Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think withdrawal is quite safe...

269 replies

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:38

Whenever I see threads on here about natural family planning and the withdrawal method as means of contraception, people always act as if it's stupid and completely unreliable. Now don't get me wrong, it's not fool proof. But is it really as reckless as people make out?

Dh and I have recently had a baby (3 months ago) and are yet to sort contraception. I don't want to go back on the pill and he's thinking of getting a vasectomy but there's a wait. Having done my research it seems like withdrawal can work when done properly - i.e fully withdrawn a decent length of time before ejaculation not left right until the last second. Studies also seem to indicate that 'pre-ejaculate' for the most part doesn't contain sperm. So why are people so against it? Have you had any experience with it and did it work for you?

OP posts:
newnamethanks · 19/06/2022 18:02

Plenty of kids running around to disprove your theory. It can work well. Until it doesn't.

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 18:00

@ReneBumsWombats If you mean not pulling out in time I have addressed that several times. It's not an issue for us. The risk would be the pre cum secretion which he is aware of and so am I.

OP posts:
BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 18:00

@LilyPotter44 Are you wilfully ignoring every post by all these women who are telling you this doesn’t work?

thedogwithnoname · 19/06/2022 17:58

Can anyone really be this stupid. Sounds like the kind of thing a 12 year old would say about sex.

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:58

girlmom21 · 19/06/2022 17:55

OP is your DH saying he doesn't want anymore and you do, and this is the way you're going to get what you want by still practising 'safe' sex? Has he done any research?

No that's not the case at all. He has researched and is fully aware of the risks.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 17:58

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:57

But that isn't the case for us.

I'm sure many couples would say that. People wouldn't try it if they didn't think they were doing it properly.

Luredbyapomegranate · 19/06/2022 17:58

It's not very effective so just use condoms or a cap or get a coil fitted.

It's not hard.

But another baby will be.

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:57

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 17:55

Anecdotally it seems like a lot of people have fallen pregnant this way but I suspect it wasn't done properly in many of these cases.

Which shows how hard it is to do properly.

But that isn't the case for us.

OP posts:
Americano75 · 19/06/2022 17:56

LordEmsworth · 19/06/2022 17:32

Nice to see anti-Catholic sentiment alive and well on a Sunday!

Yeah, this Catholic uses condoms so less of that please.

'..But alongside natural family planning it's got similar odds to condoms.'

The Billings Method (ie natural family planning) is around 90% effective. Withdrawal is around 78%. Condoms 98%. So no, not really.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 19/06/2022 17:56

OP there's a better method for while you wait for vasectomy and don't want the pill.
Condoms. They're great.
We've never had an "accident" even the time the condom split. 10/10 would recommend.
I have found anecdotally that men who won't use condoms correlates with men who "accidentally" come inside you and "forget" to pull out because "it happened so quickly I couldn't stop it."

FainaSnowChild · 19/06/2022 17:56

DH and I have used the withdrawal method successfully for 12 years since my last child - despite being very fertile (8 pregnancies).

Basically I am pretty in tune with my body and by tracking ovulation and CM changes we could safely use no contraception for the last week of my cycle, and withdrawal for the week before that, post ov.

Never had a scare or anything.

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 17:55

Anecdotally it seems like a lot of people have fallen pregnant this way but I suspect it wasn't done properly in many of these cases.

Which shows how hard it is to do properly.

girlmom21 · 19/06/2022 17:55

OP is your DH saying he doesn't want anymore and you do, and this is the way you're going to get what you want by still practising 'safe' sex? Has he done any research?

Floella22 · 19/06/2022 17:55

I’m one of 6 dc. My parents were very careful,
None of us were planned.
Withdrawal method doesn’t work.

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 17:55

Withdrawal is basically the reproductive version of 'Russian Roulette'.

HopeIsNotAStrategy · 19/06/2022 17:54

Withdrawal method. No proper uninterrupted sex. No proper contraception.

Sounds fab. Whatever, you do you.

I'm guessing your husband doesn't like condoms?

I always think of the Billy Connolly sketch on these matters. This one from 1m 50s onwards.

bustickets · 19/06/2022 17:53

OP you say you both know the risks. So you understand that it's not a totally reliable method of contraception, which is all anyone on here is trying to say.

Tbh it sounds as if you/your DH/both of you are perhaps either not on the same page about having another child or are both ambivalent. If the latter, that's fine, but if one or both of you actively don't want another child then it's a bit silly, or reckless, to use something that isn't as reliable as a barrier method.

TheViscountessBridgerton · 19/06/2022 17:52

Oh yes, the withdrawal method is mostly successful. After all, I only fell pregnant the once when we used it, as opposed to every single time. So, I'd say it was probably 95% successful.

If you're fertile, you will get pregnant.

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:51

Furrbabymama1987 · 19/06/2022 17:46

Yes it worked for me but I only risked it when I knew I wasn't in the fertile stage of my cycle. I have an exact 28 day cycle and I know when there's a chance of pregnancy and when there's not. I've got 4 kids that I conceived quickly ( 2 were on my first cycle of trying) so I was pretty fertile before being sterilised. But I wouldn't have done it if another baby would have been a disaster. I think the main issue is not the precum having a tiny amount of sperm in it, it's the man reaching orgasm and in that split second, pulling out doesn't matter so he comes inside.

This isn't an issue for us. His...er...'completion' is always achieved other ways. That doesn't mean sex isn't good for us by the way, it's just what we do.

The only real risk is the pre cum and whether or not dh is one of these elusive 'secreters'

I'm also not advocating this. I've just done my research and weighed up the risks of the method when well times and done correctly. Anecdotally it seems like a lot of people have fallen pregnant this way but I suspect it wasn't done properly in many of these cases. I'm absolutely certain we are doing it properly. The risk comes from the pre cum side of things.

OP posts:
BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 17:51

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:52

And this is exactly the sort of attitude I'm talking about. You act as if it's idiotic but why? If the penis is removed well in time and the pre ejaculate fluid doesn't contain sperm then why is it so reckless and stupid? Combined with ovulation tracking/natural family planning (particularly after ovulation has occurred) I genuinely don't see why it's viewed as being so high risk. I'm not being goady, I just don't get it.

Oh honestly! Pre-ejaculate fluid DOES contain sperm: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3564677/

AquaticSewingMachine · 19/06/2022 17:51

SmithsterSister · 19/06/2022 17:46

We've used it for 10 years so far, had 1 baby who was very much planned and I fell pregnant the first month we decided to try so obviously fairly fertile.

It can work if you're careful, most people just aren't. 🤷‍♀️

You happen to have a man who never secretes sperm into pre-cum. Other people happen to have a man who does. Literally the only way to tell the difference is to have withdrawal fail on you. Which is an idiotic risk to take if a pregnancy would be a problem.

user1490298596 · 19/06/2022 17:50

I’ve used this method for 16 years and only had my planned pregnancies. Fell pregnant first month so would say I’m pretty fertile

labazslovesliving · 19/06/2022 17:50

I guess you have to take into account and respect people who wish to do this method perhaps because of Religious grounds but I am another one for whom it did not work.

liveforsummer · 19/06/2022 17:49

SmithsterSister · 19/06/2022 17:46

We've used it for 10 years so far, had 1 baby who was very much planned and I fell pregnant the first month we decided to try so obviously fairly fertile.

It can work if you're careful, most people just aren't. 🤷‍♀️

It can also work if you're lucky and not everyone is.

Notfancyfree · 19/06/2022 17:49

You could ask my friend. He ended up in a loveless marriage for ten years after impregnating a woman on their third date using the withdrawal method (which I had taught him).

Swipe left for the next trending thread