Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think withdrawal is quite safe...

269 replies

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:38

Whenever I see threads on here about natural family planning and the withdrawal method as means of contraception, people always act as if it's stupid and completely unreliable. Now don't get me wrong, it's not fool proof. But is it really as reckless as people make out?

Dh and I have recently had a baby (3 months ago) and are yet to sort contraception. I don't want to go back on the pill and he's thinking of getting a vasectomy but there's a wait. Having done my research it seems like withdrawal can work when done properly - i.e fully withdrawn a decent length of time before ejaculation not left right until the last second. Studies also seem to indicate that 'pre-ejaculate' for the most part doesn't contain sperm. So why are people so against it? Have you had any experience with it and did it work for you?

OP posts:
Cyw2018 · 19/06/2022 17:34

It worked for us for 2 or 3 years before starting TTC (when it wouldn't have been a disaster of I had become pregnant), which then took only 3 months of trying.

However, now that we definitely don't want another baby I have the copper coil fitted.

MassiveSalad22 · 19/06/2022 17:33

I completely agree OP 🤫

MamTDM · 19/06/2022 17:33

We used withdrawal in combination with very careful use of the Persona fertility tracking monitor. The result is currently in the middle of his GCSEs.

Queenoftheashes · 19/06/2022 17:33

It has worked fine for me and I wish it didn’t now I’m TTC and still unwillingly using this method.

LordEmsworth · 19/06/2022 17:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Nice to see anti-Catholic sentiment alive and well on a Sunday!

Isonthecase · 19/06/2022 17:32

We tried this and ended up with two pregnancies, one from precum and one from randomly ovulating really early when I think I'd been consistent for years. The trouble is you don't know if you're susceptible to either of those until you find out the hard way.

EerieSilence · 19/06/2022 17:32

Greetings from Eerie, the withdrawal that didn't work that well.
Could have been the exception to the rule but I still exist, so good luck. It's a Russian lottery, only nobody dies, quite the other way round.

rnsaslkih · 19/06/2022 17:31

My brother was conceived using this method.

girlmom21 · 19/06/2022 17:30

If it works for you, that's great. For me, it'd massively take the enjoyment out of sex.

AhNowTed · 19/06/2022 17:30

@LilyPotter44

The circumstances suggest it will work for you.

As it did for me and @WalkerWalking

No planned pregnancy, but not a disaster if it happens.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 19/06/2022 17:29

Useranon1 · 19/06/2022 16:51

Typical use is 76% effective. Condoms are only 79% effective typical use so maybe people could stop being so snooty!!!

That being said there are far more reliable contraceptives out there, though they are all hormonal.

Since when? All the condom packs say they're 96% effective. The NHS states they're 98% effective.

1moreyear · 19/06/2022 17:27

1moreyear · 19/06/2022 17:26

We do it a lot. I've not got pregnant this way. I could do though and I'm fully aware of that risk.

To add to this when we have conceived it has been first time every time so super fertile! It's still a risk though

FallopianTubeTrain · 19/06/2022 17:27

"studies seem to indicate"
"for the most part"

I'd want a bit more reassurance than that for basing life changing decisions.

In fact I'm currently looking to buy a new sleeping bag and want to know whether it will be warm enough for camping and I want more reassurance than that!

1moreyear · 19/06/2022 17:26

We do it a lot. I've not got pregnant this way. I could do though and I'm fully aware of that risk.

sleepymum50 · 19/06/2022 17:26

I read that withdrawal is used as the method when the female doesn’t or can’t take the pill any more, or it’s after a baby and it’s really the man’s “turn” to sort contraception.

Men will often try and convince their partners that withdrawal is fine and it’s often because he doesn’t want to wear a condom because “it’s not as good”.

So really the reliability of withdrawal is down to the man entirely. Considering the number of men who can’t be trusted to sit the right way on a toilet with two hands and a map - I ask you, would you fall for that? Because I did, and you can come and say hello to my DD for proof.

WalkerWalking · 19/06/2022 17:25

I have done lots of research on this. A significant minority of men produce viable sperm within their "pre-cum" (most men do not). Some men are more reliable than others about pulling out in time. If you have sex twice in a row he should urinate in between.

We used withdrawal in between babies when it wasn't very important. It worked perfectly well, so I'm fairly sure that my husband falls into the "no sperm in pre-cum" category (we were lucky enough to fall pregnant first try with 3 kids, so our baseline fertility is clearly quite high).

For us, withdrawal has worked fine for 10+ years, even though we get pregnant very easily. This may not be the same for you. No contraception is 100% (you might be especially terrified by the "real life" stats of condoms, which fall well below 90% when not used perfectly). The last time I checked, withdrawal had something like a 96% effectiveness, compared to the pill at about 98% (again, "real world" data, so allowing for people who miss pills etc)

AquaticSewingMachine · 19/06/2022 17:24

Men either do or don't secrete sperm in their pre-cum. You only find out whether your partner is a secretor or not when you get pregnant from the withdrawal method.

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:23

bustickets · 19/06/2022 17:13

The fact that your husband is thinking of a vasectomy enough to have made enquiries about timelines suggests he doesn't want another baby? What will happen if you potentially get pregnant? Are you on board with no more children too?

We aren't planning another pregnancy but it wouldn't be the end of the world if it happened. We have a big enough house, are financially secure and very happy, but no it isn't on the cards. We both know the risks. But there are risks with everything.

It just baffles me why people get so irate about it. They make out you're an immature idiot for even considering it. But alongside natural family planning it's got similar odds to condoms. So why the attitude that has been so brilliantly demonstrated on this thread? Wilfully having unprotected sex when you definitely don't want a baby is one thing. But looking at odds, stats and then weighing it all up against your personal situation is another. And it's far from idiotic.

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 19/06/2022 17:21

I’m not sure why you’re getting such sassy replies, the conception board is literally full of posts talking about tracking ovulation dates and now unlikely to the point of impossibility it is to get pregnant apart from those times. This is just that in reverse.

Yes it worked for us for years. I like it cos no hormones for the woman or foreign bodies involved and you maintain the “natural” feeling without the mess.

That said, im always surprised at how daft the general public is so I assume it works for people who understand how it works but it’s generally looked down upon cos there will always be people who completely misinterpret how it works

RoyKentsChestHair · 19/06/2022 17:21

I used it successfully for 9 years. DP preferred oral anyway, so there was never a huge amount of PIV and when there was it was rarely ‘to completion’ unless deemed a safe day for it. I was very aware of my cycle and clearly made a decent job of keeping track. For people who had some kind of sex at least 3 times a week, it worked for us.

AngelinaFibres · 19/06/2022 17:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LordEmsworth · 19/06/2022 17:20

You are missing the highly relevant fact that when we are turned on, we don't always make logical, rational decisions.

Before starting sex, the intention might be to stop well before it becomes a risk factor.

During sex, that becomes - hmm maybe a bit more. Then - would it be that bad? Then - ah it'll probably be ok. If you are fully in control of that decision then frankly, the sex is really quite poor so why bother...

So the point is you might not be reckless now. But you will be when it gets to "a decent amount of time". All recks out the window at that point... you won't care about the consequences of carrying on!

AhNowTed · 19/06/2022 17:20

@LilyPotter44

"Without going into the gory details....this is basically what we do! There is no last second pull out. I can see how that could go wrong easily."

As I said it worked fine for us. Bear in mind, we didn't want (for good reason) another baby, but it wouldn't have been a disaster if I got pregnant. Committed, stable relationship of many years.

I wouldn't have had an abortion if I did get pregnant, but that never happened, despite getting pregnant immediately on both planned attempts.

Posters calling you names are ridiculous.

But the circumstances need to be right.

Applesandroses · 19/06/2022 17:18

bustickets · 19/06/2022 17:13

The fact that your husband is thinking of a vasectomy enough to have made enquiries about timelines suggests he doesn't want another baby? What will happen if you potentially get pregnant? Are you on board with no more children too?

that is a very good point!

Pudmyboy · 19/06/2022 17:17

ZenNudist · 19/06/2022 16:47

What do you call people who rely on the withdrawal method?

Parents!

I came on to say this!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread