Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to just go with the weird double barrel?

62 replies

victorioussponges · 19/06/2022 08:37

DH and I got married last year. Beforehand, DH had suggested of his own accord that he take my surname. His is quite difficult to spell whereas mine is more distinctive. I said that was entirely his choice - I was also open to double barrelling our names (even though it becomes quite a long, odd mouthful) or we could each stick with our names and have a think later about what to do for any children. I just would prefer not to take his as I feel a bit odd about the tradition.

We ended up sticking with our names after DH aired the idea of changing to mine with his parents and after initially not saying anything, his DF seemed to get pretty upset about it on our wedding day and it left a bit of a cloud.

Roll on to now when we've been TTC for a while, so the question of names has come up again, and DH says because of his DF's reaction any children will definitely need to have his surname or his surname followed by mine, or his DF will be "devastated".

I'm a bit annoyed that tradition is overriding the option of taking my name - which was DH's preference - but I don't want to be hypocritical as I appreciate I'm being a bit inflexible in not wanting to take his. I see the only suitable compromise to be the double barrel but the result would be pretty long and impractical - is that a bit unfair on a child?

Even if we don't manage to have a child I think we need to get to the bottom of it, as every time I visit DPIL they ask if I've changed my name to theirs yet...

OP posts:
SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 08:58

victorioussponges · 19/06/2022 08:56

Thanks all - yes I think I'm biting my tongue a bit in my OP 😅 the whole "tradition" annoys me. No judgement against people who choose to change their name, but it's when you're following it mindlessly when there are practical reasons not to that it all seems bizarre.

@KangarooKenny middle name is a really interesting idea, thank you! Then it gives the child a bit more of a say as to how much they use the full version. Definitely will give that more thought.

@SandyWedges I just say: "We have kept our names as they are" and then glare at DH to pick it up from there/shut it down as I figure it's for him to manage his parents there!

Yes I agree your DH needs to step up when you're asked and say, please stop asking, we'll let you know if we ever change our names.

victorioussponges · 19/06/2022 08:56

Thanks all - yes I think I'm biting my tongue a bit in my OP 😅 the whole "tradition" annoys me. No judgement against people who choose to change their name, but it's when you're following it mindlessly when there are practical reasons not to that it all seems bizarre.

@KangarooKenny middle name is a really interesting idea, thank you! Then it gives the child a bit more of a say as to how much they use the full version. Definitely will give that more thought.

@SandyWedges I just say: "We have kept our names as they are" and then glare at DH to pick it up from there/shut it down as I figure it's for him to manage his parents there!

OP posts:
SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 08:54

It's understandable FIL was upset. It's tradition (in the U.K. anyway) & carrying on the name is traditionally important to a lot of people. He can be upset all he wants but I don't see why that should stop OP and her DH doing what they want with their and their children's names?

parietal · 19/06/2022 08:53

Let the kids has HisName as an additional middle name. So

Babyname MiddleName HisName HerName
Oliver Jonas Higglepop Smith

That way, his name is preserved and the child can use it in future if they want but they don't have to spell it out for every form.

LividLaVidaLoca · 19/06/2022 08:53

My kid has an uber-weird double barrel because I kept my weird name and DH kept his.

Nothing else would seem fair.

(DH’s family still send cards and gifts to me personally with weird combinations of surnames on, which doesn’t actually bother me as I accept I’m the one going against the patriarchy norm)

3luckystars · 19/06/2022 08:50

Could you merge the names?

my friends double barrelled their names when they go married 50 years ago and it’s a real mouthful, they said they regretted it.

pick what YOU BOTH LIKE and ignore everything else.

How often will your family actually be using your name anyway, just tell PIL you picked his name for a quiet life, you don’t have to prove anything to them, it’s not a big deal.

JuneJubilee · 19/06/2022 08:50

It's understandable FIL was upset. It's tradition (in the U.K. anyway) & carrying on the name is traditionally important to a lot of people.

nothing wrong with that, despite the sneery posts.

It's difficult to say what I'd do as a lot depends on the actual names.

one of my ex's had a really terrible surname & wanted to take mine when we got married (we didn't get married in the end, but his parents would have hit the roof. So I don't know what he'd have done, kept his I suspect!) but I'd have kept mine & any kids would have had mine as he wouldn't have put kids through what he went through.

but if it's just tricky spelling I'd change my name (it's just easier.) and so obviously give the kids 'our' name.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 19/06/2022 08:48

Why don't you choose a new surname together?
combine parts of both or a totally new one?
it's pathetic that your DH has changed his mind because his father is acting out. I hope you've told them you're never changing your name!!

lookforthesun · 19/06/2022 08:45

This isn't your FIL's child. He has had his turn to name his children, now it's your turn.

I think your DH needs to grow a backbone and follow through with his own decision to take your name.

You can't let this impact your future children and their names. It is a choice between you and your DH and it sounds like you're already agreed and realised that just having your name is the sensible option.

FIL will have to stop being such a chauvinist and accept the decision. Also come up with some good one liners to stop the constant comments. They're rude and tiresome.

SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 08:41

Even if we don't manage to have a child I think we need to get to the bottom of it, as every time I visit DPIL they ask if I've changed my name to theirs yet... What do you say? Do you say, no still thinking about it? Or no, and I'm never going to so please stop asking its really irritating.

KangarooKenny · 19/06/2022 08:40

Have his surname as a middle name, and yours as the surname. It will look double barrelled on paper, even if it isn’t.
But as your DH obviously doesn’t have a back bone, you’re going to have to accept his name or a double barrel.

SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 08:40

No this would be your child. Not DH's DF. He can get over his weird obsession with names. If he's devastated find a counsellor for him. It's a weird obsession some people seem to have with carrying on the family name. My inlaws were similar and FIL was gutted we had a girl as there weren't many boys to carry on the family name. Ridiculous.