Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think withdrawal is quite safe...

269 replies

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:38

Whenever I see threads on here about natural family planning and the withdrawal method as means of contraception, people always act as if it's stupid and completely unreliable. Now don't get me wrong, it's not fool proof. But is it really as reckless as people make out?

Dh and I have recently had a baby (3 months ago) and are yet to sort contraception. I don't want to go back on the pill and he's thinking of getting a vasectomy but there's a wait. Having done my research it seems like withdrawal can work when done properly - i.e fully withdrawn a decent length of time before ejaculation not left right until the last second. Studies also seem to indicate that 'pre-ejaculate' for the most part doesn't contain sperm. So why are people so against it? Have you had any experience with it and did it work for you?

OP posts:
Itsanofromme1 · 19/06/2022 17:49

We used it successfully for about three years before and between babies. The two times he (deliberately) didn’t withdraw I got pregnant. So I’d say we’re pretty fertile and if there was sperm in that pre cum I would have caught. Daren’t risk it anymore though as really don’t want more children.

Londonnight · 19/06/2022 17:49

My ex partner and I used the withdrawal method. That child is now 22 :)
So didn't work for us.

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 17:47

Wilfully having unprotected sex when you definitely don't want a baby is one thing. But looking at odds, stats and then weighing it all up against your personal situation is another.

How is it not wilfully having unprotected sex when you definitely don't want a baby?

2022again · 19/06/2022 17:46

OP you specifically asked "is it really as reckless as people make out?" the answer is a resounding YES if you do not want a baby, simple as. If a baby isn't the end of the world and you'd BOTH be equally happy to conceive (i suspect this a method perhaps popular with men who don't like the idea of condoms but then expect the woman to deal with the consequences of the method failing) then of course go for it - in your particular circumstances it sounds as if you are both choosing it in a careful, considered way- but it's not considered a particularly successful method of contraception hence why people feel snippy about it, not everyone is going to be as thoughtful about it as you!!! likewise am from a catholic background and having done my family tree(!)am from a long line of people conceived before marriage for the very reason that people didn't feel able to use appropriate contraception for their circumstances.

SmithsterSister · 19/06/2022 17:46

We've used it for 10 years so far, had 1 baby who was very much planned and I fell pregnant the first month we decided to try so obviously fairly fertile.

It can work if you're careful, most people just aren't. 🤷‍♀️

BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 17:46

There is enough sperm in pre-cum to populate the Isle of Wight. Maybe think about that…

Furrbabymama1987 · 19/06/2022 17:46

Yes it worked for me but I only risked it when I knew I wasn't in the fertile stage of my cycle. I have an exact 28 day cycle and I know when there's a chance of pregnancy and when there's not. I've got 4 kids that I conceived quickly ( 2 were on my first cycle of trying) so I was pretty fertile before being sterilised. But I wouldn't have done it if another baby would have been a disaster. I think the main issue is not the precum having a tiny amount of sperm in it, it's the man reaching orgasm and in that split second, pulling out doesn't matter so he comes inside.

YellowSticker · 19/06/2022 17:45

It’s a difficult one. You know the theory. You listen to those who prove the theory wrong.
It doesn’t work sadly. You may want it to work, the risks of getting pregnant are high. It’s your choice.

DaysOfOurLives88 · 19/06/2022 17:45

We've done the withdrawal method for 4 years. No pregnancy. Im very fertile as well.

2weeones · 19/06/2022 17:44

We used it for about 4 years and didn't get pregnant. I got pregnant the first time we didn't use it so I think my DH must be very good at the timing. I think it's used a lot more than people think. Nobody will admit using it because of the comments you will get (like the ones on this post).

liveforsummer · 19/06/2022 17:44

SpilltheTea · 19/06/2022 17:39

I don't think it's sensible to rely on a man to pull his dick out in time or to take a chance on precum. Why would you?

Also this, you actually have little control of any of this and are relying on a man to have massive self control whilst approaching orgasm. I imagine a lot of accidents happen when he's just that little bit too late

Goldencarp · 19/06/2022 17:43

I guess if you do it right! There’s 14 months between my youngest two so obviously we didn’t 😂

Ponderingwindow · 19/06/2022 17:43

if you wouldn’t be bothered by another pregnancy, then you aren’t really that concerned with sorting proper birth control. Relying on withdrawal when finding out you were pregnant would be bad news would make you irresponsible because it has low rates of effectiveness. Those couples need to abstain from Piv sex or find at least one real birth control method.

someone like op who doesn’t necessarily want to be pregnant, but clearly doesn’t mind shouldn’t be advocating ineffectual give birth control methods.

Notanotherwindow · 19/06/2022 17:42

The middle two are twins! Fraternal twins 😂

girlmom21 · 19/06/2022 17:41

Notanotherwindow · 19/06/2022 17:39

I've got 4 nieces and nephews downstairs who can tell you differently...

All unplanned, all conceived due to the withdrawal method.

Did nobody learn after the first 3? Grin

PeakyBlinda · 19/06/2022 17:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ichifanny · 19/06/2022 17:39

Worked out in way It worked for about 3 years until it didn’t and I now have a 3 year old .

SpilltheTea · 19/06/2022 17:39

I don't think it's sensible to rely on a man to pull his dick out in time or to take a chance on precum. Why would you?

Notanotherwindow · 19/06/2022 17:39

I've got 4 nieces and nephews downstairs who can tell you differently...

All unplanned, all conceived due to the withdrawal method.

EveningOverRooftops · 19/06/2022 17:37

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:52

And this is exactly the sort of attitude I'm talking about. You act as if it's idiotic but why? If the penis is removed well in time and the pre ejaculate fluid doesn't contain sperm then why is it so reckless and stupid? Combined with ovulation tracking/natural family planning (particularly after ovulation has occurred) I genuinely don't see why it's viewed as being so high risk. I'm not being goady, I just don't get it.

It is idiotic if you do not want a baby as it will eventually result in a baby for the majority in a year as studies show

No method is 100% effective which is why suggestions of double up eg pill and condom are always recommended if you’re certain you don’t want any more.

NHS has efficacy rates of all methods. Start there www.nhs.uk/conditions/contraception/how-effective-contraception/

In your situation I would be seriously considering taking the pill again until your partner has had the vasectomy AND follow shows it has worked.

WalkerWalking · 19/06/2022 17:37

TheWayoftheLeaf · 19/06/2022 17:29

Since when? All the condom packs say they're 96% effective. The NHS states they're 98% effective.

My GP quoted me 78% for condoms in real-life usage (I don't know where he got that exact number from though)

It would make sense that the NHS quote the higher number (from lab trials) because they don't want people to "give up" on condoms because of the STI factor as well.

Applesandroses · 19/06/2022 17:36

EerieSilence · 19/06/2022 17:32

Greetings from Eerie, the withdrawal that didn't work that well.
Could have been the exception to the rule but I still exist, so good luck. It's a Russian lottery, only nobody dies, quite the other way round.

Oh crap yeah, now I think about it (I dont want to think too hard about my parents having sex) I am only here because this method sometimes fails...

Bornin1989 · 19/06/2022 17:35

We used it for about a year until DD came along but we didn't mind getting pregnant and were planning on having a baby within the next couple of years. So far, 8 months down the line the abstinence method has been pretty reliable 😂😭 when we do have sex again, we're definitely not going to use the withdrawal method!!!

Ormally · 19/06/2022 17:35

'the conception board is literally full of posts talking about tracking ovulation dates and now unlikely to the point of impossibility it is to get pregnant apart from those times'

...And lo, then there is the perimenopause, and all you thought was predictable, logical, and unlikely about menstrual roulette will be fucked up beyond all recognition. I have found out in no uncertain terms that sometimes it can shake up some kind of super fertility, not genteel decline.

HollowTalk · 19/06/2022 17:35

A relative of mine had ten pregnancies that way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread