Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying for wedding

135 replies

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 22:27

NC for this.
Planning our wedding and told by his family that the bride's family pays, traditionally in England.
So they'd be fully expecting to pay for his sister's, but not ours, although they will give us some money.
AIBU to be bothered by the unfairness?
Just to be clear we didn't ask them to pay for anything. They brought this up. Just a bit shocked as they're otherwise very generous (pay for meals out etc), and it's 2022!

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 01:03

^well not both all 3 but I count the sisters as a set here

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 01:02

@LicoricePizza

You are implying that ‘sisters paid wedding = unfair’ means that I expect mine paid too. That’s a logical fallacy and the error in your reasoning.

The unfairness comes from the difference in treatment due to sex. They could pay for none of the weddings. They could contribute to both. I have never said that they should be expected to pay for anything, multiple times, from my very first post
Merely that whatever they do should be the same for all sibling regardless of sex.

Based on what you said, you think I’m not being U

OP posts:
LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 00:55

@DomPerignon12

Forgot to say the bride’s side paying for the wedding is tradition because women were considered chattel and the bride's family used to have to pay off the groom's family in the form of a dowry to take their daughters off their hands.

Dinoteeth · 19/06/2022 00:51

Technically it's 'tradition' but my family have been a pay your own for generations, my Great Granny was a widow with 3 DDs. They all paid their own.

My parents paid their own although my Paternal Aunt got hers paid for.

Who's paying was my ILs first question. We paid out own. Really pisses me off we ended up with a whole table of their pals that they insisted we must invite. Then when it came SILs wedding that ILs were paying for they never invited any of them.

LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 00:51

For @DomPerignon12 👆

LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 00:50

Then why do you say in your OP that you’re bothered by the unfairness of DP’s sisters having their weddings paid for but not him?

AIBU to be bothered by the unfairness?

You then change your argument to say you don’t believe any parent should have to pay anything at all.

If that’s the case why are you bothered & finding it unreasonable then?

Are you saying traditional marriage customs (like this) are sexist & meaningless in 2022?

Of course they are! If you look into most of the customs & ritual around the ceremony itself in the U.K. at least, they originate out of being sold off, as property. Given away by the father (patriarch) to the new patriarch. The reason why bridesmaids wearing all the same dresses (they used to wear the same as the bride) was to act as decoys so as to protect the bride from being abducted & carried off by a rival male. Says a lot about how women were viewed & treated!) What’s been sold as romance & a ritual of love is borne out of some much darker origins.

chchchchch · 19/06/2022 00:30

Sorry I only got married once, not sure why I put 'again' lol

chchchchch · 19/06/2022 00:29

I am with you OP. Its about fairness and equality. My three brothers all got married in the 80s, the eldest two brothers got small contributions by my parents but their weddings were mostly paid for by their wealthy PIL. My youngest brother's was mostly paid for my parents given his PIL didnt have a lot of money and my parent did, but I think it was about fairness as my two other brothers weddings were paid for.

I was a bit slow and I got married again in 1997, my parents paid for most of the wedding, but PIL insistent on paying for the catering. TBH if my two eldest brothers were not paid for by their PIL, I doubt mine and my younger brother's weddings would have been fully paid for, we both would have got a contribution.

FOTB · 19/06/2022 00:20

@DomPerignon12 That's my view too - I'm pretty proud of all of my professional achievements and I don't understand why it's normal to change your name, when so much of your professional worth is attached to it. I can understand the desire to have the same surname, but why on earth is it always the woman who gets shafted? Very few men ever change their surname and that seems grossly unfair to me.

There are about a million wedding traditions in the UK (the bride's father paying for the wedding is only one) and whilst some of them are vaguely interesting, a lot of them are at odds with modern equality standards. I suspect this isn't the only one that's going to outrage you.

As long as your fiancé is on the same page as you (and I assume he is), tradition is interesting, but you get to decide which bits you want to follow and which bits you want to consign to history. I hope you have a lovely wedding done your way, and a very long and happy marriage.

Good luck with the rest of the planning!

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 00:12

FOTB · 19/06/2022 00:08

@DomPerignon12

Oh, wow. That's pretty unambiguous. I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt, but I see that optimism was misplaced.

Dare you to get married and not change your name. More and more women in the UK are keeping their surname on marriage (it's what I would do if I ever got married myself) and if his parents are such dinosaurs, I bet they'd have a strong reaction to ignoring that tradition...

Well luckily I'm keeping it ;) not letting my professional work be erased just because of marriage.
They don't know that though... do wonder how they'll react when they find out :D

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 00:11

stepuporshutup · 19/06/2022 00:09

I have no one around me because I expected everyone else to pay for my wedding and when they did not I threw a strop and didn't invite anyone that had not paid so I cancelled the wedding
Thank you for your concern for me it is very much appreciated

You actually need therapy ...

OP posts:
stepuporshutup · 19/06/2022 00:09

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:51

I have no idea why you're getting so angry over posts by a random internet stranger, but it can't be doing you or the people around you any good...

I have no one around me because I expected everyone else to pay for my wedding and when they did not I threw a strop and didn't invite anyone that had not paid so I cancelled the wedding
Thank you for your concern for me it is very much appreciated

FOTB · 19/06/2022 00:08

@DomPerignon12

Oh, wow. That's pretty unambiguous. I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt, but I see that optimism was misplaced.

Dare you to get married and not change your name. More and more women in the UK are keeping their surname on marriage (it's what I would do if I ever got married myself) and if his parents are such dinosaurs, I bet they'd have a strong reaction to ignoring that tradition...

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 00:04

LicoricePizza · 18/06/2022 23:57

@DomPerignon12

Bit confused. You say you object to parents paying for weddings based on gender ie the bride but are quite approving of parents paying based on
“favouritism/need/if a particular parent preferred their child of a certain sex”

Huh?

Everyone I know who had contributions, had it based on circumstances/parental opinion of the child/'need'.
OK maybe some favoritism if a particular parent preferred their child of a certain sex but nobody has ever expected the bride's family to pay just because... well bride.

So they’re all valid then?? Contradicting your own argument OP.

Where did I say that I approved?
I said that out of the reasons I have heard for unequal contributions, I have never heard BECAUSE BRIDE, BECAUSE TRADITION.
I have heard all the other reasons, which are:


  • Child needs it more, because they're less well off

  • Golden child, which parent prefers because they didn't mess up their lives and were nice and obedient unlike the black sheep

  • Golden child, which happened to be of a certain sex. For example, because parent really wanted a son and then, after 3 daughters finally got one, and he got everything.


I have not heard of anybody saying that they expected to pay solely for being parents of the bride, or otherwise. If they paid for a daughter and not a son it was because they favoured her, not because tradition dictated they paid.

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:57

*meant to say not living together or having sex/kids before marriage

OP posts:
LicoricePizza · 18/06/2022 23:57

@DomPerignon12

Bit confused. You say you object to parents paying for weddings based on gender ie the bride but are quite approving of parents paying based on
“favouritism/need/if a particular parent preferred their child of a certain sex”

Huh?

Everyone I know who had contributions, had it based on circumstances/parental opinion of the child/'need'.
OK maybe some favoritism if a particular parent preferred their child of a certain sex but nobody has ever expected the bride's family to pay just because... well bride.

So they’re all valid then?? Contradicting your own argument OP.

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:56

Thebeastofsleep · 18/06/2022 23:00

Such an old fashioned view!

Everyone I know has has some money given by both sets of parents and then they've made up any shortfall themselves. This includes my remained-virgins-until-marriage friends.

Indeed, but judging by the voting and comments not many people agree!
I'm baffled as to why 'old-fashioned' things which have a far bigger impact on people's lives (such as living together and pre-marital children) have gone the way of the dinosaurs. But paying for a wedding hasn't..?

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:54

Kite22 · 18/06/2022 23:52

No idea what your problem is

The fact that she has found out that her in-laws-to-be are planning to treat the man she loves differently from his sisters, just because he is a man....... maybe ?

Thank you! <3

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:54

catladykit · 18/06/2022 22:57

Friend group all either married/getting married in the next year or so.

Most recent engaged friend started planning her wedding, extremely extravagant, likely to be 20k+, asked her parents how much they saved for her and is now not speaking to them as they have nothing saved. Both are retired, factory workers living in a council house. I'm really not sure what she thought they'd be able to save all these years.

Came to brunch with the rest of us and ranted and raved, saying we were all so lucky our parents paid. Found out no one else's parents paid at all, and she genuinely asked confused, but how did you pay for it then? Seems gobsmacked we all saved up and paid for it ourselves.

She started planning a wedding with no intention of paying for it herself. So strange!

Strange indeed!
In some cultures it's expected, however it also comes along with other restrictions on what women are expected/allowed to do...

OP posts:
Kite22 · 18/06/2022 23:52

No idea what your problem is

The fact that she has found out that her in-laws-to-be are planning to treat the man she loves differently from his sisters, just because he is a man....... maybe ?

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:52

Also @stepuporshutup it's not about the money, but consideration.
DP has been hurt by this attitude, he's not in the mood to try and please his family. i'm certainly not going to smooth the waters.
No point in explaining anyway as you're just here to have a go at people?

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:51

stepuporshutup · 18/06/2022 23:47

Wow just bloody wow so you were expecting them to pay or contribute a substantial amount

Now they are not.going to stump up the money you want them to your wedding becomes almost pay and you go

If future Pils pay then the family they are close to can go but if not you will invite random tom dick and harry?
Don't bother spending a lot on your wedding because you will need money for your divorce
You sound entitled and selfish

I have no idea why you're getting so angry over posts by a random internet stranger, but it can't be doing you or the people around you any good...

OP posts:
stepuporshutup · 18/06/2022 23:47

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:28

See, what really throws me (and what I've mentioned several times) is that they're actually generally nice people!
Hence why I wondered whether they, for some reason thought that we'd ask for money, and clumsily tried to pre-empt it. As also mentioned earlier why they'd think that I don't know.
DP's sisters are much younger and unlikely to be getting married anytime soon anyway.

We were initially going to include members of the extended family that they (not us) are particularly close to. Probably not going to do that anymore. We'll fill the remaining spaces with whoever we want, and if Tom, Dick and Harry moan about not being invited it's their business to sort out.

Wow just bloody wow so you were expecting them to pay or contribute a substantial amount

Now they are not.going to stump up the money you want them to your wedding becomes almost pay and you go

If future Pils pay then the family they are close to can go but if not you will invite random tom dick and harry?
Don't bother spending a lot on your wedding because you will need money for your divorce
You sound entitled and selfish

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:46

TwoHundred · 18/06/2022 23:40

This happened in our family so is not too uncommon. 2017 DSis was getting married. We have a wealthy parent, as does her DH. DM offered 40k budget for the wedding. BILs parents (far wealthier than ours) offered 5k as their gift. DM politely refused but was massively shocked and did not want them to be able to tell people they paid for their share or whatever if putting in 5k. BIL was devastated as they had paid out 10 times that amount for his sisters wedding the year before. They used the daughter rule you mentioned. It soured their relationship as he then began noticing the difference in the way they treated him vs his sister. Including selling their family home and moving a 2 hour plane journey to another country to be near their daughter when she moved for her husbands work and had her first child.

Wow, that's terrible!
It's really sad to be treated differently, so openly. Not the money... that's besides the point...

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.