies which is surprisingly revealing! Thank you.

OP posts: