Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to just go with the weird double barrel?

62 replies

victorioussponges · 19/06/2022 08:37

DH and I got married last year. Beforehand, DH had suggested of his own accord that he take my surname. His is quite difficult to spell whereas mine is more distinctive. I said that was entirely his choice - I was also open to double barrelling our names (even though it becomes quite a long, odd mouthful) or we could each stick with our names and have a think later about what to do for any children. I just would prefer not to take his as I feel a bit odd about the tradition.

We ended up sticking with our names after DH aired the idea of changing to mine with his parents and after initially not saying anything, his DF seemed to get pretty upset about it on our wedding day and it left a bit of a cloud.

Roll on to now when we've been TTC for a while, so the question of names has come up again, and DH says because of his DF's reaction any children will definitely need to have his surname or his surname followed by mine, or his DF will be "devastated".

I'm a bit annoyed that tradition is overriding the option of taking my name - which was DH's preference - but I don't want to be hypocritical as I appreciate I'm being a bit inflexible in not wanting to take his. I see the only suitable compromise to be the double barrel but the result would be pretty long and impractical - is that a bit unfair on a child?

Even if we don't manage to have a child I think we need to get to the bottom of it, as every time I visit DPIL they ask if I've changed my name to theirs yet...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FayCarew · 19/06/2022 14:24

@balalake , Mr Portillo is the child of a spanish father and a scottish mother. The Xavier is a middle name not a surname

NotSoLittle · 19/06/2022 14:17

MargosKaftan · 19/06/2022 11:30

I agree with having it as a middle name, bur does FIL need to know its not dcs legal surname and a middle name? You just say "this is your granddaughter, Rosie Smith Jones" (Smith being DH name, Jones being yours). Let your PIL "hear" the double barrel then register at school and everything else as Rosie S. Jones.

I'd do this. (Going back in my family it's been "traditional" for the mother's maiden name to be the child's middle name with the father's being the surname.) Then you can double barrel it or not as you want

Notanotherwindow · 19/06/2022 14:17

I'd just pick a completely new surname between you both and change to that.

Wiiiiiiilllllsssssonnnnnn · 19/06/2022 14:10

We got married over 25 years ago and my husband took my name. A couple of people disapproved but we didn’t care.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 19/06/2022 14:08

PraiseBee · 19/06/2022 09:52

How do the surnames proceed when two double barreled people have kids together? What happens in Spain?

They use one from each and make a new double surname

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 19/06/2022 12:10

I know. He’s beyond sexist. Has 4 sons and puffs up his chest about “the family line”.

2 of them had children without getting married - kids have their mums names.

We were married but didn’t change names (and DD got one because I did all the hard work getting her here).

One SIL did change her name and passed the married name onto her kids but wished she hadn’t when her dad died and she realised nobody would be carrying the name on.

I was done with niceties years ago. I call him out on his sexism. Luckily they live several hours away so we don’t see them unless we make the effort.

SandyWedges · 19/06/2022 12:09

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 19/06/2022 12:05

FIL is still furious that we didn’t bank the cheque he gave us when we got married. He had made it out to Mr + Mrs Hisname, despite knowing that I wasn’t changing my name. We also don’t have a joint account so it needed to be adjusted to be in DH’s name only in order to be banked, which he refused.

20 years on he genuinely thinks that I should have gone through the hassle of changing my name and opening a new account just to bank a £150 cheque. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I make it clear that I’ve no interest in aligning myself more directly with that thought of thinking than my own progressive parents. Gave DD my name too. He was incensed.

Woah! Thats disgusting, trying to bribe you.

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 12:06

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 19/06/2022 12:05

FIL is still furious that we didn’t bank the cheque he gave us when we got married. He had made it out to Mr + Mrs Hisname, despite knowing that I wasn’t changing my name. We also don’t have a joint account so it needed to be adjusted to be in DH’s name only in order to be banked, which he refused.

20 years on he genuinely thinks that I should have gone through the hassle of changing my name and opening a new account just to bank a £150 cheque. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I make it clear that I’ve no interest in aligning myself more directly with that thought of thinking than my own progressive parents. Gave DD my name too. He was incensed.

Wow, it's like he was trying to pay you to change your name. The audacity!

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 19/06/2022 12:05

FIL is still furious that we didn’t bank the cheque he gave us when we got married. He had made it out to Mr + Mrs Hisname, despite knowing that I wasn’t changing my name. We also don’t have a joint account so it needed to be adjusted to be in DH’s name only in order to be banked, which he refused.

20 years on he genuinely thinks that I should have gone through the hassle of changing my name and opening a new account just to bank a £150 cheque. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I make it clear that I’ve no interest in aligning myself more directly with that thought of thinking than my own progressive parents. Gave DD my name too. He was incensed.

HoppingPavlova · 19/06/2022 12:03

@Simonjt However with children I do think they should share names with their parents, so when parents have different surnames I do think its better if the child has two surnames.

Why is that? Our (bio) children don’t have either my surname or DH’s. We made up a really cool one using the letters of both of our surnames. It’s fantastic and our kids have always loved it. Funnily, even with a different surname they knew we were mum and dad! There was never any confusion, schools knew who we were in relation to each other, the Government was across the fact we were their parents, we never once had anyone confused as to the parent/child relationship probably given away by us calling them ‘our children’ and them referring to us as ‘mum/dad’.

They are adults now and still really grateful they have such a fantabulous surname. The only thing that has ever mattered to them is that they all have the same surname, never asked why but it is something that seems important to them. I doubt my DD would ever change if she gets married but I’m pretty sure her siblings would have strong words in advance to ensure this!

HoppingPavlova · 19/06/2022 11:42

as every time I visit DPIL they ask if I've changed my name to theirs yet...

Just look super confused and say ‘uhhmm, no, why would I?’. If they bring up some bunk about tradition, look amused and say ‘oh Barry/Nancy you are SO funny’ ending with a laugh. They’ll drop it.

MargosKaftan · 19/06/2022 11:30

I agree with having it as a middle name, bur does FIL need to know its not dcs legal surname and a middle name? You just say "this is your granddaughter, Rosie Smith Jones" (Smith being DH name, Jones being yours). Let your PIL "hear" the double barrel then register at school and everything else as Rosie S. Jones.

Derbee · 19/06/2022 11:15

Seeing as your DH has no backbone, you’ll need to be the strong one. When FIL asks when you’re changing your name you reply “I’m not. Ever. So you may as well stop asking!” And then move the conversation on.

When FIL complains about your child’s name you respond “You’ve named your children. It’s our turn now, and this is what we’ve chosen” and again, move the conversation on.

If he keeps coming back to complaining a simple “I’m not discussing this with you anymore” is surely sufficient?

Iliada · 19/06/2022 11:09

PraiseBee · 19/06/2022 09:52

How do the surnames proceed when two double barreled people have kids together? What happens in Spain?

In Spain people often use one of the surnames as their main surname, normal the one that comes first.

Each of the couple passes on one of their surnames, normally the one they use most commonly as their ‘main’ surname.

It used to traditionally be the father’s surname that was passed on to kids as it would be most people’s first surname, but you could always choose the mother’s name as your professional name instead and nowadays you can pass on whichever surname you like more in whatever order you prefer. It’s especially common to pass on a more unusual surname, as otherwise it might disappear.

So in modern times María Dolores García Jones and José Manuel Gil Rodríguez could have a kid who had any two of those four surnames, whichever their parents used most or preferred.

Each person still has to pick just one of their surnames. But it’s normally not a big deal at all.

I should say that also you can only legally have one middle name (which is often used as a first name anyway to get around the number of first name Josés and Marías) in Spain. Not like in the U.K. where you can have four middle names if you want.

CaptSkippy · 19/06/2022 10:57

I'd say it's time to shut down the nagging of your father in law. It's none of his beeswax. You made an agreement with your husband about names and you have stuck to it. It doesn't matter that your father in law is feeling butt-hurt about it. He doesn't own you and neither does your husband.

In fact I am appalled your husband allows his parents to keep harassing you about it. Totally unacceptable. What will happen if you do have children? I can garantee you they will try to meddle a lot more in your affairs than they do now.

As for your children, they should get your last name. All your husband has to do is ejeculate. You will have to be pregnant for 9 months and then give birth. Even if your husband is as supportive as a partner should be during the pregnancy and the birth, he will not have to endure what you will endure to even make children happen.

Do not give in.

Simonjt · 19/06/2022 10:53

FIL needs to grow up, when we got married my husband changed his surname to match mine. When his parents found out (not at the wedding due to covid) they both threw their toys out the pram and acted like spoiled little babies. They’re still passive aggressive about it and have made fairly innapropriate comments to their 9 year old son about what he has to do when he is older to remain part of the family. Wankers.

However with children I do think they should share names with their parents, so when parents have different surnames I do think its better if the child has two surnames.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 19/06/2022 10:51

EveryName · 19/06/2022 10:17

I don't get the issue really. Using the 'it's difficult to spell' reason not to use a name is a bit daft. Loads of names are difficult to spell. Mine is but I have an everyday abbreviation for general use and only use the full name when needed. Its occasionally confusing but very rarely.
Just double barrel the names and use yours as the every day name. It's a really common and normal thing to do. Your surname is probably your Dads name so I don't really get how using that is radically different from using your husbands name.

I changed to my husbands name when we got married but I wish we had made a new surname. He Dad was a nasty man so we weren't doing it to carry on the family name.

Why did you do it then?

CPandme · 19/06/2022 10:44

The tradition I think was that the male child of either family would inherit the property and carry on the name. Some families did have children until a male heir. So both families would have the name continue through their sons. Even then lost people weren’t inheriting as most were poor.

That doesn’t mean it’s a good thing now or something you need to follow. PP are correct your names and your child. Just maybe understand if it means that the name will die out at Dfil or DH generation.

Chantin · 19/06/2022 10:30

@EveryName

Why is her name her fathers name? It became hers - why is it only men own can names and women can only borrow them?!

happinessischocolate · 19/06/2022 10:18

What happens when two people with double barrel names then have children. 😂

Which surnames then take priority? 🤷‍♀️

EveryName · 19/06/2022 10:17

I don't get the issue really. Using the 'it's difficult to spell' reason not to use a name is a bit daft. Loads of names are difficult to spell. Mine is but I have an everyday abbreviation for general use and only use the full name when needed. Its occasionally confusing but very rarely.
Just double barrel the names and use yours as the every day name. It's a really common and normal thing to do. Your surname is probably your Dads name so I don't really get how using that is radically different from using your husbands name.

I changed to my husbands name when we got married but I wish we had made a new surname. He Dad was a nasty man so we weren't doing it to carry on the family name.

SpaceJamtart · 19/06/2022 10:10

Its not really your FILs buisness anyway, and if your husband is fine really with the baby having your name, I'd just use your name
Double barrelled names are annoying and more complucated anyway, even without one of the names being hard to spell.

Realistically though fil wouldnt know unless you explicitly told him. I didn't know my nephews surname (it was his dads)until he was five and I was asked to sew the name labels in his school jumpers. You dont often call your kid by their full name so its not going to be a real life big deal to anyone but the child when they are going through school and putting it on forms forever- I'd give them the easier/nicer name

Bergamotte · 19/06/2022 10:01

Use DH's surname as child's middle name. Keeps it in the family and child can feel a sense of connection to family.
(I know a lot of people who have family surname as a middle name; it's traditional in parts of Scotland).

But give child your surname.

You rarely have to write down your middle name, so child won't have to learn spell DH's name when only just learning to write. And no opportunity for other children to make fun of it.

It's none of FIL's business.

daisypond · 19/06/2022 10:01

It’s nothing to do with your FIL. My sister’s husband changed his name to hers 25 years ago. My dh and I have different surnames; we both kept our original ones.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 19/06/2022 09:53

SausageAndCash · 19/06/2022 09:32

@JuneJubilee It's understandable FIL was upset. It's tradition (in the U.K. anyway) & carrying on the name is traditionally important to a lot of people.

Maybe parents of women (I.e the OP’s parents) would also like to see their name carried on? This is a man who put a cloud over their wedding day!

Yes, it can be tricky going against tradition, and the FIL might find it upsetting but that doesn’t mean tradition should always win. Nothing would ever change. The marriage vows would still include ‘obey’, women could be sacked from their jobs on marriage etc.

What with women doing all the hard work for any name to carry on just who do these entitled men think they are?!