Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying for wedding

135 replies

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 22:27

NC for this.
Planning our wedding and told by his family that the bride's family pays, traditionally in England.
So they'd be fully expecting to pay for his sister's, but not ours, although they will give us some money.
AIBU to be bothered by the unfairness?
Just to be clear we didn't ask them to pay for anything. They brought this up. Just a bit shocked as they're otherwise very generous (pay for meals out etc), and it's 2022!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bananarama21 · 19/06/2022 19:19

My dm paid for my wedding dress, my auntie paid for the photographer and I paid for the rest.

My brothers got some money in a card but both their inlaws paid for a large proportion of their weddings. Dbro2 was in a posh Manor. I had mine in a nice pub function room. They helped their dd where they couldn't the two boys didn't need that. I would never have expected my inlaws to help with the costs with got some money in a card. I wouldn't be upset if they helped pay toward their dd weddings.

BritWifeInUSA · 19/06/2022 19:08

It’s an odd thing for them to say, especially as money had not even been discussed. Maybe they thought they were preempting a perceived request for money?

I don’t know anyone who is still that traditional about weddings. Are you living together? If so, how do they feel about that? Do they think women shouldn’t work also?

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 19:04

@LicoricePizza 👏👏👏👏 everything you said is spot on

LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 18:46

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 09:59

@LicoricePizza By your logic all the girls kept out of school, married off young, and drowned in the river (in certain cultures) should be relieved that their parents love them. It’s just tradition, eh?

Come on @DomPerignon12 you don’t need to twist my words - if you’re reading your own thread properly you’ll know how clear I’ve been that marriage & wedding customs are borne out of patriarchal practises & are outdated today.

You just don’t want to own up to your hypocritical & contradictory arguments.

You’ve tried to maintain that your “shock” that his sisters will be having their wedding paid for but not your DP, is purely down to the sexist nature of it all. The horror.

When I’ve pointed out that the majority of the ritual of marriage you’re even going to be carrying out is rooted in sexism you don’t want to comment.

So it’s ok for you to cherry pick the nice traditional (& sexist) bits you want to keep in like maybe bridesmaids?? Wearing a veil?? being given you away?? carried over the threshold?? (there are many more) but his parents aren’t allowed to do their traditional (& sexist) bit & pay for their daughters - whilst ALSO GIVING you & your DP a financial contribution!!

Hypocritical much?

And even when I’ve pointed out the irony of your argument & said that surely his parents being (as you say, generous & really lovely people) wanting to follow this tradition (as you yourself will be doing in other ways) is a far lesser evil than the reasons you say you are more accustomed to hearing about such as having golden child family dynamics, out & out favouritism & rewarding going on, for the perfect child.

I know which of these scenarios would be more toxic to marry into. They should be causing you to “wobble” far more than what is actually going to happen ie his parents will be giving you a financial contribution to your wedding. How awful of them.

So surely you should be telling your DP to take comfort in the fact that his DP’s love him just as much as his DS’s & are merely following (yes s sexist) tradition.

And in the traditional scheme of things it wasn’t “unfair” then, because the eldest son (ie presumably your DP) would inherit the family land & property. (Again sexist but a custom - which for all you know they may wish to continue).

Will you then be posting to say how unreasonable it is that you’re inheriting a fortune? But are being unreasonable to be annoyed that it came from a sexist tradition?

Again as others have said, why will you be deliberately inviting less of their guests than you were planning to, now that you know that they won’t be be paying the same as they would be for their daughters?

Oh I see you’re not punishing them because you’re financially getting less, you’re punishing them for their crime of sexism.

Right. With you.

Burgoo · 19/06/2022 14:57

What's this idea that family pays!?

If you want a wedding you can pay for it surely!?

Aprilx · 19/06/2022 14:53

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 23:28

See, what really throws me (and what I've mentioned several times) is that they're actually generally nice people!
Hence why I wondered whether they, for some reason thought that we'd ask for money, and clumsily tried to pre-empt it. As also mentioned earlier why they'd think that I don't know.
DP's sisters are much younger and unlikely to be getting married anytime soon anyway.

We were initially going to include members of the extended family that they (not us) are particularly close to. Probably not going to do that anymore. We'll fill the remaining spaces with whoever we want, and if Tom, Dick and Harry moan about not being invited it's their business to sort out.

So you are not bothered about them paying for your wedding, but now they have mentioned they are only going to make a contribution, yiare going to trim back on family members from that side. But you are not bitter? Right.

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 14:34

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 12:50

And @DomPerignon12 you could take your own advice. All the anger that your PIL aren't giving you enough money can't be doing you any good!

but I'm not angry :) amused at this point by this thread

OP posts:
cocorum · 19/06/2022 13:58

@JamesJJ well, when they go to university for example or even to get there.. they'll need to get the grades to get in for one. Even if we help with a deposit, the size of house they'll actually be able to afford will all be down to their hard work and what kind of careers they've chosen. I'm not saying I'll buy them a house. Just help with the deposit. They'll be working by that point, so even with my help- they can't get a house unless they're working hard and ' fending ' for themselves like you say. So I'm not sure why helping your children if you can, is a problem.

In terms of paying for the wedding, I would also think they'd contribute something.

I don't think helping children who are already fending for themselves and successful is such a bad thing. It's more of a problem if you raise them like brats, with no sense of hard work.

JamesJJ · 19/06/2022 13:33

cocorum · 19/06/2022 08:09

Why is it so terrible if parents contribute if they're wealthy ? It will hopefully be a privilege for me to pay for my Children's weddings. As well as their university and house deposit. That's what I'm working and saving for.

At what stage of their life are they expected to fend for themselves? To actually work towards something and have earned it, and feel pride in that, rather than have everything handed to them to them on a platter so their parent can feel good about themselves?

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 12:50

And @DomPerignon12 you could take your own advice. All the anger that your PIL aren't giving you enough money can't be doing you any good!

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 12:49

@DomPerignon12 i did read the full thread actually! 👍

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 12:46

Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 11:44

Why is it any of your business what traditions people want to continue? My parents have continued with the traditions here that people are now branding "sexist". I'm not going to storm in my house demanding that my parents (who have worked hard for what they have) give me some land because I've a vagina. It's theirs to what they want with. They help me out in other ways and admittedly I would have no use for land whereas my brother will use it for farming. I want to take my partners name when we marry, my personal preference, not because he is sexist and demands it! Plenty of horrendous sexist things still happening into todays world we ought to be standing up for, not way name people choose to take or how much of their own money parents give their kids. And you have said they are giving ye money anyway so I don't really see what your problem is!

Another angry kitty who hasn't RTFT
Calm down and have a cup of tea, all that anger can't be doing you much good

OP posts:
Confusion101 · 19/06/2022 11:44

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 10:53

Also as PP have mentioned if we were blindly following tradition, only the son inherits.
that certainly wouldn’t be acceptable, would it?

Why is it any of your business what traditions people want to continue? My parents have continued with the traditions here that people are now branding "sexist". I'm not going to storm in my house demanding that my parents (who have worked hard for what they have) give me some land because I've a vagina. It's theirs to what they want with. They help me out in other ways and admittedly I would have no use for land whereas my brother will use it for farming. I want to take my partners name when we marry, my personal preference, not because he is sexist and demands it! Plenty of horrendous sexist things still happening into todays world we ought to be standing up for, not way name people choose to take or how much of their own money parents give their kids. And you have said they are giving ye money anyway so I don't really see what your problem is!

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 10:53

FOTB · 19/06/2022 10:26

@LicoricePizza Well, I'm not the OP, but I'm not sure how I'd feel about people close to me blindly following tradition for tradition's sake. If tradition wasn't important to them, they'd either give all their kids the same, or nothing at all.

I have no problem with parents treating children differently based on financial need, but I don't like the idea of doing it based on gender. Just feels wrong.

Weddings are curious things anyway. I don't like the idea of the father giving away the bride - think about what it represents - but that's a tradition most people still seem to follow.

Also as PP have mentioned if we were blindly following tradition, only the son inherits.
that certainly wouldn’t be acceptable, would it?

OP posts:
FOTB · 19/06/2022 10:26

@LicoricePizza Well, I'm not the OP, but I'm not sure how I'd feel about people close to me blindly following tradition for tradition's sake. If tradition wasn't important to them, they'd either give all their kids the same, or nothing at all.

I have no problem with parents treating children differently based on financial need, but I don't like the idea of doing it based on gender. Just feels wrong.

Weddings are curious things anyway. I don't like the idea of the father giving away the bride - think about what it represents - but that's a tradition most people still seem to follow.

RosesAndHellebores · 19/06/2022 10:17

Times change. As I said above DS gets married this year. They are young, 27. They are double barrelling. It works with the surnames and ours is clumsy with her first name due to the repetition of sounds.

I hope we have brought our children up to know their own minds.

DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 10:05

fungibletoken · 19/06/2022 07:40

I'm with you, OP. Annoys me that several of the key traditions to do with marriage still point towards the woman being a burden that the man now has to bear, and/or that it's an honour for the woman to join the man's family.

We, like you, expected to pay for our own wedding. We were surprised and grateful when both parents offered us some money, but DH was annoyed to hear DFIL say in almost the same sentence as oferring us £1k (and saying what/whom it had to be spent on) how many tens of thousands he'd set aside for DH's sister's possible future wedding. I have no skin in the game so wasn't annoyed as such, but find it a bit mindless to follow that tradition (or if you believe in it, offensive!).

Also caused a stir by not changing my surname 😅

wahey, another one!
I’m also keeping my surname :)
we’re not going to bow to their ridiculousness

OP posts:
DomPerignon12 · 19/06/2022 09:59

@LicoricePizza By your logic all the girls kept out of school, married off young, and drowned in the river (in certain cultures) should be relieved that their parents love them. It’s just tradition, eh?

OP posts:
VintageVest · 19/06/2022 09:19

Isn't it also traditional for the sons to inherit the parents estate after death? The daughters have essentially received their share with the wedding and dowry. Perhaps this is a custom they will want to keep alive too!

FlibbertyGiblets · 19/06/2022 09:08

Littlebirdyouaresosweet · 18/06/2022 22:38

Think on op that traditionally mil's are closer to dd's dc than ds's. Imo that means she won't be poking her beak in your lives as much as sil's!

Why so unkind about the woman, no peep about the man . Horrible misogyny here.

LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 09:04

Yes it’s outdated & sexist but so is the majority of the wedding ritual full stop - being given away by the patriarch to another etc

LicoricePizza · 19/06/2022 08:59

I just find OP’s post so contradictory!
@FOTB
You explain on OP’s behalf that
It's the discrepancy towards their children that's thrown her.

You say OP is shocked to learn the family she’s marrying into are happy to discriminate between their DC & favour the DD’s over the DS & pay for their weddings. Causing her to have a “wobble”.

Surely OP should be relieved they’re only paying their DD’s because it’s traditional to & not what she says are more familiar (but a lot more messed up quite frankly & what would worry me more marrying into them ) reasons such as:

Golden child, which parent prefers because they didn't mess up their lives and were nice and obedient unlike the black sheep
Golden child, which happened to be of a certain sex. For example, because parent really wanted a son and then, after 3 daughters finally got one, and he got everything.

I have not heard of anybody saying that they expected to pay solely for being parents of the bride, or otherwise. If they paid for a daughter and not a son it was because they favoured her, not because tradition dictated they paid.

Shouldn’t OP be relieved they’re merely following tradition& not because they love or favour the DD’s more than her DP?

And that they’re giving them a financial contribution anyway - surely confirms this?

whatstheteamarie · 19/06/2022 08:58

I think it's a case of some parents using tradition as a way of hiding the disparity between how they treat their DC; I would be upset by this too OP.

I know a family where the son inherited a mortgage-free house at 21 and the mid-20s daughter got nothing due to "tradition".

When the daughter's husband died, leaving her up to her eyes in debt, her brother "helped" her by buying a small flat and renting it out to her, making sure everybody knew and berating her lack of financial astuteness (whilst making a monthly profit off her 🙄)

He didn't tell anyone though that if he'd split the proceeds of the inheritance (she'd been a loving a close daughter to her father, no need for her to be "disinherited") she'd have owned her own place mortgage-free and wouldn't have needed his help.

That kind of unequal treatment of your DC has got to sting and the OPs ILs being so open about how they're planning to spend £££ on one wedding but not theirs must feel like a kick in the teeth.

Penguinsaregreat · 19/06/2022 08:52

This was the very standard view, probably still is with some people. Sexism is rife.
examples include giving your child the fathers name and not the mothers, a married woman changing her name rather than a married man changing his, a woman being 'given away' from one man to another.
I would examine your future husband 's beliefs carefully here op. He has been raised within a very misogynistic environment and often the Apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 19/06/2022 08:46

DomPerignon12 · 18/06/2022 22:47

Unfortunately they were deadly serious. To add fuel to the fire DP already has a thing about his twin sisters being the favourite children. He's now very upset.

Yeah I can see how that would be upsetting. It is 2022, they are using it as an excuse for not paying for their preferred child's wedding. Shite parents. If they try to demand anything of you, tell them to do one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread