Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Father’s Day if you have two mums

185 replies

Africa2004 · 19/06/2022 09:33

My daughter has two mums. We have a good relationship with her preschool & it’s never been an issue.
This Father’s Day they produced photos of each of the children holding signs dedicated to their daddy (a few said grandad). They posted these on social media. My child was the only one holding a sign dedicated to nobody, she looked very happy in the photo but it really upset me.
I can’t decide whether it’s no big deal or whether they should’ve asked/just put mummy or not posted on social media?

OP posts:
GettingEnoughMoonshine · 19/06/2022 11:20

I was raised by just my mother (fathers a dick who walked out on us for another woman).
On fathers day, they'd suggest I could make a card for a grandad, a card for someone's birthday, my mum or someone else in my family or just make a beautiful card for fun.. I'm sure she was given a similar set of options. Maybe she has made it for herself

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:20

The child is already here. There is NOTHING kind about your post calling the OP selfish & abhorrent for having a child in a presumably loving relationship!? You may think I'm disgusting that's absolutely fine, I think you are homophobic & a truly awful person for saying the vile things you have. I have many, many gay friends and some have children, it's not a decision taken lightly & the child is always the priority. For you to say otherwise is hurtful and cruel to be honest. The child in this case has already been born - no good can come of you attacking the OP and telling her what a terrible person she is. I can't engage with you any more you clearly believe you are right to spread the hate that you are.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:20

Thejoyfulstar · 19/06/2022 11:17

@Alb0 I didn't interpret what you said to be homophobic. There are legitimate ethical discussions around anonymous egg/sperm donation and the right to know one's biological ancestry. I don't know what the OP's exact situation is so I won't surmise, but I understand what you are saying, in general and agree.

Thank you.

BiscoffSundae · 19/06/2022 11:20

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 11:12

We always wrote, "Happy Father's Day Mum" on ours. I don't remember how it started, I always figured she did all the work raising us, so she got cards/presents for both days. There was no one else to address them to.

She left it blank, that’s her choice I did not want to tell her to write it to me that would have been wrong so she chose to leave it blank, she’s only just turned 5 last month I don’t think it would have occurred to her to write it to mum on Father’s Day.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:19

BattenburgDonkey · 19/06/2022 11:17

If the father isn’t a father figure they may not have told pre school because it’s none of their business, just as it’s none of yours. She hasn’t implied once she doesn’t no who the father is. Not that it’s relevant or deserving of your attack anyway.

they may not have told pre school

What's that got to do with anything?

The GIRL will know, she would have wrote his name.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:18

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:13

Well what about children whose parent have died? Dress it up any way you like- you aren't concerned for the children you just don't believe in same sex couples having a family. Luckily the views of the world are changing and it's becoming more common so these children who are 'grieving' a sperm donor will not be alone. Your argument is bizarre - no same sex couples should have a child unless they are willing to have a sperm donor parent with them. Remain childless or find a donor who is willing to actually become a parent with you & all that entails- oh but pretend to the child he is their uncle because when they turn 18 that won't be confusing at ALL. Bizarre.

What a bizarre post with desperate whataboutery. I said - WHERE POSSIBLE, ie except in the circumstances of abuse, desertion, death etc. Must every possible angle be covered for those goady people like yourself? There is a difference between knowingly keeping your child from half of themself (parent) to that parenting dying, or abandoning their mother, walking out or abuse, DV any other situation you can (and will) dream up to excuse your lack of critical thinking and reading skills.

Cornettoninja · 19/06/2022 11:17

WaterBottle123 · 19/06/2022 11:08

@Cornettoninja

Children have an entire planets worth of stuff to learn, believe me, their education won't be less 'holistic' if they skip learning about a few Hallmark holidays, which is what mothers and Father's Day have become.

For example, international womens day or mens health day would be outstanding alternative choices. And MUCH less commercial.

My DD’s school already does international womens day (but not mens mental health).

Just because you don’t put much value on fathers/Mother’s Day doesn’t mean no one else does and clearly they do. I’m just pointing out that missing out the ‘hallmark’ holidays that surround our society is a strange thing to do if you’re going to educate about wider celebrations. It’s separating education from the society it’s taking place in.

Thejoyfulstar · 19/06/2022 11:17

@Alb0 I didn't interpret what you said to be homophobic. There are legitimate ethical discussions around anonymous egg/sperm donation and the right to know one's biological ancestry. I don't know what the OP's exact situation is so I won't surmise, but I understand what you are saying, in general and agree.

BattenburgDonkey · 19/06/2022 11:17

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:15

If the daughter knew the father, they would be on the card. It's really that obvious. As is the case with a lesbian couple I know. They know their father and have a relationship with their father (albeit not the same as other heterosexual nuclear families) and put their father's name on cards. This girl doesn't seem to know who her father is.

If the father isn’t a father figure they may not have told pre school because it’s none of their business, just as it’s none of yours. She hasn’t implied once she doesn’t no who the father is. Not that it’s relevant or deserving of your attack anyway.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:15

BattenburgDonkey · 19/06/2022 11:13

I can’t see were the OP has said she doesn’t no who the child’s father is, she simply stated there are 2 mums and pre school left the card blank, it’s very vague. For all you no the father may be a friend that the kid nos that’s just not a ‘father’ figure. You have absolutely no idea you are just here to make assumptions, attack and throw your view in, and that says a lot about you.

If the daughter knew the father, they would be on the card. It's really that obvious. As is the case with a lesbian couple I know. They know their father and have a relationship with their father (albeit not the same as other heterosexual nuclear families) and put their father's name on cards. This girl doesn't seem to know who her father is.

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:13

Well what about children whose parent have died? Dress it up any way you like- you aren't concerned for the children you just don't believe in same sex couples having a family. Luckily the views of the world are changing and it's becoming more common so these children who are 'grieving' a sperm donor will not be alone. Your argument is bizarre - no same sex couples should have a child unless they are willing to have a sperm donor parent with them. Remain childless or find a donor who is willing to actually become a parent with you & all that entails- oh but pretend to the child he is their uncle because when they turn 18 that won't be confusing at ALL. Bizarre.

Cornettoninja · 19/06/2022 11:13

On Alb0’s point about grieving unknown parents (or a known one), I actually think it’s doing a disservice to children to engineer circumstances that completely erase the possibility of any hurt. In some ways it’s easier to process as a child before knowledge and experience muddies the waters especially if it’s handled sensitively by their primary parental figures. And that requires feeling the hurt.

BattenburgDonkey · 19/06/2022 11:13

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:10

Then your ignorance says everything about you, and nothing about me.

I NEVER said I have a problem with a child growing up with same sex parents. That is YOUR insinuation.

I simply said that even in a same sex couple, many couples ensure that the other parent is known to the child. The OP is not doing this it seems. Try to READ what is there, instead of jumping to froth at the mouth and make assumptions.

I can’t see were the OP has said she doesn’t no who the child’s father is, she simply stated there are 2 mums and pre school left the card blank, it’s very vague. For all you no the father may be a friend that the kid nos that’s just not a ‘father’ figure. You have absolutely no idea you are just here to make assumptions, attack and throw your view in, and that says a lot about you.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 19/06/2022 11:12

BiscoffSundae · 19/06/2022 10:51

I am a lone parent (ex not involved at all) I actually made my own post as my dd was upset about Father’s Day cards being made at school (she hasn’t wanted to go to school since) the school did do generic cards but dd doesn’t have relationship with my dad so she didn’t think to put grandad so hers was left blank, she’s been sad about it since I don’t know how some people can say it doesn’t affect children... there seems to be an assumption that if a child doesn’t have a dad then they have another person who acts like a dad like a grandad or an uncle and that’s just not always the case. Her teacher actually said lots of the children also have absent fathers hence why it’s generic cards.

We always wrote, "Happy Father's Day Mum" on ours. I don't remember how it started, I always figured she did all the work raising us, so she got cards/presents for both days. There was no one else to address them to.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:12

Soontobe60 · 19/06/2022 11:03

The comment is brutal, but why do you think of it as homophobic? It makes no mention of homosexuality. Presumably the poster would feel the same way about a single woman (or man) who chose to have a child via a sperm donor / surrogate?

Thank you. As someone who fought for same sex couples to marry, I find the small minded judgements of that poster to be disgusting. I am fully supportive of same sex couples to marry and to have children. I have never said otherwise.

I SIMPLY believe that the child has a right to develop their own relationship with the other biological parent.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:10

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:08

I presume they are homophobic as normal people do not have an issue with a child growing up with same sex parents - nor would they accuse a poster of being selfish and not looking out for the rights of their child by not providing them with a father. For all they know the child could have multiple father figures in their life however, they have chosen to tell the OP how awful she is for daring to have a family without a man present. Doesn't exactly scream open and welcoming does it?

Then your ignorance says everything about you, and nothing about me.

I NEVER said I have a problem with a child growing up with same sex parents. That is YOUR insinuation.

I simply said that even in a same sex couple, many couples ensure that the other parent is known to the child. The OP is not doing this it seems. Try to READ what is there, instead of jumping to froth at the mouth and make assumptions.

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 11:09

WaterBottle123 · 19/06/2022 09:59

Making children make a fathers or Mother's Day card for someone who is not their parent because that parent is dead or absent is INCREDIBLY CRUEL.

If the children appear happy doing it - know this - THEY ARE NOT, they are trying not to upset the adults around them,

I say this as the parent of children who lost their dad when they were extremely young and as the daughter of a absent dad. And as the friend of many other widow(ers).

Schools should be nowhere near these Hallmark holidays.

I cannot speak to the experiences of children of sex single sex couples as I have no experience, but I hope your daughter is ok OP.

^^ This.

I'm not sure how these things can be done inclusively so far better that schools just don't engage imo.

WaterBottle123 · 19/06/2022 11:08

@Cornettoninja

Children have an entire planets worth of stuff to learn, believe me, their education won't be less 'holistic' if they skip learning about a few Hallmark holidays, which is what mothers and Father's Day have become.

For example, international womens day or mens health day would be outstanding alternative choices. And MUCH less commercial.

Friendship101 · 19/06/2022 11:08

So I commented in agreement to the post saying you have created a fatherless child. You have, it’s a fact. However that doesn’t mean to me that she’s missing out on anything. All that matters is that she’s loved, which she clearly is as you’re concerned about her feelings about this so much.

At my children’s school they are taught very early about families coming in different shapes and forms. We have children from same sex parents, children who have been adopted, foster children and obviously children from single or separated parents. We’re far past the traditional family of a dad and a mum with their children so just focus on that. One of my children’s classmates made out her Father’s Day card to her mum even though she spends half her time with her Dad. The children are given a choice in this so maybe just work on differences in families with your daughter so she knows she can celebrate anyone. Maybe she really didn’t want to celebrate anyone else because she is so content with both her mums?

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:08

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:02

You are a disgusting person. Would you say the same if a male and female couple used donor sperm to conceive? No? Your attitude and views on same sex couples having children is appalling and I hope to god you never speak them in real life. This child is clearly loved by two parents. I sincerely hope you don't pass your views on to your own offspring. Vile.

Yes, I absolutely would say the same. You are disgusting for attacking me for thinking of the child.

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:08

Soontobe60 · 19/06/2022 11:03

The comment is brutal, but why do you think of it as homophobic? It makes no mention of homosexuality. Presumably the poster would feel the same way about a single woman (or man) who chose to have a child via a sperm donor / surrogate?

I presume they are homophobic as normal people do not have an issue with a child growing up with same sex parents - nor would they accuse a poster of being selfish and not looking out for the rights of their child by not providing them with a father. For all they know the child could have multiple father figures in their life however, they have chosen to tell the OP how awful she is for daring to have a family without a man present. Doesn't exactly scream open and welcoming does it?

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:07

InChocolateWeTrust · 19/06/2022 09:50

It causes so much heartache for that one child who doesn't have a parent.

Does it? My friend's son's has no mother and happily made a beautiful card for her grandma last mother's day. BILs nieces also have no mum and love taking their nan to the various celebrations.

I think sometimes we impose our own adult view of it on to the children, who are often amazingly resilient.

It does. Many children of same sex families have said how much they grieved for their missing parent growing up. This isn't homophobic, it's simply fact. Adults think of themselves, they don't stop to think of the children who will hurt and grieve for the missing parent and it does mess them up. I fought for the right for same sex couples to marry, I am no homophobe, I simply believe even in same sex families, the rights of the child to know, where possible, both parents should be upheld. Most gay couples I know, the child knows they have 3 parents (2 mums and 1 dad, or 2 dads and 1 mum), they aren't kept from the biological parent unlike in the OP's case.

Soontobe60 · 19/06/2022 11:05

Clymene · 19/06/2022 10:58

What the fuck? I'm sure the OP is absolutely aware of who her child's father is

Not if it’s an anonymous sperm donor.

Cornettoninja · 19/06/2022 11:05

WaterBottle123 · 19/06/2022 10:25

@Artwodeetoo

No I can't speak for them all. My point is WHY RISK IT?

The kindest and safest thing to do is not make cards, schools need to focus on education

A holistic education includes marking various celebrations. It’s ridiculous for a school that would mark all kinds celebrations (which I believe is part of the curriculum) to ignore mothers/Father’s Day when all a child has to do is walk into the local shop and see signs about marking it with cards/presents/meals. For a child that even slightly questions the world around them they’re going to notice it’s not mentioned leading to exactly the same scenario.

children without fathers or mothers, for whatever reason, aren’t protected from hurt or uncomfortable realisations by just pretending it doesn’t exist. Situations will arise that evoke exactly the same feelings and questions regardless of when or where. If the school fails to handle it sensitively or reassuringly then it falls to the parental figure to help them navigate a world where majorities exist and sometimes we’re outside of that.

JacquelineCarlyle · 19/06/2022 11:05

sittingnexttochoppysea · 19/06/2022 10:46

By trying to protect children from never feeling hurt you are doing them no favours in the long run.

I completely agree with this - we need to be teaching children to be resilient and helping them with techniques to overcome situations that may affect them negatively. Trying to shield them from anything that's possibly hurtful doesn't help them in the long run.

That said, regarding the Op, given the young age of the child and the specific situation, I'm surprised they didn't ask you how you'd like them to handle it. (Either by focusing on another male relative / friend, having her mums on the thank you, leaving it blank but not posting on social media, her not taking part in the task etc etc). There are so many things they could have done and they should have spoke to you about it. Anyway, the main thing is that she is ok, so I'd let it go but maybe speak to school in advance next year if you think it will be an issue for her or you want it to be handled differently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread