Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do you think would be an appropriate response/rectification to this email?

285 replies

intheguf · 19/06/2022 17:20

Hello,

I’d like to make a complaint. I booked a table for ten people at your establishment for 8pm - Saturday, 18th June. I paid the 50 pound deposit over the phone and I asked the woman how the deposit is paid back, she replied that it would be paid back in vouchers to be spent in your establishment. I’d asked if there was any chance I could get it back in cash as would be simpler for me. She replied that she would ask her manager, which she did whilst I was on the phone, and the manager said that it was fine to pay me back cash.

Turned up on the night, all fine, table was fine etc. Went to the bar and asked about deposit at which point was given vouchers. I explained to the girl behind the bar that I was to get cash. She said she remembered speaking to me on the phone and fetched the manager.

I’m not sure of the managers name, but he was wearing a white shirt and had an ear piece in and I think his name begins with ‘A’ but could be wrong - he stated he was the only manager of your establishment. The manager came over in a really aggressive manner and denied that he had ever agreed to give me my deposit back in cash even though the girl behind the bar confirmed that she had taken the phone call and he had authorised that. I said to the manager that if he didn’t authorise it then he needs to speak to his staff about giving out misinformation. At this point he came close to my face and said ‘what do I need to tell my staff?’ and repeated this several times in a really aggressive manner. I felt very intimidated and uncomfortable to the point I just agreed to take the vouchers as I dislike confrontation and just wanted the situation to be over. I used 30 pounds of the vouchers and am now left with a 20 pound voucher which I won’t get the use out of due to the fact that I won’t be returning to your establishment after this experience.

If your policy is to return deposits via vouchers then that is fair enough, but it should have never been agreed to if that is the case. Your manager made out that I was a liar along with his member of staff that was serving behind the bar. That along with his aggressive mannerisms and the way in which he dealt with a paying customer is totally unacceptable. I left shortly afterwards as I felt so uncomfortable. If cash deposit return hadn’t been agreed then I could have booked elsewhere or worked something out with my group. However, I’ve now been left £50 out of pocket due to this.

It was my 30th birthday and I really just wanted to celebrate with my friends and this really put a dampener on the night. I am so disappointed as I have only ever had great experiences with your establishment but the customer service I received last night is the worst I have ever experienced unfortunately.

Kind regards

OP posts:
ineedafairygodmother · 19/06/2022 20:59

I'd be pretty pissed of if I was the customer!!

So the girl behind the bar (a member of your staff) also confirmed that your manager authorised the deposit to be refunded in cash? What does she have to gain from saying this is your manager didn't agree? Your manager is lying to you then, and I wouldn't be surprised if this isn't the first time they've lied to you. His behaviour is also unacceptable.

I'd refund the customer the full £50 plus extra voucher (or a complimentary table reservation for a night of her choosing) as a goodwill gesture to hopefully stop the customer from trashing your venue on SM.

Your policy also needs rewording from a deposit to 'a table reservation fee of £50 which will be substituted for vouchers to the value of £50 to be used at the venue upon guest arrival at table' (or something like that) pretty self explanatory and no mishaps in the further. A deposit is generally refunded as paid or deducted from a final bill

Orchidflower1 · 19/06/2022 20:56

i do hope@intheguf that the reason you’ve not returned to your thread is that you’re so busy apologising to the customer and searching recruitments for a new manger.

LeFeu · 19/06/2022 20:46

That’s not a deposit OP, that’s a minimum payment.

Rosscameasdoody · 19/06/2022 20:44

Utterly bizarre to think that you can ask for a £50 cash deposit to secure a table and then effectively refuse to return it except through vouchers that can only be exchanged at your own establishment. I would also think it’s illegal, so I would be thinking about what you can do to appease the customer before she contacts trading standards. Oh, and your manager needs sacking. Another member of staff has confirmed that he OK’d the cash refund so it’s not a case of believing a customer over your manager - and she wasn’t trying to get ‘free drinks’’ she was simply asking for her deposit back. Ridiculous.

Redglitter · 19/06/2022 20:43

Thats the most ridiculous system I've heard of. For one thing a £50 deposit for drinks??? Is that standard or based on the number at the table. Why on earth don't you do what every other normal pub/restaurant does & ask for a card at the time of booking

I cant believe this is the first complaint you've had. You need a far better system. Your current one is appaling

NoGoodUsernamee · 19/06/2022 20:41

You apologies & refund them the £20 at least. You have a crap deposit system so look at that. The deposit should just come off the bill total. & I strongly suspect your manager is lying.

ToysRMine · 19/06/2022 20:39

intheguf · 19/06/2022 17:52

I'm sorry but it is deducted off the bill if for a sit down meal. However, as the customer has to pay for each drink at the bar then there is no way to do this. But by providing vouchers they can use to pay, it is basically the same thing.

In that case I would use the card as holding details and charge the £50 if the table didn’t turn up because that policy is ridiculous

Motorina · 19/06/2022 20:38

The first thing you should do is thank your lucky stars your customer isn't me.

Because I'd be sueing you. Yup, it would cost me more in court fees than the £20, but I'd be doing it anyway.

And I'd be writing a negative review on every site I can find.

And reporting you to HMRC (are you declaring those deposits as income?) as well as to the ICO for publishing my email here. And maybe the Food Standards Agency for good measure. Okay, those last three may not have legs, but they'd cost me nothing and cause you grief regardless.

Causing you grief would be high on my to do list.

What should you do?

Apologise
Refund the money
Watch your CCTV if you have it
Apologise some more
Work out what to do about your manager, who has at the very least chased away a repeat customer who was bringing all her mates

And be grateful that your complainer seems inclined to be reasonable.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 19/06/2022 20:37

It isn't the same thing. You have no legal right to insist on a deposit being returned in the form of vouchers. The customer has a legal right to receive their deposit back via the same means used to make the payment.

What you're doing is forcing people to buy vouchers from you, which is not OK and is very shoddy business practice.

Whether your manager is lying or not, you only have your ridiculous policy to blame for this. You should be placing a preauthorisation on a card and releasing it once the customer arrives for their booking, or processing as a payment if a no show.

Do you have written terms and conditions regarding your deposit system, and did the customer receive them prior to placing the booking?

To reply you apologise for your shit system, your rude staff and ask her to contact you so that you can arrange to return her deposit.

Beautiful3 · 19/06/2022 20:37

Deposit should be refunded the same way it was taken. So if they paid by credit card, it has to go back on it. Ask her to bring in her voucher, to be exchanged for cash. Make sure your staff knows about it, so she doesn't have a wasted journey.

IcedOatLatte · 19/06/2022 20:35

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 19/06/2022 19:38

sounds like money laundering, taking cash and handing out vouchers. How on earth can you run a business when you cant even solve a simple customer complaint?

That's not what money laundering is, the policy is nuts but it's not ML

Paq · 19/06/2022 20:34

Your policy is terrible and potentially illegal! Apologise, refund and compensate!

SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 20:27

I hope she leaves an honest review so everyone is aware of your con

Macwomble · 19/06/2022 20:26

intheguf · 19/06/2022 17:52

I'm sorry but it is deducted off the bill if for a sit down meal. However, as the customer has to pay for each drink at the bar then there is no way to do this. But by providing vouchers they can use to pay, it is basically the same thing.

Change your policy immediately as it is illegal!

TheLette · 19/06/2022 20:25

There are some absolutely bonkers comments here about money laundering. I don't even know where to begin with those.

Anyway unless your policy of giving vouchers instead of cash back once the customer turns up to take their table is VERY CLEARLY stated to the customer prior to them making the booking, the policy is ridiculous and unfair. In my (fairly informed - it's my area of law) opinion it would be a breach of consumer protection law.

Leaving aside the law, I can't quite understand why there is any hesitation about apologizing to this customer - who doesn't sound unhinged and whose email seems quite reasonable - and just refunding her £20. And in future either changing the policy or making it very clear to customers what it involves, before they book, and preferably in writing.

Herejustforthisone · 19/06/2022 20:24

Your voucher policy is a total con.

Have you got CCTV? I am inclined to believe the customer. She has been largely flattering to your pub and she doesn’t sound like someone after a free lunch.

I’d watch your manager closely.

Fink · 19/06/2022 20:21

What an absolute shit show of a policy and customer service. Give her the bloody refund right away because your policy is so awful, and apologise profusely, and then you can work out whether the manager needs to be disciplined as a separate issue.

For once I really hope this is a reverse/troll/wind up, because it's such terrible and clueless running of a place.

BeenHereForYonkyDoodles · 19/06/2022 20:20

I think your deposit scheme is overly complicated and potentially illegal.
Her deposit should be returned in the way it was paid to avoid money laundering. So back to her card as she paid over the phone.
I'd refund her remaining £20 back to her card, apologise for any confusion and suggest she keep the £20 vouchers as a goodwill gesture (doubt she'll be back to spend them).

donquixotedelamancha · 19/06/2022 20:16

But by providing vouchers they can use to pay, it is basically the same thing.

Its clearly not the same thing because happened. If people pay a deposit in cash and then turn up you need to refund them in cash, not make their life hard work.

He is claiming none of it happened.

He's claiming not to have spoken to this customer? He's lying. Nobody would make up such a specific story.

RedHelenB · 19/06/2022 20:14

intheguf · 19/06/2022 17:35

I'm the owner and not sure how to respond. Manager is claiming he never authorised cash return.

Well your policy is awful. Time to change to giving the deposit back when they show up.

fyn · 19/06/2022 20:10

I would be absolutely amazed if it was legal to take a security deposit and only refund it in vouchers. I hope the lady takes advice from Citizens Advice.

Pancakeorcrepe · 19/06/2022 20:07

The voucher system is absolutely ridiculous and makes no sense.

angelikacpickles · 19/06/2022 20:04

intheguf · 19/06/2022 17:35

I'm the owner and not sure how to respond. Manager is claiming he never authorised cash return.

Even if you don't believe it happened, you have no business keeping £20 of customer's money. Ask her to come in to exchange the £20 voucher she still has left for cash.

Jmaho · 19/06/2022 19:58

So you're quick to say your manager isn't a liar. Therefore your other staff member who said he authorised the cash refund and also the customer are liars? So two liars and one truth teller. Interesting...
Your policy is appalling by the way and I suspect not legal

Antarcticant · 19/06/2022 19:57

Any scenario where the deposit is not simply deducted from the final bill - whether for food or drinks - is bizarre and shit.

I'm surprised the restaurant has any customers, even if the staff are lovely.

Swipe left for the next trending thread