Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying for wedding

135 replies

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 22:27

NC for this.
Planning our wedding and told by his family that the bride's family pays, traditionally in England.
So they'd be fully expecting to pay for his sister's, but not ours, although they will give us some money.
AIBU to be bothered by the unfairness?
Just to be clear we didn't ask them to pay for anything. They brought this up. Just a bit shocked as they're otherwise very generous (pay for meals out etc), and it's 2022!

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 18/06/2022 23:41

Our wedding, 31 years ago was paid for by us and my family. Wouldn't have expected a penny from ILs.

Our DS gets married this year. We are paying half of the reception costs. The bride/her parents are paying for: frock, bridesmaid, flowers, cake, cars, invitations, etc. DS is paying for the honeymoon.

TwoHundred · 18/06/2022 23:40

This happened in our family so is not too uncommon. 2017 DSis was getting married. We have a wealthy parent, as does her DH. DM offered 40k budget for the wedding. BILs parents (far wealthier than ours) offered 5k as their gift. DM politely refused but was massively shocked and did not want them to be able to tell people they paid for their share or whatever if putting in 5k. BIL was devastated as they had paid out 10 times that amount for his sisters wedding the year before. They used the daughter rule you mentioned. It soured their relationship as he then began noticing the difference in the way they treated him vs his sister. Including selling their family home and moving a 2 hour plane journey to another country to be near their daughter when she moved for her husbands work and had her first child.

stepuporshutup · 18/06/2022 23:37

No idea what your problem is
Pay for your own wedding and if dps family are of the thinking they fund their daughters wedding that was the way years ago and they are in that mindset
They are giving you some money what else do you want

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:36

FOTB · 18/06/2022 23:20

It's a British tradition. An old-fashioned one, but that doesn't make it not exist.

Did they actually say they intended to pay for his sister's wedding expenses in full, or did you just infer that from them bringing up the tradition? How much money are they going to give you? Is that enough to get married with, i.e. are they definitely treating their children differently?

Is your fiancé much better off than his sister?

I don't really care for sexist traditions, but I would subsidise one family member more than another on the basis of need. If your fiancé has a really well-paying job and his sister doesn't, then I'd understand his parents helping her out more. But that would have nothing to do with their gender.

Their exact words were 'The bride's parents usually pay, so we'd fully expect to be paying for X and Y's weddings, but not yours. We'll of course make some contribution'. His sisters are still studying/apprentices so no question of being well-off.

I don't know the amount or form of the contribution (e.g is it a fixed amount of money, or a specific expense wedding clothes). But we're planning a modest wedding anyway based on what we can afford. Anything they gave even £50 would be a welcome bonus but not really necessary.

OP posts:
lanthanum · 18/06/2022 23:29

It is indeed the tradition, but I don't think many people have taken much notice of it for the last 50 years. Possibly it made sense when the bride's parents hadn't had the expense of educating their child so that they could be the breadwinner, and were about to save money from not having to house and feed her any more.

The tradition of parents paying rather than the couple also made much more sense in the days when people married before moving in together, and so usually much younger. (We were in that category, and the budget would have been very small if it had had to come out of out savings!)

Pottedpalm · 18/06/2022 23:28

BanjoVio · 18/06/2022 22:51

I haven’t heard of any wedding in real life ever where the bride’s family pays. What 1920s bullshit is this??

Well you must have a narrow circle of acquaintances; my parents paid for our wedding many years back, as was the custom. Our DTs are of an age where many of their friends are getting married and in several cases the bride’s parents have paid. My best friend recently coughed up over £40,000 for her DD’s wedding and our own DS recently got engaged, expecting to fund the wedding, but was delighted to find that his fiancée’s parents offered to pay. It means they have a larger deposit for a house.

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:28

Moonshine5 · 18/06/2022 23:13

But clearly they are 'sexist' according to you and you are still choosing to be a part of this set up or will you go NC once they pay for their daughters wedding?

See, what really throws me (and what I've mentioned several times) is that they're actually generally nice people!
Hence why I wondered whether they, for some reason thought that we'd ask for money, and clumsily tried to pre-empt it. As also mentioned earlier why they'd think that I don't know.
DP's sisters are much younger and unlikely to be getting married anytime soon anyway.

We were initially going to include members of the extended family that they (not us) are particularly close to. Probably not going to do that anymore. We'll fill the remaining spaces with whoever we want, and if Tom, Dick and Harry moan about not being invited it's their business to sort out.

OP posts:
indoorplantqueen · 18/06/2022 23:25

My parents gave us (5 siblings) the same for our weddings (6k). No difference was made based on sex.

theoldtrout01876 · 18/06/2022 23:25

My son is getting married this year. The brides parents are paying for everythng. I have told my son I will pay for the honeymoon as I will literally have to pay for nothing, I just show up. I think I pay for the rehearsal dinner. This is the traditional way here but you hear of it less and less. When I married his dad in 1990 we paid for our own wedding. They realise how lucky they are, so far there has been ZERO drama and her parents have not demanded anything in return.

DirectionToPerfection · 18/06/2022 23:24

YANBU and judging by the vote I'm guessing most people haven't bothered to read your posts properly OP.

The sexism is unfair, and it's hardly surprising your partner feels upset at the clear favouritism.

All you can do is say 'fuck it' and carry on planning your day exactly as you want it. It's a huge milestone in your life and a special day for both of you, don't let them taint that.

Littlebirdyouaresosweet · 18/06/2022 23:23

Ils paid for sil's huge white wedding.. We didn't even get a present at our registry one.
We had the first dgc and got a second hand item.
Year later pregnant sil had 1 k spent on pram etc.
Sometimes people are just not worth trying to figure out.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 18/06/2022 23:22

They’re probably hoping they’ll get to control their daughters weddings by hosting them and they’ll want to invite all their own friends. Lots of people like tradition around weddings, even if they’re far from traditional most of the time.

RuthW · 18/06/2022 23:21

Yes that's tradition. Not saying it's right

My parents paid for mine in 1989. PIL paid for SIL's.

FOTB · 18/06/2022 23:20

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 22:27

NC for this.
Planning our wedding and told by his family that the bride's family pays, traditionally in England.
So they'd be fully expecting to pay for his sister's, but not ours, although they will give us some money.
AIBU to be bothered by the unfairness?
Just to be clear we didn't ask them to pay for anything. They brought this up. Just a bit shocked as they're otherwise very generous (pay for meals out etc), and it's 2022!

It's a British tradition. An old-fashioned one, but that doesn't make it not exist.

Did they actually say they intended to pay for his sister's wedding expenses in full, or did you just infer that from them bringing up the tradition? How much money are they going to give you? Is that enough to get married with, i.e. are they definitely treating their children differently?

Is your fiancé much better off than his sister?

I don't really care for sexist traditions, but I would subsidise one family member more than another on the basis of need. If your fiancé has a really well-paying job and his sister doesn't, then I'd understand his parents helping her out more. But that would have nothing to do with their gender.

Bywayofanupdate · 18/06/2022 23:17

My in laws paid for a big chunk of my sister in law's wedding but nothing towards ours. Funny that we're (mainly me) the ones looking after them now they need care and company. No, I'm not bitter 😬

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:16

Kite22 · 18/06/2022 23:13

Amazing how many people are struggling to read what the OP has put, VERY clearly, SEVERAL times over. Hmm

The question isn't about if parents should pay for their dcs weddings, it is about if anyone thinks it is reasonable in 2022 that parents think they "should" pay for / or are choosing to pay for their daughters' weddings, but not for their son's.

YANBU at all OP
I have 3 dc, and I would like to offer them some money towards their weddings, as I was fortunate enough that my parents paid for ours. But I will be offering the same amount regardless of whether it is a ds or a dd getting married.

Thanks for your message actually understanding what I wrote!
This place does my head in sometimes... why i keep coming back I don't know... maybe because there are sensible people like you

OP posts:
Moonshine5 · 18/06/2022 23:13

But clearly they are 'sexist' according to you and you are still choosing to be a part of this set up or will you go NC once they pay for their daughters wedding?

Kite22 · 18/06/2022 23:13

Amazing how many people are struggling to read what the OP has put, VERY clearly, SEVERAL times over. Hmm

The question isn't about if parents should pay for their dcs weddings, it is about if anyone thinks it is reasonable in 2022 that parents think they "should" pay for / or are choosing to pay for their daughters' weddings, but not for their son's.

YANBU at all OP
I have 3 dc, and I would like to offer them some money towards their weddings, as I was fortunate enough that my parents paid for ours. But I will be offering the same amount regardless of whether it is a ds or a dd getting married.

beepbeephello · 18/06/2022 23:12

OP, I understand your frustration at the sexism.

Where I'm from it is still very much seen as ok for eldest son to inherit family house/land. I know a family of 4 girls and 1 boy. Land on the family farm ready with planning permission etc for a house to be built, I think there's actually room for 2 houses. Just Sitting there while son is off in Australia, no intention of coming home or settling down.

All 4 daughters married within the past 5 years, and would love to build a house there and have been told 100% no, they're not allowed, it has to be the son.

Very very old fashioned view. Also doesn't make sense as son will get the main farmhouse on the land, so why would he need to build another one on the field next door! But apparently it's then for his son.

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:08

Moonshine5 · 18/06/2022 23:01

OP why is this even a thread if you are not bothered. Your partner was unaware his parents would do this?
AIBU as :
A) it's their money to spend
B) many parents of girls pay - for çultural reasons - it is definitely a 'thing'

I'm not bothered by not receiving their money. I'm bothered by the sexism.
'culture' isn't a valid reason for sexism being acceptable.
In india it used to be culture for a widow to step on her husband's funeral pyre, to abort female fetuses, and in the modern day...
www.reuters.com/article/india-slavery-child-marriage-idINKCN1PA0RC

I don't expect this behaviour in 2022 in the United Kingdom.

And yes, if you have read all my posts they are the last people I'd expect to do this because they have been welcoming, accepting and certainly not 'traditional' in any shape or form. Until today.

OP posts:
beepbeephello · 18/06/2022 23:05

PurpleButterflyWings · 18/06/2022 22:56

@beepbeephello you do sound quite bitter. Are you sore and wounded that you had to pay for your own wedding or something? Have a few people close to you had theirs paid for by family and it's skewed your views? Because you seem a bit annoyed by this. Why do you care if parents pay some towards peoples weddings? You sound jealous. And so do a few other posters here. Wink

Oh wow. Incredibly touchy.

No, not bitter at all. My retired parents very kindly gifted us £250, and a beautiful painting of our wedding chapel which is my most treasured possession.

I have no shame in saying here my wedding cost approx £20,000. My husband and I are fortunate enough to earn enough which meant we happily paid this, and spent 3 years saving as much as we possibly could to do so. Never once did I discuss the cost with my parents, or my PIL. Seen zero reason to, the decisions we were making were ours. Similar to any other decision we've made in our lives, it's nothing to do with anyone else.

As I said, I have zero issue with gifts such as wedding dress, or monetary gifts etc. But the idea that as soon as someone gets engaged and starts planning a wedding, people other than the bride and groom should be involved in the cost is strange to me.

I didn't ask my parents for money buying my own house either. I've been raised my incredibly kind, thoughtful parents who would give you the back of their shirt if you needed it, but I've also been raised to be independent and work for what I want. My life choices are nothing to do with anyone else. If I want something, I'll work for it and save. If I can't afford it, I won't do it.

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:04

Anniefrenchfry · 18/06/2022 23:00

So you don’t want them to pay for your wedding but object to them paying for their daughters, is that what you are saying?

because it sure sounds like you want their money.

Eh? So what you take from my multiple posts about not asking them to pay.. is that I want their money?
With that level of mental gymnastics you should be a politician.

I object to unequal treatment on the basis of sex. Do you think this would be acceptable in any other situation? Not a wedding, but buying nicer clothes, or gifts, or anything else for a child of a certain gender?

OP posts:
Thebeastofsleep · 18/06/2022 23:04

Anniefrenchfry · 18/06/2022 23:02

Everyone I know paid for themselves. I assume you move in privileged circles.

A very varied circle. The amounts given by each set of parents wasn't always much, sometimes only £50.

Anniefrenchfry · 18/06/2022 23:02

Thebeastofsleep · 18/06/2022 23:00

Such an old fashioned view!

Everyone I know has has some money given by both sets of parents and then they've made up any shortfall themselves. This includes my remained-virgins-until-marriage friends.

Everyone I know paid for themselves. I assume you move in privileged circles.

Moonshine5 · 18/06/2022 23:01

OP why is this even a thread if you are not bothered. Your partner was unaware his parents would do this?
AIBU as :
A) it's their money to spend
B) many parents of girls pay - for çultural reasons - it is definitely a 'thing'