Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think withdrawal is quite safe...

269 replies

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 16:38

Whenever I see threads on here about natural family planning and the withdrawal method as means of contraception, people always act as if it's stupid and completely unreliable. Now don't get me wrong, it's not fool proof. But is it really as reckless as people make out?

Dh and I have recently had a baby (3 months ago) and are yet to sort contraception. I don't want to go back on the pill and he's thinking of getting a vasectomy but there's a wait. Having done my research it seems like withdrawal can work when done properly - i.e fully withdrawn a decent length of time before ejaculation not left right until the last second. Studies also seem to indicate that 'pre-ejaculate' for the most part doesn't contain sperm. So why are people so against it? Have you had any experience with it and did it work for you?

OP posts:
fuzzywuzzywombat · 19/06/2022 18:47

Just use a Johnny. FGS!

Crinklecuts · 19/06/2022 18:42

@WhenAllIsLost

oh my days you are rude!

flamingmango12 · 19/06/2022 18:42

Been with my partner from 1, we're now 34 and I'm pregnant after trying for one cycle. For roughly the last 8 years, we've done a mix of withdrawal method and watching the calendar, using condoms when I'm around ovulation time.

RampantIvy · 19/06/2022 18:38

Condoms are over 90% effective if used correctly. So the argument saying that they are the same as withdrawal is ridiculous. Are you saying that all condom users are reckless?

Having to withdraw every time can't be much fun for your partner @LilyPotter44

What is his opinion on the matter? And why are you so against other forms of contraception? Is it for religious reasons?

woulducouldushouldu · 19/06/2022 18:37

And you can't get pregnant on your first time, if you do it standing up, breastfeeding, etc

Come back in a couple of months and we can line eyes your (positive) pregnancy test

Momicrone · 19/06/2022 18:36

Condom failure can be when using condoms too

Momicrone · 19/06/2022 18:35

Worked for me too

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 18:35

TBF most "condom failure" is because they're not being used at all, let alone perfectly. They don't work particularly well when left on the bedside table.

😂

AuntMargo · 19/06/2022 18:34

I have grown up children and we did it for years, worked completely for us

Minniem2020 · 19/06/2022 18:32

I have 2 friends that got pregnant using this method. I wouldn't risk it for us as DP and I have got pregnant in the 1st month of trying for our planned babies and we now know for practical/financial reasons we can't have any more.

OperationRinka · 19/06/2022 18:31

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 18:26

Most contraception failures are due to imperfect use rather than a faulty product.

This particular method is a bugger (ho ho) for user error.

TBF most "condom failure" is because they're not being used at all, let alone perfectly. They don't work particularly well when left on the bedside table.

"Typical use" includes people who when asked "what contraception are you using?" tick the box marked Condoms, but who in the heat of the moment don't actually put them on.

Bobismyfriend · 19/06/2022 18:31

You do need to have absolute trust in your partner and he needs to have good control. This can definitely work well and has done for us for many years with no accidents.
I am surprised by those saying why bother having sex as it can't be good or romantic that way. There are so many different ways to be have sex. It seems outdated to suggest it can only be fulfilling if the man can ejaculate inside the woman.

user1471538283 · 19/06/2022 18:30

Why not use condoms? My bf's sister is the happy result of this method although it did mean two babies in under 13 months.

Hutchy16 · 19/06/2022 18:29

Just WOW - I have nothing to add other than that this thread is dumb, and you could have used Google to get sensible answers

GCRich · 19/06/2022 18:27

Testina · 19/06/2022 17:02

Not the most secure of methods, but perfectly fine for couples who are totally aligned on their abortion position.

A bit brutal but pretty fair! [I do get you said "aligned" not "both in favour of".]

ReneBumsWombats · 19/06/2022 18:26

RampantIvy · 19/06/2022 18:23

The argument about this method having a similar success rate as condoms is silly. Used properly the success rate of condoms is over 90%.

Is everyone saying that most people use condoms recklessly?

IME women who really don't want to get pregnant use the belt and braces approach of hormonal contraception (if they can) and condoms.

Most contraception failures are due to imperfect use rather than a faulty product.

This particular method is a bugger (ho ho) for user error.

Hallyup89 · 19/06/2022 18:26

Pre-ejaculate doesn't contain sperm in itself, you're right, but it's entirely possible for sperm to leak into it way before the guy actually ejaculates.

If you want another baby, crack on, otherwise sort some reliable contraception out.

AG1210 · 19/06/2022 18:26

I'm not against it if that's what people want to do, each time their own but it's not something I would ever risk. I have 2 kids, I categorically do not any more babies. It's not something I know much about but it wouldn't be for me.

also, I'm not man but I feel that having to think about withdrawing is crap and my partner would probably feel the same. Want to enjoy the moment.

I want my partner to have the snip too, but in the meantime I have the Mirena which suits me well. Only contraception that's agreed with me.

the pill, coils, implants etc etc are all free and readily available in this country. I get that some woman don't get on with hormonal contraception but condoms are an option too.

if he wants the snip it's clear babies are not on the agenda for him, so why risk it now?

BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 18:24

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 18:04

No but they seem to be wilfully ignoring every post I make about the timing issue not being relevant in my personal situation.

I haven't ignored the very relevant points about some people secreting sperm into pre cum.

If you read my posts I have quoted facts from the start and never tried to suggest or advocate that it's fool proof. I think I've been quite balanced and taken a lot on board. Unlike the people who have simply hopped on the thread to call me stupid while providing absolutely no counter discussion.

You have quoted myths, not facts, e.g. the one about there being no sperm in pre-ejaculate fluid and the other one about the withdrawal method being as effective as condoms. Neither of these are true.

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 18:23

Pretty sure that the only people advocating these sorts of contraceptions and trying to convince women they're effective are pro-lifers.

RampantIvy · 19/06/2022 18:23

The argument about this method having a similar success rate as condoms is silly. Used properly the success rate of condoms is over 90%.

Is everyone saying that most people use condoms recklessly?

IME women who really don't want to get pregnant use the belt and braces approach of hormonal contraception (if they can) and condoms.

LilyPotter44 · 19/06/2022 18:21

@ReneBumsWombats well for the most part it doesn't. The studies indicate that less than half of those tested had sperm in their pre ejaculate and even less had sperm that was motile. But I can appreciate that 'for the most part' isn't exactly fail safe.

The comments about joyless pointless sex are bitchy and spiteful, different things work for different people. I wasn't asking for comments on my bedroom habits.

Appreciate the intelligent, balanced replies and it's given me a lot to think about but in typical MN style it's getting a bit school playground like now so I'll be hiding the thread, thanks again to those who are intelligent enough to provide a proper discussion rather than insults and mocking.

OP posts:
BanjoVio · 19/06/2022 18:20

Ormally · 19/06/2022 18:12

Oh god. Thanks for that. I think I'll steel my resolve again on my inner dream of tubal litigation.

Hahaha 😆 I read that on a sexual health poster in an FE college I used to work at and I’ve never forgotten it.

OperationRinka · 19/06/2022 18:20

NHS quotes 82% "typical use" effectiveness for condoms.
www.nhs.uk/conditions/contraception/how-effective-contraception/. They're really not gold standard contraception, though I assume that number is a lot higher for mature couples who aren't having a drunken quickie with a new partner.

Withdrawal method is similar odds: it's a hell of a lot better than nothing taking your odds over a year from 4/5 to 1/5 but you definitely wouldn't want to rely on it if pregnancy would be a disaster.

And the answer to "why wouldn't you just use condoms?" is that I'd literally rather not have PIV sex at all than have it with a condom. We're all different.

Dededot · 19/06/2022 18:19

I have used this method for 5 years and never got pregnant, except for when I wanted to (and first month trying so it wasn't that we weren't very fertile). My DH pulls out at the last minute, but he has perfect control of this. Other men may not know when they're about to ejaculate as well as he does.

Swipe left for the next trending thread