Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Father’s Day if you have two mums

185 replies

Africa2004 · 19/06/2022 09:33

My daughter has two mums. We have a good relationship with her preschool & it’s never been an issue.
This Father’s Day they produced photos of each of the children holding signs dedicated to their daddy (a few said grandad). They posted these on social media. My child was the only one holding a sign dedicated to nobody, she looked very happy in the photo but it really upset me.
I can’t decide whether it’s no big deal or whether they should’ve asked/just put mummy or not posted on social media?

OP posts:
pushingpoppies · 19/06/2022 12:18

What, so just because some people can't celebrate father's Day as in they don't have a living, good relationship with a male figure, so no one else at all gets to celebrate it? I'm sure you can work round it and be creative. This is aimed at posters saying whole thing should be banned or glossed over, by the way

Penguinsaregreat · 19/06/2022 12:14

I’m surprised schools do anything for Father’s Day.
the majority of children by the time they are 14 are not in a traditional nuclear family.
The average child will come from a broken home (insert whatever euphemism you like), or if their biological parents are still together, have half-siblings/step siblings.
WhereI live the majority of parents are not married either when they have a child.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/06/2022 12:11

There are legitimate ethical discussions around anonymous egg/sperm donation and the right to know one's biological ancestry.

You could say the same for adopted children.

Or surrogacy.

With surrogacy you've egg donation and the host, the host has no biological ties with baby though will have emotional ties growing the baby as pregnancy develops.

It'll be difficult for certain surrogate children to get their head around the ethical mindset of their arrival.

HelloDulling · 19/06/2022 12:09

To my mind, there's nothing sad, or shameful or embarrassing about her not having a dad, so nothing to be upset about. She has two brilliant mums, and hasn't lost a parent, it's just she has two who need a card at the end of March. But I'm surprised they didn't suggesting making it for Grandpa/Uncle Jack etc.

Latenightreader · 19/06/2022 11:59

I’m a solo parent and my daughter made a card with a picture of me on the front. For Mother’s Day the card had a preprinted bit which read ‘I love my mummy because…’ and a teacher had written the (very obviously) her words, but this time it just said ‘love [name]’. I had fully intended to remind the school she doesn’t have a dad, but it all seems to have been fine.

Cornettoninja · 19/06/2022 11:56

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:27

No. I mean there will be more support if this does turn out to be a significant problem. There has already been a change in legislation where sperm donors must agree to be contacted by any children concieved using their sperm, I assume from some children having a need to find out as they reach adulthood. I think I must be living in a parallel universe as it seems protecting the right of a same sex couple to have a family without being accused of being 'abhorrent' means I am an awful person. Good god.

I don’t think you’re awful or abhorrent but I do find a narrative that fails to take into account the impact on the resulting person hard to stomach.

Being different (as in away from the traditional family structure) is great, should be celebrated in fact, but that doesn’t mean that the downsides should be ignored or the complex feelings of the people created into these environments develop. All children go through a phase of wanting to be like someone else or get caught up in fads. It’s part of building a sense of belonging somewhere outside of your family unit, I suppose deeper than that it’s self preservation and understanding that your immediate family can’t protect you in a much bigger world.

Peers (who make up the majority just by way of biology and how most people are created) will talk about experiences you have no way to empathise with completely and force you into a role of observer and you’re immediately labelled as different. That’s fine when there’s an element of choice about it, it’s much harder to reconcile that when that’s just who you are and you need to be comfortable in a way that doesn’t come naturally.

Adults who speak on behalf of their children often fail to acknowledge that children often say what they think the adult wants to hear when what they really need is a space to put their own thoughts into words without influence.

Hallyup89 · 19/06/2022 11:55

You're not a father. She shouldn't have put mummy. She could have written it to any male role model in her life. She won't be the only one who doesn't see her dad. If she's happy, who cares? You've got to expect, and plan for, these problems when you choose to have a baby without being a traditional family.

WhenAllIsLost · 19/06/2022 11:55

If the school wrote it then they should have asked you how you wanted to handle it. However I do agree with a couple of others on here that it's wrong to stop a child from having a relationship with their other biological parent, all thinks being ok meaning there is not abuse etc. It is selfish and what will you do when you learn she resents you from keeping her from her dad. You need to think about that.

Trinity65 · 19/06/2022 11:52

WaterBottle123 · 19/06/2022 10:25

@Clymene

It's now a Hallmark holiday though. Origin is irrelevant.

In YOUR Opinion

InChocolateWeTrust · 19/06/2022 11:49

I wouldn't say that the vast majority of children have a mum and dad

Well statistically you would be wrong. You can google this sort of thing, I suggest you do. A minority of children have a completely absent/dead parent. A smaller minority have same sex parents. The majority have co-habiting male/female parents. A close second is male female parents not co-habiting but with regular contact.

WhatALoadOfWankiness · 19/06/2022 11:48

I think they left the card blank so you could choose at home who to give it to
I'm sure there's no malice in it

daisychain01 · 19/06/2022 11:41

SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 09:38

What was the sign then? Just blank? I'd expect the school to be aware that not everyone has a "dad" figure. Do they have your permission to put her on social media?

I find it staggering that a school would be so clueless in this day and age that they

a) stereotype what the members of the family include in 2022

b) make the broad assumption that all children have a father, to the extent that they will undoubtedly exclude those children who don't have a father because they've died, or have one who isn't in their life, or have 2 mums.

SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 11:39

It never used to be a thing schools get involved with or did it and it was just my school that didn't?

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 11:38

This obsession with children knowing their fathers has close links to the MRA movement and is a big factor in why access rights of violent, abusive men are prioritised over a child's needs. I know of children who were ordered to see their father even though he'd murdered their mother.

There was a thread on legal matters recently where a rapist was pursuing a DNA test. The mother of the child was warned by her solicitor to just acquiesce because the court would in all likelihood rule that the test had to go ahead. The fact that this child is being happily raised by the woman's husband is irrelevant - this dubious notion about 'knowing your origins' is apparently more important. That's the attitude that pervades in every single thread on here about same sex relationships, donor conception etc. Biology is king.

I think it's facile to say it's always in a child's interests to know their biological parents. This argument gets easily exploited.

123cupcake4 · 19/06/2022 11:36

I'm probably going to sound outdated and a bitch. But..... we can't cancel a celebration of a parent because some people have different styles of families. My mum.married 3 times and still I didn't have a father in my life because they where all twats. I didn't ever think it wasn't fair for.others to make something at school on fathers day. Nor did the child who didn't have a mum on mother's day.

We impose these issues on the kids when they don't see one. We do really seem to be changing and twisting ourselves for the minority.yes it's great we are more mindful and aware but we wouldn't cancel religious holidays because a minority wasn't religious. Might be a poor example.

If she was happy and smiling then I would be happy she was included and not left to watch

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/06/2022 11:35

It's an awkward day for many DC.

I'm another who believes it should not be done in schools.

My DC's school request a card for a special man in their life, brother, grandfather not every DC has a male supportive figure in their life.

A friend died suddenly 6 years ago, her DD was 3 it must be heartbreaking for her on the day, I always think about her during the dreaded week.

Zilla1 · 19/06/2022 11:31

HNRTT and am not sure I want to judging by the number of deleted posts but perhaps download and print the photo published on social media with the blank poster then get your DC to hand write her mums' names in the space or the name of any suitable male relative? Regarding whether to be upset with the school, perhaps wonder what your ideal would have been for your circumstances on father's day and how the school would have known that. If your answer would have been not to do anything then ask yourself if you would then be upset if they'd chosen similarly to do nothing on Mothering Sunday? If you have very firm opinions then perhaps send a note to school or call the teacher in advance next time?

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:29

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:23

You clearly don't get it and clearly lack English comprehension and critical thinking skills. I have nothing against same sex people having a child!!!

I simply say the child should also know their other biological/donor parent.

Is that really so hard to understand?

Except, you don't simply say that. You called the OP unkind, selfish and abhorrent. You could have simply said the child should be able to contact their sperm donor as it has been shown children grieve the loss of the other parent etc. whereby the poster may have replied they are aware of this etc. You chose to attack her and be unkind.

Artwodeetoo · 19/06/2022 11:28

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:23

You clearly don't get it and clearly lack English comprehension and critical thinking skills. I have nothing against same sex people having a child!!!

I simply say the child should also know their other biological/donor parent.

Is that really so hard to understand?

But rightly so as its none of our business OP hasn't spoken about this, you're assuming. Or are you really suggesting that a pre school age child writes a fathers day card to someone who is likely to have just been a sperm donor?

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:27

Cornettoninja · 19/06/2022 11:23

Luckily the views of the world are changing and it's becoming more common so these children who are 'grieving' a sperm donor will not be alone

what a bizarre, dismissive statement?

‘Luckily’ these people, whose grief you don’t recognise, will all be able to get together to keep their feelings to themselves so you don’t have to be bothered by them?

No. I mean there will be more support if this does turn out to be a significant problem. There has already been a change in legislation where sperm donors must agree to be contacted by any children concieved using their sperm, I assume from some children having a need to find out as they reach adulthood. I think I must be living in a parallel universe as it seems protecting the right of a same sex couple to have a family without being accused of being 'abhorrent' means I am an awful person. Good god.

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 11:25

BattenburgDonkey · 19/06/2022 11:23

She’s in PRE SCHOOL, how many pre schoolers are that great at writing other peoples names? You’ll just argue regardless though so I’m finishing up here, it’s clear we won’t agree. You did make me laugh when you called someone else goady though 😅

This is MN, you’ll have people posting that their child could write mutliple names in perfect cursive at pre-school.

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:23

Thefoxsays · 19/06/2022 11:20

The child is already here. There is NOTHING kind about your post calling the OP selfish & abhorrent for having a child in a presumably loving relationship!? You may think I'm disgusting that's absolutely fine, I think you are homophobic & a truly awful person for saying the vile things you have. I have many, many gay friends and some have children, it's not a decision taken lightly & the child is always the priority. For you to say otherwise is hurtful and cruel to be honest. The child in this case has already been born - no good can come of you attacking the OP and telling her what a terrible person she is. I can't engage with you any more you clearly believe you are right to spread the hate that you are.

You clearly don't get it and clearly lack English comprehension and critical thinking skills. I have nothing against same sex people having a child!!!

I simply say the child should also know their other biological/donor parent.

Is that really so hard to understand?

Cornettoninja · 19/06/2022 11:23

Luckily the views of the world are changing and it's becoming more common so these children who are 'grieving' a sperm donor will not be alone

what a bizarre, dismissive statement?

‘Luckily’ these people, whose grief you don’t recognise, will all be able to get together to keep their feelings to themselves so you don’t have to be bothered by them?

BattenburgDonkey · 19/06/2022 11:23

Alb0 · 19/06/2022 11:19

they may not have told pre school

What's that got to do with anything?

The GIRL will know, she would have wrote his name.

She’s in PRE SCHOOL, how many pre schoolers are that great at writing other peoples names? You’ll just argue regardless though so I’m finishing up here, it’s clear we won’t agree. You did make me laugh when you called someone else goady though 😅

WhatALoadOfWankiness · 19/06/2022 11:22

Bloody hell, this is ridiculous now...
Speak to the school @Africa2004 to find out what happened if you are upset

Swipe left for the next trending thread