Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think withdrawal is quite safe...

269 replies

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:38

Whenever I see threads on here about natural family planning and the withdrawal method as means of contraception, people always act as if it's stupid and completely unreliable. Now don't get me wrong, it's not fool proof. But is it really as reckless as people make out?

Dh and I have recently had a baby (3 months ago) and are yet to sort contraception. I don't want to go back on the pill and he's thinking of getting a vasectomy but there's a wait. Having done my research it seems like withdrawal can work when done properly - i.e fully withdrawn a decent length of time before ejaculation not left right until the last second. Studies also seem to indicate that 'pre-ejaculate' for the most part doesn't contain sperm. So why are people so against it? Have you had any experience with it and did it work for you?

OP posts:
Sunshine10012 · 19/06/2022 18:19

It works if it’s done properly ie penis pulled out and ejaculated elsewhere.
for those where it failed, it’s because the man ejaculated unintentionally inside their vagina.
There is no possible way for a women to become pregnant without ejaculation inside the vagina and yes pre cum does not contain sperm.
so ladies who claim they got pregnant this way it’s because your man wasn’t careful enough.

Birdflower · 19/06/2022 18:19

Totally agree with this! I don't know why other commenters are being so nasty.

It's worked for the best part of 10 years for me and OH, we got together when I was 21 and we're both very fertile. Was on the pill for 2 years in that time which was horrible. Withdrawal and FAM worked amazingly well for us, both to avoid pregnancy and we've had two planned pregnancies and none unplanned. I think if you're in touch with your body and on the same page about unplanned pregnancies, go for it! But that would be the same for any method of contraception.

MaggieFS · 19/06/2022 18:15

liveforsummer · 19/06/2022 16:42

I know plenty people that it worked for until it didn't. The time frame of that varies.

This.

DashboardConfessional · 19/06/2022 18:14

I can definitely see a line!

...Oh, am I a bit early?

In seriousness, friend has 2 under 2. Guess why. 1st took 7 years and IVF.

MiniCooperLover · 19/06/2022 18:14

Ha ha I cannot wait to read the post in about 2 months time 'how did no-one tell me it's not safe?!?' 😂

LilyMarshall · 19/06/2022 18:14

If you're charting properly at the same time I cannot see why it would be that much of an issue.

Ormally · 19/06/2022 18:12

BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 17:46

There is enough sperm in pre-cum to populate the Isle of Wight. Maybe think about that…

Oh god. Thanks for that. I think I'll steel my resolve again on my inner dream of tubal litigation.

Tandora · 19/06/2022 18:11

YANBU. I used this method for years and years and years, never Failed. (No issues getting preg when I wanted to).

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 18:09

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 18:00

@ReneBumsWombats If you mean not pulling out in time I have addressed that several times. It's not an issue for us. The risk would be the pre cum secretion which he is aware of and so am I.

I've read all your posts, including the ones where you said pre cum doesn't contain sperm.I'm not going to insult you or anything. You asked us what we think. I think it's a famously unreliable method and everyone who uses it thinks they're doing it properly, or else they wouldn't do it. Personally, I also don't like the idea of having to keep thinking about it and not being able to just go wild, so to speak, but that's me. It's your decision.

ozymandiusking · 19/06/2022 18:09

Come back when you're pregnant and tell us about your revised opinion!

RosesAndHellebores · 19/06/2022 18:08

I haven't read the full thread but the second poster @LividLaVidaLoca did make me smile. Reminded me of MNet of yore.

OP I hope it works. It sounds less romantic than a condom.

Fink · 19/06/2022 18:07

You're conflating two entirely different things. Natural family planning is highly effective if charting is done properly and the couple don't risk sex on any days when the chart may not be clear. The reason it's less effective in real life than condoms or the pill is because it's more prone to human error. But if it's done as a proper method, not a vague 'I'm probably not ovulating yet', then it's very effective.

Withdrawing before ejaculation is not a reliable way of avoiding pregnancy. It might work for you, in which case crack on, but it's so open to misunderstanding and mistiming that it can't really be seen as an actual method of contraception.

WhenAllIsLost · 19/06/2022 18:07

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:51

This isn't an issue for us. His...er...'completion' is always achieved other ways. That doesn't mean sex isn't good for us by the way, it's just what we do.

The only real risk is the pre cum and whether or not dh is one of these elusive 'secreters'

I'm also not advocating this. I've just done my research and weighed up the risks of the method when well times and done correctly. Anecdotally it seems like a lot of people have fallen pregnant this way but I suspect it wasn't done properly in many of these cases. I'm absolutely certain we are doing it properly. The risk comes from the pre cum side of things.

His...er...'completion' is always achieved other ways.

Then what's the point to even having sex then if he is just going to be wanked off (or sucked off) then? May as well not even have sex, and him finishing inside is really the whole entire point of sex. What you do sounds like an absolute misery, and not enjoyable at all. So why even bother having sex?

Crinklecuts · 19/06/2022 18:06

Worked for me for the past 7 years

Gigi42p · 19/06/2022 18:05

P.s I should also add that DH and I were not against having kids, so it was always - well if it happened it wouldn't be the end of the world - just not the best timing wise (more to do with careers etc) from the ages of 25-35yrs.

If I was in a place of I absolutely do not want to get pregnant, we would have used contraception.

pinkfondu · 19/06/2022 18:05

I think part of tge problem is the name, it suggests pulling out at the last minute.

serendipity8888 · 19/06/2022 18:05

We call it "pull and pray" lol

If you have sex on non fertile days it will work. However you have to KNOW when you are likely to ovulate...

If you ovulate late or early... you can get pregnant.

Use a condom

MrsGamgee · 19/06/2022 18:05

Just buy a box of condoms 🙄

skinnythick · 19/06/2022 18:04

if you’re happy having the sort of sex where you don’t get so absorbed into the pleasure of it that you can absolutely 100% stop to pull out, I guess it might work for you. Sounds joyless and mechanical to me but if you’re happy with it 🤷🏾‍♀️

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 18:04

BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 18:00

@LilyPotter44 Are you wilfully ignoring every post by all these women who are telling you this doesn’t work?

No but they seem to be wilfully ignoring every post I make about the timing issue not being relevant in my personal situation.

I haven't ignored the very relevant points about some people secreting sperm into pre cum.

If you read my posts I have quoted facts from the start and never tried to suggest or advocate that it's fool proof. I think I've been quite balanced and taken a lot on board. Unlike the people who have simply hopped on the thread to call me stupid while providing absolutely no counter discussion.

OP posts:
hammsalllad · 19/06/2022 18:04

Go for it if you would be absolutely 100% fine with the possibility of another baby.

Applesandroses · 19/06/2022 18:04

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 17:57

But that isn't the case for us.

But you've only been doing it for 3 months max, that's not proof of anything i.e. if your DH's pre cum does contain sperm or not, which is essentially what you are banking on.

Given some women do not resume ovulating until 3 months after giving birth, and you can resume periods before resuming ovulation, you literally could have been doing this for 3 months without ovulating and then fall pregnant next month because it turns out your DHs pre cum does contain sperm. You dont actually know yet

howtomoveforwards · 19/06/2022 18:03

It has it's place if you want to space babies and another pregnancy wouldn't be devastating.

But as you are awaiting a vasectomy, it seems your family is complete. In which case, preumably, another pregnancy is problematic. So why take the risk? Because it's risky. It carries a high failure rate in comparison with other methods of contraception.

Gigi42p · 19/06/2022 18:03

Worked for me for 10yrs. However, my period is every 27days. Regular as clock work, so it was withdrawal coupled with abstinence over the fertile window!

girlmom21 · 19/06/2022 18:02

So really you both want another baby and neither of you want to just say that out loud?

Because I don't understand why you'd take the risk unless it's actually what you wanted, especially if you're already on the waiting list for a vasectomy. You'd just use condoms for a few months.

Swipe left for the next trending thread