Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Father’s Day if you have two mums

185 replies

Africa2004 · 19/06/2022 09:33

My daughter has two mums. We have a good relationship with her preschool & it’s never been an issue.
This Father’s Day they produced photos of each of the children holding signs dedicated to their daddy (a few said grandad). They posted these on social media. My child was the only one holding a sign dedicated to nobody, she looked very happy in the photo but it really upset me.
I can’t decide whether it’s no big deal or whether they should’ve asked/just put mummy or not posted on social media?

OP posts:
Africa2004 · 19/06/2022 19:24

WhenAllIsLost · 19/06/2022 19:18

I had read the entire thread even before deletions and I saw no 'hate', just people saying your daughter had a right to have a relationship with her father and that many/most ss relationships usually make sure the child has a relationship during childhood with the father/donor. Which I am sure most would agree with. I think you've manufactured hate where there is none because you didn't like the answers and it made a you feel a bit guilty.

You’re wrong. I don’t feel guilt, why does she need that relationship? She has two loving parents and a huge family. Would you advise a straight couple who used a speed donor to maintain a relationship with the donor?
the hate was minimal but referred mostly to the person who said I was selfish & abhorrent and bought this situation on myself.
the fact there have been deletions proves there was some breach of kindness.

OP posts:
WhenAllIsLost · 19/06/2022 19:18

I had read the entire thread even before deletions and I saw no 'hate', just people saying your daughter had a right to have a relationship with her father and that many/most ss relationships usually make sure the child has a relationship during childhood with the father/donor. Which I am sure most would agree with. I think you've manufactured hate where there is none because you didn't like the answers and it made a you feel a bit guilty.

Africa2004 · 19/06/2022 19:11

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/06/2022 17:35

I have a memory of the compulsory Fathers' Day card making being the first time I got angry/stroppy in school. I had no memory of ever having to make one before, which probably means I'd been taken for another activity since I was in Reception - this was in Year 4.

The supply teacher ordered me to make one even though I'd said that I didn't have a father. She'd told me that everybody did, I was being silly and if I didn't make one, I'd be kept behind after school until I did. So I stomped back to my table and drew one of a graveyard out of sheer bloodymindedness.

One of the other regular teachers came into the class shortly afterwards, said hello to me/asked about my picture and I complained at great length that that teacher had said she was going to keep me behind unless I made a Fathers' Day card, so I'm doing one of where my father is and I didn't think my Mum was going to be very happy - whilst adding extra vampire bats over the big headstone labelled DAD.

Five minutes later, I was collected by the Headmaster because 'Mrs B needs somebody to help her in the Office this afternoon'. I got to use the Banda printer, so I was happy, albeit still cross that the supply teacher wouldn't listen to me. I assume that my mother had been phoned and asked to pick me up from the office instead of the usual location and been told I'd kicked up a fuss, as she asked me what happened and I then grumbled at her about it.

That’s sounds horrendous, I’m sorry you were put in that situation but love how you dealt with it (& the name)

OP posts:
Africa2004 · 19/06/2022 19:08

Wow, didn’t mean to start a debate on same sex parenting. We’re comfortable with that decision and as pointed out, our daughter is here so your hate and pity is not needed. She’s happy and loved.
to answer some questions-she will have a relationship with the donor (he’s not a dad) when she’s older.
she has many male role models in her life (yes I have a dad). They didn’t ask. But I take on board they may have asked dd and all the people she adores happen to be female.
i have talked to her about fathers, we’ve read so many books on different families. My concern wasn’t Father’s Day but having a card to hold up with nobody’s name on it (ie different to the rest of the children).
I am in no way comparing our situation to bereaved children. Although my partner lost her dad at a young age and very much remembers how hard the day was for her in school.
thanks again, everyone (even the haters, you’ve opened my eyes to what we may have to contend with as a family).

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 19/06/2022 17:35

If they approached you, what-who would you have suggested? What did she have on her sign?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/06/2022 17:35

I have a memory of the compulsory Fathers' Day card making being the first time I got angry/stroppy in school. I had no memory of ever having to make one before, which probably means I'd been taken for another activity since I was in Reception - this was in Year 4.

The supply teacher ordered me to make one even though I'd said that I didn't have a father. She'd told me that everybody did, I was being silly and if I didn't make one, I'd be kept behind after school until I did. So I stomped back to my table and drew one of a graveyard out of sheer bloodymindedness.

One of the other regular teachers came into the class shortly afterwards, said hello to me/asked about my picture and I complained at great length that that teacher had said she was going to keep me behind unless I made a Fathers' Day card, so I'm doing one of where my father is and I didn't think my Mum was going to be very happy - whilst adding extra vampire bats over the big headstone labelled DAD.

Five minutes later, I was collected by the Headmaster because 'Mrs B needs somebody to help her in the Office this afternoon'. I got to use the Banda printer, so I was happy, albeit still cross that the supply teacher wouldn't listen to me. I assume that my mother had been phoned and asked to pick me up from the office instead of the usual location and been told I'd kicked up a fuss, as she asked me what happened and I then grumbled at her about it.

KoalasNext15km · 19/06/2022 17:04

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 16:53

Have you read the thread at all? The OP said her daughter has two mothers! Zero mention of their child losing a parent!!

Exactly - I am talking about a situation where the child has two loving parents, no trauma, but there is a predictable awkwardness on this particular day.

Blondeshavemorefun · 19/06/2022 17:01

InChocolateWeTrust · 19/06/2022 09:43

There are so many children now who don't have a traditional mum and dad.

But there arent. There are relatively few young children who have a completely absent/dead parent.

Statistically, the vast majority have a mother and a father, even if they are separated. Children who don't often have a grandfather/mother, aunts and uncles who can be celebrated?

Its about celebrating special people in our lives, not traditional nuclear families.

Not in way there isnt

widowed and young

many children in that group have no mum or dad coz dead

same With the group I admin on for suicide

have many members feeling Shit today as they can celebrate with their dad but their children can’t

I do agree should be a special persons day sometimes rather then mum or dad

is your dad not about @Africa2004

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 16:53

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 16:51

Please don't presume to tell widows how to make their children feel secure. Father's Day is not a 'great opportunity' for a kid whose own dad dropped dead in front of them.

Have you read the thread at all? The OP said her daughter has two mothers! Zero mention of their child losing a parent!!

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 16:51

KoalasNext15km · 19/06/2022 16:44

You have a great opportunity here to shape the narrative for your child in a very positive way, e.g. "Some people celebrate Father's day, but in our family we like to do x and y for Mother's day which is extra special because .... "

You can anticipate the situation, and make your child feel secure and supported while letting them know that other families are different and do things in different ways.

Children do compare themselves to others - I should think that's unavoidable - but there's no reason for your child to make an unfavourable comparison.

Please don't presume to tell widows how to make their children feel secure. Father's Day is not a 'great opportunity' for a kid whose own dad dropped dead in front of them.

KittenKong · 19/06/2022 16:51

Our teachers check with the office if there is a dad/grandfather in the picture.

But not all families tell you what’s going on at home - of course they don’t need to tell you anything but it helps in some circumstances especially when there is a nasty break up or divorce going through, or dad has swanned off and mum doesn’t want him collecting the kids.

KoalasNext15km · 19/06/2022 16:44

You have a great opportunity here to shape the narrative for your child in a very positive way, e.g. "Some people celebrate Father's day, but in our family we like to do x and y for Mother's day which is extra special because .... "

You can anticipate the situation, and make your child feel secure and supported while letting them know that other families are different and do things in different ways.

Children do compare themselves to others - I should think that's unavoidable - but there's no reason for your child to make an unfavourable comparison.

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 16:37

WhenAllIsLost · 19/06/2022 12:52

Every child still has a mother and a father, we have not yet reached the point where we can create a child from two women only or two men only. I know a few ss couples and they've ensured the biological mother / biological father is known to the child and the child has a relationship with them. That's as should be. Barring abuse or death of course.

I guess that's the point. The ones who have absent parents through abuse or death feel a bit shit when schools enthusiastically encourage kids to make/buy gifts for these non-existent parents.

So given that schools can't realistically be inclusive or prevent that pain, isn't it better to just not get involved at all?

WhenAllIsLost · 19/06/2022 12:52

Every child still has a mother and a father, we have not yet reached the point where we can create a child from two women only or two men only. I know a few ss couples and they've ensured the biological mother / biological father is known to the child and the child has a relationship with them. That's as should be. Barring abuse or death of course.

Penguinsaregreat · 19/06/2022 12:45

Nobody is wrapping kids in cotton wool.
The reality is weather you like it or not, the majority of children do not live in some Janet and John book where they live with happily married parents who are heterosexual. Where there are a biological mother and a biological father and 2 children. Life is not like that for many, many children.
Yes there might be a man in their life but so what? He is not their father just some guy who statistically will not be there for the rest of their life.
Plenty of children know some kind of woman but that does not make them their mother either.
I have no skin in this game just stating facts.

Mittens1717 · 19/06/2022 12:41

I cannot understand why schools still do this every year, by all means celebrate Mothers and Fathers day but let the children make their cards at home if they wish to do so, it shouldn't have anything to do with the school really

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/06/2022 12:39

No one said it should be banned. Just that schools shouldn't celebrate it. 👍

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 12:32

WaterBottle123 · 19/06/2022 10:25

@Artwodeetoo

No I can't speak for them all. My point is WHY RISK IT?

The kindest and safest thing to do is not make cards, schools need to focus on education

But that's the thing. It is an education... First of all you have the writing skills, creative skills, colouring skills, etc that goes with card making. Then you also have the life skills, educating that everyone has different families, resilience, that it's OK to feel a little sad and learn how to deal with those emotions..... Wrapping our kids in cotton wool and shielding them from any form of discomfort is hardly doing them justice for life! They will not be shielded from days like fathers day / mothers day forever and need to learn how to cope with it! And sorry but in the majority of schools, children without any sort of male / female role model would be in the minority... Just another example of where minorities rule the roost yet again!

OP I'm sorry you felt upset by this. All we can do is learn and move forward. Perhaps next year have a convo in advance if their is a male figure they would like to dedicate fathers day too.

Comedycook · 19/06/2022 12:32

pushingpoppies · 19/06/2022 12:18

What, so just because some people can't celebrate father's Day as in they don't have a living, good relationship with a male figure, so no one else at all gets to celebrate it? I'm sure you can work round it and be creative. This is aimed at posters saying whole thing should be banned or glossed over, by the way

No one said it should be banned. Just that schools shouldn't celebrate it.

Luckily my DC's headteacher is very sensible and ignores both mothers and fathers day at the school.

FAQs · 19/06/2022 12:32

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 12:19

So I thought I'd put this to someone with some experience...

I just asked my nine year old who lost his dad aged five whether he'd prefer it if schools didn't get involved with mother's and father's day.

He instantly answered 'They shouldn't. It makes me feel very left out'.

I was surprised actually. He normally puts aside his feelings to see 'the bigger picture' and wouldn't dream of special treatment but he feels quite strongly about this he said.

My daughter was the same, I don’t see why Schools have to be involved in Mothers/Fathers day as it’s a family event which should be left to the families to navigate.

It’s also unfair on those in foster care in School settings.

ElenaSt · 19/06/2022 12:31

But on Mother's Day she will have two cards to make so I can't see the big deal about this.

Comedycook · 19/06/2022 12:31

You're not a father. She shouldn't have put mummy

Ohhhh why's that? Will it upset the marketing men who ram father's Day down our throats?! She can put whatever she wants...it's hurting no one.

Thejoyfulstar · 19/06/2022 12:28

EmeraldShamrock1 · 19/06/2022 12:11

There are legitimate ethical discussions around anonymous egg/sperm donation and the right to know one's biological ancestry.

You could say the same for adopted children.

Or surrogacy.

With surrogacy you've egg donation and the host, the host has no biological ties with baby though will have emotional ties growing the baby as pregnancy develops.

It'll be difficult for certain surrogate children to get their head around the ethical mindset of their arrival.

Yes I do think the same for those issues.

1000yellowdaisies · 19/06/2022 12:23

pushingpoppies · 19/06/2022 12:18

What, so just because some people can't celebrate father's Day as in they don't have a living, good relationship with a male figure, so no one else at all gets to celebrate it? I'm sure you can work round it and be creative. This is aimed at posters saying whole thing should be banned or glossed over, by the way

They are perfectly able to celebrate it as a family at home. But there isnt any reason why it needs to be an activity at school.

orwellwasright · 19/06/2022 12:19

So I thought I'd put this to someone with some experience...

I just asked my nine year old who lost his dad aged five whether he'd prefer it if schools didn't get involved with mother's and father's day.

He instantly answered 'They shouldn't. It makes me feel very left out'.

I was surprised actually. He normally puts aside his feelings to see 'the bigger picture' and wouldn't dream of special treatment but he feels quite strongly about this he said.

Swipe left for the next trending thread